╌>

Obama’s Republican Foreign Policy Critics Don’t Understand How the World Works

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  johnrussell  •  10 years ago  •  11 comments

Obama’s Republican Foreign Policy Critics Don’t Understand How the World Works

http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/war_stories/2016/01/the_gop_presidential_candidates_think_obama_s_foreign_policy_victories_are.html


They seem to think that “hitting them hard” is the only way to get people to do things.





505386686-president-barack-obama-leaves-after-he-delivered-a

President Barack Obama leaves after he delivered a statement on the relations between U.S. and Iran in the cabinet room of the White House on Jan. 17, 2016 in Washington, D.C.

Aude Guerrucci–Pool/Getty Images





"Wherever your stance on the political spectrum, there’s no point listening to Republicans rail against President Obama’s policies. No matter what he does, his foreign policy is feckless, clueless, or downright treasonous according to GOP talking points.



A case in point is the past week’s diplomatic feats with Iran. First, a  crisis over the seizure of two U.S. patrol boats , which had trespassed into Iranian waters, was settled peacefully in a day. Then, the Iranians were declared in compliance with the nuclear deal that was signed in July, as a result of which decades-long economic sanctions were lifted. Finally, five Americans were released from Iranian jails as part of a prisoner exchange.



And yet the leading Republican presidential candidates denounced these deals—which would be impressive achievements in any commander-in-chief’s record-book—as signs of weakness, cowardice, and worse.



In August, when Obama was making a strong pitch for the Iran nuclear deal,  he told a group of columnists  in an on-the-record session, “If I presented a cure for cancer, getting legislation passed to move that forward would be a nail-biter.” That understates what the response would be in today’s eve-of-Iowa frenzy. The row of GOP contenders would denounce the cure as a jobs-killer (all those nurses out of a job at Sloan-Kettering) and an aggravation of the housing crisis (all those people, who should have died, crowding the market).



You might think the prisoner release would put the Republicans in an awkward position. They’ve been pushing Obama to get the Americans freed for months, and now, here they are, back home with their families.  Donald Trump  tried to resolve the cognitive dissonance by claiming personal credit for the release. “I’ve been hitting them hard, and I think I might’ve had something to do with it,” Trump said in a campaign stop on Saturday. (A minute later, though, he denounced the release anyway, saying it should have happened three or four years ago. How, he didn’t reveal.)



Even Obama’s foreign policy victories are feckless, clueless, or downright treasonous.




Even by Trump standards, the egomania embedded in this remark is staggering. But it also reflects something more dangerous about not just Trump but most of the leading GOP candidates: a view that “hitting them hard” is the only way to get people to do things, and that patient diplomacy is for suckers and weaklings. As we now know, the prisoner-release came as the result of  14 months of negotiation s between U.S. and Iranian diplomats—who, by the way, would have had no way of even speaking with one another, had it not been for the ties built up during the three years of talks on Iran’s nuclear program.



Sen. Marco Rubio wrote an op-ed for  RedState , denouncing the whole complex of Iranian-American deals as  “appeasement.”  This is the stuff of rhetorical hot air. What territory or interests did the United States cede in any of these deals? Rubio, Trump, Sen. Ted Cruz, and others denounce the $150 billion that Obama is “giving” to Iran as part of the nuclear deal—not acknowledging, in some cases perhaps not knowing, that the money (more like $100 billion, minus $50 billion that will instantly go to pay off debts) is Iran’s own assets, which were frozen in response to Iran’s nuclear program. Now that the program is largely dismantled, as required the assets are unfrozen. That’s what the nuclear deal—negotiated by the United States, Iran, and five other powers (England, France, Russia, China, and Germany)—was all about.



For its part of the deal, Iran was required not merely to freeze its nuclear program but to substantially roll it back. Specifically, it had to dismantle two-thirds of its centrifuges and 98 percent of its enriched uranium, to fill its Arak plutonium reactor with concrete, and, for verification, to allow international inspectors unprecedented access to its facilities. The big news this weekend, in this regard, is that the International Atomic Energy Agency—which monitors compliance with the deal—announced that, at this stage of the deal, Iran has fulfilled its end of the bargain, ahead of schedule.



That’s what triggered the lifting of economic sanctions. (Rubio wrote that the release “rewards bad behavior,” but in fact it rewards good behavior.) And officials acknowledge that, while the prisoner-exchange was not an explicit part of the deal, side-room conversations during the nuclear talks kept the issue alive and accelerated progress, so that, when the time came, no extraneous issues would impede sanctions-relief. If Trump wants to keep score, tallying which side won, lost, or compromised the most, it was the Iranians who felt more pressure on this one.



The events of the past week reveal a few things about the Republican critique of Obama’s foreign policy. First, it is completely uninformed on substantive grounds: The jeremiads against the nuclear accord in particular reflect a deep-seated ignorance of what’s in the nuclear deal. Second, it is completely uninformed on procedural grounds: The candidates know nothing about the diplomatic back-and-forth that produced the nuclear deal, the prisoner release, or the release earlier this week of the 10 U.S. sailors who’d somehow crossed into Iranian territorial waters. Trump rails against the “stupid” deals concocted by “political hacks”: If the deals were what he says they are, he might have a point. But they aren’t, and he doesn’t. (We are still awaiting the list of his advisers on these issues; he says that, as president, he’d appoint “brilliant people,” “the best people,” but who are they?)



As Obama acknowledged in his press statement Sunday morning, the United States and Iran still have conflicting interests on many issues. Iran still supports terrorist movements in the Middle East, and it recently test-fired ballistic missiles in violation of U.N. Security Council resolutions. Sanctions imposed for those reasons, by the way, remain in place. In fact, shortly after the prisoners were out of Iranian airspace,  Obama imposed new sanctions against Iranians involved in the ballistic-missile program.



But the centuries-long history of international relations shows that it’s possible for adversaries—even, during the Soviet-American Cold War, bitter foes who have the ability to incinerate each other in a matter of minutes—to negotiate deals that benefit the security interests of both sides, and to do so in ways that might open up avenues of accord in other realms worth exploring.



This is what Obama’s approach to foreign policy—which isn’t so different from the approach of many past presidents—has wrought this week. It’s an approach and an outcome that most of the Republican candidates not only couldn’t pull off but explicitly, if bizarrely, condemn."



Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    10 years ago

Donald Trump  tried to resolve the cognitive dissonance by claiming personal credit for the release. “I’ve been hitting them hard, and I think I might’ve had something to do with it,” Trump said in a campaign stop on Saturday. (A minute later, though, he denounced the release anyway, saying it should have happened three or four years ago. How, he didn’t reveal.)

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    10 years ago

Now our pundits here can begin to explain how both sides are right and both sides are wrong, of course.  

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    10 years ago

You might think the prisoner release would put the Republicans in an awkward position.

Of course not. One of the remarkable characteristics of the Fox Nation echo chamber / feedback loop is that the talking heads are never wrong. When reality does not conform to their predictions... those predictions simply disappear. Are forgotten. 

History is not significant. 

Afghanistan is a good example. Ever since Alexander the Great, invaders have been "quagmired". The Soviet Union easily occupied the country... and then was defeated by CIA-armed Muslim guerilla fighters. (They weren't "terrorists"  because they were on our side.) America defeated the Taliban in just a few weeks... but is still quagmired there fourteen years later. 

Two thousand years of history... and the last fifty years of history... tell us the futility of using force in Afghanistan. But what is the GOP candidates' recipe? More troops. 

 

 

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    10 years ago

ROFL!  Well we can already tell from BO's policies he doesn't understand how the world works.  If the Republicans are as bad as BO then we really are in deep shit.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    10 years ago

we can already tell

Excellent! Would you mind presenting the evidence?

   talk to the hand    talk to the hand

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty  replied to  Bob Nelson   10 years ago

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson  replied to  Dean Moriarty   10 years ago

So you're a fan of Salon, now, Dean??

You do realize that Salon's business model is criticism of Obama from the left?

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty  replied to  Bob Nelson   10 years ago

Ya even the lefties know his foreign policy sucks. 

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6  replied to  Dean Moriarty   10 years ago

Well at least some of them do.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    10 years ago

These apologist arguments show how far divorced from reality the Obama true believers are. All of his many manifest failures are waived away while pretending Obama's own disastrous decisions haven't destabilized the world. Thankfully, google exists and Obama's failures are preserved for reality.  Look at what they said in the past and look at the world now.

Iraq. Iraq has been an unmitigated disaster. It was relatively stable when Bush left office and remained so into Obama's first term. Just ask Obama and Biden, who were gloating about how well Iraq was doing and that Iraq should be considered one of his finest accomplishments. 

Of course, he was making those pronouncements when he pushed to withdraw the troops over the strenuous objections of his military advisers and pretty much every informed politicians to the left and right.  But Obama didn't care about the situation on the ground, he wanted the credit for withdrawing the troops (which he took, repeatedly.)

Predictably, the stable Iraq descended into chaos and civil war. 

ISIS  When Obama took office, ISIS consisted of a few guys living in the desert. But after Obama prematurely withdrew the troops ISIS immediately stared to gain strength and Obama ignored them. In fact, his officials manipulated intelligence reports to downgrade their threat, which Obama was only to happy to do in public (the JV team) who he admitted not having a strategy to deal with after they started conquering Iraqi cities like Mosul.

Under his watch, ISIS went from a threat to sheep to the largest, most dangerous terrorist threat in the world that's killed thousands of innocent civilians across the globe.

Syria.  Obama started out praising Assad as a reformer and than made the empty "red line" threat as the Syrian civil war escalated. After Assad violated walked all over his "red line""  Obama claimed Assad's days were numbered. Years later Assad remains in power and looks to remain in power after Obama is out of office. Meanwhile the largest refugee crises in generations as Syria devolves into an failed state.

Egypt  Obama pushed for ouster of the American ally Mubarak in favor of the Muslim Brotherhood, which his administration brazenly lied and said was a secular organization. Egypt descended into an absolute hell hole with widespread genocidal acts perpetrated against Christians as the "non-secular" Muslim brotherhood implemented Sharia law, killed thousands and destroyed the economy. Even after the army rescued the country, the people of Egypt  remains much worse off then they were before Obama helped overthrow Mubarak.

Libya- With the example of Iraq fresh in their minds, Obama decided to overthrow a secular dictator without any idea what to do next. Predictably, Libya descended into hell and became a terrorist haven. ISIS now has their own city in Libya to rule. 

Russia- Russia after the famous "reset"Russia was supposedly such a good friend that Obama mocked Romney for claiming  that Russia remained our Geo-political rival. Russia preceded to start a war with and bite off large chunks of Ukraine while becoming  much more aggressive through out the world.  

Afghanistan- The situation in  Afghanistan has descended precipitously since Obama took office. The Afghan government has lost ground to the Taliban and more American soldiers have died under Obama than Bush. As the situation has steadily worsened, Obama has ignored his Generals and treated troop levels as a matter of politics instead of strategy.  

Lucky for Obama, the media stopped caring about dead Americans and casualty counts once bush left office, otherwise the exposure of what's been happening since he took office would have been calamitous.  

Iran George Bush famously negotiated with Iran but refused to make a deal that wasn't good for America (stopping uranium enrichment) Obama took over with the sole purpose of getting a deal, and he got one at tremendous cost to American interests. It accomplished none of items Obama claimed were important at the start of negotiations whole giving Iran everything.

Meanwhile, Iran has steeped up it's aggressive behavior, flaunted UN resolutions and been rewarded with 150 billion dollars and a path to a bomb. 

Everywhere you look Obama has left death and destruction behind as a result of his mistakes.  I could keep going, but what's the point. The true believers of the Church of Obama will continue to live int heir fantasy world.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober  replied to  Sean Treacy   10 years ago

Obama is def out of his league when it comes to foreign policy ...

 
 

Who is online



Tacos!


111 visitors