Rank and File Republicans Tell Party Elites: We're Sticking With Donald Trump
Rank and File Republicans Tell Party Elites: We’re Sticking With Donald Trump
From Michigan to Louisiana to California on Friday, rank-and-file Republicans expressed mystification, dismissal and contempt for the instructions that their party’s most high-profile leaders are urgently handing down to them: reject and defeat Donald J. Trump.
Their angry reactions, in the 24 hours since Mitt Romney and John McCain urged millions of voters to cooperate in a grand strategy to undermine Mr. Trump’s candidacy, has captured the seemingly inexorable force of a movement that still puzzles the Republican elite and now threatens to unravel the party they hold dear.
Sign Up For NYT Now's Morning Briefing Newsletter
In interviews, even lifelong Republicans who cast a ballot for Mr. Romney four years ago rebelled against his message and plan. “I personally am disgusted by it — I think it’s disgraceful,” said Lola Butler, 71, a retiree from Mandeville, La., who cast a ballot for Mr. Romney in 2012. “You’re telling me who to vote for and who not to vote for? Please.”
“There’s nothing short of Trump shooting my daughter in the street and my grandchildren — there is nothing and nobody that’s going to dissuade me from voting for Trump,” Ms. Butler said.
A fellow Louisiana Republican, Mindy Nettles, 33, accused the party of “using Romney as a puppet” to protect themselves from Mr. Trump because its leaders cannot control him. “He has a mind of his own,” she said. “He can think.”
The furious campaign now underway to stop Mr. Trump and the equally forceful rebellion against it captured the essence of the party’s breakdown over the past several weeks: Its most prominent guardians, misunderstanding their own voters, antagonize them as they attempt to reason with them, driving them even more energetically to Mr. Trump’s side.
As Mr. Romney amplified his pleas on Friday, Mr. Trump snubbed a major meeting of Republican activists and leaders after rumblings that protesters were prepared to demonstrate against him there, in the latest sign of Mr. Trump’s breakaway from the apparatus of the party whose nomination he is marching toward.
As polls showed Mr. Trump likely to capture the Louisiana primary on Saturday, the biggest prize among states holding contests this weekend, the party establishment in Washington seemed seized by anxiety and despair. At the Conservative Political Action Conference, a long-running gathering of traditional conservatives, attendees feared that they were witnessing an event that has not occurred in more than a century: the breaking apart of a major American political party.
They spoke ruefully of “fidelity” lost and “values” forgone. They conceded a strange new feeling of powerlessness in the face of Mr. Trump’s ascendance. And they mourned for a 162-year-old party that is starting to seem unrecognizable to them.
Robert Walker, a former Pennsylvania congressman, lamented that the nomination of Mr. Trump, with his profane style and ideological flexibility, “would rebrand the party in ways that would take us a long time to recover from.”
Rick Santorum, a former Republican presidential candidate, warned of the “Republican Party potentially being torn up,” and Senator Ben Sasse of Nebraska groused about what would “actually make American great again.” (It was not Mr. Trump.)
Steve Forbes, the publisher and two-time Republican presidential candidate, summed up the mood at the event. “Parties,” he said, “don’t usually commit suicide,” suggesting the party was well on its way with Mr. Trump.
The problem, for figures like Mr. Forbes and Mr. Romney, is that Mr. Trump’s supporters seem profoundly uninterested at the moment with the image, expectations or traditions of the Republican Party, according to interviews with more than three dozen voters, elected officials and operatives. They are, in many cases, hostile to it.
“I want to see Trump go up there and do damage to the Republican Party,” said Jeff Walls, 53, of Flowood, Miss.
From the moment Mr. Romney delivered it in a speech on Thursday from Salt Lake City, his entreaty to voters struck many in the party as high-minded and impractical: He all but begged them to vote for Mr. Trump’s rivals, thereby denying Mr. Trump enough delegates to clinch the nomination and force a contested convention this summer. Voters have not taken kindly to the recommendation, describing the request as a patronizing directive from an elite figure that thoroughly misunderstands their feelings of alienation from the political system. (Soon after, Mr. McCain endorsed his remarks.)
Conservative talk radio shows lit up Friday with incensed callers who said they were “livid,” “mad” and “on the verge of tears” as they listened to Mr. Romney scoldingly describe what he called Mr. Trump’s misogyny, vulgarity and dishonesty, and urged them to abandon him.
“The Trumpists out there,” predicted Rush Limbaugh, “are going to feel like the establishment is trying to manipulate them, sucker them, and they’re just going to dig in deeper.”
They did.
Kathy, from Sun City, Ariz., told Mr. Limbaugh she was “absolutely livid by the Romney speech. He’s condescending,” she said, adding that he sounded like a “Democrat the whole time.” Steve from Temecula, Calif., said he had a message for Mr. Romney: “The Republican electorate is not a bunch of completely ignorant fools.”
“We know who Donald Trump is,” he added, “and we’re going to use Donald Trump to either take over the G.O.P. or blow it up.”
As Mr. Romney hopped between television stations on Friday, proclaiming his dismay over Mr. Trump’s crudeness, challenging his decency and questioning his integrity, he declared that his overtures were breaking through — though not necessarily to the audience he intended. In an interview conducted inside the headquarters of Bloomberg News in Manhattan, far from the crucial primary voting states that could decide Mr. Trump’s fate, he observed that Midtown office workers had offered their gratitude as he rode up to the studio.
“Just coming up the escalator, Mr. Romney said, people said, “ ‘Thanks for what you did yesterday.’ ”
But outside of that orbit, the response was less welcoming.
Mr. Trump’s supporters and those backing his rivals, in interviews across the country, suggested that Mr. Romney’s move was presumptuous and described him as out of touch and ineffectual. “They want to control the election because they don’t like Trump,” said Joann Hirschmann of Shelby Township, Michigan, a supporter of Gov. John Kasich of Ohio. “And I can understand that. But you have to let the people speak.”
Frustrated Republicans seized on Mr. Romney’s status as a party insider who was insulated from the realities, indignities and rage of average Americans headed to the polls this year. “He’s an establishment figure,” said Faith Sheptoski-Forbush of Romulus, Mich. “So that’s what you get.”
She called Mr. Romney’s diatribe against Mr. Trump “a desperate attempt” that left her deeply disappointed in him.
“What we need is the voice of the people,” said Ms. Sheptoski-Forbush. “The voice of the people want Trump.”

Trump has 41% of the republican vote, Cruz 19 and Rubio 16.
This campaign against Trump by the party establishment could backfire in a big way.
Donald Trump has won 34 % of the vote do far.
“There’s nothing short of Trump shooting my daughter in the street and my grandchildren — there is nothing and nobody that’s going to dissuade me from voting for Trump,” Ms. Butler said.
A fellow Louisiana Republican, Mindy Nettles, 33, accused the party of “using Romney as a puppet” to protect themselves from Mr. Trump because its leaders cannot control him. “He has a mind of his own,” she said. “He can think.”
These people are morons and I don't see the point in encouraging them.
JR, the report I read shows exactly the % that I posted.
The people have a right to voice their opinion whether you like it or not. It's that simple.
Wikipedia is updated to the day. Unless they have bad math, I will go with that. There have been 15 primaries and caucuses so far. Trump has gone over 40% in only a few of them and has a few where he was in the 20's. I don't see how he could have a 41% average.
People have a right to their opinion, but people who don't care whatsoever what a candidate says or what his background is, and say that only if the candidate kills their children will they object to him , are morons.
I say stop blaming the "system" for Trump and start blaming our literally thoughtless population. This is the product of 25 years of right wing media brainwashing the willing.
Here ya go read it and weep.
I'm not not talking about polls Dean, I'm talking about votes.
I don't think that anything that he says will deter his followers. I guess we'll see with this weekends 5 republican primaries.
I'm not so sure about that. The more he waffles back to positions that are reasonable for any candidate to claim, like 'torturing innocent Muslims is a bad thing', the less appealing he is going to be to the knuckle dragging mouth breathers that are attending his rallies. He is treating his campaign like a crime boss, and voters who normally pay no attention to politics are eating it up.
''He is treating his campaign like a crime boss, and voters who normally pay no attention to politics are eating it up.'' That is true, and I'm interested how this weekends primaries go. I believe that Trump was favored in all of them before his torture comment.
Yes he's bringing a lot of fresh new faces out to the polls. The Republicans are seeing record turnout. He's the hitman on the broken establishment and fat cat bureaucrats.
Yes he's bringing a lot of fresh new faces out to the polls. The Republicans are seeing record turnout. He's the hitman on the broken establishment and fat cat bureaucrats.
Trump speaks to angry authoritarians and does so across party lines … but, among the angry middle class Trump followers are those whose anger is not just at government … rather these individuals go a step further and blame scapegoats … minorities, certain religions, women, gays, immigrants -- including LEGAL immigrants … AND THEREIN EXISTS THE DANGER OF A DONALD TRUMP WHO ENCOURAGES AND PANDERS TO THE WORST OF "HUMANITY".
Blaming corporations, unions, sell-out politicians … I get that (even as a union guy); but once the all-purpose hate cry and propaganda tool called "political correctness" becomes a focal point and scapegoat, focused anger gives way to the anger of knuckle-dragging hatred.
This is the kind of frightening, dumb shit that has come out of the ant-political correctness mantra/propaganda.
Texas State School Board Candidate: Obama Loves Gays Because He Was A Male Prostitute
by John Wright
February 15, 2016 | 1:17pm
Don't tell me that racism and hatred don't drive this kind of dangerous insanity!
How does a poop-bag like this get a political following?
No Racism and Hatred don't drive it, Racism and Hatred latches onto to it and then uses it for it's own evil intents.
T Rump doesn't care where his support comes from at this time, but he does listen to his advisers.
I suspect if he does get the nomination, it will come with advisers that are a bit more capable than the ones he has now.
And the angry rhetoric will at least make more sense.
I've said it before I'll say it again, Hitting Donald Trump with insults makes him stronger.
His ..... WHATEVER.... is resonating with the electorate. An electorate that was essentially told their votes and opinions don't matter last cycle. They were stupid morons that haven't a clue., so they stayed home and didn't vote.
Not going to happen this time around and you know what? they are bringing daddy, mommy and all their friends with them. Thousands of voters that haven't pulled a lever in decades,
ARE NOW ENERGIZED!
Keep slamming T Rump, and you will hand him the presidency.
He is the quintessential outsider. In an election that looks more and more as a rejection of politics as usual.
(that is that polling over the last few yeas showing less than 10% approval for the political parties in congress showing up. It's about BOTH SIDES)
Democrats blame republicans, Republicans blame democrats, both are calling each other names like on the school playground. the people have picked a candidate that is immune to such childish treatment.
They better get their heads out of their asses pretty quick, their chances of beating him are razor thin at this point.
But the lesson for the Politicians?
DON'T TREAT THE AMERICAN PEOPLE LIKE THEY ARE STUPID.