╌>

Army and Marine Corps chiefs: It’s time for women to register for the draft

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  pj  •  10 years ago  •  52 comments

Army and Marine Corps chiefs: It’s time for women to register for the draft

Army and Marine Corps chiefs: It’s time for women to register for the draft

The Washington Post

Dan Lamothe 23 mins ago

 

The top officers in the Army and Marine Corps testified on Tuesday that they believe it is time for women to register for future military drafts, following the Pentagon’s recent decision to open all jobs in combat units to female service members.

Gen. Mark A. Milley, chief of staff of the Army, and Gen. Robert B. Neller, the Marine Corps commandant, both said they were in favor of the change during an occasionally contentious Senate Armed Services Committee hearing on the forthcoming full integration of women in the military. They offered their opinions in response to a question from Sen. Claire McCaskill (D-Mo.), who said that she also is in favor of the change.

“Senator, it’s my personal view that, based on this lifting of restrictions… every American who’s physically qualified should register for the draft,” Neller said.

“Senator, I think that all eligible and qualified men and women should register for the draft,” said Milley.

After the hearing, Neller added in an short interview that any young American as a rite of passage should have to register for Selective Service.

“Now that the restrictions that exempted women from that don’t exist, then you’re a citizen of a United States,” Neller said. “It doesn’t mean you’re going to serve, but you go register.”

[ Why the Pentagon opening all combat roles to women could subject them to a military draft ]

The comments are a first in the Defense Department. Previously, senior defense officials have said only that the issue would need to be researched following Defense Secretary Ashton B. Carter’s historic decision in December to open all jobs in the military to women without exception.

Carter’s action allows women for the first time to apply for a variety of physically punishing positions, including Army and Marine Corps infantryman, as well as Special Operations jobs, including Navy SEAL and Green Beret. The Defense Department plans to begin implementing associated changes in training and evaluation by April 1.

The Selective Service System has existed for decades, and was created to make sure the military has enough manpower when it is short-handed in a time of war. A variation of it was first adopted in 1917, as the United States prepared to join enter World War I.

But Selective Service laws have never required women to subject themselves to the draft and face the prospect of being forced into military service. The current version of the Military Selective Service Act requires that virtually all men in the United States between the ages of 18 and 26 register, most within 30 days of turning 18. That includes non-U.S. citizens living in the United States, such as refugees.

The comments came during an occasionally contentious hearing in which senators questioned senior defense officials on how efforts to evaluate and implement the integration of women in all combat roles. The Marine Corps sought an exception to policy that would have allowed it to keep closed some physically demanding jobs, including machine gunner and reconnaissance man, while the Army showed support for opening all jobs.

The Marine Corps’ opposition to the change spilled into public frequently, with Navy Secretary Ray Mabus questioning why the service conducted extensive research on how the average woman performs an infantry unit, but did not specifically track elite female performers.

Sen. John McCain (R.-Ariz.), the Armed Services Committee chairman, pressed Mabus on the issue Tuesday, questioning how much time he spent observing the Marine Corps task force that spent months researching how men and women operate in combat condition through a series of experiments at Twentynine Palms, Calif., and Camp Lejeune, N.C. Mabus responded that he did not visit it at all.

  “So you, with a straight face, make claims that the Marines’ study was flawed and biased, even if you did not even go see the study being performed?” McCain said.

Mabus did not respond then, but said at another point in the hearing that it was “clear that the conclusions focused on the average performance of female Marines rather than on individual abilities.

“Averages don’t tell the abilities and performance of an individual Marine,” he said. “There were and are capable women who can meet the arduous standards the Marine Corps set for ground combat arms units and we all that Marines have never been about average.”

http://www.msn.com/en-us/news/us/army-and-marine-corps-chiefs-it%E2%80%99s-time-for-women-to-register-for-the-draft/ar-BBp1Los


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
PJ
Masters Silent
link   seeder  PJ    10 years ago

The top officers in the Army and Marine Corps testified on Tuesday that they believe it is time for women to register for future military drafts, following the Pentagon’s recent decision to open all jobs in combat units to female service members.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  PJ   10 years ago

I, for one, strongly support females registering for and (if needed) being drafted even in combat units and roles.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober  replied to  Randy   10 years ago

Draft Taylor Swift !

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    10 years ago

Very controversial  . I'm guessing it will be too hot a topic for this site ...

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior  replied to  Petey Coober   10 years ago

Any intelligent conversation - you're right.

 
 
 
PJ
Masters Silent
link   seeder  PJ  replied to  Petey Coober   10 years ago

Well Petey - from what I've seen here on NT, you've never shied away from controversy.  You thrive on it. 

The last time you and I touched on this topic we didn't quite agree...in fact you chastised me on my comments.  This time, I'm keeping my sexist comments to myself. :op

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober  replied to  PJ   10 years ago

I am not shy about controversy PJ . Feel free to launch some of your humorous barbs . I promise to be more receptive ...

On this particular topic I am torn . How about you ?

 
 
 
PJ
Masters Silent
link   seeder  PJ  replied to  Petey Coober   10 years ago

I'm actually with you on this.  I'm torn.  I think women should have to register but I'm not sure that I'm ready to see women in combat units.  My hesitation is based on physical capability in helping a male counterpart if he's injured.   But I don't have the perspective of someone who has served and knows what it requires physically. 

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober  replied to  PJ   10 years ago

I'm not sure that I'm ready to see women in combat units.

I guess you didn't see Holly Holmes demolish Rhonda Rousey in the UFC ...

 
 
 
PJ
Masters Silent
link   seeder  PJ  replied to  Petey Coober   10 years ago

No I didn't but I heard about it.  I think it only took a couple minutes if that long.  I'm sure there are women that have no problem keeping up physically with men but I don't think that's the norm.  I don't see many guys gravitating towards women that can kick their a$$. 

 

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  PJ   10 years ago

I'm sure there are women that have no problem keeping up physically with men but I don't think that's the norm.

I agree. However, just as with the men in Basic Training, those that can not cut it, mentally or physically, will be weeded out. My flight in the USAF (in 1973) started with more then 50 men and ended up with less then 40 and Air Force Basic Training was not that difficult compared to other branches. The other 10 "washed out" and were discharged. That's a policy needs to be changed. In the modern military there are jobs that do not necessarily require a person, male or female, to have the same physical capabilities as a Basic Training Graduate. I graduated tied as top Airman in my Basic Training Flight. However my job was as a computer operator at a SAC ICBM base. The truth is my job could have been done by someone who did not pass all of the physical requirements of Basic Training. The same holds true for other branches of the military.

 
 
 
PJ
Masters Silent
link   seeder  PJ  replied to  Randy   10 years ago

Yes, I could see how different tests and requirements could help in identifying those who meet the standards and those who don't but then there is the mentality of the military that would have to be overcome.  That will be a challenge that I think will be far more difficult then the physical element.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  PJ   10 years ago

There will always be those who will be discharged as "Unable to adapt to military life" as happened when I was in to some of those who washed out. Not all of the men who washed out did so because they couldn't cut it physically. There are just some people, I suspect of both genders, who just can't cut the discipline and expectations required. It would be nice if they could be weeded out beforehand, but I don't think there is a way to do that

 
 
 
ArkansasHermit
Freshman Silent
link   ArkansasHermit  replied to  Randy   10 years ago

I agree. However, just as with the men in Basic Training, those that can not cut it, mentally or physically, will be weeded out. My flight in the USAF (in 1973) started with more then 50 men and ended up with less then 40 and Air Force Basic Training was not that difficult compared to other branches.

 

Your experience reminded me of my own Randy. 

Paris Island summer of 1970, training Platoon 259 started out with more than 90 recruits but there were only 35 or 40 of the original left on graduation day,

My two younger brothers went through Army & Navy basic, when their time to serve came about, and whenever we compared stories I was gob smacked at how easy their basic training sounded compared to what the Marines put you through, especially the Navies.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior  replied to  ArkansasHermit   10 years ago

You were a Sand-flea Marine???

Wuz on the West Coast, started with 94, ended with 42 in '64.  'Course at that time, all of us knew we were going to get to visit the Southeast vacation capital of the world so many of them "self-imploded" just to get out of that vacation.

The same is true in today's military.  Have a nephew who spent six tours in Iraq/Afghan, wound up with 8 concussions, broken back, many broken ribs, shrapnel wounds and a medical discharge - as a tanker in the Army.  Today's youth don't want to go through that carnage and will do what they can to "self-implode".

There have been numerous studies of women attempting to complete the advanced combat training in the Army over many years - and only three have graduated.  None for the Marine Corps.  The physical demands are horrendous when you're in a combat situation and the vast majority of women simply do not have the physical characteristics to meet those challenges.  That's not saying that there aren't women who do have the characteristics, but they ain't gonna get them in 12 weeks of basic training.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober  replied to  PJ   10 years ago

I don't see many guys gravitating towards women that can kick their a$$.

It does seem that women prefer to be popular :

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    10 years ago

Back to the original topic..... sure, women should be required to register for the draft.  (like we will ever have one again as all future engagements will be a "come as you are" affair/no time to build up.)

Like everyone else discussing here... women and men... that are going into combat rolls MUST pass the SAME tough/rugged physical requirements.  There are lives at stake! 

 
 
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   Spikegary    10 years ago

The vast majority of jobs in the military are not direct combat jobs.  In the Air Force, more and more with Remote Piloted Drones-are farther from the battlefront.  And regardless of how you come in to the service, these jobs, the vast majority being combat support, need to be filled.

In a nutshell?  Everyone should have to register, in the case of a draft, everyone should have to serve or at least have the same chance of being drafted as everyone else.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior  replied to  Spikegary   10 years ago

Yeah, those in Creech with the joy-sticks aren't really going to be put in harms way.

 
 
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   Spikegary  replied to  1stwarrior   10 years ago

More than just Creech, my friend.......

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    10 years ago

Should there be a compulsory service requirement for all citizens of the country?

Yes. 

 I look around and I see entitlement, disrespectful youth, and greed at the expense of one’s country.  I see a small percentage of our sons and daughters carrying the burden of our freedom.  Rather than working together I see our leaders actively working to divide this country.  The future is our youth.  What stronger bond is there than to serve and sacrifice together? 

I agree. I can see a huge difference in my daughter's boyfriend who served in the Coast Guard. He is level headed, self sacrificing, respectful, and not the least bit entitled. He worked hard as a coastie, and now he is getting a college education. Compared to most other 25 year olds. he is a man. 

There are so many branches of the armed forces that one can serve. I don't see why women should be exempt anymore. 

 

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  Perrie Halpern R.A.   10 years ago

Yes also. I believe in some form of compulsory service to the country. I believe that, if we are born here or immigrate here, we owe the country a debt for being lucky enough to be here.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    10 years ago

IMO I think there's a related question we should be considering-- should men be drafted as well as woman?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober  replied to  Krishna   10 years ago

Men are not currently drafted but they are required to register for the draft ...

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1  replied to  Krishna   10 years ago

Having seen both, our military functions much better as an all volunteer force rather than one formed through the draft.  That being said I do agree with everyone doing some sort of 1-2 year civic service.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    10 years ago

Equal opportunity to serve in all military positions entails equal responsibility for military service.

Sounds reasonable

 
 

Who is online



mocowgirl


113 visitors