Are Republicans Playing With Fire By Saying They Will Not Hold Supreme Court Confirmation Hearing ?
As the days come after the death of Supreme Court Justice Anton Scalia, the landscape is getting a little clearer concerning a possible replacement. Sen Mitch McConnell, the GOP Senate Majority Leader says there will be no confirmation hearing of a new nominee during President Obama's term. This can be presumed to be a rejection of Obama's nominee on the basis of ideological unacceptability to conservatives, and also a roll of the dice hope that the new President might be a Republican and someone who would appoint a conservative to the seat.
Fair or not, these motives are clear. How will the voters react in an election year ?
Consider -
Every prior nominee to the Supreme Court has received a Senate confirmation hearing within 100 days of the nomination.
Since 1900, every time a high court opening came up during an election year, the "lame duck" President nominated a potential successor and the nominee was given a hearing.
- President William Taft, a Republican running for re-election, nominated Mahlon Pickney in 1912, and the GOP-controlled Senate confirmed him. Taft lost the election later that year.
- In 1916, Democratic President Woodrow Wilson nominated Louis Brandeis and John Clark while running for re-election. The Democrat-controlled Senate confirmed both of them, and Wilson won another four years in office.
- GOP President Herbert Hoover, running for re-election in 1932, nominated Benjamin Cardozo, and the Republican-controlled Senate confirmed him. Hoover was voted out of office that year.
- In 1940, President Franklin Delano Roosevelt, a Democrat, nominated Frank Murphy, who was confirmed by the Democrat-controlled Senate. Roosevelt went on to win another term that year.
- President Dwight Eisenhower, running for re-election, nominated appointed William J. Brennan to the court while the Senate was in recess in late 1956. Eisenhower won the election, and Brennan was formally confirmed by the Senate the following year.
- President Lyndon Johnson, who had chosen not to seek re-election, nominated Abe Fortas, who was already an associate justice on the court, to become chief justice in 1968. In that case, the Senate blocked Fortas' promotion with a filibuster.
And there is the sitting justice Anthony Kennedy, who was confirmed in February of 1988, an election year, after having been nominated by Reagan late in 1987.
The logical and reasonable basis for McConnell saying no hearing will be held and the SC seat kept vacant seems not to exist.
What about the people who voted for Barack Obama for president in 2012 ? When they punched that ballot, was it with the understanding that Obama's term would only be three years long, or was it with the belief and understanding that he would perform his appointed functions until the day he leaves office in Jan of 2017 ? Why would someone vote for a president who was going to be cut short of his 4 years ? So the Republicans want to disenfranchise, so to speak, the 50 some million Obama voters from last time.
What is going on?
The Republicans do not want to confirm an Obama nominee. It is anathema to them. They are scared to death that Obama will appoint someone that the public will see as reasonable and proper for the court, and when they vote such a person down they believe it will negatively effect them in the fall elections.
Not good enough.
Tags
Who is online
105 visitors

Laurence Tribe, a Supreme Court expert historian, said tonight that the Republican stance is unprecedented and disgraceful.
It is disgraceful. It's a temper tantrum.
After all, what difference does it make if Obama or Hillary/Bernie selects a Supreme Court Judge?
Dowser, every prior Supreme Court nominee has gotten a hearing, including the six , post 1900, who were nominated in a presidential election year.
On what possible basis do they now say, "no, not this time" ?
It makes it look like they are trying to delegitimize President Obama or somethin'.
What a joke. Tribe parrots whatever democrats want him to say and has been doing so since the Bork nomination. He's the epitome of a hack.
Every sentient person knows the Democrats would do the exact same thing. Schumer publicly announced with 18 months left in Bush's second term that the Democrats would not confirm another Bush Supreme Court nominee.
The Democratic arguments are completely hypocritical, simply embarrassing.
Sean, every one who has ever been nominated to the Supreme Court got a Senate hearing within 100 days.
The longest that it has ever taken to have an up and down vote for a nominee is 129 days.
Every nominee that came up in an election year since 1900 has gotten a senate hearing.
On what POSSIBLE basis would you deny it now ?
This is set to blow up in the Republican faces if they try to go through with this.
How often have you and your ilk complained about "pointless" votes on Obamacare? Why tie up the Senate for months for a nomination that has no chance of confirmation?
Republicans are just playing by the rules championed by democrats. Barack Obama had no problem denying an up or down vote for Supreme Court nominees as a Senator, no reason why Republicans shouldn't follow his example.
This is not a good look for the GOP.
Nothing stands as a better testament to Scalia's correctness of jurisprudence then the uproar surrounding his replacement. The politicization of the judiciary ushered in by judges setting themselves up as super legislators is tearing the country apart, because Supreme Court nominations now mean more than appointing someone to solve legal problems.
Instead, justices are now priests imposing their morals on the country in the name of a "living Constitution." So all's fair now in appointing these overlords, who impose their will more surely than Roman emperors.
Jonah goldberg encapsulates it better than I can:
But philosophically this is a world liberals created. They have invested in the courts’ having power the Framers never intended. Their doctrine of the living Constitution has given, in theory, an open-ended warrant for courts to do whatever they want. People lament the rush of money into politics, but that money is made necessary by a government that has evermore control over the economy and peoples’ lives. Similarly, when we turned justices into monarchs, we increased the incentives for people to care much more than they should. If Scalia’s interpretation of the Constitution held sway in the land, the Court and the government would have much less power over our lives. And that, more than anything else, explains why the Left hated him so much.
Read more at:
Touching.
I believe there should be a nomination, followed by hearings, then a vote. That's how it is supposed to work. Not holding hearings is a lot like holding your breath to get your own way. Far more likely, this is all just posturing with the sudden death of Judge Scalia.
I guess we'll see how the drama plays out.