╌>

Conservative Columnist - Trump’s nomination would rip the heart out of the Republican Party

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  johnrussell  •  10 years ago  •  10 comments

Conservative Columnist - Trump’s nomination would rip the heart out of the Republican Party












By  Michael Gerson   Opinion writer   January 7 at 8:26 PM



Every Republican of the type concerned with winning in November has been asking the question (at least internally): “What if the worst happens?”

The worst does not mean the nomination of Ted Cruz, in spite of justified fears of political disaster. Cruz is an ideologue with a message perfectly tuned for a relatively small minority of the electorate. Uniquely in American politics, the senator from Texas has made his reputation by being roundly hated by his colleagues — apparently a prerequisite for a certain kind of anti-establishment conservative, but unpromising for an image makeover at his convention.

Cruz’s nomination would represent the victory of the hard right — religious right and tea party factions — within the Republican coalition. After he loses, the ideological struggles within the GOP would go on.

No, the worst outcome for the party would be the nomination of Donald Trump. It is impossible to predict where the political contest between Trump and Hillary Clinton would end up. Clinton has manifestly poor political skills, and Trump possesses a serious talent for the low blow. But Trump’s nomination would not be the temporary victory of one of the GOP’s ideological factions. It would involve the replacement of the humane ideal at the center of the party and its history. If Trump were the nominee, the GOP would cease to be.

Whatever your view of Republican politicians, the aspiration, the self-conception, of the party was set by Abraham Lincoln: human dignity, honored by human freedom and undergirded by certain moral commitments, including compassion and tolerance.  Lincoln described  the “promise that in due time the weights should be lifted from the shoulders of all men, and that all should have an equal chance.”

 

It is this universality that Trump attacks. All of his  angry resentment  against invading Hispanics and Muslims adds up to a kind of ethno-nationalism — an assertion that the United States is being weakened and adulterated by the other. This is  consistent with  European, right-wing, anti-immigrant populism. It is  not consistent with  conservatism, which, at the very least, involves respect for institutions and commitment to reasoned, incremental change. And Trumpism is certainly not consistent with the Republicanism of Lincoln, who admitted no exceptions to the promises of the Declaration of Independence and was nominated, in part, because he could appeal to  anti-slavery German immigrants .

Liberals who claim that Trumpism is the natural outgrowth, or logical conclusion, of conservatism or Republicanism are simply wrong.  Edmund Burke is not the grandfather of  Nigel Farage . Lincoln is not even the distant relative of Trump.

Trump, in some ways, is an odd carrier of ethno-nationalist beliefs. He held few of them, as far as I can tell, just four years ago. But as a demagogue, he has followed some of America’s worst instincts wherever they have led, and fed ethnic and religious prejudice in the process. All presidential nominees, to some extent, shape their parties into their own image. Trump would deface the GOP beyond recognition.

Trump is disqualified for the presidency by his erratic temperament, his ignorance about public affairs and his scary sympathy for authoritarianism. But for me, and I suspect for many, the largest problem is that Trump would make the GOP the party of racial and religious exclusion.

American political parties are durable constructions. But they have been broken before by powerful, roiling issues such as immigration and racial prejudice. Many Republicans could not vote for Trump but would have a horribly difficult time voting for Clinton. The humane values of Republicanism would need to find a temporary home, which would necessitate the creation of a third party. This might help elect Clinton, but it would preserve something of conservatism, held in trust, in the hope of better days.

Ultimately, these political matters are quite personal. I have spent 25 years in the company of compassionate conservatives, reform conservatives, Sam’s Club conservatives or whatever they want to call themselves, trying to advance an agenda of social justice in America’s center-right party. We have shared a belief that sound public policy — promoting opportunity, along with the skills and values necessary to grasp it — can improve the lives of our fellow citizens and thus make politics an honorable adventure.

The nomination of Trump would reduce Republican politics — at the presidential level — to an enterprise of squalid prejudice. And many Republicans could not follow, precisely because they are Republicans. By seizing the GOP, Trump would break it to pieces.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    10 years ago

"Trump is disqualified for the presidency by his erratic temperament, his ignorance about public affairs and his scary sympathy for authoritarianism. But for me, and I suspect for many, the largest problem is that Trump would make the GOP the party of racial and religious exclusion."

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    10 years ago

The nomination of Trump would certainly be the end of the power of the true Conservative wing of the GOP. George Will wrote an interesting column about it a couple of weeks ago. Well worth a read.

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    10 years ago

Too funny this guy was the voice of George Bush he even wrote his speeches. This guy represents what is wrong with the party and why it needs to be shaken up. Take his advice with a grain of salt. 

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     10 years ago

My plan for the U.S. is so huge, you won't believe it. I can hardly believe it, not only is it huge, it won't work. No problem, cuz I'm so rich you can't believe it. /s

 
 
 
PJ
Masters Silent
link   PJ    10 years ago

I think both Parties are going through some transitions.  Admittedly, the most noticeable is the Republican Party because of its own internal battle on what the Party platform is or should be.  I’m not so sure that the Republican Party can reclaim what it once had but I’m also not so sure whether that’s a bad thing.  I’ll admit that for me it’s disturbing to see such a hostile and anti-everything that isn’t white display from the current “grassroots” of the Party but sometimes things have to go completely south (no pun intended) for change to occur.  I view Mr. Trump’s campaign as a conduit to the changes that are needed.  It’s important that the Country have opposing parties and the Republican Party is very much needed and is very important in order to help keep the checks and balances.  I’m not a fan of what I’m seeing from Mr. Trump’s supporters but things normally do have to go to shit before change is accepted.     

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    10 years ago

Before one has one's heart ripped out …

One must first possess a heart.

Heart before the horse so-to-speak.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  A. Macarthur   10 years ago

True and, much like the NRA, the right wing of the GOP has no heart. There used to be a group of moderate Republicans who actually put the best interests of the country and the American people ahead of the interests of the Party, but they are either dead or hiding or are having their voices drowned out by the screaming, George Wallace type racism, bigotry, hate and fear of the lies spread by the Trumps and the Cruz's and the Christie's of what is now jokingly referred to as an American political party. Today they are Party first and America a far, far, far distant second.

 
 

Who is online


Right Down the Center


96 visitors