╌>

How Income Inequality Puts Social Security In Jeopardy

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  johnrussell  •  10 years ago  •  15 comments

How Income Inequality Puts Social Security In Jeopardy

http://www.govexec.com/management/2016/01/how-united-states-government-underestimated-extent-income-inequality/125071/

 

"The financial picture for Social Security isn’t as dire as  some describe : Without any modifications to its funding, Social Security will generate enough revenue to pay for  three-quarters of promised benefits .

The main reason it’ll fall short, though—the reason that that remaining one-quarter of benefits hasn’t yet materialized—is that the method of funding for Social Security was calibrated to an America with much less inequality than the nation currently has.

Since the late ‘70s,  most of the growth  in workers’ earnings has gone to the people who have made the most money. To be precise, the wages of the top 1 percent of workers have grown 138 percent since 1979, while the wages for the bottom 90 percent grew only 15 percent during that period.

If all of that income growth were taxed evenly, Social Security would have no shortfall. But it’s not taxed evenly: Any dollar that an American earns beyond $118,500 is, under current laws, not subject to Social Security taxes. In other words, someone who makes $118,500 this year is going to pay the same amount in Social Security taxes as someone who makes $4 million this year.

For most people, this doesn’t really matter:  Less than six percent  of wage-earners last year took home more than $120,000. But because lots of the last three decades’ earnings growth has been in the realm beyond $118,500 a year, much of it has escaped Social Security taxes.

One way to think about this is how much time each year a worker spends making money that’s subject to Social Security taxes. Most people—anyone who earns $118,500 or less—will be paying taxes on every dollar they earn all year. But, compared to this group, very wealthy Americans dispense with this tax obligation very early on in the year: For example, the top 10,000 or so earners will  make over $4 million this year , so by the end of their first week back at work, they’re done paying Social Security taxes for the year.

But that’s nothing. At the time of this article’s mid-January publication, making money that’s subject to Social Security is a distant memory for the top 565 wage-earners, who make  on average over $28 million per year . They finished paying their Social Security taxes within the first eight hours of the year’s first workweek. The  top 110 American wage-earners  were done paying in the first two hours. This exercise could go on ad infinitum: Who had paid by the time of their first coffee break? By the time they finished brushing their teeth in the morning?

The system  can easily be made  solvent if it adjusts to the reality of income inequality. Eliminating the earnings cap would be an effective, fair way to fully restore Social Security’s strength. Those affected by such a shift in tax policy would  remain the richest handful of people  in the country, and the move’s biggest effect would be that the retirement system for the bottom 99 percent of workers would be solvent for three generations. (And that’s only discussing the possibility of removing the tax cap on wages earned—every single dollar of capital gains is exempt from Social Security taxes too.)

In 1994, a bipartisan group of politicians eliminated a cap that limited the taxes high-earning workers paid toward Medicare, and now every dollar earned in wages is subject to a 2.45 percent tax. Making a similar change to how Social Security is funded, then, isn’t out of the question."



Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    10 years ago

In 1994, a bipartisan group of politicians eliminated a cap that limited the taxes high-earning workers paid toward Medicare, and now every dollar earned in wages is subject to a 2.45 percent tax. Making a similar change to how Social Security is funded, then, isn’t out of the question."

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    10 years ago

Sounds like someone wants to steal the earnings of men more successful than themselves and give the money to themselves. I'm not in favor. High earners should have the option to opt out of the program as should everyone else that wants out. 

Lifting the cap would also increase business payroll taxes making us less competItive in a global economy. No such thing as a free lunch. 

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy  replied to  Dean Moriarty   10 years ago

No such thing as a free lunch. 

It's amazing how many people don't get that. 

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    10 years ago

If all of that income growth were taxed evenly, Social Security would have no shortfall.

The present article talks about taxing all income , for social security, - I don't believe the projections you refer to are based on taxing all income for social security purposes, including income from capital.  

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

Since it's inception, Social Security has always been a wage tax. I'm sure it's possible to add all sorts of new taxes to make it solvent, but that would radically change it's premise. 

My point was that you can't fix the problem simply by raising the wage cap. Realistically, the contribution rate will have to be raised or money will have to borrowed, which is the most likely outcome. Taking money from our grand-kids is always the most popular political choice. 

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell  replied to  Sean Treacy   10 years ago

I don't know exactly what particulars this article is basing it's statements on , but I am gathering that it is based on all income. Why shouldn't income from capital be taxed ? It makes no sense outside of a plutocratic viewpoint. 

Whether the article means all income or all wages, it is still different numbers than the graph you presented. 

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

W hether the article means all income or all wages, it is still different numbers than the graph you presented. 

no, that's exactly the scenario the graph describes:

Even if the cap on taxable wages were  entirely  eliminated – that is, a new 12.4% payroll tax were applied on all wages from $106,800 to infinity – most of the annual shortfalls (62% of them over the long term)  would still remain .

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    10 years ago

Not this lame trope again.

"In other words, someone who makes $118,500 this year is going to pay the same amount in Social Security taxes as someone who makes $4 million this year."

Those two classes of people would get the exact same benefits too. SS is not a charity, not a handout, and not an entitlement. What you get out is proportional to what you put in. It's simple if you are not blinded by class warfare and the politics of envy.

 
 

Who is online





MrFrost


122 visitors