Hillary Clinton AP / Scott Morgan While many people are busy speculating whether former Secretary of State and presidential candidate Hillary Clinton should be charged with a crime, few are paying attention to the actual laws that govern the handling and disclosure of classified information. It is worth examining those laws before making up one's mind.
The handling of classified information is a serious matter in the United States. "Classified information," under 18 U.S.C. Section 709(b), is defined as information which, at the time of the alleged violation, was specifically designated for reasons of national security by a United States government agency to be limited or restricted in its dissemination or distribution.
Individuals who are given access to classified information must sign a "Classified Information Nondisclosure Agreement" accepting the obligations in the handling of such information. In the standard agreement, it is noted that "classified information is marked or unmarked classified information, including oral communications," that is classified under the standards of Executive Order 12958, or any other executive order or statute, as requiring protection because it involves national security.
In signing the agreement, an individual acknowledges that he or she has received a security indoctrination concerning the nature and protection of classified information, including the procedures to be followed in ascertaining whether other persons to whom they contemplate disclosing the information have been approved for access.
The agreement also provides that even "negligent handling of classified information … could cause damage or irreparable injury to the United States." The agreement further provides that a breach of the rules may constitute a violation of an array of United States criminal laws, including 18 U.S.C. Sections 641, 793, 794, 952 and 1924, and 50 U.S.C. Section 783(b).
Most of these criminal statutes require a knowing or intentional disclosure or mishandling of classified information. Section 641 prohibits the stealing or embezzlement of government property. By its terms, a person must intend to take something of value from the United States, which could include classified information. Section 793(a) similarly states that "Whoever, for the purpose of obtaining information respecting the national defense with intent or reason to believe that the information is to be used to the injury of the United States, or to the advantage of any foreign nation," obtains or willfully communicates such classified information is guilty of that felony. Edward Snowden and Army Private Bradley Manning were charged with violating this statue for their intentional leaking of confidential information to Wikileaks.
Yet, there are some provisions that prohibit gross negligence in the handling of classified information. Section 793(f) states: "Whoever, being entrusted with or having lawful possession of … information relating to the national defense … through gross negligence permits the same to be removed from its proper place of custody or delivered to anyone in violation of his trust, or to be lost, stolen, abstracted, or destroyed …" shall be guilty of an offense.
It is unlike Section 794, a conventional espionage statute, which requires that the defendant act with intent to injure the United States or advantage a foreign nation; or Section 952 which prohibits the willful publishing of diplomatic codes; or 50 U.S.C. Section 783 which punishes a defendant who knows or should know that information he is conveying to an agent of a foreign government is classified information.
One of the more commonly charged statutes, Section 798, also requires that the defendant act in a knowing and willful manner. It provides: "Whoever knowingly and willfully communicates, furnishes, transmits, or otherwise makes available to an unauthorized person" classified information is guilty of a 10-year felony. This charge was used to convict Shamai Leibowitz, a linguist and translator for the FBI, who pleaded guilty to leaking classified information to a blogger and was sentenced to 20 months in prison.
Finally, within Title 18 of the United States Code, there is Section 1924. This section prohibits an officer or employee of the United States who comes into possession of classified documents or materials from "knowingly remov[ing] such documents or materials without authority and with the intent to retain such documents or materials at an unauthorized location." Former CIA Director David Petraeus pleaded to this misdemeanor when he shared classified information with his biographer and girlfriend, Paula Broadwell.
Thus, in sorting out Hillary Clinton's actions, there are at least two critical questions: First, to what extent was using a private email server an "unauthorized" handling of classified information. Second, did Clinton ever knowingly mishandle classified information or act in a grossly negligent manner that led to information being lost, destroyed or stolen?
Politics aside, it is difficult to find prior cases where the unwise handling of classified information led to a federal indictment. For the last 20 years, the federal statutes have been used when there were intentional unauthorized disclosures. The Department of Justice appears to have gone after "leakers," but not bunglers. Twenty years ago, John Deutsch found himself in hot water and the target of a DOJ investigation for transferring classified materials to his government-owned computer at home — a computer that he used to access a wide range of Internet searches. He was never charged; President Bill Clinton pardoned Deutsch on his last day as president. It remains to be seen what will happen in Hillary Clinton's case.

I know expert analysis is not as titillating as the latest from Sean Hannity or Fox and Friends, but I will settle for informative.
Politics aside, it is difficult to find prior cases where the unwise handling of classified information led to a federal indictment. For the last 20 years, the federal statutes have been used when there were intentional unauthorized disclosures.
So you think that this precedent will be broken in order to indict the leading presidential candidate of one of the two major parties ? Good luck.
I'm glad you brought up the Deutsch case. It undercuts your whole argument. The DOJ was going to indict Deutsch. Deutsch actually reached a plea agreement with the DOJ for storing classiifed information on an unsecure network. it took a pardon from his boss end the case before sentencing.
notice it also took two years for the investigation to be completed.
Twenty years ago, John Deutsch found himself in hot water and the target of a DOJ investigation for transferring classified materials to his government-owned computer at home — a computer that he used to access a wide range of Internet searches. He was never charged; President Bill Clinton pardoned Deutsch on his last day as president. It remains to be seen what will happen in Hillary Clinton's
Look how far Democrats have moved to the "party over country line" over the last 20 years. This is the New York Times blasting AG Reno for not moving against Clinton Cabinet member Deutsche for storing classified information on his home computer:
If the director of central intelligence transfers highly classified materials to insecure computers at his home, he may well be violating the law, and his conduct requires an immediate and full investigation. But when faced with just such actions by John Deutch in late 1996, the C.I.A. and the Justice Department badly fumbled the case. They are now scrambling to make amends, with Justice belatedly initiating a criminal investigation. But the affair once again demonstrates that the agency cannot adequately investigate itself and that Attorney General Janet Reno has consistently failed to enforce the law against top Clinton administration officials.,,,
It seems clear that Mr. Deutch received special treatment because he was a top official, and that Ms. Reno gave him the benefit of the doubt, just as she has done for others in the administration. For an experienced prosecutor, she has an uncanny instinct for ignoring or misreading the evidence and the law when top officials are credibly accused of misconduct. Before the books are closed on this case, the actions of Mr. Deutch and his former colleagues must be carefully examined. If the evidence warrants prosecution, the high positions they held should be no barrier."
It's impossible to envision anyone to the right of Jeb Bush arguing that Clinton should not receive special treatment in 2016. For a modern democrat, it's rally around Clinton, damn the law and damn the investigators.