Right Turn. The benefits of a Republican Party breakup
It is impossible for some in the media and in the conservative movement to conceive of American politics without a Republican Party. It is a failure of imagination but also of moral spine.
The Republican National Committee declares that the party will unite around whomever is the nominee. The Republican Jewish Coalition, whom I contacted, cannot bring itself to condemn Donald Trump for feigning ignorance about David Duke and refusing three times to disavow him and the KKK on cable TV . (Thankfully, the Anti-Defamation League did not make the same error.) Otherwise thoughtful talk show hosts like Hugh Hewitt proclaim that Republicans must support Trump if he is the nominee because Hillary Clinton is worse.
These are not bad people, nor do they support Trump. But they fail to recognize that there are only two choices in 2016: Someone other than Trump gets the nomination, or there is no unified GOP (at the least for the 2016 presidential race, and perhaps permanently). Ironically, it is sometimes more difficult to recognize a tectonic shift is underway than it is to recognize small shifts. The former prompts denial and a desire to cling to what is known, even if it what is known is on the verge of extinction.
Nevertheless, conservatives and the larger grouping that makes up the GOP should understand more is at stake than a single election and a single Supreme Court opening. For one thing, if Trump gets the nomination, he will lose, overwhelmingly. Someone with negatives as high as his and as temperamentally and ideologically erratic as he is will not get 270 electoral votes. Many Republicans will stay home; others will vote for Hillary Clinton. With his nomination and the ensuing landslide, the Senate and possibly the House would be lost.
As we have discussed, if Trump is the nominee — and we are still not there yet, as Sen. Marco Rubio (R-Fla.) rises to the occasion — all sorts of interesting possibilities unfold. A third presidential candidate is quite likely, but more important, a new party. Let’s face it: There is a lot deserving of abandonment in the GOP right now. Nativism has thoroughly infected its agenda, turning otherwise well-rounded conservatives into small-minded xenophobes. The inability to recognize lost causes (reversing gay marriage) and the refusal to address real ones (e.g. poverty) have paralyzed too many Republicans. The search for ideological purity and support for fringe candidates as well as a nihilistic approach to government personified in the shutdown have gripped vast swaths of the party. The opportunity now may present itself to leave all of this behind, to form a 21st-century party reflective of today’s United States and with a coherent vision of governance.
Some would prefer a “Constitutional Party” stressing limited government, federalism and the rule of law. But frankly, this does not have enough “sell” for a national party and is not tailored to a positive agenda. The successor to the GOP cannot be merely be against things; it must be for ideas that address needs of ordinary Americans.
The answer should come from the reform agenda that House Speaker Paul Ryan (R-Wis.) is championing. As he describes it, his effort involves applying conservative principles to a range of real-world problems, including poverty, declining upward mobility, stagnant wages, low economic, education (both K-12 and higher ed) and loss of American influence and standing in the world. We have discussed at length its intellectual underpinnings in the reform conservative movement . But constitutionalists need not fret. Both Ryan and the larger reform conservative effort rely on restoring the proper balance between federal and state power and between executive and legislative action. However, as former Texas governor Rick Perry elegantly put it during his run, conservatives should be as concerned with the 14th Amendment as they are with the 10th.
Whatever follows the GOP would also mark a change in tone and temperament. Restraint, tolerance and a preference for gradual innovation over radical revolution — the original hallmarks of modern conservatism — should predominate. In other words, everything that Trump is not .
In sum, Republican primary voters tomorrow and for the weeks that follow have more than a choice among four or five candidates. They actually have a binary choice: Rejection of Trumpism or the dissolution of the GOP, which will inaugurate a new party and a new phase for center-right politics. For those on the right appalled by Trump and the primordial proto-fascistic goo from whence he emerged, the bad news is that they may well lose the next election. The good news is that what follows may be better for center-right politics and, more important, the country. And it may help keep the Senate and the House out of the hands of the increasingly leftist Democratic Party.
Tags
Who is online
100 visitors

In sum, Republican primary voters tomorrow and for the weeks that follow have more than a choice among four or five candidates. They actually have a binary choice: Rejection of Trumpism or the dissolution of the GOP, which will inaugurate a new party and a new phase for center-right politics.
I think she is right. I think the Republican voters are voting to either keep the GOP together or to split it of into two parties. And two parties may be the best thing that happens to them.
Yep all this article loudly states (and confirms BTW) that Democrats couldn't see the signs nor read them even if they were fifty feet tall and in one syllable words.
Completely and utterly blind to what is actually happening in the real world electorate....
We've been hearing about the impending implosion of the republican party now for almost 12 years. I know it is a great liberal fantasy of some type and on some innate level. I think they feel that it is the only way they could actually claim victory. victory in what? attaining one party domination?
Great for America I'm sure.
My opinion, just another liberal diatribe of wishing and dreaming. they have no answer for T Rump. (Hillary isn't an answer, more of a good spanking partner) The usual tactics of insult after insult is only making him stronger. In fact they are now watching the republican establishment go down in flames trying it.
They say that T Rump is the gift that keeps giving.
Please keep right on saying it, and by doing so, your handing him the election.
I'm not too sure about that. If the emergence (and staying power) of the tea party doesn't clue these idiots in nothing will. Trump is a result of the people rejecting the establishment. Simple as that. I think the party is going to change or we will see a third emerge, which is the best possible outcome for our country IMO. Either way, the RNC is going to change.
Jennifer Rubin is hardly a liberal. She's a Conservative Republican.
She isn't a conservative I would recognize and accept as a conservative.
I'm sure that bothers her greatly.
I'm sure it does, liberals parading around as conservatives aren't really bothered by much at all.
Then if it bothers her greatly she is not a liberal parading around as a conservative. If she was then, as you say, it wouldn't bother her at all. She's still a conservative.
Yeah Randy to you, she's a conservative, to me she's a liberal. But then again to me most establishment republicans are liberals. Not true conservatives.
We will have to agree to disagree brother, Republican and Democrat are not synonymous with Conservative and Liberal
Two presidential terms of blatant obstructionism by the republican establishment has given birth the the sorry situation that they are in now. It's humorous to see the rabid anti-liberals try and pin the rise of Trump on liberals. It's just what they do. If there is a problem, liberals have to be to blame.
Yes sorry shape taking away the house and senate from the dems and making huge gains in state and local elections. Liberals really do have their head in the sand.
It's humorous to see the rabid anti-liberals try and pin the rise of Trump on liberals.
He is 100% the creation of the GOP. He's their Frankenstein's Monster. No matter how hard they try to duck the blame.
I didn't get past
The Republican National Committee declares that the party will unite around whomever is the nominee.
Don't they have copy-editors at the Post?
I do think that the Republican Party is going through a change and we’ve been watching this transformation through several elections now. The instability of the Party leaders is why we’re seeing the kind of candidates that are running for Office today. I don’t think the supporters are overly thrilled with the selection and that is what I believe has contributed to the ever increasing divide between the Party’s supporters. But I also believe there is much discontent within the Democratic Party and we're starting to witness the beginning of it's own transformation. The unrest just hasn’t reached the level that the Republican Party is currently facing but it’s going to happen. And the leaders of the Parties aren’t certain what to make of the changes their constituents are demanding because they mostly want to stay in control. I'm nervous but I'm also glad that the citizens are trying to take back their representation. I hate the way the leaders have divided us but we have no one to blame but ourselves because we let them.
Polling indicates that over half of Trump voters are birthers. In 2016.
"Donald Trump supporters are even more likely to hold those views than GOP voters as a whole. 66 percent of Trump voters say President Obama is a Muslim; 61 percent say they don’t think he was born in the U.S. "
These people are basically morons. This is not going to end well , either for Trump or for the country. ( I think it will be Trump. )
John - I hope you're right because that man makes me sick. He's so obnoxious and full of BS that I can't believe people actually are buying what he's selling. AND, I'm really, really, really, tired of CNN and MSNBC giving this dope all the free air time that he gets.
Trump is obviously to blame, but his followers and people that vote for him are certainly to blame as well.
In order to win the general election he needs to have the majority of the Black and Hispanic vote. Not going to happen.