Seattle Archdiocese Settles Sexual Abuse Case for $9.1 Million After Daming Letter Surfaces
After being sued by eight women who alleged they were molested by a priest four decades ago, the Seattle Archdiocese has settled for $9.1 million.
The settlement, reported by the Seattle Times , came Wednesday after a damning psychiatrist’s letter, among other documents, surfaced last year reporting Michael Cody, the priest at the center of the suit, was a pedophile who needed to “be removed from parish work as soon as possible.” The letter, part of correspondence among church officials expressing concerns about Cody, was written in 1962; the women were abused between 1968 and 1975.
“He told me that he was suffering from an abnormal sexual attraction toward young girls,” psychiatrist Albert M. Hurley wrote. “… He has molested at least eight girls twelve years of age or younger. As you know, there have been complaints about his hostility and temper in the various parishes where he has served. He also complains of feelings of severe depression, during which time he prays that God will allow him to die rather than continue this behavior.”
Hurley was explicit about his diagnosis, saying Cody was a pedophile who showed “sadistic tendencies” to boys he knew and talked of killing others and himself.
“It is likely that if external controls on his acting out are made, and this cycle of aggression and depression sufficiently interrupted, then he can once again assume a useful and productive life,” the psychiatrist wrote.
The interruption never came. Cody — who stopped serving as a priest in 1979, was defrocked in 2005 and died last year — served in a number of parishes in Washington state, where he “preyed on children for years,” as the Seattle Times put it . In a deposition in 2013 , the priest, then 82, said estimating how many children he abused “would only be a guess.” In a 1988 mental-health evaluation, he said he had molested up to 40 girls and one boy.
“At a time when I didn’t feel special, he befriended me and made me feel special,” Jeri Hubbard, 63 — who Cody had sex with repeatedly when she was a troubled 16-year-old runaway living in his rectory — told the Seattle Times . “Instinctively, I kind of knew it wasn’t right. But I didn’t know what to do and I didn’t want him to get in trouble.” When she questioned the arrangement, Cody said her no one would believe her if she told them. (She settled with the archdiocese in a separate case last year.)

In the wake of the settlement, the archdiocese, as so many in the Catholic Church have, sought to put the past behind it — and find out if other victims are out there.
In January, the Archdiocese published a list of 77 priests, brothers, nuns and deacons accused of assaulting children while serving or living in Western Washington, the Seattle Times reported .
“Our first priority is the protection of children and healing for past victims,” Seattle Archbishop Peter Sartain said, as the Associated Press reported . “It is my firm commitment to build on the good efforts of the past and continue to take steps that will truly help victims of clergy sexual abuse to heal. This $9 million settlement demonstrates our ongoing commitment to acknowledge and address the devastating impact of clergy sexual abuse, and to encourage victims to come forward.”
An attorney for the women said the settlement prevents the archdiocese from facing the terrible details of the Cody case and from acknowledging that the priest remained on the job despite the fact an archbishop knew of his crimes.
“The evidence regarding Father Cody is overwhelming, and I don’t think the Archdiocese wants more bad publicity,” Michael T. Pfau said . “The direct involvement of former Archbishop Thomas Connelly in placing this pedophile in parishes with full knowledge of his danger to children is truly disturbing.”
The psychiatrist’s letter was part of a so-called “ secret file ” on Cody kept by the church. Advocates for those abused by priests say such files only contribute to a decades-old problem.
“These records illustrate a pattern of secrecy,” Mary Dispenza, Northwest director of the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests and herself a victim of clergy abuse, said earlier this month . “Most bishops are still dragging their feet about releasing them because they’ll be embarrassed or ashamed, and past bishops might be implicated.”
“I was pissed,” Hubbard, one of Cody’s victims, said when she learned of the file. “The church knew he was a pedophile years before he ever came … And they let that happen.”

More scumbag predators protected by the church leaders.
The letter, part of correspondence among church officials expressing concerns about Cody, was written in 1962; the women were abused between 1968 and 1975.
This is why the church is considered to be a collaborator with its pedophile priests. The fucking bastards, every one of them, should be hanged, and the pope in charge at the time along with them.
They sound like a terrorist organization.
They are Dean, and have been for centuries.... the church, I mean, this does not reflect on the people who follow the faith and are as disgusted as those not of the catholic persuasion.
Pedophiles should all be hung, shot, or staked out next to a fire ant bed and poured with honey. If they don't die from the bites, THEN hang, shoot or slit their throats.
In the swamps, the people strip them naked, and tie them on the ground for the alligators to eat alive. Works for me.
When we have people who repeatedly comment on the Catholic Church issue with child sexual abuse, and essentially never comment on the far wider instances of the same behavior in the rest of the society, we are unfortunately left to conclude that anti-Catholic bias is in play.
All of the Catholic cases from the past 50 or 60 years, all of them combined, are a drop in the bucket of child sexual abuse cases in the United States. There are more cases of child sexual abuse in ONE year in the US, outside of the Catholic Church, than there is in 60 years inside the Catholic Church combined.
Unfortunately there is anti-Catholic bigotry on NT.
settlement prevents the archdiocese from facing the terrible details of the Cody case and from acknowledging that the priest remained on the job despite the fact an archbishop knew of his crimes.
Keep making excuses John .
An epidemic of child sex abuse in our public schools
There’s a banner that hangs outside of Costa Mesa’s (California) Whittier Elementary School. Its slogan— Children are our first priority —is a painfully ironic reminder of one of the biggest problems plaguing our public schools.
That problem is child sexual abuse by public school employees—an epidemic that is raging out of control.
Don’t believe it’s a problem? Here are some recent stories that should change your mind.
- See more at:
Depend the people of the faith and I will agree with you... defend the church and its pedophile leaders and you can kiss my grits.
That problem is child sexual abuse by public school employees—an epidemic that is raging out of control
Kill them all.
Parents are FORCED to send their children to school and in the arms of these vermin. You know how many were "allowed to resign" from former positions and with the help of their motherfucking UNION move somewhere else to do it again.
Fucking union officials who do this aren't any better than the pedophile popes and other church personnel. They all should be thrown in prison with mandatory full term sentences for raping children, no early releases under any circumstances.
School administrators and fucking Teacher's Unions should be prosecuted for not checking properly on backgrounds BECAUSE THE AMERICAN PUBLIC HAS NO CHOICE IN THE MATTER OF SENDING CHILDREN TO SCHOOL unless they can set themselves up to home school.
Scalp every damn one of them, leave them alive, and throw them to the alligators.
And since we aren't allowed to do that, put them in prison and take their own children away from the parent or family members left behind. What's good for the Indian is good for the rest of the fuckers.
John,
When there have been any articles posted about any other church leaders found to be pedophiles, myself and others have said "Kill them all!" or something to that effect.
It's not our fault you haven't dug up articles about protestant pedophiles and posted them here; do so and you will get the same response you do with the catholic pedophiles. The difference is when these people are found out they have to answer to the law.... there is no independent "country" of Baptists, Methodists, Church of Christ, etc. to let them cower within go avoid their punishment.
That is why the catholic church is so detested, John... because they hid, relocated to areas with other innocent children, and refused to cooperate with the law to punish the fucking pedophiles... and that makes every damn official of the fucking catholic pedophile church guilty of collaboration and conspiracy to foment and encourage pedophilia, and the rape, sodomy and destruction of innocent children.
DO YOU GET IT NOW OR SHOULD I TYPE SLOWER SO YOU CAN UNDERSTAND ?????
Mimi, you are an anti-Catholic bigot.
Maybe you feel you have good reason, I don't know. Other organizations besides the Catholic hierarchy have protected pedophiles and child sex abusers. It has been a regular practice in the nation's public school systems.
I do know I am getting sick and tired of your various bigotries.
John ,
You are a sexist and have been for a long time .
makes every damn official of the fucking catholic pedophile church guilty of collaboration and conspiracy to foment and encourage pedophilia
That pretty much spells it out but apparently you needed to type slower !
Unfortunately there is anti-Catholic bigotry on NT.
John, my friend...
there is an anti-catholic church sentiment from some of us here... it isn't bigotry.... it isn't against the people of the catholic faith... it's against the institution of the church and those who run it.
It's like.... well.... 99% of Americans love America; millions just don't love or support the policies of the elected government and feel powerless to do anything about it. I would bet there are many faithful Catholic members who feel the same way about the institution of the church.
You are Catholic, John. Do you hate gays and believe they are automatically bound for hell? Do you believe anyone not of the catholic faith is hell-bound? Do you believe children born of a married couple who divorce, then the mother converts to Catholicism in order to wed a catholic man... that those children are bastards because the mom's previous marriage was completely made null and void when she converted?
"The Senate unanimously agreed today with U.S. Senator Pat Toomey (R-Pa.) that schools receiving federal funds cannot help a child molester obtain a job at another school and move onto other victims.
The horrible practice of schools quietly letting pedophile teachers leave and helping them find school jobs elsewhere is so common it has its own moniker -- "passing the trash." The Every Child Achieves Act was amended with Toomey's language prohibiting federal funds to schools that help an employee get a new job when there is credible information that the school employee engaged in sexual misconduct with a minor.
"For the first time ever, the Senate has approved legislation that prohibits the outrageous practice of ‘passing the trash' and bans schools from helping a child-predator employee land a job in another school. It's a huge victory for children in Pennsylvania and across the country," said Sen. Toomey. "Tragically, ‘passing the trash' is a serious problem that Pennsylvanians are all too familiar with, and I am pleased that we were able to bridge our differences across the aisle to agree on a real solution. And while we were not able to also pass legislation requiring background checks for all school employees, I will continue fighting for this commonsense policy to ensure that our schools are safer. Our children deserve it."
Under the Toomey amendment, a school district that receives federal funds shall not assist a school employee in obtaining a new job if it knows, or recklessly disregards credible information indicating, that such school employee engaged in sexual misconduct with a minor."
A 1995 study of 225 cases in which pupils were sexually abused by teachers or other staff members found that in only 1% of the cases did the school-district superintendent attempt to revoke the culprit's teaching licence.
A 1995 study of 225 cases in which pupils were sexually abused by teachers or other staff members found that in only 1% of the cases did the school-district superintendent attempt to revoke the culprit's teaching licence
This is what I have been talking about... thank you, John.
Don't know who voted this comment "down" haven't checked yet, but it doesn't deserve a "down;" It is absolutely true.
Good for Toomey!!!!!!
Now, if Congress and the Supreme Court will just pass a similar to cover law enforcement we cut down on over half excessive police violence and unnecessary killings of children such as Tamir Rice.
We as American citizens should DEMAND a law such as this for law enforcement!