╌>

EVERY Supreme Court Justice Should Be A Moderate

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  johnrussell  •  10 years ago  •  23 comments

EVERY Supreme Court Justice Should Be A Moderate

EVERY Supreme Court Justice Should Be A Moderate




Shouldn't every Supreme Court justice be a moderate ? Why is the court ever politicized? 

There must be a procedural mechanism that could be put into place to make it most likely that justices confirmed to the Supreme Court have a prior record and and academic writing record of ideological objectivity. Not that they don't make decisions that seem liberal or conservative, but that they don't do so uniformly and totally predictably. Otherwise the Court becomes a political function and not a judicial one.




Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    10 years ago

Anton Scalia is described on the news today as a "steadfast conservative". We should not have ideologues on the court. Any court, but especially the Supreme Court, which is the last word.

What we have now are decisions that are totally predictable from justices who shape their legal "opinion" according to the desired political result. 

Scalia wanted to vote in affirmation of individual gun ownership in the Heller decision. He did not enter the deliberation with an open mind, and he looked in precedent and English Common Law for the rationale to vote in affirmation. These people are obviously smart and enough and schooled enough that when they want to find the legal backing for what is really a political position, they can do so.

Jeb Bush said on a show today that Obama's Supreme Court appointments have been "out of the mainstream" . What he means is that they weren't conservatives. This is the problem with the makeup of the court and has been for some time. 

The arguments put before the court by the involved parties should matter, but now they don't. The justices don't decide the case on the briefs or arguments, they decide the cases on ideology and then make the legal explanations fit the desired ideological slant. That is not how it should be imo.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

 In 1790, women had few rights, including no right to vote, including on the elected positions that were held by many of the founding fathers.
Blacks had no rights in slave states. 
Health insurance did not exist. 
Motorized transportation did not exist, in any form, other than a very fledgling steam boat. 
Corporations did not exist in their modern form. The list is long. 

To say that interpretations of the constitution should not change with the times is borderline insane.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

To say that interpretations of the constitution should not change with the times is borderline insane.

Yeah , that Patriot Act was quite a change . It deactivated a few of the original Bill of Rights amendments . Insane ...

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    10 years ago

We should not have ideologues on the court

Get rid of lawyers who believe in the "living constitution" that hinges on the whims of 5 justices and you'll go along way towards accomplishing that goal. If you want judges to judge on the law, get rid of interpretive schools that allow the judge to ignore the meaning  of the Constitution and statues. 

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell  replied to  Sean Treacy   10 years ago

"Originalists" are ideologues. 

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

"So to counterbalance the Court's criticism of our ancestors, let me say a word in their praise: they left us free to change. The same cannot be said of this most illiberal Court, which has embarked on a course of inscribing one after another of the current preferences of the society (and in some cases only the counter-majoritarian preferences of the society's law-trained elite) into our Basic Law."  Justice Scalia. 

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

Lemme guess John, the only people who aren't "idealogues" are those who faithfully implement prevailing liberal sensibilities into their interpretation  of the Constitution. 

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell  replied to  Sean Treacy   10 years ago

Should schools be desegregated by federal order or should an "originalist" viewpoint prevail ? 

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

 

Sure. under the 13th and 14th amendment, school segregation was unconstitutional.  The dissent in the 1890's Plessy v. Ferguson spells that out.

But the majority in Plessy substituted their personal beliefs for the actual text of the Constitution, and you get 50 plus years of legalized segregation as a result.  To quote Justice Harlan:

 " But in the view of the Constitution, in the eye of the law, there is in this country no superior, dominant, ruling class of citizens.  There is no caste here.  Our Constitution in color-blind and neither knows nor tolerates classes among citizens.  In respect of civil rights, all citizens are equal before the law.   The humblest is the peer of the most powerful.  The law regards man as man and takes no account of his surroundings or of his color when his civil rights as guaranteed by the supreme law of the land are involved.."

If only we would heed those words....

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

John, The Court in Brown largely abandoned any attempt at justifying it's order by originalist principles.  Instead, it relied mainly on social science evidence that demonstrated that "separate but equal" hurt black students.

So following the rationale of Brown, you would agree a State can in fact reimpose segregation if it can demonstrate through the social sciences that segregation did not harm black students? That would be the living Constituion in action, right?  

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    10 years ago

If there is a topic Justice Antonin Scalia does not relish discussing, it is how he would have voted in Brown v. Board of Education had he been on the Supreme Court when it was decided in 1954.

 

The question came up last month at the University of Arizona in what was billed as a conversation between Justice Scalia and Justice Stephen G. Breyer. The discussion, between the court’s two primary intellectual antagonists, bore the relationship to a conversation that a fistfight does to a handshake. The justices know how to get under each other’s skin, and they punctuated their debate with exasperation, eye-rolling and venomous sarcasm.

 

The Brown decision, which said the 14th Amendment prohibited segregation in public schools, is hard to square with Justice Scalia’s commitment to originalism, the theory of constitutional interpretation that says judges must apply the original understanding of the constitutional text.

 

 

Brown presents originalists with a problem. The weight of the historical evidence is that the people who drafted, proposed and ratified the 14th Amendment from 1866 to 1868 did not believe themselves to be doing away with segregated schools.

 

 

 

Justices Antonin Scalia, left, and Stephen G. Breyer have differing views of how the Constitution should be interpreted. Credit Carol T. Powers for The New York Times

Yet Brown is widely thought to be a moral triumph. A theory of constitutional interpretation that cannot account for Brown is suspect if not discredited.

 

Originalists hate the subject. Justice Scalia has called it “waving the bloody shirt of Brown.”

 

About 20 minutes into their discussion in Arizona, Justice Breyer turned to the case.

 

“Where would you be with school desegregation?” the justice asked with a satisfied expression. “It’s certainly clear that at the time they passed the 14th Amendment, which says people should be treated equally, there was school segregation and they didn’t think they were ending it.”

 

 

Justice Breyer, who has a more flexible view of constitutional interpretation than Justice Scalia, said the solution was to identify the value underlying the language in the Constitution and to ignore the specific understandings of those who ratified it.

 

Justice Scalia, in high sarcasm mode, said relying on general values was not a legitimate way to conduct judicial business, and dismissed the idea that using such a method was easy.

 

“Piece of cake,” Justice Scalia said, his voice dripping with disdain. “Piece of cake. Following the ‘values.’ ” He spat out that last word as though he had just taken a spoonful of anthrax.

 

But Justice Scalia did not give a direct answer to how he would have voted in Brown.

 

“As for Brown v. Board of Education, I think I would have” — and then he changed directions.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

What a thoroughly disingenuous article. Scalia stated on numerous occasions that he would have voted with the Brown majority.  Here's a direct quote from one of his books:

text of the Thirteenth and Fourteenth Amendments, and in particular the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment, can reasonably be thought to prohibit all laws designed to assert the separateness and superiority of the white race, even those that purport to treat the races equally.  Justice John Marshall Harlan took this position in his powerful (and thoroughly originalist) dissent in Plessy v. Ferguson.

 Reading Law: The Interpretation of Legal Texts

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell  replied to  Sean Treacy   10 years ago

I think he was glad he wasn't there in 1954. 

“Don’t make up your mind on this significant question between originalism and playing it by ear on the basis of whether, now and then, the latter approach might give you a result you like,” Justice Scalia said.

“The test is over the long run does it require the society to adhere to those principles contained in the Constitution or does it lead to a society that is essentially governed by nine justices’ version of what equal protection ought to mean?”"

What he was saying here is rather clear. There might be a "now and then" instance where "playing it by ear" would lead to the preferred result. 

Preferred by who? Preferred result implies predetermination of the decision. That of course , would not be what the founders would have wanted , would it? 

The founders had nothing to say about racial desegregation because it didn't seem to them like a potential problem. There are many many things that have occurred since 1787 that did not occur to the founders. 

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

he founders had nothing to say about racial desegregation because it didn't seem to them like a potential problem

The 14th Amendment exists, you know. It counts just as much to an originalist as any other part of the document. 

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell  replied to  Sean Treacy   10 years ago

Scalia seems to have not believed wholeheartedly that the 14th amendment was a basis to end desegregation. Something about the original intent of the amendment. 

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    10 years ago

If Scalia did not answer how he would vote on Brown it is because he knew that his "principles" would have led him opposite the decision. 

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

"In a 2005 profile in The New Yorker, Justice Scalia said he would have voted with the majority in Brown. But he did not explain why. Liptak writes that Scalia seemed to suggest that Brown reached the right result as a policy matter but that it was not compelled by the Constitution.

Still, in Arizona, Scalia was a fervent defender of the originalist approach. “Don’t make up your mind on this significant question between originalism and playing it by ear on the basis of whether, now and then, the latter approach might give you a result you like,” Justice Scalia said.

“The test is over the long run does it require the society to adhere to those principles contained in the Constitution or does it lead to a society that is essentially governed by nine justices’ version of what equal protection ought to mean?”"

 

So, if we follow this implication, Scalia would have voted with the majority to compel de-segregation, but he would have done so by modifying or dropping his originalist principles. 

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

You keep relying on implications and insinuations rather than direct evidence of what he's actually said on this topic. 

 He said he would have voted with the Brown majority and laid out the originalist interpretation that supports such a decision. 

As he made clear, the idea that Brown is some sorta "gotcha" question from liberals is a joke. It's gets run out there debate after debate by novice  after novice even though it's easily dealt with. The orginalist rationale to support desegregation was set forth 130 years ago, it's no great secret. 

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell  replied to  Sean Treacy   10 years ago

Sean, I quoted him directly, as reported by the New York Times. 

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

Scalia seemed to suggest that Brown

You are hanging  your hat on "seemed to suggest."    

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    10 years ago

It's strange but telling that having any professional opinion or philosophy means one is an ideologue to some. Apparently they should have NO ideas about jurisprudence. 

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    10 years ago

Interesting point. 

In a very unscientific study, I've seen Justices historically tack towards the center after appointment. Only in the last 25 years have I seen them pretty much linger where they started along ideological lines.

Judiciary imitating politics? I would hope not. You don't really owe anyone anything after appointment. It's kind of difficult to have a Justice removed, especially if the reason is that you don't agree with his opinions on an ideological basis. A primary reason for the lifetime appointment is to be unencumbered by external forces that might lead you to an artificial bias.

It is curious...

 
 

Who is online









105 visitors