Health Insurance Companies Seek Big Rate Increases for 2016
WASHINGTON Health insurance companies around the country are seeking rate increases of 20 percent to 40 percent or more, saying their new customers under the Affordable Care Act turned out to be sicker than expected. Federal officials say they are determined to see that the requests are scaled back.
Blue Cross and Blue Shield plans market leaders in many states are seeking rate increases that average 23 percent in Illinois, 25 percent in North Carolina, 31 percent in Oklahoma, 36 percent in Tennessee and 54 percent in Minnesota, according to documents posted online by the federal government and state insurance commissioners and interviews with insurance executives.
The Oregon insurance commissioner, Laura N. Cali, has just approved 2016 rate increases for companies that cover more than 220,000 people. Moda Health Plan, which has the largest enrollment in the state, received a 25 percent increase, and the second-largest plan, LifeWise, received a 33 percent increase.
Jesse Ellis OBrien, a health advocate at the Oregon State Public Interest Research Group, said: Rate increases will be bigger in 2016 than they have been for years and years and will have a profound effect on consumers here. Some may start wondering if insurance is affordable or if its worth the money.
President Obama, on a trip to Tennessee this week , said that consumers should put pressure on state insurance regulators to scrutinize the proposed rate increases. If commissioners do their job and actively review rates, he said, my expectation is that theyll come in significantly lower than whats being requested.
The rate requests , from some of the more popular health plans, suggest that insurance markets are still adjusting to shock waves set off by the Affordable Care Act.
It is far from certain how many of the rate increases will hold up on review, or how much they might change. But already the proposals, buttressed with reams of actuarial data, are fueling fierce debate about the effectiveness of the health law.
A study of 11 cities in different states by the Kaiser Family Foundation found that consumers would see relatively modest increases in premiums if they were willing to switch plans. But if they switch plans, consumers would have no guarantee that they can keep their doctors. And to get low premiums, they sometimes need to accept a more limited choice of doctors and hospitals.
Some say the marketplaces have not attracted enough healthy young people. As a result, millions of people will face Obamacare sticker shock, said Senator John Barrasso, Republican of Wyoming.
By contrast, Marinan R. Williams, chief executive of the Scott & White Health Plan in Texas, which is seeking a 32 percent rate increase, said the requests showed that there was a real need for the Affordable Care Act.
People are getting services they needed for a very long time, Ms. Williams said. There was a pent-up demand. Over the next three years, I hope, rates will start to stabilize.
Sylvia Mathews Burwell, the secretary of health and human services, said that federal subsidies would soften the impact of any rate increases. Of the 10.2 million people who obtained coverage through federal and state marketplaces this year, 85 percent receive subsidies in the form of tax credits to help pay premiums.
In an interview, Ms. Burwell said consumers could also try to find less expensive plans in the open enrollment period that begins in November. You have a marketplace where there is competition, she said, and people can shop for the plan that best meets their needs in terms of quality and price.
Blue Cross and Blue Shield of New Mexico has requested rate increases averaging 51 percent for its 33,000 members. The proposal elicited tart online comments from consumers.
This rate increase is ridiculous, one subscriber wrote on the website of the New Mexico insurance superintendent.
In their submissions to federal and state regulators, insurers cite several reasons for big rate increases. These include the needs of consumers, some of whom were previously uninsured; the high cost of specialty drugs; and a policy adopted by the Obama administration in late 2013 that allowed some people to keep insurance that did not meet new federal standards.
Healthier people chose to keep their plans, said Amy L. Bowen, a spokeswoman for the Geisinger Health Plan in Pennsylvania, and people buying insurance on the exchange were therefore sicker than expected. Geisinger, often praised as a national model of coordinated care, has requested an increase of 40 percent in rates for its health maintenance organization.
Insurers with decades of experience and brand-new plans underestimated claims costs.
Our enrollees generated 24 percent more claims than we thought they would when we set our 2014 rates, said Nathan T. Johns, the chief financial officer of Arches Health Plan, which covers about one-fourth of the people who bought insurance through the federal exchange in Utah. As a result, the company said, it collected premiums of $39.7 million and had claims of $56.3 million in 2014. It has requested rate increases averaging 45 percent for 2016.
The rate requests are the first to reflect a full year of experience with the new insurance exchanges and federal standards that require insurers to accept all applicants, without charging higher prices because of a persons illness or disability. The 2010 health law established the rate review process, requiring insurance companies to disclose and justify large proposed increases. Under federal rules, increases of 10 percent or more are subject to review.
Federal officials have often highlighted a provision of the Affordable Care Act that caps insurers profits and requires them to spend at least 80 percent of premiums on medical care and related activities. Because of the Affordable Care Act, Mr. Obama told supporters in 2013 , insurance companies have to spend at least 80 percent of every dollar that you pay in premiums on your health care not on overhead, not on profits, but on you.
In financial statements filed with the government in the last two months, some insurers said that their claims payments totaled not just 80 percent, but more than 100 percent of premiums. And that, they said, is unsustainable.
At Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Minnesota, for example, the ratio of claims paid to premium revenues was more than 115 percent, and the company said it lost more than $135 million on its individual insurance business in 2014. Based on first-quarter results, it said, the year-end deficit for 2015 individual business is expected to be significantly higher.
BlueCross BlueShield of Tennessee, the largest insurer in the states individual market, said its proposed increase of 36 percent could affect more than 209,000 consumers.
Theres not a lot of mystery to it, said Roy Vaughn, a vice president of the Tennessee Blue Cross plan. We lost a significant amount of money in the marketplace, $141 million, because we were not very accurate in predicting the utilization of health care.
Julie Mix McPeak, the Tennessee insurance commissioner, said she would ask hard questions of the companies we regulate, to protect consumers.
After public hearings and a rigorous review, Ms. Cali, the Oregon insurance commissioner, found that the cost of providing coverage to individuals and families in 2014 was $830 million, while premiums were only $703 million. She directed some carriers to raise rates in 2016 even more than they had proposed.
Health Net, for example, requested rate increases averaging 9 percent in Oregon. The state approved increases averaging 34.8 percent. Oregons Health Co-op requested a 5.3 percent increase. The state called for a 19.9 percent increase.
We share the concerns expressed through public comment about the affordability of health insurance in Oregon, said Ms. Cali, an actuary. But, she added, inadequate rates could result in companies going out of business in the middle of the plan year, or being unable to pay claims.
Coventry Health Care, now owned by Aetna, is seeking rate increases that average 22 percent for 70,000 consumers in Missouri. The claims experience for these plans has been worse than anticipated, Coventry reported.
In its proposal to increase rates by an average of 25 percent for more than 397,000 consumers, Blue Cross and Blue Shield of North Carolina cited inpatient costs, particularly in treatment of cancer and heart conditions, emergency room utilization, and cost for specialty drug medications to treat hepatitis C , breast cancer and cystic fibrosis .
Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Kansas sought increases averaging 37 percent for 2016 and said the increase could affect 28,600 consumers.
Kansans who purchased these individual plans since 2014 were older, in general, than expected and required more medical services than anticipated, the company told federal health officials.
http://www.nytimes.com/2015/07/04/us/health-insurance-companies-seek-big-rate-increases-for-2016.html
Tags
Who is online
72 visitors

"Well lower premiums by up to $2,500 for a typical family per year. " Whoops!
We all knew something like this was bound to happen . But president teflon will find a way to ignore these events .
Does this mean the cost of cell phone plans is going up?
I seem to remember that the costs would be similar
Gee, who saw any of this coming?/s
Remember when they said "nuclear energy would drive energy bills lower?"
Selling bad ideas to the public is always profitable. Like cheaper insurance costs.
It is not enough to be promised hundreds of thousands of new lower income customers, now they must be squeezed dry like the rest of us.
But go ahead and laugh at Canada's universal health care system, you know the system used by many civilized countries that don't pander to the insurance companies.
US Doctors love Canada's system especially in our northern states . That's where Canadian patients go to get quicker treatments and more sophisticated treatments . At a higher price , of course .
The percentage of Canadians who do that is miniscule. Are you saying that Canada is backward when it comes to medical sophistication? Have you ever heard of Dr. Wilder Penfield? or Banting and Best? I would trust a doctor who graduated from University of Toronto medical school any time before an American doctor. If there are necessary (not quack) procedures available in the USA that are not done in Canada, the Canadian health care system reimburses the patient for them.
Canadians don't pay for health care except for vanity procedures (e.g. unnecessary plastic surgery like voluntary nose jobs, etc.).
You might as well save your breath, Buzz. These people are for maximizing profit, damn the cost to society. Insurance is a scam and has been since the companies started trying to maximize profits and minimize exposure. All very sound business practices, does not really do that much for the society in which they and the rest of us live.
No . I'm saying that Canadians don't rely 100 % on their system . Am I wrong ? BTW I'm not laughing at Canada's system . But that's how you led off your comment ...
I blame you and your ilk, and, of course, the insurance companies.
"Canadians don't pay for health care."
That statement completely discredits you. Who do you imagine pays for your health care? Wood nymphs?
would trust a doctor who graduated from University of Toronto medical school any time before an American doctor
Then you are irrational as well. 7 of the top 10 medical schools in the world are in the US. None are in Canada.
Health care is covered by part of our Income Tax payments. That way, those who can afford it cover those who can't and nobody goes bankrupt because of health care costs. What I meant by "not paying" was that I can go to a hospital, have an operation, and not pay the cashier on the way out. I didn't mean the costs were not covered in some way.
Please provide a link to the report as to top medical schools. I guess I over-stated. In fact when I graduated high school, I wrote to the Johns Hopkins Medical School (which I assume is on the top 7 list) with my transcript and got back a most warmly written response from the Dean welcoming my application and indicating that I would be an acceptable candidate. It was probably one of the big mistakes I made in my life by not going there - my life would have been entirely different than what it became.
Aren't you doing the same thing? You said:
Of course, it is always right when you do it, but wrong when someone else does. That is your method of operation. Reasoning is not your strong point, but at least you are consistent.
What "ilk" is that [just for purposes of clarification] ?
Reactionaries and Randian Objectivists.
We had our largest single jump in insurance rates the exact day after the ACA went into affect. Everything, from premiums to out of pocket to clinic and ER visits went up significantly (BC/BS of North Dakota). I wonder how much of an insurance costincrease the middle class can handle, beforewe too will have to sign-up for subsidized health insurance?
The timing was not accidental. It was done then to thumb their noses at the ACA and make it appear that it was the cause.
Bottom line, they did it and no one stopped them. No one. The rate hikes were something that were talked about before the ACA ever became law, yet the government allowed them to ransack the payers. I wonder whom got who's dick sucked for that? It's not as ifinsurance companiesaren't already making considerable more profit from the ACA.
Personally I believe that we have no excuse for not having universal health care. We are the richest most powerful country in the world and health care should be covered. This law and the way it has been implemented so far though, stinks to high heaven of Crony Capitalism and is draining the pockets of the engine that drives our economy, namely, the Middle Class. Plain and simple, it's a rip off.
Actually it was done to be unfair to red states . They are bearing the majority of large rate increases .
and where else would the largest increases be made but in the states with the most opposition. Insurance companies are covering their bets and their asses to make 'sure that the cookie crumbles their way, even if it crumbles the direction of national single payer.
Larry, I am with you all the way on this one.
So ... you are saying that insurance rates should be set by political position ? Do you have any idea how crazy that sounds ?!
I did not say anything of the sort. I said that is where one would expect the largest raises because it promotes the heads-I win, tails-you lose scenario for the insurance companies.
I think that vast amounts of collusion are occurring behind the scenes and across state lines within the national insurance PACs and associations. Insurance companies didn't invent the shell game, but they have mastery and control of it.
87% of the people on Obamacare are getting some form of assistance....The middle class already can't afford it. The insurance rates will increase until companies can no longer afford it and everyone is on BO care. This is by design.
What you DID say still does not make any sense . Is that because you're an "expert" ?
Your lack of comprehension does not make me any more or less wrong.
Your lack of specifics indicates that you are more interested in arguing and attacking than discussion.