Hey, Seattle! How's that $15 minimum wage working out for you?
The American Enterprise Institute blog reveals the not very surprising news that 10 months into Seattle's radical experiment of boosting the minimum wage to $15 an hour over a period of years, the city has suffered the worst job losses since the Great Recession.
Now that the first Seattle minimum wage increase has been in effect for more than ten months, and as local employers brace for the additional minimum wage hikes that will eventually increase their annual labor costs per full-time minimum wage worker by 61% and by a whopping $11,300 (from the increase in hourly labor costs from $9.32 to $15 an hour), are there any noticeable effects so far on the city’s labor market? Is Seattle’s radical experiment with the highest-ever minimum wage in US history serving as a “model for the rest of the nation to follow”? Or is Seattle serving as an “economic canary in the coal mine” for other cities and states (and the country) considering the “bold action” of imposing higher labor costs on employers by as much as $15,500 annually per full-time minimum wage workers if they enact legislation increasing the minimum wage from $7.25 to $15 an hour?
Early evidence from the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) on Seattle’s monthly employment, the number of unemployed workers, and the city’s unemployment rate through December 2015 suggest that since last April when the first minimum wage hike took effect: a) the city’s employment has fallen by more than 11,000, b) the number of unemployed workers has risen by nearly 5,000, and c) the city’s jobless rate has increased by more than 1 percentage point (all based on BLS’s “not seasonally adjusted basis”). Those figures are based on employment data for the city of Seattle only (not the Seattle MSA or MD), and are available from the BLS website here (data are “not seasonally adjusted”).
How can we be sure that the increase in minimum wage is to blame? Employment in the neighboring suburbs of the city have hit a record high:
Update: The chart below shows that while the city of Seattle experienced a sharp drop in employment of more 11,000 jobs between April and December last year (light blue line, BLS data available here), employment in Seattle’s neighboring suburbs outside the city limits (the Seattle MSA jobs less Seattle city jobs) increased over that period by nearly 57,000 jobs and reached a new record high in November 2015 before falling slightly in December.
Bottom Line II: Additional evidence showing that while jobs in the city of Seattle were tanking starting last April, employment in the suburbs surrounding Seattle was increasing steadily to a new record high in November. That departure in employment trends: job declines inside the city limits of Seattle compared to increasing employment outside the city limits suggests the possibility that the difference in labor costs could have been a contributing factor.
If supporters of the $15 minimum wage have an alternate theory, I'm willing to consider it. But the AEI analysis suggests that not only are people losing their jobs, but that the creation of new businesses to take up the slack is also lagging.
Read more: http://www.americanthinker.com/blog/2016/02/hey_seattle_hows_that_15_minimum_wage_working_out_for_ya.html#ixzz40jKX1IQq
Follow us: @AmericanThinker on Twitter | AmericanThinker on Facebook
Now that the first Seattle minimum wage increase has been in effect for more than ten months, and as local employers brace for the additional minimum wage hikes that will eventually increase their annual labor costs per full-time minimum wage worker by 61% and by a whopping $11,300 (from the increase in hourly labor costs from $9.32 to $15 an hour), are there any noticeable effects so far on the city’s labor market? Is Seattle’s radical experiment with the highest-ever minimum wage in US history serving as a “model for the rest of the nation to follow”? Or is Seattle serving as an “economic canary in the coal mine” for other cities and states (and the country) considering the “bold action” of imposing higher labor costs on employers by as much as $15,500 annually per full-time minimum wage workers if they enact legislation increasing the minimum wage from $7.25 to $15 an hour?
Early evidence from the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) on Seattle’s monthly employment, the number of unemployed workers, and the city’s unemployment rate through December 2015 suggest that since last April when the first minimum wage hike took effect: a) the city’s employment has fallen by more than 11,000, b) the number of unemployed workers has risen by nearly 5,000, and c) the city’s jobless rate has increased by more than 1 percentage point (all based on BLS’s “not seasonally adjusted basis”). Those figures are based on employment data for the city of Seattle only (not the Seattle MSA or MD), and are available from the BLS website here (data are “not seasonally adjusted”).
How can we be sure that the increase in minimum wage is to blame? Employment in the neighboring suburbs of the city have hit a record high:
Update: The chart below shows that while the city of Seattle experienced a sharp drop in employment of more 11,000 jobs between April and December last year (light blue line, BLS data available here), employment in Seattle’s neighboring suburbs outside the city limits (the Seattle MSA jobs less Seattle city jobs) increased over that period by nearly 57,000 jobs and reached a new record high in November 2015 before falling slightly in December.
Bottom Line II: Additional evidence showing that while jobs in the city of Seattle were tanking starting last April, employment in the suburbs surrounding Seattle was increasing steadily to a new record high in November. That departure in employment trends: job declines inside the city limits of Seattle compared to increasing employment outside the city limits suggests the possibility that the difference in labor costs could have been a contributing factor.
If supporters of the $15 minimum wage have an alternate theory, I'm willing to consider it. But the AEI analysis suggests that not only are people losing their jobs, but that the creation of new businesses to take up the slack is also lagging.
Read more: http://www.americanthinker.com/blog/2016/02/hey_seattle_hows_that_15_minimum_wage_working_out_for_ya.html#ixzz40jKX1IQq
Follow us: @AmericanThinker on Twitter | AmericanThinker on Facebook

They shall enjoy the rewards of their incompetent ideology.
The taxpayers pay the bill for companies who pay low wages. Minimum wage workers invariably receive food stamps, EITC, Medicaid and other taxpayer funded aid, because they need it.
No they dont. I worked many minimum wage jobs when I was a kid, without getting welfare. Many of my friends make minimum wage as bartenders and servers without getting food stamps. Minimum wage jobs without tips are not intended to be careers.
When you were a kid, a place that rents for $1,500/mo now used to rent for $300, your parents paid far less for your health insurance than today, and a family trip to the grocery store didn't cost $250.
Thanks for the history tour. How is it germaine? Fast food entry level positions are mostly kids. It's generally not to support a household.
Restauant work, including fast food, is steadily becoming an unfortunate occupation for many. I don't eat fast food anymore, but a few years back when I worked in northern VA you couldn't find a teenager working in a fast food venue. It was nearly all adults trying to earn enough to split rent with three others for a shitty two bedroom apartment. When good paying jobs are in short supply, and you end up doing what you gotta do to get by.
Hal,
The problem with raising the minimum wage (locally or especially nationally) is not that more dollars (each dollar having a smaller value in absolute terms) will be put into the hands of the lowest level workers. The real problem is that it complicates matters for workers making significantly above the minimum and for their employers while having absolutely no useful effect upon the minimum wage employee, since all the goods and services those workers need will be just that much more expensive. In short, the objective of those in favor of raising the minimum is actually to raise those workers making it up from their present position at the bottom of the totem pole. That will not be accomplished by simply raising the amount of dollars they are paid per hour. The only thing that can do that is for those workers to learn new skills and obtain other jobs with better wages. As has always happened and always will, the highest level of wages will be reserved to those skills that are difficult to learn since not as many people are willing to go through the hard work needed to acquire those skills.
Even if they are paid $1000 per hour, burger flippers will still be at the lowest pay scale since everyone else will just end up making that much more.
That a glib outlook, and I disagree
I'm sure you do but can you refute it? Being required to pay that much for untrained labor will leave business owners with only three choices; cut back on the number of workers, raise prices drastically (inflation) or go out of business. None of those things will move minimum wage workers (whether kids just out of high school or factory workers who have found themselves competing for jobs with Chinese coolies) out of the bottom layer of workers. They will remain stuck at the bottom layer until they learn some useful skill that can be sold, and it doesn't matter how many dollars they make per hour (inflation ALWAYS stays ahead of wages).
Until that labor comes back, we need to accept that flipping burgers isn't just a teenager's summer job, it's an occupation for many overqualified individuals who are trying to feed and clothe their kids.
Those jobs are never coming back. American buyers (the ones with salable skills) will not accept the increase in prices that would be required if it did and the government will not take the only action that would force American manufacturers to bring it back (heavy tariff barriers). That means that the workers had better get off their asses and FIND AND LEARN a salable skill, whether they think they can do it or not.
I've got a son in law right now with a BA in Spanish, who has applied for numerous jobs that only pay $30-40k, but the competition is too thick. He works as a waiter because that's all he can get.
This is not a situation created by low or stagnant wages … this is what happens because of outsourcing. Sending what were once fair-wage jobs to cheap labor countries ALSO OUTSOURCES THE DISPOSABLE INCOME THAT BUSINESSES IN THE U.S. rely upon to exist and thrive AND HIRE MORE EMPLOYEES!
Increasing the minimum wage while the humane thing to do, in-and-of-itself does not BRING BACK TO THE ECONOMY ITS LIFE-BLOOD … that being WORKERS AND THEIR FAMILIES WITH MONEY TO SPEND!
Even if they are paid $1000 per hour, burger flippers will still be at the lowest pay scale since everyone else will just end up making that much more.
You are almost on to something. Burger flippers probably always will be just about the lowest paid people. That doesn't mean that they have to be paid so little they require government assistance. Everyone who works full time hours should make enough money to support themselves without government assistance. Anything otherwise means there is something rotten in the economic system.
Today why would a burger flipper make as much or more than an appliance or A/C tech.?
Where did you see anyone say that ? Nowhere ?
I said that. I know aircraft mechanics that make $17.50. That's barely more than a burger flipper in the $15.00 utopia.
If a aircraft mechanic is only making $17.50 an hour, he's in the wrong industry, or he's in a ''right to work state''...Sad, but expected.
Sadly ignorant. They work in SC where we have a reasonable cost of living. He owns a house and a new car, and just had twins. He's happy now, but he'll be pretty pissed if Joey shake-machine earns 15 for much less effort, skill, or responsibility.
If he belongs to the union in the port of Charleston he'd earn a lot more. I guess that some are happy to settle for less than then could earn elsewhere.
I have to wonder, is that what capitalism is. Earning less than is offered in other industries for the same work...Talk about a bunch of lemmings.
What's ignorant is your trying to justify lower wages for your friend. Well done Cerenkov.
Why are you so devoted to looking at only a portion of the picture ? It's not just how much you make but also how much your expenses are . In some locations housing costs are exorbitant .
He could join a union. And then he wouldn't have a job. You are clueless.
Speaking of clueless Cerenkov, one only has to look at your response to see what clueless really is.
You should stick to being a water boy for the uniformed.
Sadly ignorant. They work in SC where we have a reasonable cost of living. He owns a house and a new car, and just had twins. He's happy now, but he'll be pretty pissed if Joey shake-machine earns 15 for much less effort, skill, or responsibility.
That works well if one lives in SC, but as people are "forced" to re-locate in the SC's of the U.S., at some point there will be a saturation point … which will be manifested by unemployment increases due to more potential workers than jobs. That will enable employers to decrease wages because of the imbalance of worker supply/demand.
Economists refer to this phenomenon as "A Race to the Bottom."
When the SC retiree finds that his pension and Social Security benefits limit him to life in SC, he'll understand that what was formerly his "Right to Work" will have devolved into his "Right to a Narrow Corridor of the World."
No doubt there are those in SC, et al that will not fall into this scenario, but many will.
"Right-to-Work" as an economic model only works where it works because it compensates in a small way for exported jobs. America is paying the price for corporate greed a its pimp legislators.
Maybe people like living in SC?!
Maybe people like living in SC?!
No doubt. I'd probably like living there as well.
But I'm not talking about whether SC is a likable place to live, I'm addressing the following …
Private-sector employee compensation in right-to-work states has grown by an inflation-adjusted 12.0% between 2001-2011, according to data from the Bureau of Economic Analysis and Bureau of Labor Statistics. That compares with just 3.0% over the same period in states where workers can be forced to join a union as a condition of getting a job.
In practical terms, the $ 60,000 - $100,000 less in salaries, benefits, pensions and social security for Right to Work state workers over a working lifetime, will ultimately reduce their options in terms of where else they might like to live, travel and retire.
And I said nothing about "liking" the living in SC. Instead of putting words in my mouth, just address what I actually post.
AND YOU IGNORED THE INFORMATION REPORTED IN A SEATTLE NEWSPAPER THAT UNEMPLOYMENT HAS DROPPED!
Seattle jobless rate hits 8-year low in August
The 15.00 minimum wages are implemented incrementally for the most part, as far as I know. By the time they reach 15.00 in 4 or 5 years other wages should have gone up also.
I would say your aircraft mechanic friend is underpaid.
I honestly don't know where you guys get the idea that half the country should work for low wages while all the profit from large businesses goes to the one half of one percent. Do we really need that many more billionaires ? What does that do for everyone else ?
And don't tell me they "earned" it. They benefit from the system they have bought.
I think pay should be proportional to skill, demand, and responsibility. Most fast food workers can be replaced by an ipad.
Uh, it still takes a human to stand there, place the burger on the grill, and flip it at the right time. I've had some LOUSY fast food, lately. Stuff that is basically inedible.
That's why I said "most".
Not fond of these open-mouthed smileys, but that is just a grin...
And... They earned it.
The overall impact of increasing the minimum wage in Seattle, or any city for that matter, relies on data collection over a period of time. This employment data is a snapshot in time, data not to be argued. I find the data to narrowly focused to determine the collective impact on Seattle since the increase of minimum wage(s) is still unfolding.
For those who'd like to increase knowledge surrounding this issue you may want to take a look at the study currently underway...
It provides a comprehensive (given the limited amount of months of increased minimum wage) look at impacts throughout the community (s) not limited to employment figures.
I find the data to narrowly focused to determine the collective impact on Seattle since the increase of minimum wage(s) is still unfolding.
If you had read the linked article you would have seen the comparison between the city and the suburbs . If that is accurate it shows a strong effect due to the new minimum wage plans .
I read the article and again as it relates to employment numbers in Seattle and the MSA, I trust the employment numbers.
If you read the study currently underway, you'll see the additional factors impacted by increasing the minimum wage, specifically consumer pricing. Looking forward to the next comprehensive data collection before formulating benefit vs disadvantage of raising the minimum wage.
I expect changes to consumer pricing could be quite revealing . Thanks .
Over a year ago, tired of waiting for Congress to act on a national increase in the minimum wage, Seattle raised its minimum wage to $15.00/hour, to be implemented in stages and in accordance with certain other parameters. The usual characters predictably made the usual complaints, that this would be a job killer and that businesses would flee Seattle for the greener pastures of cheap labor.
Many of us remember in 2013 when John Boehner said this about raising the minimum wage:
GOP leaders, Fox and other right-wing media have a long history of attacking minimum wage laws, and have been misleading the public about the supposed downsides of Seattle's incremental increase to $15 by 2017.But now some quantifiable data has been published--you know, facts--and they don't support the trickle down mythology espoused by Republicans. The Seattle Times reported last week that, according to the Washington State Employment Security Department, instead of losing jobs, Seattle's jobless rate since stage one kicked in to $10-11/hour in April, has dropped by about 1% to 3.6%, an eight year low.
There you go again AMac. Using facts. Don't you know they don't care about the facts, just their delusions?
There you go again AMac. Using facts. Don't you know they don't care about the facts, just their delusions?
The thread will soon be about those who disagree with the article.
By Coral Garnick
Seattle Times business reporter
An eight-year low in the Seattle-area jobless rate announced Wednesday may mean local companies will face a tough time finding help for this holiday-shopping season.
With the holidays approaching, companies around the country are preparing to boost payrolls. For example, Target announced this week it will be hiring 70,000 seasonal workers and UPS said it will bring on more than 90,000 workers from November to January.