This Supreme Court Fight is Nothing New
This article is from 2007:
New York Sen. Charles E. Schumer, a powerful member of the Democratic leadership, said Friday the Senate should not confirm another U.S. Supreme Court nominee under President Bush “except in extraordinary circumstances.”
“We should reverse the presumption of confirmation,” Schumer told the American Constitution Society convention in Washington. “The Supreme Court is dangerously out of balance. We cannot afford to see Justice Stevens replaced by another Roberts, or Justice Ginsburg by another Alito.”
Schumer’s assertion comes as Democrats and liberal advocacy groups are increasingly complaining that the Supreme Court with Bush’s nominees – Chief Justice John Roberts and Associate Justice Samuel A. Alito – has moved quicker than expected to overturn legal precedents.
Senators were too quick to accept the nominees’ word that they would respect legal precedents, and “too easily impressed with the charm of Roberts and the erudition of Alito,” Schumer said.
“There is no doubt that we were hoodwinked,” said Schumer, who sits on the Senate Judiciary Committee and heads the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee.
A White House spokeswoman, Dana Perino, said Schumer's comments show "a tremendous disrespect for the Constitution" by suggesting that the Senate not confirm nominees.
"This is the kind of blind obstruction that people have come to expect from Sen. Schumer," Perino said. "He has an alarming habit of attacking people whose character and position make them unwilling or unable to respond. That is the sign of a bully. If the past is any indication, I would bet that we would see a Democratic senatorial fundraising appeal in the next few days."
Schumer voted against confirming Roberts and Alito. In Friday’s speech, he said his “greatest regret” in the last Congress was not doing more to scuttle Alito.
“Alito shouldn’t have been confirmed,” Schumer said. “I should have done a better job. My colleagues said we didn’t have the votes, but I think we should have twisted more arms and done more.”
While no retirements appear imminent, Bush still could have the opportunity to fill another vacancy on the court. Yet the two oldest members – Justice John Paul Stevens, 87, and Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, 74 – are part of the court's liberal bloc and could hold off retirement until Bush leaves office in January, 2009.
Earlier this week, Pennsylvania Sen. Arlen Specter, the Judiciary Committee’s ranking Republican, said he was persuaded by a conversation with Justice Stephen G. Breyer, who spoke with Specter at the Aspen Institute gathering in Colorado this month, to study the decisions of the Roberts Court. The term that ended in June was notable for several rulings that reversed or chipped away at several long-standing decisions, delighting conservatives but enraging liberals.
Breyer has publicly raised concerns that conservative justices were violating stare decisis, the legal doctrine that, for the sake of stability, courts should generally leave precedents undisturbed.
“It is not often in the law that so few have so quickly changed so much,” Breyer said, reading his dissent from the bench in June to a 5-4 ruling that overturned school desegregation policies in two cities.
Schumer said there were four lessons to be learned from Alito and Roberts: Confirmation hearings are meaningless, a nominee’s record should be weighed more heavily than rhetoric, “ideology matters” and “take the president at his word.”
“When a president says he wants to nominate justices in the mold of [Antonin] Scalia and [Clarence] Thomas,” Schumer said, “believe him.”
Tags
Who is online
105 visitors

Just to some history to the current histrionics we're seeing since Justice Scalia's death. I disagree with McConnell now and I disagreed with Schumer then. Let the President pick a nominee and let the senate review and then vote yea or nay and move on.
For those that say the Republicans are the problem? Looks like they are just following the game plan built by the Democrats.
I think it is hilarious how both parties pull crap then have a fit when the other does it.
It is hilarious to watch the "conservatives" try and spin this. Fruitlessly I might add.
There has never been a US Supreme Court nominee who did not receive either a hearing or a vote ,or both, within 100 days of when they were nominated.
The Republicans can accept the nomination of the president, hold their show hearing, and then vote down the nominee if that is their choice (since they hold the majority in the Senate) . What they can't do, according to the ENTIRETY of the historical precedent, is refuse to engage in the process.
What is it about this plain factual information that some of you don't understand ?
I understand it all, John and if you've read my comments this week, they are consistent: The President makes a nomination and the Senate holds hearings and decides by vote whether to provide or not provide their consent.
What is silly is that the Democrats, up to and including the President are acting like the Republicans are breaking new ground, which they are not, proven by the 2007 article seeded above and many other supporting articles and news stories.
I'm not sure that hiding behind the 'Pompous Ass' personality has any place in this discussion, regardless, you should try to not be that person.
People like you are locked into the "both sides do it" mode, seemingly. That's ok, a lot of people are.
There is no real equivalency between a threat made by Schumer when no Supreme Court nomination was forthcoming and the promise made by McConnell when a supreme court nomination is at the doorstep.
We can discuss whatever people like, but let's leave the "equivalency' out of it unless it applies.
They are completely consistent unless one is blinded by partisan bias.
Or you don't know how to make a logical argument, which would be your case.
I found this and just had to post it somewhere on NT... This is as good a place as any!
That's funny......or Trump-he'd probably nominate his daughter......there is something kind of creepy about his daughter fixation....outside of the whole 'Trump' personality thing I mean.
I thought it was funny... Even though I knew that the very thought would be like waving a red flag in front of a bull... I meant it to be tongue-in-cheek.
Trump IS scary. Do you think he is fixated on his daughter because she looks like her mother when she was young? I sometimes wonder about that... Trump seems to be a little bit too fixated, or adoring, or whatever. It's like Jessica Simpson's dad-- what does he know about his daughter's breasts? He sure talks about them enough! UGH!