5 Reasons the Top Tax Rate Should Be 80 Percent
http://www.commondreams.org/views/2016/02/15/5-reasons-top-tax-rate-should-be-80-percent
5 Reasons the Top Tax Rate Should Be 80 Percent
5 Reasons the Top Tax Rate Should Be 80%
It came up in the Republican debate again, the curious notion that striving for less inequality is somehow a form of "class warfare." The implication is that the richest people earned everything they have through their own initiative and hard work. But most of them have exploited an American financial system that has facilitated the transfer of our national wealth to the people who manage that wealth.
Informed Americans understand that an economic war has been waged against the middle and lower classes. As a result, there are at least five good reasons why the tax rate on the upper classes should be MUCH higher.
1. Massive Redistribution Has Occurred. Upward.
Total U.S. wealth increased by a stunning 60 percent since 2009, from $54 trillion to $86 trillion, but 3/4 of that massive increase went to the richest 10% of Americans. According to the New York Times , the wealthiest Americans have formed an "income defense industry" to shelter their riches, with, "a high-priced phalanx of lawyers, estate planners, lobbyists and anti-tax activists who exploit and defend a dizzying array of tax maneuvers, virtually none of them available to taxpayers of more modest means." From 2003 to 2012 the average income tax rate paid by the richest 1% went down, while for the 99% it went up.
2. Subsidies to the Rich are SIX Times Greater Than Subsidies to the Poor
The cost of the entire Safety Net is only about ONE-SIXTH of the $2.2 trillion in tax expenditures, tax underpayments, tax havens, and corporate nonpayment, the great majority of which went to the richest Americans.
3. The Super-Rich are the Main Beneficiaries of Our Nation's Prosperity
All the technology in our phones and computers started with government research at the Defense Department , the National Science Foundation , the Census Bureau , and public universities . The Internet made possible the quadrillion-dollar trading capacity of the financial industry. Google is using some of its billions to buy technologies that were built by DARPA with our tax dollars . Pharmaceutical companies wouldn't exist without money from the taxpayers, who have provided support for decades through the National Institutes of Health , and still pay over 80 percent of the cost of basic research for new drugs and vaccines. Big firms use intellectual property law (another gift from the taxpayers) to snatch up patents on any new money-making products, no matter how much government- and university-funded research went into it.
There's much more. The wealthiest individuals and corporations are the main beneficiaries of tax laws, tax breaks , property rights, zoning rules, patent and copyright provisions, trade pacts, antitrust legislation, and contract regulations. The largest companies benefit , despite their publicly voiced objections to regulatory agencies, from SBA and SEC guidelines that generally favor business, and from FDA and USDA quality control measures that minimize consumer complaints and product recalls. Businesses rely on roads and seaports and airports to ship their products, the FAA and TSA and Coast Guard and Department of Transportation to safeguard them, a nationwide energy grid to power their factories, communications towers and satellites to conduct online business, the Department of Commerce to promote and safeguard global markets , the U.S. Navy to monitor shipping lanes , and FEMA to clean up after them.
But instead of paying for all the taxpayer-funded benefits, S&P corporations have spent 95 percent of its profits on stock buybacks and dividend payouts to enrich their investors.
4. Progressive Taxes Actually Work
The prominent economic team of Piketty and Saez and Stantcheva determined that "the top tax rate could potentially be set as high as 83%" before the highest earners are discouraged from attempting to earn more. The National Bureau of Economic Research goes further, proposing a top marginal rate of 90%, and even some conservative analysts concede that the optimal maximum may be at least 50%.
Since the 1970s libertarians and business leaders have rallied behind trickle-down theory. Thus a series of tax cuts for the rich. But evidence from numerous sources leads to the conclusion that there is no correlation between tax cuts and GDP growth, and that in fact the cuts cause governments (as common sense would dictate) to lose revenue.
5. Higher Taxes Won't Make Rich People Leave
During the Republican debates Chris Christie claimed that higher taxes caused wealthy New Jersey residents to leave the state. It's not true. A Stanford study found that lower-income residents left New Jersey at approximately the same rate. "Overall," said the authors, "higher income earners show greater residential stability and geographic embeddedness than do low income earners."
A Conclusion: The Washington Examiner referred to Bernie Sanders as an "elderly extremist." Elderly, yes. But as Democratic debate moderators noted , over two-thirds of Americans favor increased taxes on people making over a million dollars. The desire to reduce inequality is not extreme at all.
Tags
seeder
JohnRussell
10 years agoFrom 2003 to 2012 the average income tax rate paid by the richest 1% went down, while for the 99% it went up.
-
The cost of the entire Safety Net is only about ONE-SIXTH of the $2.2 trillion in tax expenditures, tax underpayments, tax havens, and corporate nonpayment, the great majority of which went to the richest Americans.
-
The Internet made possible the quadrillion-dollar trading capacity of the financial industry. Google is using some of its billions to buy technologies that were built by DARPA with our tax dollars . Pharmaceutical companies wouldn't exist without money from the taxpayers, who have provided support for decades through the National Institutes of Health , and still pay over 80 percent of the cost of basic research for new drugs and vaccines.
-
Since the 1970s libertarians and business leaders have rallied behind trickle-down theory. Thus a series of tax cuts for the rich. But evidence from numerous sources leads to the conclusion that there is no correlation between tax cuts and GDP growth
-
seeder
JohnRussell
10 years ago
Three trillion dollars a year. That's how much the wealthiest Americans avoid through the system of subsidies and schemes and sweet deals that deprive middle-class workers of their earned benefits. That's three times more than the deficit. That's enough for a full-time job for every middle-class household in America. Here are the distressing details:
Protesters gathered in the Minnesota state capitol rotunda in April of 2010. (Fight Back! News/Kim DeFranco)
1. Tax Expenditures: $1.25 trillion
These subsidies from special deductions, exemptions, exclusions, credits, capital gains, and loopholes are estimated to be worth 7.4% of the GDP, or about $1.1 trillion. They largely benefit the richest taxpayers. Business subsidies bring the total to $1.25 trillion.
That alone is almost enough to pay for Social Security ($884 billion) and Medicare ($524 billion).
But there's so much more.
2. Tax Underpayments: $450 billion
According to the IRS, 17 percent of taxes owed were not paid in 2006, leaving an underpayment of $450 billion. The largest share of that came from underreporting of income.
3. Tax Havens: up to $250 billion
(a) It's estimated that between $21 and $32 trillion is hidden offshore, untaxed.
(b) 40% of the world's richest individuals are Americans. That's $8 to $12 trillion of the total.
(c) The historical annual stock market return is 6%. That's a return of $480 to $720 billion.
(d) The 20% to 35% tax loss amounts to a minimum of $96 billion, a maximum of $252 billion.
4. Corporate Taxes: $250 billion
For over 20 years, from 1987 to 2008, corporations paid an average of 22.5% in federal taxes. Since the recession, this has dropped to 10% -- even though their profits have doubled in less than ten years. The missing 12.5% on $2 trillion in profits amounts to $250 billion a year.
5. Financial Transaction Tax (FTT): $500 billion
The absence of an FTT constitutes tax avoidance. Not a penny of sales tax is paid on U.S. financial transactions, which have been estimated at about three quadrillion dollars annually, or three thousand times the deficit. No sales tax is paid despite the high-risk nature of "flash trading" that can lose entire pension funds in a few seconds.
Just a half penny from every dollar of total U.S. financial transactions would pay off the national debt -- not just the deficit, but the whole $15 trillion debt. More conservative estimates by the Center for Economic and Policy Research and the Chicago Political Economy Group suggest FTT revenues of a half-trillion dollars annually.
6. Payroll Tax: $300 billion
This extremely regressive tax costs the richest Americans only a small fraction of what everyone else pays. If the 12.4% tax (half employer, half employee) were assessed on the full $3.84 trillion claimed by the richest 10% in 2006 (instead of on $1.43 trillion: $110,000 times 13 million payees), an additional $300 billion in revenue would have been realized.
7. Estate Tax: $100 billion
A repeal of the estate tax , which is designed to impact only the tiny percentage of Americans with multi-million dollar estates that have never been taxed, would cost the nation about $100 billion per year.
Conclusion
The total surpasses $3 trillion. The figures may be on the high end, and there may be some overlap, and wealthy Americans may argue that much of it is legal. But the system of loopholes and deductions and exclusions is a statement by the rich that they don't have to pay for their lopsided share of benefits, and that middle-income Americans should give up their own earned benefits to pay the country's bills.
Cerenkov
replied to
JohnRussell
10 years agoWhat hogwash. The use of existing tax laws, the nonexistence of ridiculous transaction taxes, and other unrelated nonsense constitutes subsidies? ! I think the author needs more education before he continental with his purge of the elite.
seeder
JohnRussell
10 years agoThere was a comment made here yesterday decrying how the (presumably lower classes) people are demanding "breads and circuses" and a free ride, and for someone to pay their way, etc etc. , and that is supposed to be the biggest problem facing the country.
People who make those comments either give the big picture NO THOUGHT or lie to themselves, or lie to the rest of us.
Why do we hear these people whine incessantly about "welfare cheats" but we never hear them complain about tax cheats ?
The top down class warfare has succeeded beyond the top's wildest dreams.
Cerenkov
replied to
JohnRussell
10 years agoBeing successful is not warfare. Stealing their wealth is.
seeder
JohnRussell
replied to
Cerenkov
10 years agoAccording to this article, many people deliberately avoid paying taxes that they are legally and or morally obligated to pay (they are taxes that are on the books.) Unpaid taxes seemingly amount to much more than the entirety of the social safety net. It is a disgrace on this country.
Cerenkov
replied to
JohnRussell
10 years agoSo the solution to people not paying their taxes is to raise the rates for those that do pay. Brilliant.
Cerenkov
10 years agoMore ridiculous class warfare and propaganda from the socialists. Redistribution of wealth is violence. At 80%, people will simply leave. We've seen it in France. The government and it's useful idiots (like the author) do not deserve most of the fruits of my labor.
seeder
JohnRussell
replied to
Cerenkov
10 years agoI would think a little lower would be in order. The article, if you read it, isn't about an 80% tax rate. It is about tax avoidance. If people paid the taxes that are now on the books the country would be much better off.
The wealthy rig the game. I don't understand why anyone thinks this is better, more acceptable , or more noble than someone who lies to collect an extra 50 dollars of food stamps.
We don't have the money to pay people better wages, because we need it for ourselves. That is the mindset and unspoken action of the top.
seeder
JohnRussell
10 years agoDonald Trump has been asked a little lately about when he is going to release his tax returns, like all candidates do. He says he will do so "in a few months" . He has been saying that for many months.
He was asked if people will be surprised to learn that he pays so much or pays so little. He said that people will see he pays very little in taxes. "I hate what they want to do with my money" he says as a justification for "cheating" on his taxes.
If Trump wants to prepare his followers and the public for the fact that he pays so little, you can be sure it is little.
Some working chump who "wants his country back" ,and so will vote for Trump, will learn that he pays a higher tax rate than his hero.
Who is online
105 visitors
