Principles of Tax Reform
Principles of Tax Reform
By Douglas Holtz-Eakin
The U.S. personal and corporation income taxes are overly complicated, outdated, inefficient, burdensome, anti-growth, and hinder U.S. competitiveness. There is a clear need for reforms. What principles should govern reform of the U.S. income taxes?
1. The Tax System Should Be Based on Core Values
The tax code raises revenue. But it should be more than a haphazard collection of provisions that add up to a revenue target. Instead, it should be built to support core values and the pursuit of overall economic objectives.
The overriding economic imperative of this age is more rapid long-term economic growth. To support that objective, the tax code should reward saving and investment in physical capital, technological capital, and human capital. The mirror image of supporting saving and investment is taxing consumption. Since consumption represents what each individual or family takes out of the economy, this is consistent with an ethical foundation of taxing on the basis of what one takes out of society. An income tax, on the other hand, puts the burden on labor and capital income. In contrast to a tax on consumption, this taxes more heavily those that contribute the most labor effort or capital to the economy.
2. The Tax Code Should Be a Simple, Transparent Reflection of those Values
The U.S. income tax has been built on a principle of voluntary compliance. Unfortunately, a convoluted, opaque tax code makes it difficult for taxpayers to easily discern the link between their tax liabilities and the overall objectives of the code. This feeds the perception that the code can be manipulated and is unfair, which undercuts the incentives for voluntary compliance.
3. Spending Does Not Belong Hidden in the Tax Code
The tax code should be designed to raise revenue. Unfortunately, over time key spending programs to support work and incentivize research have been embedded in the tax code, such as the Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC) and the Research & Experimentation Tax Credit. The policy objectives of these programs are sound, but they should be classified for what they are: spending programs.
4. Growth and International Competitiveness are the Key Imperatives
A tax code focused on growth and international competitiveness will have three key features: (1) strong incentives for saving and investment, (2) non-interference in the allocation of capital among its competing uses, and (3) a move toward taxing firms on the basis of their activity in the United States – not worldwide – consistent with the approach of our competitors.
Too much attention has been focused on using the tax code for redistribution. A second lesson of reclassifying the EITC is that it makes it clear that the bulk of redistribution is done on the spending side of the federal budget. The need to support growth furthers the case that the tax code should not be a vehicle for redistribution.
A Model Tax Reform
Among the plans presented to the Tax Foundation is a progressive consumption tax in the style of David Bradford’s X-tax. The plan would eliminate the current individual and corporate tax code. On the business side, the tax base would be cash flow of all businesses, corporate and non-corporate. Firms would be able to deduct, among other items, purchases from other businesses and employee compensation. Notice that this provides non-taxation of capital investment (purchases of capital goods from other businesses), human capital investment (purchases of training or schooling) and technological investment (investment in labs, purchases of lab services, and lab workers). The rate applied to the remaining revenue is flat and set at the top rate for the household portion of the tax.
On the individual side, tax rates for joint filers would be 15 percent on first $50,000; 25 percent on next $100,000; and 35 percent over $150,000. Brackets for all unmarried taxpayers are half these amounts. All brackets indexed for inflation after 2015 by the chained Consumer Price Index. There would be an exemption from taxation of income equal to 100 percent of the federal poverty limit up to a family size of 2. This limit would also be indexed at the rate of inflation.
The plan contains few tax credits: a new credit of 15 percent of charitable contributions in excess of $500 and a new refundable credit for first-time homebuyers (as defined for the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act credit) equal to 15 percent of the value of the purchased home, claimed in five equal installments (i.e., 3 percent of the value) in each of the first 5 years of ownership. The existing mortgage interest deduction would be phased out for existing mortgages over 10 years. http://americanactionforum.org/research/principles-of-tax-reform

A policy proposal!
There are several points that I don’t agree with, of course.
The overriding economic imperative of this age is more rapid long-term economic growth.
Yes.
To support that objective, the tax code should reward saving and investment in physical capital, technological capital, and human capital.
No. Savings are not intrinsically productive. Investment follows demand.
The mirror image of supporting saving and investment is taxing consumption.
No. This is sleight of hand. A tax on consumption drains the economy.
But no matter! You've seeded a policy article! Congrats!
A tax on consumption drains the economy.
Isn't that a little simplistic ?
Of course it is.
I'm an eternal optimist. Charlie Brown believing that Lucy will hold that football steady... this time...
So... If you'd like to learn something about economics, I'd be happy to supply some links. I skim a bunch, every day.
For example, on corporate savings:
We should have a tax code as thus -
all income is taxed the same.
the only deductions are for dependent children or dependent disabled adults.
no one below the current poverty levels pays any income tax regardless if they work or not
the tax rates start at 1% and go to 60%. People making just above the poverty level would pay 1%, people having the highest income would pay 60%.
What makes my plan different than all others is that your income tax rate will go up for every additional $100 dollars of income you have. So for example someone making 14,000 a year (for an individual ) would have a tax rate of 1%, and someone making 20 million a year would have a tax rate of 60%. Everyone in between would have a tax rate that changed at increments of 100.00 of income.
The rates are a simple mathematical calculation that anyone with a computer could do, which would include the IRS.
We don't need three or four or five different tax rates. We need thousands of different tax rates. What this would provide is fairness. People would not be punished because they got a small raise and their income went from 49,900 to 50, 100, because they would not be pushed into a new tax bracket. With a sliding scale there are no brackets.
I agree, all along the line... although I would set the top rate at 75%.
I'd use the same sort of sliding scale for inheritance, with a top rate of 99% starting at $ 100 million. All gifts to future heirs taxed as part of projected inheritance.
How would you protect businesses with a ridiculous inheritance tax like that? Dumbest idea ever.
How would businesses be affected? Do businesses inherit? Do they inherit themselves?
Who owns the businesses? When they die the business is the bulk of the inheritance. Only a moron would think a business should die when the owner dies or it is not part of his estate,
Who said the business should die?
Your inheritance plan would kill them. Stop and think of what the inheritance tax would be with a 300 million dollar business with your plan. It is ridiculous. There should be no inheritance tax that money was already taxed.
Your inheritance plan would kill it.
Why? How? ... There is no reason for a shareholder's death to have any impact whatsoever on the company.
Or are you just playing dumb? I never know with you.
Your shares are part of your estate. If you own a business it is part of the inheritance you pass on to your kids. If you own stock it is part of your estate. How do you pass the business on without being part of your estate? Explain to me if you own a private 400 million dollar business how it won't be devastated by your plan to take almost the total value of the business in taxes. It makes no sense.
How do you pass the business on without being part of your estate?
You don't. Inheritance taxes should be almost confiscatory.
I'm all for building empires. I'm not at all for inheriting them.
A business should be built to continue on for hundreds of years after the founders death. Many of our greatest companies have been family owned for multiple generations.
A business should be built to continue on for hundreds of years after the founders death.
That's harder and harder, because of technological ruptures, but in principle, I certainly agree.
Many of our greatest companies have been family owned for multiple generations.
Sam Walton's six heirs -- who have no role whatsoever in running the Walmart empire -- have more wealth than 100 million Americans together.
Edsel Ford and Henry II were mediocre managers at best.
Multi-generation success stories generally have non-family managers doing the work, while the family just draws dividends. Three-generation rags-to-riches-to-rags stories abound.
Business competence is not an inherited trait. Only the money is inherited...
Yes I do not believe government owns the money. Inheritance taxes should be abolished that money was already taxed.
What a terribly violent government that would be. No family businesses, no continued legacy, no growth. Just an all consuming federal monster that robs it's citizens. That's why the left can never be allowed unobstructed power.
No family businesses
Why? I said nothing of the sort.
no continued legacy
I didn't say that, either.
no growth.
Why do you imagine this?
Just an all consuming federal monster
Who said anything about "federal"? Taxes are levied at all levels.
that robs it's citizens.
Taxation is not robbery. All governments, everywhere and all through history, have levied taxes.
You're arguing with yourself. You are making up stuff that I never said, and then arguing with it. Are there voices in your head, that whisper to you?
If you steal 99% of a business in each generation, you destroy that business. That's what liberals like you want.
If you steal 99% of a business in each generation, you destroy that business.
Let me repeat in simple sentences:
- Changing the ownership of shares does not harm a company.
- An inheritance tax changes the ownership of shares.
- An inheritance tax does not damage the shares.
- Taxation is not robbery.
- Repeating a false statement does not make it true, even if you repeat it many many times.
Taking 99% of a business each generation is violent and wrong. And it is exactly what you continue to propose. I don't think you know what "inheritance" means. That's why liberals are frightening.
Taking 99% of a business each generation is violent and wrong.
Why is it "violent"? Why is it "wrong"?
Repetition does not make a false statement true. There is no violence, and there is no wrong.
- Changing the ownership of shares does not harm a company.
How about the founders shares ? They may constitute a majority of the outstanding shares which gives their own a controlling interest ...
How about the founders shares ?
Ummm..... Petey??
We are talking about an inheritance tax. The founder is dead.
Bob ,
We are talking about an inheritance tax. The founder is dead.
Nevertheless the founders shares are not dead . There is no reason they should be withdrawn from the founders heirs ... unless you don't believe in the concept of private property ...
There is no reason they should be withdrawn from the founders heirs...
Ummm... No.
There is no reason that the heirs founder's children should get those shares. The founder's children have done nothing to earn them.
The founder's children have done nothing to earn them.
Your arrogant assumption is classic leftist BS . Pretending that the heirs of other founders do not "deserve" their place as future controllers of a business is absurd . Apparently you are fine breaking up important companies such as Ford Motors just to satisfy some absurd leftist ideal .
Petey...
Please explain to me why a person should own a company. There are several common reasons that are often given. Then tell me how the founder's children meet those requirements.
Is "Be born to an owner of a company" among the reasons why a person should own a company? Seriously?
Pretending that the heirs of other founders do not "deserve" their place as future controllers of a business is absurd .
Why?
I think you have this backward. I do not need to explain why the children do not "deserve". You need to explain why they do "deserve". If they have done nothing to "deserve", then they do not.
It's simple the business you build is yours not the governments. You should be free to do with your assets what you want it does not belong to the government. The founders did not institute an inheritance tax and it should be abolished.
Yeah! Why should we have any property rights at all?!
I do not need to explain why the children do not "deserve". You need to explain why they do "deserve".
I won't do they because not all of them do . You need to explain why none of them deserve it and what strange socialistic balderdash is motivating you ...
Please explain to me why a person should own a company.
I have little interest in repeating the obvious . Why don't you give your answer ? I'm sure it will be far more revealing about motivations .
Petey , Gunny , Cerenkov ...
what strange socialistic balderdash
communist doctrine
politics of envy
If you want to discuss... good. If not... that's OK, too. I don't care what you don't understand, and I really don't care what you think of my ideas. If you can't do better than badmouthing... then I see no reason to bother.
If any of you would like to converse... Let me know.
really don't care what you think of my ideas.
Your "ideas" have precious little in the way of thought in them . Have fun being content in your own ignorance Bob :
Socialists think they or the government has a right to anything you produce. They don't generally produce themselves.
that money was already taxed.
So what?
So once again we see how the takers are trying to use government to steal the earnings of the makers. The citizens should not be slaves to the government.
So once again we see how the takers are trying to use government to steal the earnings of the makers. The citizens should not be slaves to the government.
You are an enigma, Dean. Sometimes I think you are the dumbest of NT's dumbo wingnut bumper-sticker-thinkers... and sometimes I think you are a brilliant performance artist, a rival to Stephen Colbert in pseudo-wingnut fakery...
steal the earnings of the makers
We're talking about an inheritance tax. The maker is dead.
slaves to the government
Seriously?
He's a Randian. Nuff said.
Ayn Rand wrote fiction.
There are a lot of morons that are not aware of her nonfiction work.
Non-fiction Books Published in Rand's Lifetime
Non-fiction Books Published Posthumously
There are a lot of morons that are not aware of her nonfiction work.
And even more disingenuous hypocrites who would have the reader imagine that these books are anything near as widely read and influential as her fiction.
She may also have written some poetry.
... and shopping lists...
She was an intellectual its over your head.
Take look at this notice the readers list. Rand is numero uno.
Dean...
There are 350 million people in the US. If only 1% are wingnut whackjobs, that's still 3.5 million people. And if only 1% of those wingnut whackjobs buys Rand's cr*p, that's still 35 000. Whick is more than enough to get a book to n° 1 on the reader list.
The law of large numbers, Dean. In a large enough population even cr*p will find fans.
The law of large numbers, Dean. In a large enough population even cr*p will find fans.
This is proof that you have no understanding of statistics Bob . The whole idea behind a poll [which is what Dean's list amounts to] is to defeat the extremes involved in the full population . DUH ! Thanks for playing
I'm trying to be patient, Petey... I can be patient for quite a while, with someone who is wrong. But my patience in much shorter with someone who is both wrong and insulting.
This is proof that you have no understanding of statistics Bob .
You shouldn't make gratuitous insults. They may come back to bite you.
The whole idea behind a poll [which is what Dean's list amounts to]
Assimilating a sales list to a poll... demonstrates that you don't know statistics.
If you want to converse, be polite and don't pretend to know about stuff you don't. Or... you can play solitaire.
A sales list is a type of poll , one in which people are showing a monetary commitment to the results . If that is wrong it is up to you to explain how . I see it as an even stronger result than a reported opinion ...
If that is wrong it is up to you to explain how .
No, Petey.
You never accept anything I tell you. So if you want to know what the actual (statistical) constraints on a "poll" are... then you'll have to look the subject up. It should only take a few minutes with the google-machine.
Alternatively, you can remain ignorant.
You never accept anything I tell you.
Boo hoo Bob .
If this is your excuse for not explaining yourself it is a deeply pathetic one .
You misunderstood, Petey. I am quite content that you never accept anything I say. I am freed from explaining.
Oh, wait... I just did...
I am quite content that you never accept anything I say.
On the rare occasions that you say something I have no issue with I usually just don't say anything at all . The fact that you can't tell the difference between disagreement and "not listening" shows a character flaw on your part . Your inflated opinion of your own "thinking" is the problem . What arrogance !
Only the money is inherited...
Actually the management of the business is also inherited . Who has more motivation to manage responsibly than the heirs . OTW the business would likely be scrapped like a hostile takeover ...
That's not how tax brackets work. Only additional income in the next bracket is taxed at that rate.
well, this thread is derailed
You can gift your children X number of dollars per year.
There is also a thing called a ''Trust''...Each family should have one to lessen the tax burdens on your death.