Intelligence Commnity Inspector General: Clinton emails had intel from most secretive, classified programs
EXCLUSIVE: Hillary Clinton's emails on her unsecured, homebrew server contained intelligence from the U.S. government's most secretive and highly classified programs, according to an unclassified letter from a top inspector general to senior lawmakers.
Fox News exclusively obtained the unclassified letter, sent Jan. 14 from Intelligence Community Inspector General I. Charles McCullough III. It laid out the findings of a recent comprehensive review by intelligence agencies that identified "several dozen" additional classified emails -- including specific intelligence known as "special access programs" (SAP).
That indicates a level of classification beyond even “top secret,” the label previously given to two emails found on her server, and brings even more scrutiny to the presidential candidate’s handling of the government’s closely held secrets.
“To date, I have received two sworn declarations from one [intelligence community] element. These declarations cover several dozen emails containing classified information determined by the IC element to be at the confidential, secret, and top secret/sap levels,” said the IG letter to lawmakers with oversight of the intelligence community and State Department. “According to the declarant, these documents contain information derived from classified IC element sources.”
Intelligence from a "special access program,” or SAP, is even more sensitive than that designated as "top secret" – as were two emails identified last summer in a random sample pulled from Clinton's private server she used as secretary of state. Access to a SAP is restricted to those with a "need-to-know" because exposure of the intelligence would likely reveal the source, putting a method of intelligence collection -- or a human asset -- at risk. Currently, some 1,340 emails designated “classified” have been found on Clinton’s server, though the Democratic presidential candidate insists the information was not classified at the time.
“There is absolutely no way that one could not recognize SAP material,” a former senior law enforcement with decades of experience investigating violations of SAP procedures told Fox News. “It is the most sensitive of the sensitive.”
This iframe is not allowed
Executive Order 13526 -- called "Classified National Security Information" and signed Dec. 29, 2009 -- sets out the legal framework for establishing special access programs. The order says the programs can only be authorized by the president, "the Secretaries of State, Defense, Energy, and Homeland Security, the Attorney General, and the Director of National Intelligence, or the principal deputy of each."
The programs are created when "the vulnerability of, or threat to, specific information is exceptional,” and “the number of persons who ordinarily will have access will be reasonably small and commensurate with the objective of providing enhanced protection for the information involved," it states.
According to court documents, former CIA Director David Petraeus was prosecuted for sharing intelligence from special access programs with his biographer and mistress Paula Broadwell. At the heart of his prosecution was a non-disclosure agreement where Petraeus agreed to protect these closely held government programs, with the understanding “unauthorized disclosure, unauthorized retention or negligent handling … could cause irreparable injury to the United States or be used to advantage by a foreign nation.” Clinton signed an identical non-disclosure agreement Jan. 22, 2009.
Fox News is told that the recent IG letter was sent to the leadership of the House and Senate intelligence committees and leaders of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, as well as the Office of the Director of National Intelligence (ODNI) and State Department inspector general.
Representatives for the ODNI and intelligence community inspector general had no comment.
In a statement, State Department spokesman John Kirby said, “The State Department is focused on and committed to releasing former Secretary Clinton’s emails in a manner that protects sensitive information. No one takes this more seriously than we do.”
The intelligence community IG was responding in his message to a November letter from the Republican chairmen of the Senate intelligence and foreign relations committees that questioned the State Department email review process after it was wrongly reported the intelligence community was retreating from the “top secret” designation.
As Fox News first reported , those two emails were “top secret” when they hit the server, and it is now considered a settled matter.
The intelligence agencies now have their own reviewers embedded at the State Department as part of the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) process. The reviewers are identifying intelligence of a potentially classified nature, and referring it to the relevant intelligence agency for further review.
There is no formal appeals process for classification, and the agency that generates the intelligence has final say. The State Department only has control over the fraction of emails that pertain to their own intelligence.
While the State Department and Clinton campaign have said the emails in questions were “retroactively classified” or “upgraded” – to justify the more than 1,300 classified emails on her server – those terms are meaningless under federal law.
The former federal law enforcement official said the finding in the January IG letter represents a potential violation of USC 18 Section 793, “ gross negligence ” in the handling of secure information under the Espionage Act.
Tags
Who is online
123 visitors

Intelligence from a "special access program,” or SAP, is even more sensitive than that designated as "top secret" – as were two emails identified last summer in a random sample pulled from Clinton's private server she used as secretary of state. Access to a SAP is restricted to those with a "need-to-know" because exposure of the intelligence would likely reveal the source, putting a method of intelligence collection -- or a human asset -- at risk.
Here is the IG's original letter to Congress:
Is she still too big to jail?
top super duper double secret probation secret
Said by someone who has never been in the military nor worked for the Feds .
Another "Fox News" exclusive. lol
Did you read the letter from the inspector General? Of course not. Just rely on your silly ad hominem attack and stay in your bubble, where hillary is a magical divinity capable of doing no wrong and all evicdence of her doing something wrong is parted some conspiracy.
Of course I read it. This was marked super secret at the time Clinton received it, kept it or sent it, right?
No ?
Oh.
Markings are irrelevant and you know that. I've looked at the statute, does it pertain to classified information or markings? Your "markings" defense may work with Democrats who will forgive her anything, but it's legally irrelevant.
Sean, you have been saying for a year that indictment of Hillary Clinton was imminent. You have even said, many months ago, that the same thing had been uncovered that has been uncovered in this letter, that she handled classified information, even top secret information.
Has it ever occurred to you to wonder why she hasn't been indicted yet? It has been known for many months that she was "breaking the law" according to you.
Obviously, the people making the recommendation for charges don't agree with you.
It is interesting that every few weeks we hear of a "bombshell" that is going to end her campaign, and then it doesn't, and a few weeks later we get another one, usually leaked to Fox News.
You don't have any curiosity about that Sean ?
She's too big to jail. Simple answer.
u have been saying for a year that indictment of Hillary Clinton was imminent
I doubt I ever said that. My position has been that she violated federal laws and because she is Hillary Clinton, Obama's AG won't prosecute her. This new evidence makes it more likely she will be indicted, but I still would never claim it's imminent. I'd be surprised if the FBI issues a recommendation either way before June or July. 12 months would be a very quick resolution.
Has it ever occurred to you to wonder why she hasn't been indicted yet?
Since I ultimately don't think she will be indicted, no. The FBI always moves slowly compiling as much evidence as possible. Given her position, the FBI would need to accumulate an overwhelming amount of evidence to recommend indictment, and that doesn't happen in a couple months.
t is interesting that every few weeks we hear of a "bombshell" that is going to end her campaign,
Of course these "bombshells" won't end her campaign. Criminal activity is not exactly a turn off to democratic voters. Violating national security laws won't cost her many votes in the primary.
Criminal activity is not exactly a turn off to democratic voters. Violating national security laws won't cost her many votes in the primary.
What's your take on two terms for a Republican war criminal, his VP and others in his administration?
Glass house, my friend.
Who? Barry?
What charges have been lodged in the United States by a competent authority against any of the previous administration?
What charges have been lodged in the United States by a competent authority against any of the previous administration?
Remember, Spikegary, you asked the question; and regardless of what you deem a "competent authority," facts are facts -- and extensively well/thoroughly documented facts, formally pursued or not, satisfy the burden of proof.
Your question is a fair one and I not only will not duck it, I'll answer it beyond any expectations.
First, I wrote the following several years ago … it ran in Philly newspapers. Once you read this, I'll proceed with a massive list of allegations and substantive backup. First things first.
____________________________________________________________________________
Two-thirds of Americans favor investigating whether the George W. Bush administration breached legal boundaries in its "war on terror," according to polls released this week by USA Today and Gallup.
Months ago, I asked my Congresswoman and U.S. Senators to prioritize;
(1) An investigation into TORTURE and other possible WAR CRIMES
(2) An investigation into DOMESTIC SPYING and a resultant purging of all data collected on American Citizens not related to probable cause or unlawful activity with public notification when such a purge has been executed. In the interest of justice and national integrity, there are no justifiable reasons - political, Constitutional or legal - for the failure of Congress to pursue zealously and vigorously, these items.
• The planning or action of an unprovoked attack on other countries are WAR CRIMES (Crimes Against Peace).
• CRIMINAL FRAUD -- "telling of an intentional lie causing financial or physical harm."
• MURDER -- "causing the unprovoked killing of another."
If the war crimes and other "shoes" fit and the Bush Administration wore them, we need to know. In the way the Nuremburg War Trials followed Nazi-perpetrated war crimes, so must a true judicial process follow the alleged Bush crimes; if it does not, America as a nation will be viewed by history as the criminal!
It would be a weak and unconscionable excuse for Congress to avoid such investigations because it "wants to look forward, not back at the past." Indeed - what illegal acts were ever prosecuted before being committed? Imagine a judge's response to a lawyer pleading; "Your Honor, I move for a dismissal of this case as the alleged crimes were committed weeks ago and, why dwell on the past?"
______________________________________________________________________________
Unfortunately, they, their colleagues and the Obama Administration blinked, IMO, out of political cowardice!
Stay tuned throughout the day.
And to all who may enter the discussion … let's have a discussion … spare me the thumbs and articulate positions.
By your own standards, shouldn't you wait until Bush or Cheney was convicted of war crimes before calling them war criminals?
Let me quote you: "but in America, because of what is referred to as …
The presumption of innocence, sometimes referred to by the Latin expression Ei incumbit probatio qui dicit, non qui negat …
… the burden of proof is on the one who declares, not on one who denies … which means …
… one is considered innocent unless proven guilty.
Unless the right-wing slime machine can rally its minions to disregard that American protocol.
It would be interesting if one of you so quick to run with stories like this … were to be accused of some bad shit … and before you had your day in court, the allegation ran all over your hometown media.
Then you'd develop the quality of empathy."
By your own standards, shouldn't you wait until Bush or Cheney was convicted of war crimes before calling them war criminals?
Oh, suddenly Sean got religion.
But you are correct … still, on the other hand, If you back off, I will.
The difference between Bush and Clinton is that, with regard to Bush, Congress was presented with thirty-plus SPECIFIC AND HIGHLY DETAILED ALLEGATIONS which they chose not to act! And of course, I'll be all to happy to present every last detail.
With Clinton, who clearly appears to have been either sloppy or worse, for whatever reason(s) -- interest-of-justice? (unlike re: Bush) the righties in Congress have pushed this investigation along.
Don't get me wrong … it should be investigated.
But let's cut the partisan bullshit/selective indignation. Demanding/expecting integrity from elected officials is the correct thing to do … but do it across the board … and if you don't, I'll call you on it.
The planning or action of an unprovoked attack on other countries are WAR CRIMES (Crimes Against Peace).
If the country being attacked refuses to cooperate by harboring terrorists that accusation is invalid .
CRIMINAL FRAUD -- "telling of an intentional lie causing financial or physical harm."
Proof of intention is difficult at best or impossible at worst .
MURDER -- "causing the unprovoked killing of another."
Yup , war is hell ...
Yup , war is hell ...
No question, Petey … but even war has rules and attendant laws.
So let me be more detailed.
CREATING A SECRET PROPAGANDA CAMPAIGN TO MANUFACTURE A FALSE CASE FOR WAR AGAINST IRAQ
In his conduct while President of the United States, George W. Bush, in violation of his constitutional oath to faithfully execute the office of President of the United States and, to the best of his ability, preserve, protect, and defend the Constitution of the United States, and in violation of his constitutional duty under Article II, Section 3 of the Constitution "to take care that the laws be faithfully executed", has both personally and acting through his agents and subordinates, together with the Vice President, illegally spent public dollars on a secret propaganda program to manufacture a false cause for war against Iraq.
The Department of Defense (DOD) has engaged in a years-long secret domestic propaganda campaign to promote the invasion and occupation of Iraq. This secret program was defended by the White House Press Secretary following its exposure. This program follows the pattern of crimes detailed in Article I, II, IV and VIII.. The mission of this program placed it within the field controlled by the White House Iraq Group (WHIG), a White House task-force formed in August 2002 to market an invasion of Iraq to the American people. The group included Karl Rove, I. Lewis Libby, Condoleezza Rice, Karen Hughes, Mary Matalin, Stephen Hadley, Nicholas E. Calio, and James R. Wilkinson.
The WHIG produced white papers detailing so-called intelligence of Iraq's nuclear threat that later proved to be false. This supposed intelligence included the claim that Iraq had sought uranium from Niger as well as the claim that the high strength aluminum tubes Iraq purchased from China were to be used for the sole purpose of building centrifuges to enrich uranium. Unlike the National Intelligence Estimate of 2002, the WHIG's white papers provided "gripping images and stories" and used "literary license" with intelligence. The WHIG's white papers were written at the same time and by the same people as speeches and talking points prepared for President Bush and some of his top officials.
The WHIG also organized a media blitz in which, between September 7-8, 2002, President Bush and his top advisers appeared on numerous interviews and all provided similarly gripping images about the possibility of nuclear attack by Iraq. The timing was no coincidence, as Andrew Card explained in an interview regarding waiting until after Labor Day to try to sell the American people on military action against Iraq, "From a marketing point of view, you don't introduce new products in August."
September 7-8, 2002:
NBC's "Meet the Press: Vice President Cheney accused Saddam of moving aggressively to develop nuclear weapons over the past 14 months to add to his stockpile of chemical and biological arms.
CNN: Then-National Security Adviser Rice said, regarding the likelihood of Iraq obtaining a nuclear weapon, "We don't want the smoking gun to be a mushroom cloud."
CBS: President Bush declared that Saddam was "six months away from developing a weapon," and cited satellite photos of construction in Iraq where weapons inspectors once visited as evidence that Saddam was trying to develop nuclear arms.
The Pentagon military analyst propaganda program was revealed in an April 20, 2002, New York Times article. The program illegally involved "covert attempts to mold opinion through the undisclosed use of third parties." Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld recruited 75 retired military officers and gave them talking points to deliver on Fox, CNN, ABC, NBC, CBS, and MSNBC, and according to the New York Times report, which has not been disputed by the Pentagon or the White House, "Participants were instructed not to quote their briefers directly or otherwise describe their contacts with the Pentagon."
According to the Pentagon's own internal documents, the military analysts were considered "message force multipliers" or "surrogates" who would deliver administration "themes and messages" to millions of Americans "in the form of their own opinions." In fact, they did deliver the themes and the messages but did not reveal that the Pentagon had provided them with their talking points. Robert S. Bevelacqua, a retired Green Beret and Fox News military analyst described this as follows: "It was them saying, 'We need to stick our hands up your back and move your mouth for you.'"
Congress has restricted annual appropriations bills since 1951 with this language: "No part of any appropriation contained in this or any other Act shall be used for publicity or propaganda purposes within the United States not heretofore authorized by the Congress."
A March 21, 2005, report by the Congressional Research Service states that "publicity or propaganda" is defined by the U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO) to mean either (1) self-aggrandizement by public officials, (2) purely partisan activity, or (3) "covert propaganda."
These concerns about "covert propaganda" were also the basis for the GAO's standard for determining when government-funded video news releases are illegal:
"The failure of an agency to identify itself as the source of a prepackaged news story misleads the viewing public by encouraging the viewing audience to believe that the broadcasting news organization developed the information. The prepackaged news stories are purposefully designed to be indistinguishable from news segments broadcast to the public. When the television viewing public does not know that the stories they watched on television news programs about the government were in fact prepared by the government, the stories are, in this sense, no longer purely factual -- the essential fact of attribution is missing."
The White House's own Office of Legal Council stated in a memorandum written in 2005 following the controversy over the Armstrong Williams scandal:
"Over the years, GAO has interpreted 'publicity or propaganda' restrictions to preclude use of appropriated funds for, among other things, so-called 'covert propaganda.' ... Consistent with that view, the OLC determined in 1988 that a statutory prohibition on using appropriated funds for 'publicity or propaganda' precluded undisclosed agency funding of advocacy by third-party groups. We stated that 'covert attempts to mold opinion through the undisclosed use of third parties' would run afoul of restrictions on using appropriated funds for 'propaganda.'"
Asked about the Pentagon's propaganda program at White House press briefing in April 2008, White House Press Secretary Dana Perino defended it, not by arguing that it was legal but by suggesting that it "should" be: "Look, I didn't know look, I think that you guys should take a step back and look at this look, DOD has made a decision, they've decided to stop this program. But I would say that one of the things that we try to do in the administration is get information out to a variety of people so that everybody else can call them and ask their opinion about something. And I don't think that that should be against the law. And I think that it's absolutely appropriate to provide information to people who are seeking it and are going to be providing their opinions on it. It doesn't necessarily mean that all of those military analysts ever agreed with the administration. I think you can go back and look and think that a lot of their analysis was pretty tough on the administration. That doesn't mean that we shouldn't talk to people."
In all of these actions and decisions, President George W. Bush has acted in a manner contrary to his trust as President and Commander in Chief, and subversive of constitutional government, to the prejudice of the cause of law and justice and to the manifest injury of the people of the United States. Wherefore, President George W. Bush, by such conduct, is guilty of an impeachable offense warranting removal from office.
Documentation:
David Barstow, Behind TV Analysts: Pentagon’s Hidden Hand , New York Times, April 20, 2008.
Pentagon Pundit Scandal Broke the Law , the Center for Media and Democracy.
Joshua Bolton, Memorandum For Heads of Departments and Agencies: Use of Government funds for Video News Releases , March 11, 2005.
Steven G. Bradbury, Memorandum For The General Counsels of the Executive Branch , March 1, 2005.
Carl Levin’s Letter to Secretary of Defense Robert Gates , April 22, 2008.
Congresswoman Rosa L. DeLauro’s letter to major news outlets asking them to disclose Ethics Standards for Military Analysts , April 24, 2008.
NBC Meet the Press, Interview with Dick Cheney , September 8, 2002.
New York Times, Parts of the Message Machine: Excerpts from Documents , April 19, 2008.
Rep. Paul Hodes, Congressman Hodes Calls for Hearing on Bush Administration Manipulation of Iraq War News Analysts , April 24, 2008.
David Barstow, Two Inquiries Set on Pentagon Publicity Effort , May 24, 2008.
______________________________________________________________
Feel free to continue to challenge.
I have much, much more.
This is about Billary - quit throwing Georgie and his boys in the discussion. As a moderator, you know better - stay on topic, regardless of the questions you love to get (or think you got) that are thrown at you.
C'mon Mac - play the game the right way - please
As a moderator, you know better
1st,
I'm not moderating, I'm posting as a member … and this is in direct response to a specific comment as I noted.
If responses to blanket indictments receive no response, they go on and on.
Can't allow that.
No Mac - YOU intentionally went off topic with your comment that had NOTHING to do with Sean's question -
"
01/19/16 07:51:20PM @A-Macarthur :
Criminal activity is not exactly a turn off to democratic voters. Violating national security laws won't cost her many votes in the primary.
What's your take on two terms for a Republican war criminal, his VP and others in his administration ?
Glass house, my friend."
Sean's comment dealt with Billary and nothing else - Billary.
Why did you have to go off topic?
Sean's comment dealt with Billary and nothing else - Billary.
Sean's comment had also to do with national security and a President lying the country into war certainly has national security implications.
When a member opens a can of worms, they tend to crawl around.
Fire the first shot and take your chances regarding return fire. I'm sick of the demagoguery that goes on here … I won't let a broad brush allegation go un-challenged … to let one stand gives the false impression that it's irrefutable … and invites more of the same.
Rather than get on my case for reacting, admonish those who think they can hit and run.
Mac ,
has both personally and acting through his agents and subordinates, together with the Vice President, illegally spent public dollars on a secret propaganda program to manufacture a false cause for war against Iraq.
Meh ... Minor expense . And falsity is hard to substantiate in a dynamically changing event .
As to the rest of that fire hdyrant load coming out of your puter , I only point out that the top Dems were all behind these allegations about Iraq . It should be understandable to any rational westerner that Saddam Hussein was a very dangerous dictator . Preventing him from even the possibility of having nukes was a goal worth pursuing ...
Petey,
You can equivocate the language but it doesn't change the reality and the documentation which is pinpointed and voluminous.
I don't want to play word games … I didn't write the documentation, and, beyond that, as I have explained, this came about because of a blanket indictment made as if only one party has its misbehavior, criminals and foolish jackasses.
Allowing a a broad-brush piece of demagoguery to go unanswered is to invite an endless barrage of more. I'm a counter-puncher … i rarely toss the first one.
It should be understandable to any rational westerner that Saddam Hussein was a very dangerous dictator . Preventing him from even the possibility of having nukes was a goal worth pursuing ...
No one argues that, Petey … but we didn't go into Iraq because Saddam was a "very dangerous dictator," we went because of the non-existent WMD's, the phony "intelligence" and the orchestrated lies … some of which I've posted or alluded to … lies that were told and later debunked … told on television interviews for example.
I can post endless particulars … unless we call impasse.
I don't want to play word games
Of course you do . You throw around infrequently used language like equivocate but it does not apply to what I said . I have successfully disputed the points you made but you do nothing to refute what I said except to broadly dismiss with a wave of your semantic hand .
but we didn't go into Iraq because Saddam was a "very dangerous dictator," we went because of the non-existent WMD's
How do you distinguish between the 2 ?
but we didn't go into Iraq because Saddam was a "very dangerous dictator," we went because of the non-existent WMD's
How do you distinguish between the 2 ?
The devil you know … the premise for invading Iraq was not to be the world cop and take out a bad guy … it was because Saddam allegedly posed an imminent threat …
I'll pos the specifics if you like … the lies, who told them, when they were told … Bush destabilized the region … Iran for one was in check while Saddam was in Iraq … now we have ISIS because of the destabilization.
Last two …
I'm not wasting anymore time trying to discuss with members what they'll equivocate because they cannot viably rebut.
Nothing personal.
Falsely, Systematically, and With Criminal Intent Conflating the Attacks of September 11, 2001 With Misrepresentation of Iraq as an Imminent Security Threat as Part of a Fraudulent Justification for a War of Aggression
In his conduct while President of the United States, George W. Bush, in violation of his constitutional oath to faithfully execute the office of President of the United States and, to the best of his ability, preserve, protect, and defend the Constitution of the United States, and in violation of his constitutional duty under article II, section 3 of the Constitution ‘to take care that the laws be faithfully executed’, has both personally and acting through his agents and subordinates, together with the Vice President, executed a calculated and wide-ranging strategy to deceive the citizens and Congress of the United States into believing that there was and is a connection between Iraq and Saddam Hussein on the one hand, and the attacks of September 11, 2001, and al Qaeda, on the other hand, so as to falsely justify the use of the United States Armed Forces against the nation of Iraq in a manner that is damaging to the national security interests of the United States, as well as to fraudulently obtain and maintain congressional authorization and funding for the use of such military force against Iraq, thereby interfering with and obstructing Congress’s lawful functions of overseeing foreign affairs and declaring war.
The means used to implement this deception were and continue to be, first, allowing, authorizing and sanctioning the manipulation of intelligence analysis by those under his direction and control, including the Vice President and the Vice President’s agents, and second, personally making, or causing, authorizing and allowing to be made through highly-placed subordinates, including the President’s Chief of Staff, the White House Press Secretary and other White House spokespersons, the Secretaries of State and Defense, the National Security Advisor, and their deputies and spokespersons, false and fraudulent representations to the citizens of the United States and Congress regarding an alleged connection between Saddam Hussein and Iraq, on the one hand, and the September 11th attacks and al Qaeda, on the other hand, that were half-true, literally true but misleading, and/or made without a reasonable basis and with reckless indifference to their truth, as well as omitting to state facts necessary to present an accurate picture of the truth as follows:
(1) On or about September 12, 2001, former terrorism advisor Richard Clarke personally informed the President that neither Saddam Hussein nor Iraq was responsible for the September 11th attacks. On September 18, Clarke submitted to the President’s National Security Adviser Condoleezza Rice a memo he had written in response to George W. Bush’s specific request that stated: (1) the case for linking Hussein to the September 11th attacks was weak; (2) only anecdotal evidence linked Hussein to al Qaeda; (3) Osama Bin Laden resented the secularism of Saddam Hussein; and (4) there was no confirmed reporting of Saddam Hussein cooperating with Bin Laden on unconventional weapons.
(2) Ten days after the September 11th attacks the President received a President’s Daily Briefing which indicated that the U.S. intelligence community had no evidence linking Saddam Hussein to the September 11th attacks and that there was ‘scant credible evidence that Iraq had any significant collaborative ties with Al Qaeda’.
(3) In Defense Intelligence Terrorism Summary No. 044-02, issued in February 2002, the United States Defense Intelligence Agency cast significant doubt on the possibility of a Saddam Hussein-al Qaeda conspiracy: ‘Saddam’s regime is intensely secular and is wary of Islamic revolutionary movements. Moreover, Baghdad is unlikely to provide assistance to a group it cannot control.’.
(4) The October 2002 National Intelligence Estimate gave a ‘Low Confidence’ rating to the notion of whether ‘in desperation Saddam would share chemical or biological weapons with Al Qaeda’. The CIA never informed the President that there was an operational relationship between al Qaeda and Saddam Hussein; on the contrary, its most ‘aggressive’ analysis contained in ‘Iraq and al-Qa’ida: Interpreting a Murky Relationship’ dated June 21, 2002, was that Iraq had had ‘sporadic, wary contacts with al-Qa’ida since the mid-1990s rather than a relationship with al-Qa’ida that has developed over time’.
(5) Notwithstanding his knowledge that neither Saddam Hussein nor Iraq was in any way connected to the September 11th attacks, the President allowed and authorized those acting under his direction and control, including Vice President Richard B. Cheney and Lewis Libby, who reported directly to both the President and the Vice President, and Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld, among others, to pressure intelligence analysts to alter their assessments and to create special units outside of, and unknown to, the intelligence community in order to secretly obtain unreliable information, to manufacture intelligence or reinterpret raw data in ways that would further the Bush administration’s goal of fraudulently establishing a relationship not only between Iraq and al Qaeda, but between Iraq and the attacks of September 11th.
(6) Further, despite his full awareness that Iraq and Saddam Hussein had no relationship to the September 11th attacks, the President, and those acting under his direction and control have, since at least 2002 and continuing to the present, repeatedly issued public statements deliberately worded to mislead, words calculated in their implication to bring unrelated actors and circumstances into an artificially contrived reality thereby facilitating the systematic deception of Congress and the American people. Thus the public and some members of Congress, came to believe, falsely, that there was a connection between Iraq and the attacks of 9/11. This was accomplished through well-publicized statements by the Bush Administration which contrived to continually tie Iraq and 9/11 in the same statements of grave concern without making an explicit charge:
(A) ‘[If] Iraq regimes [sic] continues to defy us, and the world, we will move deliberately, yet decisively, to hold Iraq to account. . . . It’s a new world we’re in. We used to think two oceans could separate us from an enemy. On that tragic day, September the 11th, 2001, we found out that’s not the case. We found out this great land of liberty and of freedom and of justice is vulnerable. And therefore we must do everything we can--everything we can--to secure the homeland, to make us safe.’ Speech of President Bush in Iowa on September 16, 2002.
(B) ‘With every step the Iraqi regime takes toward gaining and deploying the most terrible weapons, our own options to confront that regime will narrow. And if an emboldened regime were to supply these weapons to terrorist allies, then the attacks of September 11th would be a prelude to far greater horrors.’ March 6, 2003, Statement of President Bush in National Press Conference.
(C) ‘The battle of Iraq is one victory in a war on terror that began on September the 11, 2001--and still goes on. That terrible morning, 19 evil men--the shock troops of a hateful ideology--gave America and the civilized world a glimpse of their ambitions. They imagined, in the words of one terrorist, that September the 11th would be the ‘beginning of the end of America’. By seeking to turn our cities into killing fields, terrorists and their allies believed that they could destroy this nation’s resolve, and force our retreat from the world. They have failed.’ May 1, 2003, Speech of President Bush on U.S.S. Abraham Lincoln.
(D) ‘Now we’re in a new and unprecedented war against violent Islamic extremists. This is an ideological conflict we face against murderers and killers who try to impose their will. These are the people that attacked us on September the 11th and killed nearly 3,000 people. The stakes are high, and once again, we have had to change our strategic thinking. The major battleground in this war is Iraq.’ June 28, 2007, Speech of President Bush at the Naval War College in Newport, Rhode Island.
(7) Notwithstanding his knowledge that there was no credible evidence of a working relationship between Saddam Hussein and al Qaeda and that the intelligence community had specifically assessed that there was no such operational relationship, the President, both personally and through his subordinates and agents, has repeatedly falsely represented, both explicitly and implicitly, and through the misleading use of selectively-chosen facts, to the citizens of the United States and to the Congress that there was and is such an ongoing operational relationship, to wit:
(A) ‘We know that Iraq and al Qaeda have had high-level contacts that go back a decade. Some al Qaeda leaders who fled Afghanistan went to Iraq. These include one very senior al Qaeda leader who received medical treatment in Baghdad this year, and who has been associated with planning for chemical and biological attacks. We’ve learned that Iraq has trained al Qaeda members in bomb-making and poisons and deadly gases.’ September 28, 2002, Weekly Radio Address of President Bush to the Nation.
(B) ‘[W]e we need to think about Saddam Hussein using al Qaeda to do his dirty work, to not leave fingerprints behind.’ October 14, 2002, Remarks by President Bush in Michigan.
(C) ‘We know he’s got ties with al Qaeda.’ November 1, 2002, Speech of President Bush in New Hampshire.
(D) ‘Evidence from intelligence sources, secret communications, and statements by people now in custody reveal that Saddam Hussein aids and protects terrorists, including members of al Qaeda. Secretly, and without fingerprints, he could provide one of his hidden weapons to terrorists, or help them develop their own.’ January 28, 2003, President Bush’s State of the Union Address.
(E) ‘[W]hat I want to bring to your attention today is the potentially much more sinister nexus between Iraq and the al Qaeda terrorist network, a nexus that combines classic terrorist organizations and modern methods of murder. Iraq today harbors a deadly terrorist network. . . .’ February 5, 2003, Speech of Former Secretary of State Colin Powell to the United Nations.
(F) ‘The battle of Iraq is one victory in a war on terror that began on September the 11, 2001--and still goes on. . . . [T]he liberation of Iraq . . . removed an ally of al Qaeda.’ May 1, 2003, Speech of President Bush on U.S.S. Abraham Lincoln.
(8) The Senate Select Committee on Intelligence Report on Whether Public Statements Regarding Iraq by U.S. Government Officials Were Substantiated by Intelligence Information, which was released on June 5, 2008, concluded that:
(A) ‘Statements and implications by the President and Secretary of State suggesting that Iraq and al-Qa’ida had a partnership, or that Iraq had provided al-Qa’ida with weapons training, were not substantiated by the intelligence.’.
(B) ‘The Intelligence Community did not confirm that Muhammad Atta met an Iraqi intelligence officer in Prague in 2001 as the Vice President repeatedly claimed.’.
Through his participation and instance in the breathtaking scope of this deception, the President has used the highest office of trust to wage a campaign of deception of such sophistication as to deliberately subvert the national security interests of the United States. His dishonesty set the stage for the loss of more than 4,000 United States servicemembers; injuries to tens of thousands of soldiers, the loss of more than 1,000,000 innocent Iraqi citizens since the United States invasion; the loss of approximately $527 billion in war costs which has increased our Federal debt and the ultimate expenditure of three to five trillion dollars for all costs covering the war; the loss of military readiness within the United States Armed Services due to overextension, the lack of training and lack of equipment; the loss of United States credibility in world affairs; and the decades of likely blowback created by the invasion of Iraq.
In all of these actions and decisions, President George W. Bush has acted in a manner contrary to his trust as President and Commander in Chief, and subversive of constitutional government, to the prejudice of the cause of law and justice and to the manifest injury of the people of the United States. Wherefore, President George W. Bush, by such conduct, is guilty of an impeachable offense warranting removal from office.
Article III--Misleading the American People and Members of Congress To Believe Iraq Possessed Weapons of Mass Destruction, so as To Manufacture a False Case for War
In his conduct while President of the United States, George W. Bush, in violation of his constitutional oath to faithfully execute the office of President of the United States and, to the best of his ability, preserve, protect, and defend the Constitution of the United States, and in violation of his constitutional duty under article II, section 3 of the Constitution ‘to take care that the laws be faithfully executed’, has both personally and acting through his agents and subordinates, together with the Vice President, executed instead a calculated and wide-ranging strategy to deceive the citizens and Congress of the United States into believing that the nation of Iraq possessed weapons of mass destruction in order to justify the use of the United States Armed Forces against the nation of Iraq in a manner damaging to our national security interests, thereby interfering with and obstructing Congress’s lawful functions of overseeing foreign affairs and declaring war.
The means used to implement this deception were and continue to be personally making, or causing, authorizing and allowing to be made through highly-placed subordinates, including the President’s Chief of Staff, the White House Press Secretary and other White House spokespersons, the Secretaries of State and Defense, the National Security Advisor, and their deputies and spokespersons, false and fraudulent representations to the citizens of the United States and Congress regarding Iraq’s alleged possession of biological, chemical and nuclear weapons that were half-true, literally true but misleading, and/or made without a reasonable basis and with reckless indifference to their truth, as well as omitting to state facts necessary to present an accurate picture of the truth as follows:
(1) Long before the March 19, 2003, invasion of Iraq, a wealth of intelligence informed the President and those under his direction and control that Iraq’s stockpiles of chemical and biological weapons had been destroyed well before 1998 and that there was little, if any, credible intelligence that showed otherwise. As reported in the Washington Post in March of 2003, in 1995, Saddam Hussein’s son-in-law Hussein Kamel had informed U.S. and British intelligence officers that ‘all weapons--biological, chemical, missile, nuclear were destroyed.’ In September 2002, the Defense Intelligence Agency issued a report that concluded: ‘A substantial amount of Iraq’s chemical warfare agents, precursors, munitions and production equipment were destroyed between 1991 and 1998 as a result of Operation Desert Storm and UNSCOM actions . . . [T]here is no reliable information on whether Iraq is producing and stockpiling chemical weapons or whether Iraq has--or will--establish its chemical warfare agent production facilities.’ Notwithstanding the absence of evidence proving that such stockpiles existed and in direct contradiction to substantial evidence that showed they did not exist, the President and his subordinates and agents made numerous false representations claiming with certainty that Iraq possessed chemical and biological weapons that it was developing to use to attack the United States, to wit:
(A) ‘[T]he notion of a Saddam Hussein with his great oil wealth, with his inventory that he already has of biological and chemical weapons . . . is, I think, a frightening proposition for anybody who thinks about it.’ Statement of Vice President Cheney on CBS’s Face the Nation, March 24, 2002.
(B) ‘In defiance of the United Nations, Iraq has stockpiled biological and chemical weapons, and is rebuilding the facilities used to make more of those weapons.’ Speech of President Bush, October 5, 2002.
(C) ‘All the world has now seen the footage of an Iraqi Mirage aircraft with a fuel tank modified to spray biological agents over wide areas. Iraq has developed spray devices that could be used on unmanned aerial vehicles with ranges far beyond what is permitted by the Security Council. A UAV launched from a vessel off the American coast could reach hundreds of miles inland.’ Statement by President Bush from the White House, February 6, 2003.
(2) Despite overwhelming intelligence in the form of statements and reports filed by and on behalf of the CIA, the State Department and the IAEA, among others, which indicated that the claim was untrue, the President, and those under his direction and control, made numerous representations claiming and implying through misleading language that Iraq was attempting to purchase uranium from Niger in order to falsely buttress its argument that Iraq was reconstituting its nuclear weapons program, including:
(A) ‘The regime has the scientists and facilities to build nuclear weapons, and is seeking the materials needed to do so.’ Statement of President Bush from White House, October 2, 2002.
(B) ‘The [Iraqi] report also failed to deal with issues which have arisen since 1998, including: . . . attempts to acquire uranium and the means to enrich it.’ Letter from President Bush to Vice President Cheney and the Senate, January 20, 2003.
(C) ‘The British Government has learned that Saddam Hussein recently sought significant quantities of uranium from Africa.’ President Bush Delivers State of the Union Address, January 28, 2003.
(3) Despite overwhelming evidence in the form of reports by nuclear weapons experts from the Energy, the Defense and State Departments, as well from outside and international agencies which assessed that aluminum tubes the Iraqis were purchasing were not suitable for nuclear centrifuge use and were, on the contrary, identical to ones used in rockets already being manufactured by the Iraqis, the President, and those under his direction and control, persisted in making numerous false and fraudulent representations implying and stating explicitly that the Iraqis were purchasing the tubes for use in a nuclear weapons program, to wit:
(A) ‘We do know that there have been shipments going . . . into Iraq . . . of aluminum tubes that really are only suited to--high-quality aluminum tools [sic] that are only really suited for nuclear weapons programs, centrifuge programs.’ Statement of then National Security Advisor Condoleezza Rice on CNN’s Late Edition with Wolf Blitzer, September 8, 2002.
(B) ‘Our intelligence sources tell us that he has attempted to purchase high-strength aluminum tubes suitable for nuclear weapons production.’ President Bush’s State of the Union Address, January 28, 2003.
(C) ‘[H]e has made repeated covert attempts to acquire high-specification aluminum tubes from 11 different countries, even after inspections resumed. . . . By now, just about everyone has heard of these tubes and we all know that there are differences of opinion. There is controversy about what these tubes are for. Most U.S. experts think they are intended to serve as rotors in centrifuges used to enrich uranium.’ Speech of Former Secretary of State Colin Powell to the United Nations, February 5, 2003.
(4) The President, both personally and acting through those under his direction and control, suppressed material information, selectively declassified information for the improper purposes of retaliating against a whistleblower and presenting a misleading picture of the alleged threat from Iraq, facilitated the exposure of the identity of a covert CIA operative and thereafter not only failed to investigate the improper leaks of classified information from within his administration, but also failed to cooperate with an investigation into possible federal violations resulting from this activity and, finally, entirely undermined the prosecution by commuting the sentence of Lewis Libby citing false and insubstantial grounds, all in an effort to prevent Congress and the citizens of the United States from discovering the fraudulent nature of the President’s claimed justifications for the invasion of Iraq.
(5) The Senate Select Committee on Intelligence Report on Whether Public Statements Regarding Iraq by U.S. Government Officials Were Substantiated by Intelligence Information, which was released on June 5, 2008, concluded that:
(A) ‘Statements by the President and Vice President prior to the October 2002 National Intelligence Estimate regarding Iraq’s chemical weapons production capability and activities did not reflect the intelligence community’s uncertainties as to whether such production was ongoing.’.
(B) ‘The Secretary of Defense’s statement that the Iraqi government operated underground WMD facilities that were not vulnerable to conventional airstrikes because they were underground and deeply buried was not substantiated by available intelligence information.’.
(C) Chairman of the Senate Intelligence Committee Jay Rockefeller concluded: ‘In making the case for war, the Administration repeatedly presented intelligence as fact when in reality it was unsubstantiated, contradicted, or even non-existent. As a result, the American people were led to believe that the threat from Iraq was much greater than actually existed.’.
The President has subverted the national security interests of the United States by setting the stage for the loss of more than 4,000 United States servicemembers and the injury to tens of thousands of U.S. soldiers; the loss of more than 1,000,000 innocent Iraqi citizens since the United States invasion; the loss of approximately $500 billion in war costs which has increased our Federal debt with a long term financial cost of between three and five trillion dollars; the loss of military readiness within the United States Armed Services due to overextension, the lack of training and lack of equipment; the loss of United States credibility in world affairs; and the decades of likely blowback created by the invasion of Iraq.
In all of these actions and decisions, President George W. Bush has acted in a manner contrary to his trust as President and Commander in Chief, and subversive of constitutional government, to the prejudice of the cause of law and justice and to the manifest injury of the people of the United States. Wherefore, President George W. Bush, by such conduct, is guilty of an impeachable offense warranting removal from office.
______________________________________________________________
I'm out.
I'm not wasting anymore time trying to discuss with members what they'll equivocate because they cannot viably rebut.
Maybe if you wouldn't put up such lengthy cut/paste jobs with no attempt to select just the material that is relevant you wouldn't get cold feet so often . Considering the event contexts that the 2nd Iraq war happened in , I think George Bush Jr. did an adequate job trying to reduce the potential threat . Making shit up in the way of phoney war crimes does not change that .
BTW it seems that everyone here has ways of weaseling out of arguments . Yours is a claim that I'm "equivocating" . But I think that is just a cop-out way of dealing with my points ...
When I ask a question you immediately dismiss it as rhetorical . That's pure chickenshit ... I refuse to accept such words games from you anymore and I find your dismissive attitude offensive .
Minor expense . And falsity is hard to substantiate in a dynamically changing event .
Equivocate this. (EQUIVOCATE -- use ambiguous language so as to conceal the truth or avoid committing oneself)
ILLEGALLY MISSPENDING FUNDS TO SECRETLY BEGIN A WAR OF AGGRESSION
In his conduct while President of the United States, George W. Bush, in violation of his constitutional oath to faithfully execute the office of President of the United States and, to the best of his ability, preserve, protect, and defend the Constitution of the United States, and in violation of his constitutional duty under Article II, Section 3 of the Constitution "to take care that the laws be faithfully executed", has both personally and acting through his agents and subordinates, together with the Vice President, illegally misspent funds to begin a war in secret prior to any Congressional authorization.
The president used over $2 billion in the summer of 2002 to prepare for the invasion of Iraq. First reported in Bob Woodward's book, Plan of Attack, and later confirmed by the Congressional Research Service, Bush took money appropriated by Congress for Afghanistan and other programs and—with no Congressional notification -- used it to build airfields in Qatar and to make other preparations for the invasion of Iraq. This constituted a violation of Article I, Section 9 of the U.S. Constitution, as well as a violation of the War Powers Act of 1973.
In all of these actions and decisions, President George W. Bush has acted in a manner contrary to his trust as President and Commander in Chief, and subversive of constitutional government, to the prejudice of the cause of law and justice and to the manifest injury of the people of the United States.
Wherefore, President George W. Bush, by such conduct, is guilty of an impeachable offense warranting removal from office.
Article VI.
INVADING IRAQ IN VIOLATION OF THE REQUIREMENTS OF HJRes114.
In his conduct while President of the United States, George W. Bush, in violation of his constitutional oath to faithfully execute the office of President of the United States and, to the best of his ability, preserve, protect, and defend the Constitution of the United States, and in violation of his constitutional duty under Article II, Section 3 of the Constitution "to take care that the laws be faithfully executed", exceeded his Constitutional authority to wage war by invading Iraq in 2003 without meeting the requirements of HJRes 114, the "Authorization for Use of Military Force Against Iraq Resolution of 2002" to wit: (1) HJRes 114 contains several Whereas clauses consistent with statements being made by the White House at the time regarding the threat from Iraq as evidenced by the following: A) HJRes 114 states "Whereas Iraq both poses a continuing threat to the national security of the United States and international peace and security in the Persian Gulf region and remains in material and unacceptable breach of its international obligations by, among other things, continuing to possess and develop a significant chemical and biological weapons capability, actively seeking a nuclear weapons capability, and supporting and harboring terrorist organizations;"; and (B) HJRes 114 states "Whereas members of Al Qaeda, an organization bearing responsibility for attacks on the United States, its citizens, and interests, including the attacks that occurred on September 11, 2001, are known to be in Iraq;".
(2) HJRes 114 states that the President must provide a determination, the truthfulness of which is implied, that military force is necessary in order to use the authorization, as evidenced by the following: (A) Section 3 of HJRes 114 states: "(b) PRESIDENTIAL DETERMINATION.—In connection with the exercise of the authority granted in subsection (a) to use force the President shall, prior to such exercise or as soon thereafter as may be feasible, but no later than 48 hours after exercising such authority, make available to the Speaker of the House of Representatives and the President pro tempore of the Senate his determination that— (1) reliance by the United States on further diplomatic or other peaceful means alone either (A) will not
adequately protect the national security of the United States against the continuing threat posed by Iraq or (B) is not likely to lead to enforcement of all relevant United Nations Security Council resolutions regarding Iraq; and (2) acting pursuant to this joint resolution is consistent with the United States and other countries continuing to take the necessary actions against international terrorist and terrorist organizations, including those nations, organizations, or persons who planned, authorized, committed or aided the terrorist attacks that occurred on September 11, 2001."
(3) On March 18, 2003, President George Bush sent a letter to Congress stating that he had made that determination as evidenced by the following: (A) March 18th, 2003 Letter to Congress stating: Consistent with section 3(b) of the Authorization for Use of Military Force Against Iraq Resolution of 2002 (Public Law 107-243), and based on information available to me, including that in the enclosed document, I determine that: (1) reliance by the United States on further diplomatic and other peaceful means alone will neither (A) adequately protect the national security of the United States against the continuing threat posed by Iraq nor (B) likely lead to enforcement of all relevant United Nations Security Council resolutions regarding Iraq; and (2) acting pursuant to the Constitution and Public Law 107-243 is consistent with the United States and other countries continuing to take the necessary actions against international terrorists and terrorist organizations, including those nations, organizations, or persons who planned, authorized, committed, or aided the terrorist attacks that occurred on September 11, 2001.
(4) President George Bush knew that these statements were false as evidenced by: (A) Information provided with Article I, II, III, IV and V. (B) A statement by President George Bush in an interview with Tony Blair on January 31st 2003: [WH] Reporter: "One question for you both. Do you believe that there is a link between Saddam Hussein, a direct link, and the men who attacked on September the 11th?"
President Bush: "I can't make that claim"
(C) An article on February 19th by Terrorism expert Rohan Gunaratna states "I could find no evidence of links between Iraq and Al Qaeda. The documentation and interviews indicated that Al Qaeda regarded Saddam, a secular leader, as an infidel." [InternationalHeraldTribune]
(D) According to a February 2nd, 2003 article in the New York Times: [NYT] At the Federal Bureau of Investigation, some investigators said they were baffled by the Bush
administration's insistence on a solid link between Iraq and Osama bin Laden's network. "We've been looking at this hard for more than a year and you know what, we just don't think it's there," a government official said.
(5) Section 3C of HJRes 114 states that "Nothing in this joint resolution supersedes any requirement of the War Powers Resolution."
(6) The War Powers Resolution Section 9(d)(1) states:
(d) Nothing in this joint resolution--
(1) is intended to alter the constitutional authority of the Congress or of the President, or the provision of existing treaties; or
(7) The United Nations Charter was an existing treaty and, as shown in Article VIII, the invasion of Iraq violated that treaty
(8) President George Bush knowingly failed to meet the requirements of HJRes 114 and violated the requirement of the War Powers Resolution and, thereby, invaded Iraq without the authority of Congress.
In all of these actions and decisions, President George W. Bush has acted in a manner contrary to his trust as President and Commander in Chief, and subversive of constitutional government, to the prejudice of the cause of law and justice and to the manifest injury of the people of the United States.
Wherefore, President George W. Bush, by such conduct, is guilty of an impeachable offense warranting removal from office.
Good night and that's it.
You must think all my time needs to be spent reading your large propaganda tracts . But I've got better things to do .
You must think all my time needs to be spent reading your large propaganda tracts . But I've got better things to do.
You likely have better things to do, no argument from me; but you are consistent in the use of …
A dismissive statement, that is any statement which negates the value of an opposing argument without actually addressing any of its substance .
Although it is not actually a valid form of argument, it is frequently phrased in such a way that it might be mistaken for one; this usage is a form of rhetorical deception .
Argument by collective dismissal is an especially severe form of this, in which multiple points are dismissed as a group without any of them being addressed.
Types
Real-world Usage
And this is on topic how???
And this is on topic how???
If you have followed the conversation, you'd see the sequence of comments that led to this.
In short, it began with a comment was made regarding the left-wing's love of criminals … implying rightly or wrongly that liberals would not repudiate Clinton (of course, until she's been convicted, some will hold out personal judgement); I've commented in this thread that if she is guilty as charged (which has not formally happened), that wrong-is-wrong regardless of the perpetrator's politics.
And if this were an ice hockey brawl … we had a "third man in" … so here we are.
Now you're almost caught up, 1st.
In the vernacular … someone throws a punch at me … I tend to punch back.
It sounds like Obama should be impeached for covering up Bush's crimes and not prosecuting.
It sounds like Obama should be impeached for covering up Bush's crimes and not prosecuting.
Well then, let's go chronologically … Bush would be first on the docket.
'Course, Obama didn't cover up Bush's crimes, Obama the Congress just lacked the balls to do the right thing and instead did the politically-innocuous thing … which was cowardly.
But let us begin … I'll post the short versions first, then if anyone cares to debate, I'll post the considerably longer and greatly-detailed versions.
Here we go Conservative loathers of dirty deeds … just the first of many.
Justification for invasion of Iraq
… the president with illegally creating a case for war with Iraq, including charges of a propaganda campaign, falsely representing Iraq as responsible for 9/11, and falsely representing Iraq as an imminent danger to the United States. [1]
If ya'll are gonna start at the beginning - Daddy Bush "said" Kuwait asked for our help so he knocked shit outta Saddam - little George "said" Saddam tried to assassinate "Daddy" which gave him the reason to start the "War on Terror" but, in '07, declared he'd won. So Obammer continued the fight, expanding into Afghan and the rest of the ME.
Kinda up-to-date? Still, Billary is guilty of mishandling classified information/material and "SHOULD" wind up in jail 'til Chelsea's rug-rat is 95.
Up-to-date … not even close.
Say when.
CREATING A SECRET PROPAGANDA CAMPAIGN TO MANUFACTURE A FALSE CASE FOR WAR AGAINST IRAQ
In his conduct while President of the United States, George W. Bush, in violation of his constitutional oath to faithfully execute the office of President of the United States and, to the best of his ability, preserve, protect, and defend the Constitution of the United States, and in violation of his constitutional duty under Article II, Section 3 of the Constitution "to take care that the laws be faithfully executed", has both personally and acting through his agents and subordinates, together with the Vice President, illegally spent public dollars on a secret propaganda program to manufacture a false cause for war against Iraq.
The Department of Defense (DOD) has engaged in a years-long secret domestic propaganda campaign to promote the invasion and occupation of Iraq. This secret program was defended by the White House Press Secretary following its exposure. This program follows the pattern of crimes detailed in Article I, II, IV and VIII.. The mission of this program placed it within the field controlled by the White House Iraq Group (WHIG), a White House task-force formed in August 2002 to market an invasion of Iraq to the American people. The group included Karl Rove, I. Lewis Libby, Condoleezza Rice, Karen Hughes, Mary Matalin, Stephen Hadley, Nicholas E. Calio, and James R. Wilkinson.
The WHIG produced white papers detailing so-called intelligence of Iraq's nuclear threat that later proved to be false. This supposed intelligence included the claim that Iraq had sought uranium from Niger as well as the claim that the high strength aluminum tubes Iraq purchased from China were to be used for the sole purpose of building centrifuges to enrich uranium. Unlike the National Intelligence Estimate of 2002, the WHIG's white papers provided "gripping images and stories" and used "literary license" with intelligence. The WHIG's white papers were written at the same time and by the same people as speeches and talking points prepared for President Bush and some of his top officials.
The WHIG also organized a media blitz in which, between September 7-8, 2002, President Bush and his top advisers appeared on numerous interviews and all provided similarly gripping images about the possibility of nuclear attack by Iraq. The timing was no coincidence, as Andrew Card explained in an interview regarding waiting until after Labor Day to try to sell the American people on military action against Iraq, "From a marketing point of view, you don't introduce new products in August."
September 7-8, 2002:
NBC's "Meet the Press: Vice President Cheney accused Saddam of moving aggressively to develop nuclear weapons over the past 14 months to add to his stockpile of chemical and biological arms.
CNN: Then-National Security Adviser Rice said, regarding the likelihood of Iraq obtaining a nuclear weapon, "We don't want the smoking gun to be a mushroom cloud."
CBS: President Bush declared that Saddam was "six months away from developing a weapon," and cited satellite photos of construction in Iraq where weapons inspectors once visited as evidence that Saddam was trying to develop nuclear arms.
The Pentagon military analyst propaganda program was revealed in an April 20, 2002, New York Times article. The program illegally involved "covert attempts to mold opinion through the undisclosed use of third parties." Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld recruited 75 retired military officers and gave them talking points to deliver on Fox, CNN, ABC, NBC, CBS, and MSNBC, and according to the New York Times report, which has not been disputed by the Pentagon or the White House, "Participants were instructed not to quote their briefers directly or otherwise describe their contacts with the Pentagon."
According to the Pentagon's own internal documents, the military analysts were considered "message force multipliers" or "surrogates" who would deliver administration "themes and messages" to millions of Americans "in the form of their own opinions." In fact, they did deliver the themes and the messages but did not reveal that the Pentagon had provided them with their talking points. Robert S. Bevelacqua, a retired Green Beret and Fox News military analyst described this as follows: "It was them saying, 'We need to stick our hands up your back and move your mouth for you.'"
Congress has restricted annual appropriations bills since 1951 with this language: "No part of any appropriation contained in this or any other Act shall be used for publicity or propaganda purposes within the United States not heretofore authorized by the Congress."
A March 21, 2005, report by the Congressional Research Service states that "publicity or propaganda" is defined by the U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO) to mean either (1) self-aggrandizement by public officials, (2) purely partisan activity, or (3) "covert propaganda."
These concerns about "covert propaganda" were also the basis for the GAO's standard for determining when government-funded video news releases are illegal:
"The failure of an agency to identify itself as the source of a prepackaged news story misleads the viewing public by encouraging the viewing audience to believe that the broadcasting news organization developed the information. The prepackaged news stories are purposefully designed to be indistinguishable from news segments broadcast to the public. When the television viewing public does not know that the stories they watched on television news programs about the government were in fact prepared by the government, the stories are, in this sense, no longer purely factual -- the essential fact of attribution is missing."
The White House's own Office of Legal Council stated in a memorandum written in 2005 following the controversy over the Armstrong Williams scandal:
"Over the years, GAO has interpreted 'publicity or propaganda' restrictions to preclude use of appropriated funds for, among other things, so-called 'covert propaganda.' ... Consistent with that view, the OLC determined in 1988 that a statutory prohibition on using appropriated funds for 'publicity or propaganda' precluded undisclosed agency funding of advocacy by third-party groups. We stated that 'covert attempts to mold opinion through the undisclosed use of third parties' would run afoul of restrictions on using appropriated funds for 'propaganda.'"
Asked about the Pentagon's propaganda program at White House press briefing in April 2008, White House Press Secretary Dana Perino defended it, not by arguing that it was legal but by suggesting that it "should" be: "Look, I didn't know look, I think that you guys should take a step back and look at this look, DOD has made a decision, they've decided to stop this program. But I would say that one of the things that we try to do in the administration is get information out to a variety of people so that everybody else can call them and ask their opinion about something. And I don't think that that should be against the law. And I think that it's absolutely appropriate to provide information to people who are seeking it and are going to be providing their opinions on it. It doesn't necessarily mean that all of those military analysts ever agreed with the administration. I think you can go back and look and think that a lot of their analysis was pretty tough on the administration. That doesn't mean that we shouldn't talk to people."
In all of these actions and decisions, President George W. Bush has acted in a manner contrary to his trust as President and Commander in Chief, and subversive of constitutional government, to the prejudice of the cause of law and justice and to the manifest injury of the people of the United States. Wherefore, President George W. Bush, by such conduct, is guilty of an impeachable offense warranting removal from office.
Documentation:
David Barstow, Behind TV Analysts: Pentagon’s Hidden Hand , New York Times, April 20, 2008.
Pentagon Pundit Scandal Broke the Law , the Center for Media and Democracy.
Joshua Bolton, Memorandum For Heads of Departments and Agencies: Use of Government funds for Video News Releases , March 11, 2005.
Steven G. Bradbury, Memorandum For The General Counsels of the Executive Branch , March 1, 2005.
Carl Levin’s Letter to Secretary of Defense Robert Gates , April 22, 2008.
Congresswoman Rosa L. DeLauro’s letter to major news outlets asking them to disclose Ethics Standards for Military Analysts , April 24, 2008.
NBC Meet the Press, Interview with Dick Cheney , September 8, 2002.
New York Times, Parts of the Message Machine: Excerpts from Documents , April 19, 2008.
Rep. Paul Hodes, Congressman Hodes Calls for Hearing on Bush Administration Manipulation of Iraq War News Analysts , April 24, 2008.
David Barstow, Two Inquiries Set on Pentagon Publicity Effort , May 24, 2008.
________________________________________________________________________________
I am not going to be dissuaded or badgered when I raise a point … if no one challenges … that's usually it, I leave it … if someone does … I'm ready to go on.
If someone merely replies with, "I disagree" and doesn't try to make it "case closed" (as some herein do), I'll often end it there, indicate we agree to disagree, and call it a day … but if the disagreement is a kind of comeback … then the discussion may well go on.
_________________________________________________________________________________
You're still invited to go fishing if you're ever out my way … politics aside.
I guess you also missed multiple articles and posts explaining that it does not have to be labeled. (on purpose?) Even though most of them were directed at you.
When you were a kid you used to stick your fingers in your ears and yell LALALALA when people said things you didn't want to hear didn't you?
Without intent this is probably something that would be handled administratively. Since she doesn't work there any more, they cannot suspend her or fire her.
As I said to Sean, it has been known for some time that she had e-mails that were LATER classified by the intelligence community. Obviously this nuance is not lost on the investigators, although it appears to be lost on you and Sean.
I suppose this is OK too:
Sen. Chuck Grassley said the email, released at about 1:30 am Friday morning along with about 3,000 other emails from Clinton's State Department tenure, is "disturbing," and " appears to show the former Secretary of State instructing a subordinate to remove the headings from a classified document and send it to her in an unsecure manner."
On June 16, 2011, top Clinton aide Jake Sullivan wrote to Clinton to say she would get "tps" -- presumably short for "talking points" that evening. The subject of the email is redacted so it's not clear what topic these points covered.
The next morning, Clinton wrote back to say she hadn't received them yet, and after a few minutes Sullivan responded that staff were having issues sending the document in a secure fax but that they were "working on it."
"If they can't," Clinton replies, "turn into nonpaper w no identifying heading and send nonsecure."
I guess you also missed multiple articles and posts explaining that it does not have to be labeled. (on purpose?) Even though most of them were directed at you.
When you were a kid you used to stick your fingers in your ears and yell LALALALA when people said things you didn't want to hear didn't you?
I may have … but I'm not a kid any more and when I am involved in a serious discussion with (alleged) adults … oh … I see my mistake now …
Thumb-away kids …
LALALALA …
Got it … now I'm communicating on their level.
Thanks for reminding me how to respond in kind.
Not so exclusive anymore NBC is reporting too.
Sorry this is on NBC News also, this morning. She broke security rules, rules that would send anyone else to jail, especially if you are in the military. This shows she is either not as smart as she thinks she is (I personally think she is very smart), very lazy or thinks the rules are for other people, not her.
This shows a lack of good judgment on her part. Is that what we need for President?
Based on the letter, it appears that the emails in question are still being reviewed for determination whether all or part of the content would be available under the FOIA. Until that is determined those involved in the investigation won't be able to finalize their findings. That's not to say there isn't anything here but I still think it's premature to come to any conclusions.
According to the Inspector General's letter, he's received sworn declarations form intelligence officials that were responsible for the content that dozens of emails were in fact classified, including two that contained "intelligence from a "special access program,” which is a higher classification than "Top Secret." Those documents cannot be released under the FOIA.
It's no longer a question of whether she violated the FOIA, it's whether she violated espionage laws through her handling of top secret information.
My problem with these sworn affidavits is that if they had merit she'd already have been served with some type of indictment but that hasn't happened. That's why I tend to think they are still information gathering and determining wrong doing, if any exist. Nothing they have at this time would hit it out of the park. This is fodder for those who are anxious to see criminal charges against her. As far as treason being leveled, I think that term is thrown around too easily these days and it's starting to lose its value. I wish our leaders would not release any of this information until they have something concrete that they can actually charge her with. This just adds to the divide between parties.
Yes, they are continuing their investigation,and until the investigation is complete, they won't recommend/ not recommend an indictment. The last thing they would do is issue piecemeal indictments each time they find evidence of a crime. Considering the investigation is about 6 months old, it's not surprising nothing has happened yet. It took years to finish investigating General Petreaus and that was a much narrower case then this.
If the FBI finds evidence of a crime, they will work to build the strongest possible case covering the most possible territory. They will then issue a report to the Department of Justice and it will be up to Obama's AG to indict or not to indict.
What will be interesting is if the FBI recommends indictment and DOJ decides against doing so.
Violated the FOIA? That's something totally different. To violate the FOIA, you have to fail to provide information requested that is not restricted. All classified is restricted.
Just trying to clarify. The FOIA request is for all e-mails, the request cannot and will not be fully approved due to classification issues (just because it was in her e-mails does not make it unclassified now, though potentially compromised). Just because someone makes a request, they will not necessarily receive what they are asking for.
Little clarification Gary - FOIA is for all information - not just e-mail traffic - and, yes, serious fines/issues can be/has been raised/awarded for failure to follow FOIA regulations.
The last paragraph of the Fox piece reads …
The former federal law enforcement official said the finding in the January IG letter represents a potential violation of USC 18 Section 793 , “ gross negligence ” in the handling of secure information under the Espionage Act.
___________________________________________________________________
If in fact said violation is substantiated, then we have a case … but in America, because of what is referred to as …
The presumption of innocence , sometimes referred to by the Latin expression Ei incumbit probatio qui dicit, non qui negat …
… the burden of proof is on the one who declares, not on one who denies … which means …
… one is considered innocent unless proven guilty.
Unless the right-wing slime machine can rally its minions to disregard that American protocol.
It would be interesting if one of you so quick to run with stories like this … were to be accused of some bad shit … and before you had your day in court, the allegation ran all over your hometown media.
Then you'd develop the quality of empathy.
Bring on the thumbs … I'm keeping a count.
It's interesting that this letter from the non- partisan Inspector General of the Intelligence Community generates this response from you.
Considering you seem okay with the plethora of left wing seeds on this site that consist solely of wild accusations based only on partisan fear-mongering with nary a display of empathy. You seem to have no problem hurling all sorts of attacks at right wingers without any recognizable display of empathy.
DO you believe it's inappropriate to mention this topic one second before she is convicted?
Please correct me if I'm wrong, but it's my understanding that the Inspector General, I. Charles McCullough III, referred this to the FBI at least five months ago!
So, why is Fox just getting around to running this story?
I think this is a new story Mac. It just seems like an old one because every few weeks (every time new emails are released) Fox finds a way to repeat the same theme.
Here is a story , if anyone is interested in reading something half way intelligent about this
John,
This is in the linked article …
The FBI’s interest in Clinton’s e-mail system comes after the intelligence community’s inspector general referred the issue to the Justice Department in July. Intelligence officials expressed concern that some sensitive information was not in the government’s possession and could be “compromised.” The referral did not accuse Clinton of any wrongdoing, and the two officials said Tuesday that the FBI is not targeting her.
When I open the linked article, I am not seeing anything that mentions July. It says the letter was sent to Congress on Jan 14.
The letter disclosing the presence of previously unknown TAP/Top Secret information on Hillary Clinton's server was written to Congress last week and just publicly released today.
Amac, do you believe it inappropriate to discuss evidence of illegal behavior by a public figure prior to conviction?
Amac, do you believe it inappropriate to discuss evidence of illegal behavior by a public figure prior to conviction?
Evidence?
Discuss the specifics by all means … but until allegations are validated (PROVEN) they are just that … and not necessarily evidence.
So discuss what's on the table, speculate away … but be clear about what's verified and what's charged (formally or informally).
The FBI’s interest in Clinton’s e-mail system comes after the intelligence community’s inspector general referred the issue to the Justice Department in July. Intelligence officials expressed concern that some sensitive information was not in the government’s possession and could be “compromised.” The referral did not accuse Clinton of any wrongdoing, and the two officials said Tuesday that the FBI is not targeting her.
We have people like Sean ENDLESSLY speculating on Clinton's supposed crimes, even though the investigating agency HAS NEVER SAID A WORD ABOUT IT.
Almost all of the speculation and assumption of guilt is coming from conservative media, mainly Fox News (one of the least reliable news organizations in existence).
What about the NBC report I posted?
Was NBC speculating on her guilt? I didn't read it.
Fox totally leads the way in this game Dean, I think you know that.
After reading the NBC story I didn't think there was much doubt about it.
Amac,
Time did not stop in July.
Amac,
Time did not stop in July.
I guess my watch stopped, Sean.
My point in mentioning the time frame is that, after all this time and despite this story being reported now (from Fox, hotair, Breitbart, etc.), …
The FBI’s interest in Clinton’s e-mail system comes after the intelligence community’s inspector general referred the issue to the Justice Department in July. Intelligence officials expressed concern that some sensitive information was not in the government’s possession and could be “compromised.” The referral did not accuse Clinton of any wrongdoing, and the two officials said Tuesday that the FBI is not targeting her.
Please acknowledge that you've read this.
It's a new development. That's why I seeded it.
It's a new development. That's why I seeded it.
Got it … and the following is in regard to the new development; That's why I posted it … and will continue to do so as long as those who are commenting on the seed fail to acknowledge this significant fact …
The FBI’s interest in Clinton’s e-mail system comes after the intelligence community’s inspector general referred the issue to the Justice Department in July. Intelligence officials expressed concern that some sensitive information was not in the government’s possession and could be “compromised.” The referral did not accuse Clinton of any wrongdoing, and the two officials said Tuesday that the FBI is not targeting her.
Please acknowledge that you've read this.
I did and it's no longer relevant. The FBI, as even Clinton friendly outlets like Politico reported, ramped up it's investigation in November.
The presumption of innocence does not apply to the views of citizens appraising a candidate.
The presumption of innocence does not apply to the views of citizens appraising a candidate.
If the citizens appraisals are not based on facts or realities, that speaks volumes about the ignorance and bias of the citizens.
But I'm talking about the seed posted and this thread … are you meaning to say that the presumption of innocence doesn't apply to an American being investigated for an alleged crime?
Or, are you intentionally referencing something other than what I was referencing.
If the seeded article is intended to color the "views of citizens appraising a candidate" … and the seeder posted it to sway that appraisal NOT BASED ON A FORMAL INDICTMENT AND CONVICTION, rather on a yet to be determined outcome, that's slimy.
But I'll let you clarify it for me.
I seeded the article because it's news. I know "news" on Newstalkers typically consists of "Fox News host or person you never heard of said something that, if taken out of context, might offend some people and that can be used to demonize all right wingers," but I think the the fact that the former Secretary of State kept top secret information on an unsecured home server in possible violation of Federal law is actual news. I'm sure if you took your partisan hat off, you'd agree with me.
I think the the fact that the former Secretary of State kept top secret information on an unsecured home server in possible violation of Federal law is actual news.
It was news the first hundred times we heard about it too.
BTW, your phrasing is questionable. Unless Clinton was aware such e-mails were top secret , at the time, she didn't "keep top secret information on her e-mail". That is a retroactive conclusion.
Sorry John - not true.
The information is top secret or higher whether Clinton knew it or not. The status of classified knowledge doesn't change based on what someone knows. And the IG has already made clear the information was classified when Clinton received it and stored it.
Aslo, the statues she is being investigated under don't require intent, they require gross negligence.Setting up your own server will make that a pretty easy bar to clear.
And this was caused by Secretary Clinton violating the rules of handling information, any information, that belongs to the government, by using a private e-mail server. So, if she knew about the classified or not, why did she violate government rules by using a private server? Laziness? Aloofness?
There is a reason there are rules. The rules apply to everyone in the employ of the government, not just those that choose to follow them.
I seeded the article because it's news. I know "news" on typically consists of "Fox News host or person you never heard of said something that, if taken out of context, might offend some people and that can be used to demonize all right wingers," but I think the the fact that the former Secretary of State kept top secret information on an unsecured home server in possible violation of Federal law is actual news. I'm sure if you took your partisan hat off, you'd agree with me.
At best it was a foolish decision; at worst it was a security breach … it's news in terms of it being investigated, and, in that it was such poor judgement from someone who should have known better …
But tell me, Sean … if this goes nowhere and there's news stories to that effect … will you seed those?
No, he will seed about the "cover-up".
Why don't you carry that conversation over to General Petreaus - who's getting ready to lose another star and receive further punishment. -
For what??? Oh, yeah - for mishandling classified documents.
Kind of like the left wing slime machine talking about those War Criminals form the previous information? I think I saw it somewhere above. Who said that?
And you know as well as I, that they do a full investigation before indictments are issued. Knowing they have the burden of proof and all.
Kind of like the left wing slime machine talking about those War Criminals form the previous information? I think I saw it somewhere above. Who said that?
I said it and I've begun to back it up.
If I make a statement, you can agree or disagree -- but you can be sure I'll back it up with particulars.
This format is confusing me! I can't tell if someone is responding to me or someone else......
UGH.......if I don't respond don't take it personally.
Since no one is "too big to jail" I am sure she will turn herself in immediately LMAO!!!!
Since no one is "too big to jail" I am sure she will turn herself in immediately LMAO!!!!
Shouldn't one wait for a conviction or exoneration?
No matter what they find, and how bad it is, there won't be a conviction or exoneration.
To put in perspective how classified this information was:
An intelligence official familiar with the matter told NBC News that the special access program in question was so sensitive that McCullough and some of his aides had to receive clearance to be read in on it before viewing the sworn declaration about the Clinton emails.
McCullough and some of his aides had to receive clearance to be read in on it
Protocol. Doesn't necessarily mean a thing about the specific Clinton e-mails being discussed.
Of course it does. The emails in question contained information that was higher than top secret. It's right there in the excerpt. If the information wasn't that highly classified, there'd be no reason for the special clearance.
The mails were on HER SERVER - not anyone elses.