The Rise of Intolerant Liberals
Why have liberals become so intolerant? They think nothing of denying someone as prominent as former Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice from speaking on a college campus. They embrace activists who shut down speakers. They publicly shame people for the slightest deviation from liberal orthodoxy.
For them everything from science to the law is “settled” once they get into power. Progress is a one way street. Their mindset is the very definition of closed-mindedness.
The easy answer would be “they are all bad people.” But frankly that’s a cop out. Not all liberals are bad people, any more than all conservatives are angels. No doubt among the fevered minions of liberal activists there are people with, shall we say, psychological issues, but that doesn’t explain why so many otherwise reasonable people are so beholden to liberalism as an ideology.
The short answer is that it pays. A lot of people in and out of government benefit. Liberalism also makes people feel good. Whether you are politician dispensing government benefits or the citizen receiving them, liberalism hides the self-interest and sometimes even greed that motivate people.
But the devolution of liberalism into something now openly illiberal has causes far more complex than these familiar explanations provide.
For one thing, liberalism is no longer mainly about ideas but power—as in who has it and who doesn’t. Believing they already know the answers to all questions, liberals view politics and governing as mopping up operations.
Academic research is about proving a point rather than discovering the truth. Science is treated as the private preserve of a certain ideology, not to mention a political weapon to justify preferred policy outcomes. Mistaking as they do their ideology for morality, they see no reason to shun the most cynical of political tactics to get their way. For them, the end justifies the means.
Second, liberalism today is not the liberalism of yesteryear. It’s not Franklin Roosevelt’s or John Kennedy’s liberalism. It’s not even the liberalism of Bill Clinton. It has become something much more radical. Bill Clinton talked about the “era of big government” being over.
Today there is virtually no government program that liberals won’t embrace. Clinton had his Sister Souljah moment when he repudiated extremism in his party. Today liberals can’t get close enough to the “black lives matter” movement.
Third, liberals have surrendered to (some would say created) the nasty culture of intolerance that infuses our popular culture. To this extent they are no different than some self-proclaimed right wing people who do the same. But the difference is—or at least is supposed to be—that liberals profess to be the party of the open mind. They have become anything but.
Now that they control so many of our institutions—our universities, high tech corporate board rooms, the entertainment industry and increasingly even mainstream churches—they are closing the door behind them, making sure that no one, especially conservatives, will sneak in the back door.
Finally, liberalism has become hostile to open inquiry. Liberal intellectuals used to love open-ended debates because they thought they could win people over with their intelligence and wit. No more. Today’s liberal intellectuals are much more interested in stifling debates than having them. After all, who needs debates when all the big questions have been answered by their ideology? Liberals are no longer the scruffy radicals of Washington Square but a tenured Mandarin class hotly competing for government research grants.
As I argue in my forthcoming book, “The Closing of the Liberal Mind,” to this Mandarin class,
“Knowledge, like human progress, must be created and managed by state policy, bureaucratized and forced on all people equally despite the infinite differences that exist between individual human beings. It is a sad state of affairs, especially for intellectuals who are expected to know better.”
There’s an old saying, he who controls knowledge controls power. Liberals get this adage instinctively. They treat truth not as wisdom—as something to be discovered—but as a will to power to be imposed by law and governmental fiat.
In this quest for power they have become masters at controlling not only knowledge but popular culture. For example, when Americans watch entertainers like Jon Stewart they don’t see an ideologue channeling liberal clichés. They just see a really funny guy. The ideology is completely buried. Young people respond in lock step not because they were indoctrinated by some boring Maoist, but because they think the whole thing is great fun.
What we have here is nothing less than a new and highly attractive form of illiberalism—an illiberal liberalism, if you will. Intolerance is championed in the name of tolerance; closed-mindedness in the name of open-mindedness; and hatred in the name of compassion. It’s classic double-think, and the deception is precisely the danger. Americans don’t expect liberals to be authoritarian wolves in sheep’s clothing. They are not prepared to be on guard all the time because liberals are supposed to be the good guys—the guardians of freedom of speech and the like.
Alas, they are not. http://www.cnsnews.com/commentary/kim-holmes/rise-intolerant-liberals
For them everything from science to the law is “settled” once they get into power. Progress is a one way street. Their mindset is the very definition of closed-mindedness.
The easy answer would be “they are all bad people.” But frankly that’s a cop out. Not all liberals are bad people, any more than all conservatives are angels. No doubt among the fevered minions of liberal activists there are people with, shall we say, psychological issues, but that doesn’t explain why so many otherwise reasonable people are so beholden to liberalism as an ideology.
The short answer is that it pays. A lot of people in and out of government benefit. Liberalism also makes people feel good. Whether you are politician dispensing government benefits or the citizen receiving them, liberalism hides the self-interest and sometimes even greed that motivate people.
But the devolution of liberalism into something now openly illiberal has causes far more complex than these familiar explanations provide.
For one thing, liberalism is no longer mainly about ideas but power—as in who has it and who doesn’t. Believing they already know the answers to all questions, liberals view politics and governing as mopping up operations.
Academic research is about proving a point rather than discovering the truth. Science is treated as the private preserve of a certain ideology, not to mention a political weapon to justify preferred policy outcomes. Mistaking as they do their ideology for morality, they see no reason to shun the most cynical of political tactics to get their way. For them, the end justifies the means.
Second, liberalism today is not the liberalism of yesteryear. It’s not Franklin Roosevelt’s or John Kennedy’s liberalism. It’s not even the liberalism of Bill Clinton. It has become something much more radical. Bill Clinton talked about the “era of big government” being over.
Today there is virtually no government program that liberals won’t embrace. Clinton had his Sister Souljah moment when he repudiated extremism in his party. Today liberals can’t get close enough to the “black lives matter” movement.
Third, liberals have surrendered to (some would say created) the nasty culture of intolerance that infuses our popular culture. To this extent they are no different than some self-proclaimed right wing people who do the same. But the difference is—or at least is supposed to be—that liberals profess to be the party of the open mind. They have become anything but.
Now that they control so many of our institutions—our universities, high tech corporate board rooms, the entertainment industry and increasingly even mainstream churches—they are closing the door behind them, making sure that no one, especially conservatives, will sneak in the back door.
Finally, liberalism has become hostile to open inquiry. Liberal intellectuals used to love open-ended debates because they thought they could win people over with their intelligence and wit. No more. Today’s liberal intellectuals are much more interested in stifling debates than having them. After all, who needs debates when all the big questions have been answered by their ideology? Liberals are no longer the scruffy radicals of Washington Square but a tenured Mandarin class hotly competing for government research grants.
As I argue in my forthcoming book, “The Closing of the Liberal Mind,” to this Mandarin class,
“Knowledge, like human progress, must be created and managed by state policy, bureaucratized and forced on all people equally despite the infinite differences that exist between individual human beings. It is a sad state of affairs, especially for intellectuals who are expected to know better.”
There’s an old saying, he who controls knowledge controls power. Liberals get this adage instinctively. They treat truth not as wisdom—as something to be discovered—but as a will to power to be imposed by law and governmental fiat.
In this quest for power they have become masters at controlling not only knowledge but popular culture. For example, when Americans watch entertainers like Jon Stewart they don’t see an ideologue channeling liberal clichés. They just see a really funny guy. The ideology is completely buried. Young people respond in lock step not because they were indoctrinated by some boring Maoist, but because they think the whole thing is great fun.
What we have here is nothing less than a new and highly attractive form of illiberalism—an illiberal liberalism, if you will. Intolerance is championed in the name of tolerance; closed-mindedness in the name of open-mindedness; and hatred in the name of compassion. It’s classic double-think, and the deception is precisely the danger. Americans don’t expect liberals to be authoritarian wolves in sheep’s clothing. They are not prepared to be on guard all the time because liberals are supposed to be the good guys—the guardians of freedom of speech and the like.
Alas, they are not. http://www.cnsnews.com/commentary/kim-holmes/rise-intolerant-liberals

I'm guessing this member has seeded about 500 "articles" that sound almost exactly like this one. He is a creature of habit.
As are your ad hominem responses.
They think nothing of denying someone as prominent as former Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice from speaking on a college campus.
I disagree with Rutgers University denying Rice as a speaker. She should have been permitted to speak, if for no other reason, because of her 1st Amendment rights.
But to just note that she was denied that right without ant specific explanation is half-assed journalism.
Opposition to the Board of Trustee’s decision stems from Rice’s tenure as former president George W. Bush’s National Security Advisor (2000-2005) and Secretary of State (2005-2008). As a high-ranking member of Bush’s staff, Rice and the rest of the Bush Administration can legally be held accountable for violations of international law committed by their subordinates according to a concept known as “command responsibility.”
Command responsibility was most famously invoked during the Nuremberg Trial in the wake of the Second World War. The principle was used by Allied forces after World War II to convict Nazi leaders for the aggregated crimes of the Nazi Party. By knowingly participating in, consenting to, or failing to prevent the war crimes and crimes against humanity committed under their command, the leaders of the Nazi Party were deemed liable for those crimes under international law.
The concept of command responsibility is officially codified as an aspect of international law in Article 86(2) of the Additional Protocol of 1977 to the Third Geneva Convention of 1949 …
Whether one concurs or disagrees with Rutgers' decision, without knowing the reason, either way, any opinion would be an uninformed one.
Rice has not been charged with any war crimes. Nor has the elected government of Bush. That's a red herring at best. Bigotry at worst.
Rice has not been charged with any war crimes. Nor has the elected government of Bush. That's a red herring at best. Bigotry at worst.
The "race card" from YOU of all people.
There is much evidence regarding the allegations … which I will post should it be requested.
The lack of political balls on the part of Obama and Congress is what prevents the charges from being leveled.
While I voted for and support President Barack Obama, I deem it
proper to be critical of his somewhat implied unwillingness to pursue
war crimes and constitutional-violations investigations of the Bush
Administration.
I asked my Congresswoman, U.S. Senators and the President to
prioritize; (1) An investigation into TORTURE and other possible WAR
CRIMES; (2) An investigation into Domestic Spying; (3) The purging of
all resultant data collected on American Citizens not related to
probable cause or unlawful activity and public notification that such
a purge has been executed. In the interest of national integrity,
there are no justifiable reasons - political, Constitutional or legal
- for the failure to pursue zealously and vigorously, these items.
The planning or action of an unprovoked attack on other countries are
war crimes (Crimes Against Peace). "Criminal fraud" is "telling of an
intentional lie causing financial or physical harm," and "murder" is
"causing the unprovoked killing of another." If the metaphorical war
crimes "shoe" fits and the Bush Administration wore it, we need to
know. In the same way the Nuremburg Trials followed the perpetration
of Nazi war crimes, so must a conscionable judicial process follow
the alleged Bush crimes; if it does not, America as a nation will be
viewed by history as the criminal!
It would be unconscionable for Congress or the President-elect to
avoid such investigations because they "want to look forward, not
back at the past." Indeed - what illegal acts were ever prosecuted
before being committed? Imagine a judge's response to a lawyer
pleading; "Your Honor, I move for a dismissal of this case as the
alleged crime was committed weeks ago and, why dwell on the past?"
POLITICS AHEAD OF JUSTICE … bad for humanity in my opinion.
Lol. Is your tinfoil hat too tight? Bush et al committed no war crimes. If they did, Obama et al would be equally guilty.
Be serious.
Lol. Is your tinfoil hat too tight? Bush et al committed no war crimes. If they did, Obama et al would be equally guilty.
Be serious.
Ah the "Lol" opening statement followed by a dismissive argument …
A dismissive statement is any statement which negates the value of an opposing argument without actually addressing any of its substance .
Although it is not actually a valid form of argument, it is frequently phrased in such a way that it might be mistaken for one; this usage is a form of rhetorical deception .
Argument by collective dismissal is an especially severe form of this, in which multiple points are dismissed as a group without any of them being addressed.
Types
Real-world Usage
For them everything from science to the law is “settled” once they get into power. Progress is a one way street. Their mindset is the very definition of closed-mindedness.
I think XX needs to stop seeding the same article over and over again, just slightly rephrased as it is passed around from one American Thinker author to another.
It is dreary.
Find another hobby, John. Ad hominem is passe.