Republicans say they won’t eliminate the filibuster in 2017. Should we believe them?
Now that their hopes that the Supreme Court will undo the Affordable Care Act have been so cruelly dashed, Republicans are looking ahead to the future, to see how they might one day smash that vile law to pieces through the legislative process. But theres a problem: Even if a Republican wins the White House in 2016, Democrats in the Senate will still likely have enough seats to filibuster any attempt to repeal the law. So the answer seems clear: Why not eliminate the filibuster for legislation?
But Mitch McConnell seems be standing in the way :
Senate Republicans appear to be closing the door on gutting the filibuster, brushing aside calls from GOP presidential hopefuls Jeb Bush and Scott Walker to consider lowering the 60-vote threshold for repealing ObamaCare.
Sources close to Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.) say theres virtually no chance he will go along with abolishing the filibuster, something he has strongly criticized in the past.
Its a point on which McConnell and his frequent antagonist, conservative Sen. Ted Cruz (R-Texas), agree. Although Cruz often criticizes McConnell for lacking aggressiveness, he also views abolition of the legislative filibuster as a step too far.
Bush and Walker recently told conservative talk show host Hugh Hewitt they would support lowering the threshold for major legislation from 60 votes to a simple majority. Curbing the power of the Senate minority would make it easier to repeal and replace ObamaCare in 2017.
A little history to remind you: When Democrats took control of the Senate in 2006, the number of filibusters increased dramatically , as the minority Republicans realized that there was nothing preventing them from filibustering essentially every bill of any consequence, which is what they proceeded to do throughout the Obama presidency. In November 2013, during a controversy over a group of filibustered nominees, Senate Democrats eliminated the filibuster for most presidential nominees, including Cabinet secretaries and judicial appointees (but not those nominated to the Supreme Court), meaning those nominees could be approved on a simple majority vote. Though this was called the nuclear option by everyone, it really wasntthe true nuclear option would have been to eliminate the nuclear option entirely , for legislation as well.
And thats what Republicans are now contemplating. The perfectly reasonable point that McConnell and Cruz make is that a filibuster-free Senate is all well and good when youre in the majority and control the White House, but there will come a day when Democrats have both, and if Republicans cant use the filibuster then, America will truly become the nightmare of oppression and social decay theyve been warning about since 2009.
Republicans could win the White House but lose the Senate in 2016 they have to defend 24 seats, while Democrats only have to defend 10 in which case, it wouldnt matter (nor would it if they lose the presidential race, of course). But the greater likelihood is that the two will move in tandem, with a good election for Democrats giving them the Senate (or at least significant gains there), and a good election for Republicans keeping it in their hands.
As emphatic as McConnell is on this question, its one thing to say now that you wont eliminate the filibuster, when its all hypothetical, but consider this scenario. Its the spring of 2017, just months after Republicans achieved their victory at the polls. President Walker (or Rubio, or Bush) is moving to implement the agenda that he ran on. Republicans in Congress are eager to pass the bills theyve been fantasizing about for the last eight years. And theres a full docket of them: tax cuts, a national ban on abortions after the 20th week of a womans pregnancy, eliminating the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, forbidding the EPA from regulating greenhouse gas emissions, lightening Wall Streets terrible regulatory burden, block granting safety net programs, and, of course, the repeal of the Affordable Care Act. Yet Democrats and their filibuster stand in the way of it all.
It isnt hard to imagine that the pressure from Republican legislators, the partys base and a new president eager to make his mark, all of whom would be urging McConnell to get rid of the filibuster, would be overwhelming. After all, once all that legislation is passed and America strides into its glorious new dawn of prosperity and moral uprightness, why would they ever want to elect Democrats again anyway?
In the interests of full disclosure, I should note that back in 2013 I predicted that whenever the day came that the GOP had the Senate majority and White House in their hands, theyd destroy the filibuster forthwith. McConnell makes me a little less sure of that today, but theres no question that on that day the demand for the nuclear option would be intense. Theres one more thing to consider, though. If the Affordable Care Act is going to be the centerpiece of that debate, Republicans may feel something like they did with King v. Burwell theyd want to repeal it outright at the first possible moment, but theyd also know that doing so would hurt millions of Americans and end up being a political nightmare. So their best option might be to try to repeal the law and fail, then blame the whole thing on the Democrats. Then they could negotiate a partial, piecemeal repeal with Democrats that minimizes the damage to the public.
Of course, that would take some restraint and long-term strategic thinking on the part of congressional Republicans. Which hasnt exactly been their strong suit of late.

The GOP has to remember that there will come a time, perhaps sooner then they think, that the Democrats will control the Senate. When that happens are they sure they don't want a filibuster?
With 24 seats to defend in the next election cycle, McConnell knows enough to leave the filibuster alone.
True. A good night for the Democrats in the Presidential race can translate into the Senate being controlled by the Democrats again. They'll need the filibuster then.