Reality Check: Trump Says He’d Kill Terrorists’ Families, But Obama Already Has
Donald Trump has been making headlines saying that, if elected, he wouldn’t just go after terrorists—he would kill their families.
And while the media has been shocked by this, why weren’t they outraged when President Barack Obama actually did?
This is a Reality Check you won’t see anywhere else.
“I would be very, very firm with families, and that would make people think because they may not care about their lives, but they care—believe it or not—about their family’s lives.”
That was Trump insisting that he would be so tough on terror that, if elected, he would kill terrorists and he would target their families as well.
So while the media scrambles to demonize remarks about killing family members of terrorists, as they should, they seem to forget their collective silence when President Obama didn’t talk about doing that—he actually did it.
You probably don’t recognize this man, but his name was Anwar al-Awlaki, an American-born Muslim cleric who at one time was invited to the Pentagon after 9/11 to talk about the role of Muslims in America.
al-Awlaki became increasingly angry at the U.S. government’s spying on Muslims in mosques. He left the U.S. in 2004, traveled back to Yemen and became radicalized.
The U.S. government called him an inspiration for the Fort Hood shooter, the failed underwear bomber, the failed Times Square bomber.
On September 30th, 2011, President Obama ordered a drone strike that killed al-Awlaki along with another U.S. citizen.
Plenty of you watching will say, so what? He was a terrorist. And you won’t be concerned about the fact that al-Awlaki was a U.S. citizen who got no due process.
But that is a discussion for another time, because the point I want to make today is not about al-Awlaki. It’s actually about what happened two weeks later.
Because two weeks after the killing of al-Awlaki, President Obama ordered a second drone strike, this one killed al-Awlaki’s 16-year-old son, Abdulrahman al-Awlaki.
Who was he? He too was a U.S. citizen. He was born in Denver, CO. He was not a member of al-Qaeda. He was not a militant.
He had not lived with his father for over two years because Anwar al-Awlaki had gone into hiding. Abdulrahman was not at a terror training camp when he was killed on September 4, 2013. He was at his second cousin’s home, a cousin he lived with while his father was in hiding.
He was the son of a man the U.S. government had decided was an enemy, and yet he himself was not even on the president’s kill list .
And what’s worse, after killing that 16 year old, the Obama Administration justified the killing by essentially saying that he should have had a better father.
We Are Change reporter Sierra Adamson: “…It’s an American citizen that is being targeted without due process, without trial. And, he’s underage. He’s a minor.”
Former White House Press Secretary Robert Gibbs: “I would suggest that you should have a far more responsible father if they are truly concerned about the well being of their children. I don’t think becoming an al-Qaeda jihadist terrorist is the best way to go about doing your business.”
What you need to know is that when Trump says he would kill the families of terrorists, members of the media point to the Geneva Convention insisting that to kill terrorists’ families would be a war crime. They might be right.
So why have they been so quiet when this president has actually done it?
That’s Reality Check. Let’s talk about that on Twitter @BenSwann_
Watch Ben Swann’s full interview with President Obama, including questions about his kill list, courtesy of Fox 19, here:
http://truthinmedia.com/reality-check-trump-says-kill-terrorists-families-but-obama-already-has/

I thought the lefties that were outraged over Trumps remarks might be interested in this.
I thought the lefties that were outraged over Trumps remarks might be interested in this.
So while the media scrambles to demonize remarks about killing family members of terrorists, as they should, they seem to forget their collective silence when President Obama didn’t talk about doing that—he actually did it.
The atrocities of war -- traditional or in retaliation to terrorism -- tragically and inevitably include the loss of innocent lives; that's a given.
BUT THERE IS A SIGNIFICANT DIFFERENCE BETWEEN THE ADVOCATING, AND PROCEEDING, WITH INTENT , TO TAKE INNOCENT LIVES!
What Trump advocates is a WAR CRIME/CRIME AGAINST HUMANITY!
Before posting articles like this, one needs to educate himself;
What acts are war crimes?
War crimes are defined by the Geneva Conventions, the precedents of the Nuremberg Tribunals, an older area of law referred to as the Laws and Customs of War, and, in the case of the former Yugoslavia, the statutes of the International Criminal Tribunal in The Hague (ICTY).
War crimes fall into three groups - or four if you include genocide.
Crimes against peace
War crimes
Violations of the laws or customs of war, including:
Crimes against humanity
Atrocities and offences committed against any civilian population, before or during the war, including:
Responsibility for such crimes
Leaders, organisers, instigators and accomplices participating in the formulation or execution of a common plan or conspiracy to commit any of the crimes above are criminally responsible for everything done by anyone in carrying out such a plan.
Superior orders
The fact that a person was obeying an order of his Government or of a superior does not free him from responsibility, but can be considered and may reduce the appropriate punishment.
A very detailed list of crimes against humanity and war crimes can be found in articles 7 and 8 of the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court, which is online at the United Nations website. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external websites
Genocide
Genocide
Genocide is considered one of the most severe crimes against humanity. It means the deliberate attempt to destroy a national, ethnic, racial or religious group.
The term was coined in 1943 by the Jewish-Polish lawyer Raphael Lemkin who combined the Greek word 'genos' (race or tribe) with the Latin word 'cide' (to kill).
Definition
Genocide means any of the following acts committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnic, racial or religious group, as such:
Individuals are chosen as victims purely, simply and exclusively because they are members of the target group, and not because of anything an individual has done.
Genocide is a crime under international law even if it is not a crime in the country where it takes place, and incitement to commit genocide is also a crime.
_______________________________________________________
If the author of the seeded article believes Obama has acted with intent as the article implies, he should follow the docket in chronological order and begin with Nuremberg-like procedures against the Bush Administration.
I deem the article just one more Obama-bash like those that have permeated the last 7 and1/2 years, articles and lies that created the angry, sometimes mob-like stupidity and following of the Republican Ministry of Propaganda's poster boy, Donald Trump!
I agree Trump is talking about war crimes. Do you agree BO already committed them?
"The atrocities of war -- traditional or in retaliation to terrorism -- tragically and inevitably include the loss of innocent lives; that's a given".
You seem to be classifying it as an "accident" or "collateral damage" while the evidence suggests otherwise.
Who was he? He too was a U.S. citizen. He was born in Denver, CO. He was not a member of al-Qaeda. He was not a militant.
He had not lived with his father for over two years because Anwar al-Awlaki had gone into hiding. Abdulrahman was not at a terror training camp when he was killed on September 4, 2013. He was at his second cousin’s home, a cousin he lived with while his father was in hiding.
Take a look at the link Petey provided for more info.
Amac. I am not a trump fan. I just like pointing out hypocrisy. Like people who call Trump a liar but give Hillary a pass. The boy was murdered because of who he was related to. Not because of his own actions. Is this not exactly what you are decrying against Trumps words and listing as war crimes, crimes against humanity and the like?
Take a look at the link Petey provided for more info.
I did look.
I want to look again; it's not clear to me after the first look whether the victim was involved in actual terrorism.
And if we're talking about a "lack of due process," then all prisoners at Gitmo who were never formally charged, nor, for whom there was ever any evidence … they too were denied due process.
I'm not taking a side; I am in all cases saying that the "Burden of Proof" should always be satisfied.
and "He Said, NO!, HE said"
Does not constitute proof on any side.
"I'm not taking a side; I am in all cases saying that the "Burden of Proof" should always be satisfied."
Burden of proof that he was a terrorist? Or that he was not? If the burden of proof is to prove his guilt, before killing him it was not satisfied. Now the burden of proof is what? To find out who ordered it? Who pulled the trigger?
Burden of proof that he was a terrorist? Or that he was not? If the burden of proof is to prove his guilt, before killing him it was not satisfied. Now the burden of proof is what? To find out who ordered it? Who pulled the trigger?
If the allegation is comprised of multiple components, then the burden of proof must be satisfied for each component; while in terms of a life taken, the point is moot, nevertheless a protocol must be satisfied lest we are no better than barbarians.
Being a lawyer [or just thinking like one] leaves you clueless during a shooting war ...
Being a lawyer [or just thinking like one] leaves you clueless during a shooting war ...
WWII was a "shooting war"! Are you okay with that whole Nuremberg Trials thing?
Nuremberg happened after the war . It was an minor attempt to deal with the massive destruction of the actual war .
Obama killed an American citizen because he was related to a v terrorists. Case closed.
Obama killed an American citizen because he was related to a v terrorists. Case closed.
Motive has yet to be established. Case reopened.
1ofmany
"Motive has yet to be established. Case reopened."
That is a VERY DANGEROUS attitude my friend.
So I can kill someone and as long as I can find a motive within (how long? This kid has been dead almost 3 YEARS.. how long is the window open before people are prosecuted? Indefinitely? ) then you are OK with me killing someone? Before you answer, let me ask this. What if I or the government "suspect" YOU are a terrorist, and decide to kill you before proving it? Gosh the government could never make a mistake in this regard right?/s
You are basically throwing a pillar of our society, "innocent until proven guilty" out the window. You know that right?
1ofmany
"Motive has yet to be established. Case reopened."
That is a VERY DANGEROUS attitude my friend.
So I can kill someone and as long as I can find a motive within (how long? This kid has been dead almost 3 YEARS.. how long is the window open before people are prosecuted? Indefinitely? ) then you are OK with me killing someone? Before you answer, let me ask this. What if I or the government "suspect" YOU are a terrorist, and decide to kill you before proving it? Gosh the government could never make a mistake in this regard right?/s
You are basically throwing a pillar of our society, "innocent until proven guilty" out the window. You know that right?
You misunderstand me. I was responding to the assumption that Obama assassinated a kid simply because he was related to a terrorist. It's undisputed that the kid is dead; what's in dispute is the motive. As near as I can tell, Obama has not admitted to killing a kid for simply being a relative and nobody has proven it. The motive isn't established by passage of time. So no I don't think Obama should be executing people on that basis, and said so, but Obama is also entitled to the presumption of "innocent until proven" guilty so I won't presume his guilt based on a motive that hasn't been established. That's not because I like Obama (I don't) or because the government is infallible (it isn't) but because I believe in fundamental fairness for everybody . . . even Obama.
OK I see, and agree, although I think as commander in chief, he bares some responsibility. However, There will be no investigation, of course. So he will never be proven guilty.
OK I see, and agree, although I think as commander in chief, he bares some responsibility. However, There will be no investigation, of course. So he will never be proven guilty.
He may bear complete responsibility but, as a sitting President, he is immune from criminal prosecution in a court of law and even if Congress wanted to question him in a legislative inquiry, he can assert executive privilege and decline to answer or even appear. All this is further muddled by the notion that he's acting as commander in chief during a war on terrorism and collateral damage is acceptable in war (even in a never-ending metaphorical war like this). I had problems with this issue under George Bush and I have the same problem with Obama . . . Presidents have too much unfettered authority. But I'm glad you raised the issue for discussion, even if we have no answers.
So no I don't think Obama should be executing people on that basis, and said so, but Obama is also entitled to the presumption of "innocent until proven" guilty so I won't presume his guilt based on a motive that hasn't been established.
And in fact motive, in and of itself, is not proof. Prosecutors are not even required to show motive and they can't make a case based only on it. There needs to be evidence.
Depending on the charge, the ideal is intent, motive goes towards intent.
Motive can also be an element of the crime, and an element of the crime is a fact that HAS to be proven beyond a reasonable doubt to secure a conviction.
Yes there are crimes where motive doesn't matter, but not ALL crimes.
When there is no effort to try to provide burden of proof for one side, it seems unfair doesn't it? As if one is above the law.
When there is no effort to try to provide burden of proof for one side, it seems unfair doesn't it? As if one is above the law.
96,
The Burden of Proof falls on the plaintiff, not the defendant; the one making the allegation must satisfy the burden of proof -- consistent with the tenet of "presumption of innocence".
According to the stated clauses in the Nuremberg protocall,,,
Every American President since the Korean War is guilty of war crimes.
But then again so is every leader on the other side also.
This is the conundrum of political actions arising after a war is concluded, where the victors in moral fervent plaster their acts of murderous intent with platitudes to civility, honor and integrity after ordering the most horrific crimes against humanity.
The ENDS NEVER JUSTIFY THE MEANS!
I only wish our politicians would get that tattooed on their foreheads so they can read it in a mirror every day.
Every American President since the Korean War is guilty of war crimes.
I expect you can go back further than the Korean event ...
Depends on what constitutes a war crime and who ordered it.
everyone knows that full blown warfare is the unleashing of the dogs. anything and everything comes into play. War is the discarding of societal rules. Time to kill people and break things.
According to the Founders sometimes war is justified. I don't think that anyone will argue that WWII was not justified. I don't think anyone can argue that the Korean war wasn't justified and even if it wasn't, It was a legal war.
The War in Vietnam was NOT justified. The first Iraq War WAS justified, the second one was NOT justified. the War against Al Quaida and their Taliban supporters WAS justified, so justified that even the Russians could see that it was.
So no I disagree with your interpretations of what constitutes a war crime obviously.
And no WWII did not constitute the commission of war crime by FDR. Neither Truman in the Korean War.
How about the Whiskey Rebellion ?
What?
GW committed a war crime cause he squeezed into his old generals uniform to lead the troops as Commander in Chief? (Only president to take ever the field in direct command of organized troops, first of only two presidents to actually assume the role of commander in chief, James Madison during the war of 1812 directed the military evacuation of Washington DC, was the other)
Put down the rebellion without firing a shot?
Where's the war crime?
Was it justified?
Under the constitution ABSOLUTELY!
I don't know if the 16 year-old was targeted just because he was the son of a terrorist (which is deplorable and illegal) or whether he was accidental collateral damage. However, Trump is openly advocating killing people based solely on guilt by association or family relationship. That is a war crime. If Trump carries out that threat, then I fully support hanging him as a war criminal when he is eventually brought to justice.
Same as Obama.
I don't know if the 16 year-old was targeted just because he was the son of a terrorist (which is deplorable and illegal) or whether he was accidental collateral damage. However, Trump is openly advocating killing people based solely on guilt by association or family relationship. That is a war crime. If Trump carries out that threat, then I fully support hanging him as a war criminal when he is eventually brought to justice.
Same as Obama.
If Obama admits that he killed the kid based solely on his familial relationship or if it's proven, then I would agree with you. But conjecture isn't proof.
Since it has been the practice of terrorist groups to provide financial benefits to the families of "martyrs" the extreme strategy of killing those family members was the strategy arrived at to counter that tactic . Extreme tactics result in extreme countermeasures ...
Since it has been the practice of terrorist groups to provide financial benefits to the families of "martyrs" the extreme strategy of killing those family members was the strategy arrived at to counter that tactic . Extreme tactics result in extreme countermeasures ...
If the extreme countermeasures constitute War Crimes then the expeditors of those measures are, like the terrorist groups, by definition, "War Criminals".
Tell that to Obama . The killing of the father Anwar al-Awlaki was itself probably illegal as well ...
"Since it has been the practice of terrorist groups to provide financial benefits to the families of "martyrs" the extreme strategy of killing those family members was the strategy arrived at to counter that tactic . Extreme tactics result in extreme countermeasures ..."
Iran has announced (now that Obama and his yes-man partners have given them the money) that it will pay $30,000 to the family of a terrorist who dies while attacking Jews, and the PA uses the aid the US and EU gives it to support the families of imprisoned terrorists who have blood on their hands. Since the USA under the Iran agreement is releasing the sanctioned money to Iran then perhaps the USA and other members of the Iran deal group are war criminals as well as enablers through complicity and providing the means.
However, Iran will soon have developed the means to carry out its shouted threats to "The Big Satan" after it has tested its prowess by wiping "The Little Satan" off the map.
Since the USA under the Iran agreement is releasing the sanctioned money to Iran then perhaps the USA and other members of the Iran deal group are war criminals as well as enablers through complicity and providing the means.
Sanctions were imposed because Iran was violating the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty and properly lifted once Iran complied with its obligations. Israel, on the other hand, won't even sign the treaty and jumps up and down because they believe Iran will do what it has already done (i.e. develop a nuclear bomb). But if funding an atrocity were itself a war crime, then the US would already be guilty for funding Israel's rampages through Gaza, the West Bank and Lebanon . . . you can't hang the same people twice.
Oh, I guess you forgot about the rockets fired into Israel civilian areas from residential areas in Gaza, and of course you don't believe Col. Richard Kemp who you probably think is the liar-in-chief. Oh, I guess you forgot about the terrorist attacks against civilians perpetrated by Arabs incited by their leaders through their imams and TV and radio broadcasts. Oh, I guess you forgot about Hezbollah's firing rockets into Israel (I once had to hide in a bomb shelter on a kibbutz in Northern Israel - I guess you never had that experience).
. . . Oh, I guess you forgot about Hezbollah's firing rockets into Israel (I once had to hide in a bomb shelter on a kibbutz in Northern Israel - I guess you never had that experience).
And I suspect you've never been on the receiving end of Israeli guided missiles and artillery shells. Like a kicked dog that snaps back, Palestinians and any other occupied people have the right to resist occupation. Rather than complain that the dog snaps back, stop kicking it and end the occupation. Either create one "viable" Palestinian state (an option that Israel has almost eliminated by expanding settlements) or let the Palestinians return home and have one unified state of Jews and Palestinians that includes the occupied territories or fight forever.
let the Palestinians return home
Actually those palis left so long ago they have nearly all expired by now . But have fun defending muli-generational refugee status ...
i didn't fire a rocket into Arab territory. The Israeli missiles and artillery are caused by the launching of missiles into residential Israeli areas, and are designed to take out those Arab missile and rocket launchers. Of course your hatred of Israel will not allow you to comprehend that, but you will find any excuse to support Arab terrorism. You should move to Iran.
. . . Of course your hatred of Israel will not allow you to comprehend that, but you will find any excuse to support Arab terrorism. You should move to Iran.
The Palestinians are just as intent on resisting occupation as you are in imposing it so, by all means, fight each other forever. Hopefully, one day, we'll pry Israel's hand out of our back pocket so they can fight on their own dime.
Looking forward to the day I can keep my money instead of the government sending it overseas.
Since it has been the practice of terrorist groups to provide financial benefits to the families of "martyrs" the extreme strategy of killing those family members was the strategy arrived at to counter that tactic . Extreme tactics result in extreme countermeasures ...
And extreme criminal penalties like being hanged.
Is there any documented proof or other evidence that Obama or any American in a leadership or controlling position in any American institution such as the armed forces or CIA actually ordered the killing of the son of the terrorist (who could very well be an innocent)? How about documented evidence that the Obama administration made the statement that the son should have had a better father, in an attempt to justify the killing of the son?
Such accusations must be backed up with valid evidence or they are slanderous.
How Team Obama Justifies the Killing of a 16-Year-Old American
The American Teen Whose Death-by-Drone Obama Won't Explain
Thanks Petey!
The Mother Jones article isn't proof of anything other than Obama declined to answer a question.
The Atlantic article could be proof of the killing, but it provides no honest justification. The excuse given by the "Obama team" just visits the sins of the father upon the son without justification or evidence of wrongdoing. Would it be right to harm Malia and Sasha if you thought their father was a criminal? I guess there is a lesson to be learned here. Without proof of complicity can Israel justify the destruction of the family house of a terrorist? At least it isn't murder of the family, as the US has done in the case of Al-Awlaki, but is an attempt to deter terrorism, and perhaps that should be considered by critics of the policy.
When the policy is to launch a counterattack against "Al -Quaeda" no one goes to the site to verify who is there . What does that prove other than "war is hell" ?!
If there is proof, then the proof speaks for itself; no argument.
Blinders on!