╌>

This is actually what America would look like without gerrymandering

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  bob-nelson  •  10 years ago  •  15 comments

This is actually what America would look like without gerrymandering

This is actually what America would look like without gerrymandering
original article   --   by Christopher Ingraham   --   Wonkblog
-------------------------------

 


In his  State of the Union speech , President Obama called on lawmakers and the public to take a number of steps "to change the system to reflect our better selves" for "a better politics." The top item on that list was to end partisan gerrymandering: "we have to end the practice of drawing our congressional districts so that politicians can pick their voters, and not the other way around," Obama said.

In most states, state legislatures draw the district boundaries that determine how many delegates the state sends to the U.S. Congress, as well as the general partisan make-up of that delegation. State legislatures are partisan beasts, and if one party is in control of the process they can draw boundaries to give themselves a numeric advantage over their opponents in Congress. This process is called gerrymandering .


Some state legislatures  are more brazen about the process than others . Maryland's districts, drawn by Democrats, are one particularly egregious example. North Carolina's, drawn by Republicans, are another. Advocates of report have proposed various solutions to the problem over the years. In some states, redistricting is put in the hands of  an independent commission . In others,  lengthy court battles  are playing out to draw the districts more fairly.

But a fundamental problem with district-drawing still remains: as long as humans are drawing the lines, there's a danger of bias and self-interest to creep into the process. There is another way, however: we could simply  let computers do the drawing for us .

From a technological standpoint it's fairly straightforward -- a software engineer in Massachusetts named Brian Olson  wrote an algorithm to do it in his spare time . As I described it in 2014, Olson's algorithm creates  "optimally compact" equal-population congressional districts in each state , based on 2010 census data. It draws districts that respect the boundaries of  census blocks , which are the smallest geographic units used by the Census Bureau. This ensures that the district boundaries reflect actual neighborhoods and don't, say,  cut an arbitrary line  through somebody's house."

To see what this looks like in practice, compare this map of our current congressional districts (top) with one we stitched together from Olson's output (bottom).


Big difference, isn't it? You can check out  a larger version of the compacted map here . Rather than a confusing snarl of interlocked districts, you have neat, trim boundaries that make intuitive sense. Here are some individual state comparisons I made back in 2014 that let you see some more of the detail:


Screen Shot 2016-01-13 at 11.35.23 AM

Algorithms like this one prioritize compactness -- that is, ensuring that voters are geographically close together. One of the telltale signs of gerrymandering is dramatically non-compact districts that squiggle and squirm out in all different directions -- evidence of lawmakers trying to bring far-flung voters into a single district in order to achieve the partisan mix that best favors their party. Or, as Obama said: districts that let politicians pick their voters, rather than the other way around.

Many political scientists are  skeptical  about the merits of drawing districts based on compactness. Their general argument is that districts are ideally based on communities of interest -- people who share a common demography, culture, class, etc. There's no particular reason, they say, that grouping voters by geographic proximity ensures this coherent community any more than drawing lines according to any other metric. Moreover,  algorithms can be biased too .

It's a point well-taken. But "community of interest" is an incredibly squishy term. You can define it pretty much however you want. As I wrote in 2014, if you're a politician in search of a figleaf justification for putting voters from disparate corners of the state into the same congressional district, you can always find one. Communities of interest are a great ideal, but in practice they're so fuzzy that they open the door to all manner of redistricting shenanigans,  as we've seen .

The main obstacles to automated redistricting are legal. For starters, the Voting Rights Act mandates that in some states,  race needs to be a factor  in redistricting to ensure that minority voters are represented in Congress. Again: a nice idea. But there's a tradeoff: packing all your minority voters into one district diminishes their clout everywhere else. We've  seen this in the real world in Florida : the 5th District was originally drawn as a majority-minority district by Democrats. But Republicans saw fit to keep it that way in subsequent years, because it gave black voters less power in the surrounding districts.

In the end, the prospect of an open, transparent algorithm drawing districts based on population and compactness may be an improvement upon the status quo, where politicians draw the boundaries that best serve their interests. Of course, the chances of this ever becoming reality are slim: doing so would require state legislators to voluntarily cede their redistricting powers to a computer program. And if there's anything lawmakers dislike, it's giving up power.

Laris Karklis contributed to this story.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    10 years ago

One man, one vote.

        laughing dude

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    10 years ago

Or two or three where they don't check ID's.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Dean Moriarty   10 years ago

Nope. No applause for this one, Dean. There's no off-center humor. It's just...stupid.

     tough guy      tough guy

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    10 years ago

I hate gerrymandering. I don't even see why we need it. We live in a computerized age where it can be one person one vote. For that matter they can ditch the "Electoral College" as well. 

 
 
 
LynneA
Freshman Silent
link   LynneA  replied to  Perrie Halpern R.A.   10 years ago

With you regarding ditching the "Electoral College"!  It served its purpose when the pony express was in vogue.  Perhaps it's elimination would encourage the Independent participation you sighted...just thinkin'.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.  replied to  LynneA   10 years ago

With you regarding ditching the "Electoral College"!  It served its purpose when the pony express was in vogue.

Love your description Lynne. And that is a very good point. I would love me some one person one vote. 

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     10 years ago

We don't need gerrymandering. Another con job by both parties.

As the article states, there is a slim chance that the computer age will dent the head of the ''political scientists''.

What the hell is a political scientist anyway? Politics is a profession, the second oldest profession, and closely related to the oldest. Which, IMO is an insult to the oldest profession.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    10 years ago

At the local level, this is done, all the time.  This politician has a lot of friends in this neighborhood, so they make sure that that neighborhood is within their district.  It's pretty sad when it is on the national level, too...

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    10 years ago

Proposals for your considerations.

And a very good proposal. The biggest change due to a "statewide slate" system would be that an elected official would not have a geographically recognizable electorate. To whom would citizens turn, if they do not have "their" representative?

But let's think a bit further: There are several possible solutions to this question... and I purposely avoid saying "this problem", because I'm not sure it is a problem at all.

It would be easy to "retrofit" elected representatives to geographical zones, if that is desired... but we might want to take the opportunity to think about other methods. If there are no geographical attachments at all, then a common citizen would address a representative according to the representative's special competences, as signified by committee memberships. For example, a citizen with a public health concern would seek a member of that committee. A subject concerning education would go to that committee. And so on.

Congratulations, Augur, for thinking outside the box. Most Americans are unaware that the " by district, winner take all" system seen in most US elections is not the only system used around the world. I think Israel uses a "nation-wide slate, partly proportional" system, somewhat like your proposal.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    10 years ago

I wouldn't restrict anyone's access to any representative. If the representative feels competent to act then s/he will. Or s/he may redirect the applicant to a more competent colleague. 

 
 

Who is online







95 visitors