Ted Cruz must recuse himself on Scalia replacement
http://www.cnn.com/2016/02/15/opinions/supreme-court-ted-cruz-must-recuse-lubet/index.html
It is far from a given that Cruz is constitutionally qualified to be president, and his status, if nominated, is sure to be challenged in court. (The one case already filed was an easily dismissed nuisance suit, but serious litigation would certainly follow from an actual Cruz nomination.)
Such a case would ultimately reach the U.S. Supreme Court, which gives Cruz a unique stake in filling the current vacancy. If Cruz were to remain an active member of the Judiciary Committee, he would actually have a chance to interrogate -- and to vote upon -- his own potential judge.
Tags
Who is online
105 visitors

An interesting twist to be sure...
Birthers are funny.
Did you read the article ?
Yes, it was funny. Cruz won't recuse himself, he doesn't need to, and it wouldn't matter if he did.
I did and it makes a some very good points. There is a conflict of interests, but I am not sure if there is enough law on the books to make that stick.
I think it would set a precedent if it did.
I agree... but until then, the only reason he would do it, is to be honorable.
Whether or not Cruz should recuse himself, it is unlikely to happen, because that would require a sense of moral duty, and he has none.
If he did, then that would elevate his character, in my own mind. But, when you're starting at rock bottom, he has a long way to go, and I don't believe that I have to worry about it...
Can other members of the legislature require that he do so? Perhaps, but they are unwilling to do so...
If Kagan didn't recuse herself previously for much better (i.e., real) reasons, Cruz certainly does not need to.
Who was Kagan? Was he running for president?
I'm not being ugly, the name is truly unfamiliar to me...
I agree, there is a conflict of interest with Cruz.
A person of integrity would withdraw, but that person isn't Cruz.
The article implies that the Code of Conduct for US judges should apply to Congress with absolutely no basis whatsoever for thinking that members of the judicial and legislative branches are similarly situated. Federal judges make decisions based solely on the law and the record in the case before them. Their decisions are supposed to be unbiased. Federal judges are appointed, not elected, and can only be removed for very limited reasons. Legislators, on the other hand, make political decisions on any basis they see fit and, if the public doesn't like it, they vote them out at the next election cycle. I doubt Cruz would bother interrogating an appointee on a point of law that is not the subject of a dispute between federal circuits.
As for Trump's threatened suit, he should file it or just shut up because he's not scaring Cruz at all. There are only two ways of becoming a citizen: you must either be natural born or naturalized. Cruz was born to an American mother and was therefore a "natural born citizen" at birth. Because he was "natural born", he didn't need to go through a naturalization process. This is true of any child born to an American citizen, traveling or living abroad. I don't know why Lawrence Tribe (in the lined article) is acting like this is an open issue to him when he himself, in a 2008 memo on John McCain, said the phrase "natural born citizen" includes "both birth abroad to parents who were citizens AND birth within the nation's territory and allegiance." According to Tribe, the First Congress recognized that children born abroad to American citizens are natural born citizens. In McCain's case, he was both the natural born child of an American citizen and also born in a US territory but there's nothing that says he had to meet both criteria. A federal court would likely reach the same conclusion and the Supreme Court could simply deny to hear any appeal as they do in most cases.
Being born to one American parent does not make you a citizen, especially when being born on foreign soil such as Canada. The INS law was changed in 1986 and we know Cruz is older than that.
Being born to one American parent does not make you a citizen, especially when being born on foreign soil such as Canada. The INS law was changed in 1986 and we know Cruz is older than that.
I disagree. Confusion may arise if a child is born to a naturalized citizen. That raises acquisition and derivation issues. However, a child born to a mother who was herself a natural born citizen, is a natural born citizen.