AP: 22 Clinton Emails too Classified to be released even in redacted form
WASHINGTON (AP) -- The Obama administration confirmed for the first time Friday that Hillary Clinton's unsecured home server contained closely guarded government secrets, censoring 22 emails with material requiring one of the highest levels of classification. The revelation comes just three days before the Iowa presidential nominating caucuses in which Clinton is a candidate.
Department officials also said the agency's Diplomatic Security and Intelligence and Research bureaus will investigate whether any of the information was classified at the time of transmission, going to the heart of one of Clinton's primary defenses of her email practices.
The State Department will release its next batch of emails from Clinton's time as secretary of state later Friday.
But The Associated Press learned seven email chains are being withheld in full from the Friday release because they contain information deemed to be "top secret." The 37 pages include messages recently described by a key intelligence official as concerning so-called "special access programs" - a highly restricted subset of classified material that could point to confidential sources or clandestine programs like drone strikes or government eavesdropping.
"The documents are being upgraded at the request of the intelligence community because they contain a category of top secret information," State Department spokesman John Kirby told the AP, describing the decision to withhold documents in full as "not unusual." That means they won't be published online with the rest of the documents, even with blacked-out boxes.
Department officials wouldn't describe the substance of the emails, or say if Clinton sent any herself.
Clinton, the front-runner for the Democratic presidential nomination, has insisted she never sent or received information on her personal email account that was classified at the time. No emails released so far were stamped "CLASSIFIED" or "TOP SECRET," but reviewers previously had designated more than 1,000 messages at lower classification levels for public release. Friday's will be the first at the top secret level.
Even if Clinton only read, and didn't write or forward the secret messages, she still would have been required to report classification slippages that she recognized. But without classification markings, that may have been difficult, especially if the information was in the public domain.
"We firmly oppose the complete blocking of the release of these emails," Clinton campaign spokesman Brain Fallon said in a statement. "Since first providing her emails to the State Department more than one year ago, Hillary Clinton has urged that they be made available to the public. We feel no differently today."
Fallon accused the "loudest and leakiest participants" in a process of bureaucratic infighting for withholding the exchanges. The documents, he said, originated in the State Department's unclassified system long before they ever reached Clinton, and "in at least one case, the emails appear to involve information from a published news article."
"This appears to be overclassification run amok," Fallon said.
Kirby said the State Department was focused, as part of the Freedom of Information Act review of Clinton's emails, on "whether they need to be classified today." Questions about their past classification, he said, "are being, and will be, handled separately by the State Department."
Possible department responses for classification infractions include counseling, warnings or other action, State Department officials said, though they declined to say if these applied to Clinton or senior aides who've since left the department. The officials weren't authorized to speak on the matter and spoke on condition of anonymity.
Separately, Kirby said the department also was withholding eight email chains, totaling 18 messages, between President Barack Obama and Clinton. These are remaining confidential "to protect the president's ability to receive unvarnished advice and counsel," but will ultimately be released like other presidential records.
Friday's release is coming at an awkward time for Clinton. The Iowa caucus is on Feb. 1, and her main challenger, Vermont Sen. Bernie Sanders, is running a competitive campaign in Iowa and New Hampshire. Clinton still holds a strong advantage in national polls.
The emails have been an issue for Clinton's campaign since it became known 10 months ago that she exclusively used a nongovernment account linked to a homebrew server while in office. Clinton first called the decision a matter of convenience and then termed it a mistake, even if doing so wasn't expressly forbidden. But the matter could prove more troublesome now that Clinton's former agency has confirmed that business conducted over the account included top-secret matters.
Like Clinton, the State Department discounted such a possibility last March. Both also said her account was never hacked or compromised. Security experts assess that as unlikely, and that the vast majority of her emails were preserved properly for archiving purposes because she corresponded mainly with government accounts. They've backtracked from the archiving claim, while the AP discovered several phishing attempts on her server connected to Russia.
The question of special access programs first surfaced last week, when Charles I. McCullough, the inspector general for U.S. intelligence agencies, cited examples on Clinton's account in a letter to Congress. Republicans pounced on the report, though Clinton's campaign insisted none of the exchanges were "classified at the time" and accused McCullough and GOP lawmakers of selectively leaking materials to damage her presidential hopes.
Kirby confirmed that the "denied-in-full emails" are among those McCullough recently cited. One of the emails, he said, was among those McCullough identified last summer as possibly containing top secret information.
The AP reported last August that one focused on a forwarded news article about the classified U.S. drone program run by the CIA. Such operations are widely discussed in the public sphere, including by top U.S. officials, and the State Department immediately argued with McCullough's claim. The other concerned North Korean nuclear weapons programs, according to officials.
At the time, several officials from different agencies suggested the disagreement over the drone emails reflected the government's tendency to overclassify material, and the lack of consistent policies across difference agencies about what should and shouldn't be classified.
The FBI also is looking into Clinton's email setup, but has said nothing about the nature of its probe. Independent experts say it is highly unlikely that Clinton will be charged with wrongdoing, based on the limited details that have surfaced up to now and the lack of indications that she intended to break any laws.
"What I would hope comes out of all of this is a bit of humility" and an acknowledgement from Clinton that "I made some serious mistakes," said Bradley Moss, a Washington lawyer who regularly handles security clearance matters.
Legal questions aside, it's the potential political costs that are probably of more immediate concern for Clinton. She has struggled in surveys measuring her perceived trustworthiness and an active federal investigation, especially one buoyed by evidence that top secret material coursed through her account, could negate one of her main selling points for becoming commander in chief: Her national security resume.

Even generous use of redactions (which have been used for the previous 1340 emails containing classified information that have already been released) can prevent damage to national security by the release of these emails.
I guess the Obama administration is now part of the Vast Right Wing Conspiracy out to get poor Hillary.
"I guess the Obama administration is now part of the Vast Right Wing Conspiracy out to get poor Hillary. "
LMAO! It just keeps getting better and better. Sad that no matter how bad it gets no justice will be served.
Sadly, you are correct. Obama will never let Clinton go to jail, or even be indicted.
This case is why independent prosecutors aren't such a bad idea.
Obama will never let Clinton go to jail, or even be indicted.
This case is why independent prosecutors aren't such a bad idea.
• Obama may allow the issue to be protracted as a way of opening the door to the drafting of Joe Biden.
• I'm all for independent prosecutors … but I don't recall you being the cheerleader for those in the Ferguson or the Eric Garner Grand Juries
If you're going to advocate the end of such conflicts-of-interests, you'll appear more sincere if you don't make it a matter of "black-and-white".
Obama's essentially hitched his wagon to Clinton over Sanders without explicitly saying so in an interview last week. I just don't think a draft Biden at the convention movement is practically possible for the Democrats. Sanders supporters would go nuts if he's handed the nomination without running in the primaries.
What reason was their for an independent investigator in the Brown case?
What reason was their for an independent investigator in the Brown case?
What was unusual about the grand jury proceedings in the Michael Brown shooting?
There is an inherent conflict of interest in giving local prosecutors so much control over the decision whether to charge police for allegations of bias or excessive use of force — and a compelling need for an independent special prosecutor to handle such cases from start to finish. That’s true in states such as Missouri, where prosecutors can choose to initiate charges either directly or via grand jury, and in states such as New York, where felonies must be charged through the grand jury process.
Local prosecutors rely heavily on local police departments to get their indictments and convictions; when a grand jury deliberates possible police improprieties, local prosecutors need to recuse themselves.
Neither in the Brown nor the Garner case did recusals take place.
“Of course the SVR got it all,” explained a high-ranking former KGB officer to me about EmailGate (the SVR is the post-Soviet successor to the KGB’s foreign intelligence arm). “I don’t know if we’re as good as we were in my time,” he added, “but even half-drunk the SVR could get those emails, they probably couldn’t believe how easy Hillary made it for them.”
Any foreign intelligence service reading Ms. Clinton’s emails would know a great deal they’re not supposed to about American diplomacy, including classified information: readouts from sensitive meetings, secret U.S. positions on high-stakes negotiations, details of interaction between the State Department and other U.S. agencies including the White House. This would be a veritable intelligence goldmine to our enemies. Worse, access to Ms. Clinton’s personal email likely gave foreign spy agencies hints on how to crack into more sensitive information systems. Not to mention that if Clinton Inc. was engaged in any sort of illegal pay-for-play schemes, our adversaries know all about that, as well as anything else shady that Ms. Clinton and her staff were putting in those unencrypted emails.
This is the same old shit Sean. How many times are you going to seed articles about the same old shit that you have been seeding for a year now ? Is it going to magically become more persuasive through overuse ?
"Even if Clinton only read, and didn't write or forward the secret messages, she still would have been required to report classification slippages that she recognized. But without classification markings, that may have been difficult, especially if the information was in the public domain.
"We firmly oppose the complete blocking of the release of these emails," Clinton campaign spokesman Brain Fallon said in a statement. "Since first providing her emails to the State Department more than one year ago, Hillary Clinton has urged that they be made available to the public. We feel no differently today.""
This is another new development, which you know. Keep moving the goalposts and spewing paranoid conspiracy b.s. while the truth is revealed over Clinton's stonewalling drip by drip.
Does it bother you that you shill for a liar? I hope you feel at least a little dirty. Time and time again, you make these pronouncements only for Hillary to be shown a liar, yet again.
Time for you move the goalposts again. I'm sure her bought and paid for propaganda arm, Media Matters, will release talking points for you to parrot soon. It should get you through to the next development, when you have to start anew.
When people seed articles like this on a discussion forum, there is a natural expectation that there may be "news" in the story. No such luck with the repetitive scandal mongering Sean serves up.
e is a natural expectation that there may be "news" in the story
e Obama administration confirmed for the FIRST TIME Friday that Hillary Clinton's unsecured home server contained closely guarded government secrets, censoring 22 emails with material requiring one of the highest levels of classification.
Struggle with English much? Or point me to a source prior to today where the administration admitted she kept closely gaurded top secret information on her unsecured home server.
I'll note that this story is also on the front page of pretty much every major media outlet from CNN to the Washington Post to Yahoo News. I recommend you look up the definition of "news" in the dictionary, before you go seeding some more trash from crazy ass partisan sites like Daily Kos or Rawstory.
There is nothing new in the gist of this story, we all know that. But it keeps your hopes up, so bully for you.
Spiiiiiin. Nice try. She's guilty.
The fallout for Republicans could bring a Joe Biden candidacy … careful what you wish for.
What difference does it make? They are both equally as bad.
What difference does it make? They are both equally as bad.
whistle past the graveyard
I think it's too late for Biden
I think it's too late for Biden
In United States politics, a brokered convention is a situation in which no single candidate has secured a pre-existing majority of delegates (whether those selected by primary elections and caucuses, or superdelegates) prior to the first official vote for a political party's presidential candidate at its nominating ...
Delegates can bolt …
"a sudden desertion from a meeting, political party, social movement, etc."
There is nothing new about this story.
The federal government is censoring 37 pages of emails from Hillary Clinton's private email server, saying they contain information considered "top secret." The move marks the first time her State Department emails have been accorded such a high level of classification and comes just days before the Iowa caucuses.
Seven email chains are being withheld in their entirety from a release scheduled later Friday for including "top secret" information.
"The documents are being upgraded at the request of the intelligence community, because they contain a category of top secret information," State Department spokesman John Kirby said. He added, though, that the messages had not been designated as top secret when they were sent, though the department "is focusing on whether they need to be classified today." .
(JR note - this has been the case throughout this investigation)
Clinton, who served as secretary of State from 2009 to 2013, has long maintained that she did not send or received information that was classified at the time, which Kirby said Friday was the case.
(This contention between Clinton and the State dept and the intelligence community has gone on just like this for most of the past year, as Clinton e-mails have been dumped on a every couple months basis)
She's in a tight battle with Vermont Sen. Bernie Sanders in Iowa, which holds caucuses that open the 2016 primary calendar on Monday.
After the department's announcement, Clinton press secretary Brian Fallon said in a statement that the campaign objected to the decision.
"We firmly oppose the complete blocking of the release of these emails," Fallon said. "Since first providing her emails to the State Department more than one year ago, Hillary Clinton has urged that they be made available to the public. We feel no differently today."
The State Department has been releasing monthly batches of Clinton's emails following a court order last summer. News coverage of most releases have largely highlighted quirky office routines and humorous requests and responses from Clinton, but Friday's announcement will likely trigger increased criticism from her GOP rivals about her decision to use a private email server, which has hung over her presidential campaign from its start.
You know, the Republicans, and an element in the media, is fostering the idea that this is some sort of new escalation of culpability for Clinton - it is not. This story is a disservice to news reporting and to the American people.
It is.
The New York Times, CNN, Washington Post etc.. are now all part of the vast Right wing Conspiracy. All the liberal journalists at these sites are actually secret Republicans. Keep exposing your paranoia.
It's amazing how powerful truth can be.
"none of the information she possessed and/or presumably “removes” had officially been declared “classified” at that time. That matters. Sure, there is an argument that classified “documents” are not the same as classified “information” and that certain information is “ classified at birth ” and therefore always officially classified. And there’s no question that some of the information and/or documents were later declared classified. But this isn’t a law school exam where we attempt to figure out how creative one can become in fitting a law into a particular fact pattern. We are talking about whether a criminal charge should be filed based on intentional conduct when even governmental agencies squabble over what is classified and what isn’t. So proving that she “knowingly” removed “classified information” “without authority” at the time seems far-fetched based on what we know today."
Try and acquaint yourselves with reality.
Try and acquaint yourselves with reality.
Reality as described by a failed MSNBC talk show host who was the channel's principle Hillary backer in 2008. It says a lot that you go to the proprietor of the website "Gossip Cop" for your legal news.
His analysis is nothing but base stealing and misdirection. He cites "politfact" while making a legal argument? What a joke.
I would be remiss if I did not acknowledge several of the responses to detailed comments in which I expended the time and effort, and, gave the respect warranted by members' questions and replies.
Discussion can be educational and fun.
I hope some of our members will one day try to have one.
Good night.