╌>

On the Vacancy Question, Learn from Justice Scalia

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  bruce-tarleton  •  10 years ago  •  12 comments

On the Vacancy Question, Learn from Justice Scalia
by Ramesh Ponnuru February 13, 2016 9:02 PM @rameshponnuru

 

A common criticism of Justice Scalia—one that I’m sure will affect the obituaries—was that his “angry,” “bitter” dissents were unbecoming of a justice, self-defeating as a matter of coalition-building, and corrosive to the institution. I myself think that Justice Scalia’s tone, when he wrote in this style, usually reflected a justifiable dismissiveness of bad arguments. More than that: He was warning Americans that the enterprise in which his colleagues were too frequently engaged was not the interpretation of law at all. He was saying, bluntly, that they were rewriting the Constitution to suit their preferences.

 

Those of us who agree with Scalia’s view should keep it in mind as we consider how to respond to the vacancy on the Supreme Court. The Constitution gives President Obama the power to nominate someone to fill it, and gives the Senate the power to decide whether to hold a vote on his nominee. Those who want Obama to have another Supreme Court appointment are going to make their arguments that time-honored norms militate in favor of what they want, and those who don’t will find time-honored norms that militate the other way. The fact that this president has repeatedly stretched the Constitution will doubtless also be part of the debate, as it should be.

 

But the norms surrounding the Court also need to be rethought in light of the role it has come to play in our national life over the last few decades. Senators—first the Democrats, then the Republicans—have already largely abandoned the old norm of “deference” to a president’s nominees: the idea that a nominee should be confirmed so long as he is ethical, has the relevant credentials, and is respected by other lawyers. As the Court has taken on more legislative authority, senators have begun to evaluate nominees as potential lawmakers.

 

As presidents also evaluate them. Obama has made it clear that he wants justices who will satisfy certain liberal litmus tests.

 

If the Supreme Court were a fundamentally apolitical body in the relevant sense—if the justices were engaged in the interpretation of legal texts in as neutral a manner as possible, letting the chips fall where they may; if, because they were neutrally interpreting a Constitution that does not grant them significant authority to decide nearly as many policy questions as they do, their decisions mattered less for the dirction of public policy; if the justices disagreed merely on the close and technical questions that even a sound judicial philosophy would leave open—then it would be entirely reasonable for senators who disagree with Obama on most issues to vote for his judges anyway. And it would be entirely reasonable to facilitate Obama’s replacement of Justice Scalia, even in a presidential-election year.

 

But that is not the situation we are now in, and Republicans should have no compunctions about acting accordingly.

Read more at: http://www.nationalreview.com/corner/431282/what-scalias-jurisprudence-suggests-about-his-replacement

 


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Uncle Bruce
Professor Silent
link   seeder  Uncle Bruce    10 years ago

Sen. Ted Cruz, appearing this morning on Meet the Press, explained why he’s opposed to President Obama nominating anyone to replace Justice Scalia. “The Senate’s duty is to advise and consent,” Cruz said. “You know what? The Senate is advising right now, we are advising that a lame-duck president in an election year is not going to be able to tip the balance of the Supreme Court. That we’re going to have an election, and if liberals are so confident that the American people want unlimited abortion on demand, want religious liberty torn down, want the Second Amendment taken away, want veterans memorials torn down, want the crosses and stars of David sandblasted off of the tombstones of our fallen veterans, then go and make the case to the people.” The statement came in response to host Chuck Todd asking why the Senate doesn’t process the nominations, even if they’re going to be rejected.

Read more at:

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell  replied to  Uncle Bruce   10 years ago

The Republican argument is basically that a president's term is only three years. 

You could expand the argument to that the president , any president, is a "lame duck" and therefore merits no power , to a presidents appointments to any office, his input on legislation, and even his plans for long and medium term foreign policy. The argument is absurd on it's face, but absurdity is seen as a positive political attribute on the right these days. 

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell    10 years ago

The Republicans will "not even bring it up" in the Senate, McConnell says. Why would that be ? We know he has the votes to defeat any Obama nominee.

They don't want the public seeing them vote down a possible moderate Obama nominee. I have already heard it speculated this tactic could cost the GOP the senate in November, as there are a number of GOP senators up for re-election in states that will not take lightly to the idea of not even holding a hearing on a Supreme Court nominee and thus keeping the chair empty for AT LEAST a year (and likely more). 

 
 
 
Uncle Bruce
Professor Silent
link   seeder  Uncle Bruce  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

a possible moderate Obama nominee

Such an animal does not exist.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell  replied to  Uncle Bruce   10 years ago

I've heard the names of a couple federal judges who were confirmed 97-0 by the senate for the federal court. So every Republican in the Senate voted for the man. If Obama nominates him , or the other one with that same 97-0 approval, the Republicans in the Senate will vote unanimously to reject him. How will that look to the voters Bruce ?

THAT is why they don't want any hearings or any vote. No matter what other bs they are pushing. 

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming   replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

I submit , I have seen a couple lists of contenders also , and some on this list have as stated met with very favorable votes already as has been mentioned , I would also submit that those votes were for specific positions , where there is a layer that if they make a mistake  it can be corrected in the higher court, being qualified for one position does not nessisarily translate to being qualified for another higher position , it may indicate consideration , but not qualification

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  Mark in Wyoming   10 years ago

I have not yet see appointments the President of the United States (as is his duty) put forward. I have no doubt that he has a team of exert jurists that the Senate can approve now or risk getting an even more liberal justice when Clinton becomes the next President

I mean did you see the last GOP debate? A bunch of inept school children could have put on a better demonstration of leadership and given better reason to elect them to such a powerful office. Compered to Hillary Clinton and even Bernie Sanders they are immature brats right out of jr high school, insulting each other and hoping the insults sick enough for the right to be the GOP representative that loses in November. The GOP does not only not have a deep bench this election year, none on their starting bench are worthy of the office they hold now, let alone President.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  Randy   10 years ago

I am watching the Movie "300" where Leonidas holds back a huge army led by Xerxes in the battle of Thermopylae. The funny part is that I could actually see Hillary Clinton in armor leading the fight against an overwhelming force.

When I look at the GOP side I see Trump trying to invite them in to buy a time-share condo and Cruz trying to convert them to Christ, when his own conversion is in question and Rubio...well Rubio...would be trying to get them to do...something...he's not sure what...but just something. Kasich asking them to pray for conversion. Oh and Christie closing off lanes of traffic.

I see no leaders on their side in an actual war. If the U.S. ever gets involved in an actual World War type war, a real serious shooting war with 100's of thousands of our troops committed to it, out of all of the candidates, I would rather have Clinton calling the shots.

 
 
 
Uncle Bruce
Professor Silent
link   seeder  Uncle Bruce  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

And don't worry about the year thing there John.  Look back at when Justice Powell retired.  It took 18 months for Reagan to get Kennedy approved, after the Democrats stalled the nomination of Bork for over a year. 

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    10 years ago

Does anyone believe  that in 2008 the democrats would have confirmed  a conservative justice to replace a  liberal Justice ? 

Of course not. In the words of barack Obama when he shut the republicans out of the stimulus negotiations in 2009, elections matter and the republicans won the senate.

 

 
 

Who is online









105 visitors