Joe Biden: 1992 Video Resurfaces of Biden Advising Against Supreme Court Nomination in Election Year
community » Discussions » Category » News & Politics » Discussion » Joe Biden: 1992 Video Resurfaces of Biden Advising Against Supreme Court Nomination in Election Year
0
Category: News & Politics
Via: community • 10 years ago • 26 comments
"President Bush should consider following the practice of the majority of his predecessors and not, and not, name a nominee until after the November election is completed."
Not to sound like a broken record but I'm confused why this argument is a good one. It has nothing to do with the responsibility of the President and Senate as outlined in our constitution.
Did a number of lawmakers from both parties throughout our history oppose nominating during an election year? Yes. So What They don't have the power to override the constitution.
The President still has to nominate and the Senate still has to vote yea or nay.
Is the point to show the hypocrisy? If so, then it's pretty evident and quite appalling but it is still irrelevant.
Yes the point is to show hypocrisy. Come on now PJ. The liberals have been countering every stupid move BO makes with "Bush did it first" for over 7 years. They think it's a great argument. How can one resist spinning it after all that time?
For what it's worth I also agree he should nominate and senate should do their job.
I agree, I agree. This is complete hypocrisy and I'm sick to death of these games. It's we the people who are getting screwed by these actions. We have to get these career politicians out of our government and we have to get the money out also.
But your point is well taken. For anyone to suggest that there hasn't been hypocrisy isn't being honest.
Sean - Respectfully, I disagree. The constitution states that the President shall nominate and the Senate shall vote and confirm. This shouldn't be something we are disputing. That's like Donald Trump saying he isn't certain whether or not Marco Rubio is an American Citizen. Yes, Marco Rubio was born in America and he is an American citizen. It's ridiculous for Donald to suggest otherwise and it's ridiculous for anyone to dispute what is in the constitution.
I understand that there is a benefit to taking this position but it would be for political purposes only and not in support of what is in the constitution.
It's always fun to watch Liberals bitch, piss, moan, whine, and complain about Republicans doing something they had no qualms whatsoever doing when they were in power.
I have no problem with deferring the nomination until the next President takes office …
PROVIDED THAT ALL CURRENT MEMBERS OF CONGRESS AND ALL CURRENT CANDIDATES FOR ANY CONGRESSIONAL/SENATE OFFICE, IMMEDIATELY SIGN A BINDING CONTRACT STIPULATING THEY WILL APPROVE ANY SUCH NOMINEE PRESENTED BY THE NEXT PRESIDENT.
Put up or shut up.
Those who make the argument that the "electorate" (by virtue of who it elects as President) should thus "determine" who will fill the SCOTUS vacancy is hypocritical in that THE ELECTORATE HAS ELECTED AND RE-ELECTED THE CURRENT POTUS.
You think Congress should be bound to approve President Trump's nomination of Ann Coulter?
Of course not; it's a call out … force Congress to put up or shut up now. What's the point in creating a delay that will go on for the better part of a year?
It's a ploy to embarrass those wanting the delay the process via a bullshit partisan deference to the electorate! What they really want is a Republican President and a Republican Senate majority to approve a Conservative Justice. I get that … the Democrats would be just as hypocritical were the tables turned!
The reasons pro and con for the delay or a proceed now, are the manifestation of political/partisan thinking on both sides … one hopeful of an outcome of the election and one in fear.
Let's have it all on the table now … let the yays and nays and filibusters own their positions AND THEN LET THE ELECTORATE MAKE THE CALL ON THE SENATE -- (IF THAT'S THE REAL REASON FOR ADVOCATING THE DELAY).
Screw the partisan same-old-same-old … let the Constitution prevail and elected officials exercise their Constitutional responsibility AND REAP WHAT THEY SOW!
The Constitution provides no time requirements for the Senate. Your point is moot.
If that were the case, if a Supreme Court vacancy or vacancies occurred on the first day of the first term of a two-term President, by your view, those vacancies could remain as such until the next President were elected, or, indefinitely.
The point may appear moot until one considers the potential outcomes of delay.
A prompt nomination is certainly a potential partisan advantage to the party of a sitting President; BUT IT IN NOTHING BUT PARTISAN WHEN THE OTHER PARTY DELAYS THE PROCESS.
This thread is a complete waste of time. There has never been a Supreme Court nominee who has not received either a hearing or a vote. That is the only historical factoid that matters.
For that reason, there will be a hearing and/or a vote on Obama's nominee this year too.
The Republicans don't want it, because it would be potentially damaging to their candidates fortunes in November. It is that simple.
So BOTH Obama AND Biden thought this was a bad idea before BO became president. Who would have thought?
"President Bush should consider following the practice of the majority of his predecessors and not, and not, name a nominee until after the November election is completed."
Perfect.
Not to sound like a broken record but I'm confused why this argument is a good one. It has nothing to do with the responsibility of the President and Senate as outlined in our constitution.
Did a number of lawmakers from both parties throughout our history oppose nominating during an election year? Yes. So What They don't have the power to override the constitution.
The President still has to nominate and the Senate still has to vote yea or nay.
Is the point to show the hypocrisy? If so, then it's pretty evident and quite appalling but it is still irrelevant.
Yes the point is to show hypocrisy. Come on now PJ. The liberals have been countering every stupid move BO makes with "Bush did it first" for over 7 years. They think it's a great argument. How can one resist spinning it after all that time?
For what it's worth I also agree he should nominate and senate should do their job.
I agree, I agree. This is complete hypocrisy and I'm sick to death of these games. It's we the people who are getting screwed by these actions. We have to get these career politicians out of our government and we have to get the money out also.
But your point is well taken. For anyone to suggest that there hasn't been hypocrisy isn't being honest.
"The President still has to nominate and the Senate still has to vote yea or nay."
No, they don't. It's completely up to the President and Congress to do either. The Constitution doesn't require either party to act.
Sean - Respectfully, I disagree. The constitution states that the President shall nominate and the Senate shall vote and confirm. This shouldn't be something we are disputing. That's like Donald Trump saying he isn't certain whether or not Marco Rubio is an American Citizen. Yes, Marco Rubio was born in America and he is an American citizen. It's ridiculous for Donald to suggest otherwise and it's ridiculous for anyone to dispute what is in the constitution.
I understand that there is a benefit to taking this position but it would be for political purposes only and not in support of what is in the constitution.
The left's hypocrisy continues apace.
It's always fun to watch Liberals bitch, piss, moan, whine, and complain about Republicans doing something they had no qualms whatsoever doing when they were in power.
I have no problem with deferring the nomination until the next President takes office …
PROVIDED THAT ALL CURRENT MEMBERS OF CONGRESS AND ALL CURRENT CANDIDATES FOR ANY CONGRESSIONAL/SENATE OFFICE, IMMEDIATELY SIGN A BINDING CONTRACT STIPULATING THEY WILL APPROVE ANY SUCH NOMINEE PRESENTED BY THE NEXT PRESIDENT.
Put up or shut up.
Those who make the argument that the "electorate" (by virtue of who it elects as President) should thus "determine" who will fill the SCOTUS vacancy is hypocritical in that THE ELECTORATE HAS ELECTED AND RE-ELECTED THE CURRENT POTUS.
Elected is elected is elected.
That's insane.
You think Congress should be bound to approve President Trump's nomination of Ann Coulter?
That's insane.
You think Congress should be bound to approve President Trump's nomination of Ann Coulter?
Of course not; it's a call out … force Congress to put up or shut up now. What's the point in creating a delay that will go on for the better part of a year?
It's a ploy to embarrass those wanting the delay the process via a bullshit partisan deference to the electorate! What they really want is a Republican President and a Republican Senate majority to approve a Conservative Justice. I get that … the Democrats would be just as hypocritical were the tables turned!
The reasons pro and con for the delay or a proceed now, are the manifestation of political/partisan thinking on both sides … one hopeful of an outcome of the election and one in fear.
Let's have it all on the table now … let the yays and nays and filibusters own their positions AND THEN LET THE ELECTORATE MAKE THE CALL ON THE SENATE -- (IF THAT'S THE REAL REASON FOR ADVOCATING THE DELAY).
Screw the partisan same-old-same-old … let the Constitution prevail and elected officials exercise their Constitutional responsibility AND REAP WHAT THEY SOW!
NO THANKS. THEY WOULD BE ABROGATING THEIR RESPONSIBILITY BY CONFIRMING BLINDLY.
NO THANKS. THEY WOULD BE ABROGATING THEIR RESPONSIBILITY BY CONFIRMING BLINDLY.
If they agreed to my ploy… you're right, they would.
So, by calling their bluff, they either DO NOTHING AND RISK THE ELECTORATE ASKING (i.e.) …
"THEN WHY NOT GO AHEAD AND FULFILL YOUR CONSTITUTIONAL RESPONSIBILITY NOW"?
The popularity of Trump is allegedly in part due to voter frustration with "politics as usual and nothing gets done."
While both parties are being partisan on this, THE CONSTITUTION SAYS NOTHING ABOUT DELAYING THE PROCESS.
That, then, should be the "tie breaker".
The Constitution provides no time requirements for the Senate. Your point is moot.
The Constitution provides no time requirements for the Senate. Your point is moot.
If that were the case, if a Supreme Court vacancy or vacancies occurred on the first day of the first term of a two-term President, by your view, those vacancies could remain as such until the next President were elected, or, indefinitely.
The point may appear moot until one considers the potential outcomes of delay.
A prompt nomination is certainly a potential partisan advantage to the party of a sitting President; BUT IT IN NOTHING BUT PARTISAN WHEN THE OTHER PARTY DELAYS THE PROCESS.
This thread is a complete waste of time. There has never been a Supreme Court nominee who has not received either a hearing or a vote. That is the only historical factoid that matters.
For that reason, there will be a hearing and/or a vote on Obama's nominee this year too.
The Republicans don't want it, because it would be potentially damaging to their candidates fortunes in November. It is that simple.
"This thread is a complete waste of time."
Just pointing out history to folks like you who are so outraged the republicans have suggested the same thing.