╌>

Iran Makes Damning New Claims About GOP Trying To Sabotage Obama’s Prisoner Exchange

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  jwc2blue  •  10 years ago  •  18 comments

Iran Makes Damning New Claims About GOP Trying To Sabotage Obama’s Prisoner Exchange

http://www.addictinginfo.org/2016/02/11/iran-makes-damning-new-claims-about-gop-trying-to-sabotage-obamas-prisoner-exchange/

An explosive allegation has come out of Tasnim News against Republicans. The Secretary of Iran’s Supreme National Security council said that the recent prisoner exchange between the U.S. and Iran had an attempt made by Republicans to sabotage it when they requested Iran delay release of the prisoners until the eve of the 2016 election.

Ali Shamkhani, Secretary of Iran’s Supreme National Security Council, released the following statement:

“In the course of the talks for exchanging prisoners, the Republican rivals of the current US administration who claim to be humanitarians and advocates of human rights sent a message telling us not to release these people (American prisoners) and continue this process (of talks) until the eve of US presidential elections.”

“However” he said “we acted upon our independent resolve and moved the process forward.”

Source: Tasnim News

This is the second time that the allegations have been raised that Republicans requested Americans were to be held hostage by Iran in order to serve their domestic political interests. The first time came from the suggestion that Republicans conspired with Iran to delay the release of American hostages until Ronald Reagan was inaugurated in 1980. They were to be rewarded for this by Reagan then selling them weapons. This was supposedly done to hurt Carter’s re-election while allowing Republicans to claim that the act of electing a Republican made our enemies cower in fear. Iran did end up releasing the hostages 20 minutes after Reagan completed his inaugural address.

Now here we are again. There is an upcoming presidential election, Republican prospects look grim as usual and now they might have gotten caught using the same old trick a second time. If this turns out to be true, the consequences could destroy the party.

One could discount this by saying it’s Iran, and we can’t believe what they say because they are an “enemy.” However, if you look at the fact Republicans have admitted to trying to work with Iran to hurt America before, it seems very plausible. Republicans tried to sabotage the Iranian peace deal by contacting Iran directly and suggesting that any peace deal would not last after Obama left office . They have a history of trying to conspire with Iran, for political reasons at home.

Republicans are obsessed with hurting this nation, and it’s people, in order to create an environment of fear, rage and paranoia. Only in this mindset would Americans ever want to vote them into power.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell    10 years ago

Rubio wrongly credits Reagan for 1981 release of hostages from Iran

 

Pants on Fire!

 

 

By  Angie Drobnic Holan ,  Louis Jacobson  on Sunday, January 17th, 2016 at 5:31 p.m.

As news of Iran’s release of American prisoners spread, Republicans were quick to deny President Barack Obama much credit for the deal.

Presidential candidate Marco Rubio said the United States should not have made any concessions to Iran. Part of the deal included Obama granting clemency to seven Iranians charged in U.S. courts with violating economic sanctions against Iran.

"Our enemies now know that if you can capture an American, you can get something meaningful in exchange for it," Rubio said on  Meet the Press  on Jan. 17, 2016.

Host Chuck Todd pressed Rubio on that position: "So under President Rubio, you would not have negotiated any sort of prisoner exchange for those four American hostages?"

Rubio replied: "When I become president of the United States, our adversaries around the world will know that America is no longer under the command of someone weak like Barack Obama, and it will be like Ronald Reagan, where as soon as he took office the hostages were released from Iran."

We flagged Rubio’s comment as a misleading framing of history. Reagan’s inauguration in 1981 may have coincided with the release of the hostages, but historians say it did not cause it. Instead, the Iranians had tired of holding the hostages, and that the administration of Jimmy Carter did the legwork to get the hostages released.

We asked the Rubio campaign for response but did not hear back.

The hostage crisis of 1979

It’s a GOP talking point  we’ve debunked before .  In 2012, Republican candidate Mitt Romney said, "I believe the right course is what Ronald Reagan called peace through strength ... There's a reason why the Iranians released the hostages on the same day and at the same hour that Reagan was sworn in." We rated his claim Pants on Fire. 

In 1979, Islamic revolutionaries overthrew the Shah of Iran, who had been installed and supported by successive U.S. administrations. Militants took over the American embassy and held 52 American hostages from Nov. 4, 1979, until Jan. 20, 1981 -- the day Carter passed the reins to Reagan, who had defeated him amid widespread public disapproval of Carter’s handling of the crisis.

But negotiations for the hostages’ release started well before Election Day. In September 1980, the Iranians contacted the Carter administration with a proposal, according to Gary Sick, a Columbia University professor and the author of  October Surprise: America's Hostages in Iran and the Election of Ronald Reagan .

The agreement that led to the release involved $11 billion to $12 billion in Iranian assets that Carter had frozen 10 days after the seizure of the U.S. embassy. Sick told us that the Iranians feared having to start negotiations over with a new administration and believed that they had extracted most of the benefits from holding the hostages.

Carter informed Reagan at 8:31 a.m. that the release of the hostages was imminent, according to a contemporary report in the  New York Times . "The hostages, whose 14 months of captivity had been a central focus of the presidential contest last year, took off from Tehran in two Boeing 727 airplanes at 12:25 p.m., Eastern standard time, the very moment that Mr. Reagan was concluding his solemn Inaugural Address at the United States Capitol," its report says. Reagan announced the news at 2:15 p.m. at a luncheon with congressional leaders in the Capitol’s Statuary Hall. So Reagan, not Carter, got to bask in the glow of the hostages’ safe return.

Despite the showy announcement, scholars of the period say that Reagan did not play any significant role in freeing the hostages.

"Well before Reagan became president, the deal for releasing the hostages had already been worked out by the Carter administration's State Department and the Iranians, ably assisted by Algerian diplomats," said David Farber, author of  Taken Hostage: The Iranian Hostage Crisis and America's First Encounter with Radical Islam .

No Reagan administration officials participated in the negotiations, Farber said, and the Iranians waited to officially release the Americans as a final insult to Carter, whom they despised.

"They believed Carter had betrayed the Iranian revolution by allowing the self-exiled Shah to receive medical attention in the United States and then had threatened their new government by attempting, unsuccessfully, to use military force in April 1980 to free the hostages," Farber said.

Dave Houghton, a political scientist and author of  U.S. Foreign Policy and the Iran Hostage Crisis , told PolitiFact that Iran had a relatively unsophisticated grasp of U.S. politics, and that it was possible that the Iranians "didn’t even know what Reagan had said on the campaign trail."

"I don't think they were scared into the release," Houghton said. "In all likelihood, they released the hostages because they needed the sanctions we'd placed on them lifted so they could finance their war with Iraq."

Rubio’s comments are a misreading of history, said Michael Gunter, professor of political science at Tennessee Technological University, who has authored several papers on the 1981 hostage release.

"It is clear that Sen. Marco Rubio is falling back on an exaggerated urban legend that the only way to deal with Iran is through implied threats of military retaliation, as President Reagan supposedly did," he said. "Actually, successful U.S. diplomacy then and now played the most significant role."

Our ruling

Rubio said that Iranian hostages were released in 1981 as Reagan took office because Iran perceived that America was "no longer under the command of someone weak." In reality, Reagan’s foreign policy approach wasn’t a factor in the hostages’ release, as scholars told us. The Carter administration negotiated the deal months before Reagan’s inauguration, without involvement by Reagan or his transition team. Rubio’s claim is an imaginative re-reading of history.

 

We rate the statement Pants On Fire.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    10 years ago

Lets set back and see where this goes.  Was there bribe money involved.... was Israel involved.... is there real verifiable evidence to support the claim of the article?  

St. Raygun got away with bribery in the 1980s....... why wouldn't they now?

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    10 years ago

What does Pravda say on this issue?

The spam site is now conspiring with foreign dictatorships to spread lies. How low can the left go? 

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy  replied to  Cerenkov   10 years ago

She's now sourcing stories based solely on the media mouthpiece of the Iranian Revolutionary Guard Corp, the ideological enforces of the Islamic revolution. It's like regurgitating propaganda as news from the SS during WWII.  I'm sure she probably would have, if she were that old. 

No surprise, since she believes Iran humiliating American sailors and exploiting them for propaganda purposes is something the sailors should be thankful for.  She's exactly the type of person who would parrot translations of Pravda if it would have made the USA look bad and the USSR good.   There's no foreign dictatorship's lie she won't parrot, if she can use it to attack Republicans. 

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell  replied to  Sean Treacy   10 years ago

Come  Sean, spit it out and call him a communist. 

 
 

Who is online


mocowgirl


118 visitors