╌>

It’s Time for Hillary Clinton to Concede the Democratic Nomination to Bernie Sanders

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  sean-treacy  •  10 years ago  •  33 comments

It’s Time for Hillary Clinton to Concede the Democratic Nomination to Bernie Sanders


With Bernie Sanders now  slightly ahead  of Clinton nationally in the latest Bloomberg poll, it’s time to reevaluate the meaning of pragmatism. Hillary Clinton might be ahead of Bernie Sanders in delegates, but Vermont’s Senator has a monopoly on political momentum. Sadly, his opponent has a monopoly on controversy, and will face FBI interviews in the near future. A  Los Angeles Times article titled  Clinton email probe enters new phase as FBI interviews loom  highlights why Clinton’s campaign is stuck in political quicksand:


 


 


Federal prosecutors investigating the possible mishandling of classified materials on Hillary Clinton’s private email server have begun the process of setting up formal interviews with some of her longtime and closest aides, according to two people familiar with the probe, an indication that the inquiry is moving into its final phases.



Prosecutors also are expected to seek an interview with Clinton herself, though the timing remains unclear.


 


 


Yes, federal prosecutors will interview Hillary Clinton, in addition to her close associates.



At what point will establishment Democrats admit this fiasco is horrible for a general election? 

When federal prosecutors are interviewing your candidate for president, even Donald Trump has a good chance at the White House.



Furthermore, former U.S. attorney general Michael Mukasey believes  A Criminal Charge is Justified . Former Obama intelligence official Lt. Gen.  Michael Flynn  says that “If it were me, I would have been out the door and probably in jail.” Former NSA director  Michael Hayden  called Clinton’s email setup “stupid and dangerous.” Even Edward Snowden, the antithesis of America’s intelligence community in many ways, says it’s  “ridiculous”  to think Clinton’s emails were secure.



It’s time for Democrats to deal with reality, not just allegiance to a political icon, and rally around the only candidate not linked to an FBI investigation, and other controversies . With recent victories and future wins ahead, Bernie Sanders has all the political momentum heading towards Election Day. Most importantly, Bernie Sanders is the only leading candidate with  positive favorability ratings  in 2016.



Hillary Clinton has negative favorability ratings in  ten national polls . When people forget about Trump’s rallies, and the billionaire pivots to his former identity as a Democrat ( “I probably identify more as a Democrat” ), then the Clinton campaign is in big trouble.



In terms of these favorability polls, Hillary Clinton holds negative ratings by an over 10-point margin  in 9 of these polls. 

The fact that in 9 out of 10 national polls, Clinton is viewed in a negative manner by an over  10-point margin  should worry anyone fearing Trump, or a Republican White House.



Clinton is even viewed unfavorably by a  21-point margin  in a March CBS/Times poll. Democrats can’t run a winning presidential campaign with the slogan, “We’ll save you from Trump with a person who’s less despised.”



Furthermore, the Clinton campaign won’t tell you that nationally,  64% of women  find Hillary Clinton “not honest and trustworthy.”  Young feminists  are choosing Bernie Sanders over potentially the first female president and  61.4% of women ages 18-29 prefer Bernie Sanders over Clinton.



In terms of the future of the Democratic Party, NPR  writes  “A recent Quinnipiac poll found that Sanders bests Clinton among 18- to 44-year-olds, 78 percent to 21 percent.” Because of this energy and enthusiasm, Bernie Sanders has  raised more money  than Clinton in February.



When Jann S. Wenner of  Rolling Stone  endorsed Hillary Clinton, Mr. Wenner  wrote “Clinton is far more likely to win the general election than Sanders.” First, this statement is undermined by the fact  Real Clear Politics  shows Bernie Sanders defeating Donald Trump by  17.5 points  in an average of national polls. In contrast, the “far more likely to win” Hillary Clinton beats Trump by  11.2 points , and this margin was less than 4 points several months ago, before Trump’s violent rallies.



Bernie Sanders hasn’t only  “destroyed “ Donald Trump by a wider margin since last December, he’s performed better against Trump in national polls since last October. I wrote a  piece  on October 21, 2015 titled  Bernie Sanders Defeats Trump By a Wider Margin Than Clinton in a General Election . From last October until today, Bernie Sanders has consistently outperformed Clinton in matchups against Donald Trump.



Also, nothing in the  Rolling Stone  piece endorsing Clinton mentions the ongoing FBI investigation.  The Christian Science Monitor  clearly states the nature of the FBI’s investigation, stating “The FBI is indeed conducting a criminal investigation into the possible mishandling of classified information on the private email server Clinton used for State Department communications.”



Yes, Hillary supporters, “The FBI is indeed conducting a criminal investigation.”



Like  The Christian Science Monitor ,  The Washington Post  has clearly stated the nature of the FBI’s investigation and in early March wrote that “The Justice Department has granted immunity to a former State Department staffer, who worked on Hillary Clinton’s private email server, as part of a criminal investigation into the possible mishandling of classified information, according to a senior law enforcement official.”



You’ve read the words correctly, and the FBI investigation is a “criminal investigation.”



Say it  again , “criminal investigation.”



Even the best defense of Clinton’s email fiasco, a piece by Ruth Marcus titled  Why Hillary Clinton is unlikely to be indicted over her private email server ,  states  “Lucky for her, political idiocy is not criminal.”



This too, makes for an interesting campaign slogan.



However, “political idiocy” is indeed criminal, when there’s intent and motive involved in the idiotic behavior. The example given my  Duke Law Journal  regarding intent and motive states “As far as the criminal law is concerned, Donny intended and attempted to kill a human being; his motive for doing so is simply not relevant.”



Hillary Clinton might have been motivated by  convenience , but she intended to circumvent government networks, and this intentional act resulted in  22 “Top Secret” emails  on a private server.



Furthermore, everyone knows that convenience wasn’t the only reason Clinton had the private server. In addition, the FBI isn’t spending over one year investigating with  100 agents  to give Hillary Clinton a parking ticket.



I explain in this  YouTube segment  why Hillary Clinton will likely face FBI indictments. I also state in a recent  CNN International  appearance with John Vause that Clinton indeed faces the possibility of indictment from the FBI investigation.



In addition to the political momentum favoring Bernie Sanders, Vermont’s Senator doesn’t have to worry about a cover-up. Like Watergate, Hillary Clinton’s political future rests upon the actions of others. A recent Reuters  article  describes the precarious state of Clinton’s campaign in a piece titled  Role of tech who set up Clinton’s server unknown to bosses at State :


 


 


Wisecarver and Swart, who had worked in the department for decades, were soon swapping emails expressing confusion and surprise that a political appointee, a so-called Schedule C employee who is more commonly hired to work in the secretary of state’s offices, should be joining the IT department’s ranks...



The department told Reuters that Pagliano and Kennedy had little contact, and that Kennedy was unaware of the server or his subordinate’s role in running it. Nor did Wisecarver, Pagliano’s day-to-day boss, or Swart know, according to the former colleague, who said the IT office should have been informed.


 


 


Like Watergate, it’s the cover-up that dooms politicians, not necessarily the original act linked to unethical behavior.



Bryan Pagliano is just one of many people involved with the FBI’s investigation. Future indictments are likely, considering the scope of the FBI’s investigation and the bewilderment of top intelligence officials. With recent wins, and future wins on the horizon, political momentum is clearly on the side of Vermont’s Senator. It’s not pragmatic or realistic to champion Clinton, knowing that Bernie Sanders defeats Trump by a wider margin, without an FBI investigation, and with the highest favorability ratings of any candidate in 2016. I explain in another interview on  CNN International  with John Vause that voters should choose Bernie Sanders, if indeed they fear Donald Trump.



Remember, Trump can’t ask Bernie Sanders for his Goldman Sachs speech transcripts during a televised debate. Clinton’s campaign can’t even stand being pointed at, so just imagine Trump explaining why he  donated to Clinton’s Senate campaigns  during a debate. Bernie is by far the superior candidate, and already matches up better against GOP rivals; without the myriad of issues faced by Clinton. For the country, and especially the Democratic Party, Hillary Clinton should concede the nomination to Bernie Sanders.

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/h-a-goodman/its-time-for-hillary-clin_b_9555422.html



Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    10 years ago

Sanders, whose won 5 of 6 contests, is now beating Hillary in national polling among democrats. 

 

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika   replied to  Sean Treacy   10 years ago

Actually he's won 6 of the last 7....Utah, Idaho, Alaska, Hawaii, Washington and the ex pat vote.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy  replied to  Kavika   10 years ago

Thank you for the correction. 

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika   replied to  Sean Treacy   10 years ago

Sean, Bernie took 69% of the vote to Clinton's 31 %.....9 delegates to 4 for Clinton.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6  replied to  Kavika   10 years ago

I think it is great but I am going to be pissed when the DNC screws him out of the nomination.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    10 years ago

Wait till CA comes in, The democrats ready to anoint Hillary will have a real problem....

She built an early lead on the backs of east coast democrats, I said, wait till we get to Bernie country. Laugh

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

The latest Los Angeles Times polling that is shown in Real Clear Politics has Clinton up 11 pts. , a figure that is in line with the previous polls over the past 6 months. 

You have been wrong so often about these things I think the better place for anyone to start would be to just assume the opposite of what you say and go from there. 

 

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

I'm wrong cause John says I'm wrong, that is a badge of honor.

RCP had Hillary leading in WA also, and Bernie won by 70%. (according to the pundits on the radio)

We have had all kinds of talking heads all over the radio yesterday and today trying to explain away that one.

Go figure.

BUT, according to John, not only am I wrong, all the liberal talking heads in the Puget Sound region are wrong also.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

  John only likes his own brand and sources of reality.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

I can't find any RCP poll about Washington state. Maybe you can point it out.

I know that prior to the voting last week the networks were predicting a Sanders win. 

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

Bernie is Killing it

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  96WS6   10 years ago

THANK YOU for that Link 96!

It shows that King County flipped for Bernie! (we do absentee ballots for everything here, so it takes some time to get them all counted, especially when they are not going the annointed's way)

100% of the state supports Bernie.

 

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell  replied to  96WS6   10 years ago

If you would like to show Washington state polling that showed Clinton was in the lead in Washington state as the election approached, please do. What the actual outcome on caucus day was  is not at issue here.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

I'm talking about RCP's state predictions which disappear once the caucus is over. They have no link to any direct polls because there isn't a newspaper in WA state that is affiliated with RCP. Hence they do not report polling in WA state.

Understanding this is key to understanding that RCP is not an unbiased reporter of political outcomes. Particularly on the democrat side.

AND, just the fact that they do away with their predictions after the vote is taken means you cannot go back on them for their errors in predicting.

The fact that the talking heads are all over it here in the state is telling. LA Times? using that as a basis for the entire state?

RCP was getting their info from local polls taken by the party limited to King County, which is the only county in the state that went for Hillary, but just barely.

So their predictions were a bit off.

The other thing it demonstrates is how your analysis relies on only one real source, RCP, which to you is the end all and be all, when in reality it is no better than any other media source. and leads to it's followers being afflicted by the political disease called "having blinders on"

Hillary is going to get the nomination, but not by the overwhelming majority she would like to claim or her supporters claim is the state of democrats in this nation. She has had to change her campaign spiel already in attempts to woo Bernie supporters.

What it really represents is many democrats do not believe that Hillary is the best choice for the nation.

A position I happen to agree with.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

AND, just the fact that they do away with their predictions after the vote is taken means you cannot go back on them for their errors in predicting.

 

I have no idea what you are talking about. Here is a small sample of RCP state polling that is on the site weeks after the primary voting took place.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

There is nothing inherently wrong or distasteful about you trying to pass yourself off as an election expert. There are a lot of self proclaimed experts. I just don't recall seeing you have real good results so far.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

Well you see here is a perfect example of arrogant opinion used as characterization.

I have never proclaimed my self as an "Expert" on elections, neither am I an "Expert" on polling.

Just more experience, and education on how it really works.

The first thing Dick taught me was in politics, THERE ARE NO EXPERTS! (the "experts" predicted that Carter would trounce Reagan, and we all saw how that turned out)

Something you need to learn.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

They have no link to any direct polls because there isn't a newspaper in WA state that is affiliated with RCP.

you musta missed this John.....

They leave the polls that are directly affiliated (they have permission for) up.

You would think that the Seattle Times would affiliate with RCP, but they don't. The TNT (Tacoma News Tribune) doesn't have the budget to do polling anymore.

Newspapers are dying in WA state. Hence RCP has a hard time getting local info they can use. So you don't find RCP polling on Washington for caucus votes.

You will when the general election gets here though, more people willing to spend more.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

Whatever.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

LMAO!  You just can't stand that your hand picked establishment crony is going to lose.   Face it John.  Times are changing.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell    10 years ago

Sean is suddenly a Bernie Sanders fan - rofl. 

 

I read the Los Angeles Times article that is being misused in the seeded article. Rather than hinting at possible indictments for Clinton as Sean would suggest, the article goes out of it's way to suggest that Clinton will not be indicted and did nothing illegal. 

This thread is a joke. 

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

I'm not suggesting anything. This is a piece by a progressive author. Although its amusing that you think the progressive author is "misusing" the LA Times piece by relying on the actual facts reported in the article, rather than the opinions of a Democratic donor the article cites in damage control mode.

Sure John, 147 FBI agents have spent almost a year working on a case against Clinton despite nothing to suggest that Clinton did something illegal. Keep running with that logic.  

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell  replied to  Sean Treacy   10 years ago

Did you read the LA Times article? I doubt it. 

Would you like me to quote the article where it says it is unlikely that Clinton will be indicted, and the legal experts they consulted who said what she did does not conform to breaking the law? 

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

Of course I read it. And I also looked to see who its "experts" are,  where the the LA Times bothered to identified them. Usually, it just made an unverifiable  b.s. statement like "experts say." No surprise, liberal media sources get opinions from liberals. The liberal expert the LA Times uses to insert opinions into a news story has no idea what evidence the FBI has. None.  

The media doesn't even pretend to be objective. The AP used an attorney who donated hundreds of thousands to Clinton and other democrats as it's "expert."  None of the donations are disclosed, of course. 

 In John's world, the FBI has just deployed more agents then were used to track down Dillinger and spent almost a year on a case where's there no absolutely no chance she committed a crime.  Obama's FBI is just engaged in  some vast right wing conspiracy to waste taxpayer dollars to make HRC look bad when she's obviously innocent.   

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell  replied to  Sean Treacy   10 years ago

LA Times : Federal Prosecutors "Have Begun The Process Of Setting Up Formal Interviews" With Clinton Aides Over Email Practices. A March 27 Los Angeles Times article reported that the federal prosecutors investigating former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton's private email server "have begun the process of setting up formal interviews with some of her longtime and closest aides." The article said the planned meetings "are also an indication that much of investigators' background work ... is nearing completion":

Federal prosecutors investigating the possible mishandling of classified materials on Hillary Clinton's private email server have begun the process of setting up formal interviews with some of her longtime and closest aides, according to two people familiar with the probe, an indication that the inquiry is moving into its final phases.

Those interviews and the final review of the case, however, could still take many weeks, all but guaranteeing that the investigation will continue to dog Clinton's presidential campaign through most, if not all, of the remaining presidential primaries.

No dates have been set for questioning the advisors, but a federal prosecutor in recent weeks has called their lawyers to alert them that he would soon be doing so, the sources said. Prosecutors also are expected to seek an interview with Clinton herself, though the timing remains unclear.

The interviews by FBI agents and prosecutors will play a significant role in helping them better understand whether Clinton or her aides knowingly or negligently discussed classified government secrets over a non-secure email system when she served as secretary of State.

The meetings also are an indication that much of the investigators' background work - recovering deleted emails, understanding how the server operated and determining whether it was breached - is nearing completion. [ Los Angeles Times , 3/27/16 ]

Media Use Report To Hype Clinton Wrongdoing

Fox's Andrew Napolitano: Clinton "Might Be A Criminal Defendant In A Felony Prosecution" For Her Email Setup. On the March 28 edition of Fox News' Fox & Friends , Fox senior judicial analyst Andrew Napolitano discussed the LA Times report, claiming that Clinton "could be prosecuted for failure to safeguard secrets" in her email, and asserting that she "might be a criminal defendant in a felony prosecution" for her email setup:

BRIAN KILMEADE (HOST): Federal prosecutors handling Hillary Clinton's email server investigation have started a new phase of the probe, setting up the formal interviews with some of her longtime and closest aides, and an interview with Hillary Clinton herself. So, what happens now? Here now to weigh in on this -- the guy's been all over this from day one -- Fox News senior judicial analyst, Judge Andrew Napolitano. Judge, what do you mean the interviews are just starting? They've been just accruing the background information to set them up on who they should be talking to one-on-one?

ANDREW NAPOLITANO: Precisely, Brian. The interview stage of people who are either potential targets, meaning they could have committed a crime and they might be prosecuted, or people with exceptional knowledge of the case who have not yet given anything voluntarily to the FBI is the last phase. There's 147 FBI agents that have been working on this for over a year. They have a mountain of evidence. They are now ready to test that evidence by asking questions of these aides around Hillary. There's about five of them and they are publicly known. They each have their own lawyers and they have to decide whether or not to go in. If they go in, they're not under oath. But it is very, very dangerous because if they mislead or lie to the FBI, that's a felony, the equivalent of perjury. And they can be prosecuted. And they do not know and their lawyers do not know what the FBI knows about them.

[...]

NAPOLITANO: Look, on Clinton's first day in office, Brian, she got a two-hour FBI tutorial which everybody gets who's entrusted with the government secrets. And among other things in the tutorial, she promised as a result at the end of the tutorial under oath that she would recognize secrets when she saw them and she had an absolute duty to safeguard secrets and she could be prosecuted for failure to safeguard secrets, even if that failure was negligent. The next day is when Brian Pagliano began the migration of the two email streams over to her server in Chappaqua. Did she tell that to the FBI? Of course not.

[...]

KILMEADE: When are we going to find out what's going to go on, if anything?

NAPOLITANO: The timing is very, very treacherous. I would think that Democrats need to know whether or not they're about to nominate somebody for president who might be a criminal defendant in a felony prosecution before November. [Fox News, Fox & Friends , 3/28/16 ]

MSNBC's Scarborough: "The Scale Of This Is So Remarkable." During a discussion of the Los Angeles Times report on the March 28 edition of MSNBC's Morning Joe , host Joe Scarborough referred to "the scale" of the investigation into Clinton's email arrangement as "so remarkable" and said, "I do not know how [FBI Director] James Comey doesn't do something definitive, election year or not":

MIKA BRZEZINSKI (CO-HOST): The Los Angeles Times reports this morning that the investigation into Hillary Clinton's email server is about to enter a new phase. The paper cites two sources familiar with the probe, who say that federal prosecutors have begun to step up formal interviews in the coming weeks with longtime Clinton aides.

[...]

JOE SCARBOROUGH (CO-HOST): The bar is reckless use of classified information,and I will tell you if an FBI agent took a classified document out and went and just left it in a coffee shop and then went back, you know, their career would be over. I can tell you also that if I had gone to an intel briefing and they had told me what happened, you know, in whatever program and then I went back to my office and I sent an email,as a congressman,out about the information that I learned in that intel briefing, they would be in my office in three hoursand would say,"Congressman, you need to get an attorney because that's illegal." And the scale of this is so remarkable. I do not know how [FBI Director] James Comey doesn't do something definitive, election year or not. [MSNBC, Morning Joe , 3/28/16 ]

Fox's Andrea Tantaros: "There Is A Strong Chance" Clinton Aides Will Go To Jail, "FBI Will Recommend Charges" Against Clinton, And "She Should Go To Jail." On the March 28 edition of Fox News' Outnumbered , co-host Andrea Tantaros commented on the LA Times article, saying "I think this is a big deal." Tantaros claimed "there is a strong chance that either of" Clinton's former aides "will go to prison," and that Clinton "should go to jail ... the FBI will recommend charges," but that they will not indict Clinton because "this entire administration is in on it":

LISA KENNEDY MONTGOMERY (CO-HOST): The federal probe into Hillary Clinton's email scandal could be moving into its final phase. A new report from the LA Times says federal prosecutors are beginning to set up formal interviews with some of Clinton's long-time aides. Those interviews will help the FBI and federal prosecutors find out if Clinton or her aides knowingly discussed classified government secrets over a nonsecure personal server when she served as secretary of state. The report says the Democratic presidential candidate could also be interviewed but no word when that would take place. So Howie, I have to ask, what do you think about this? Is it a formality bringing in some of her long-term aides or are they really on to something?

[...]

ANDREA TANTAROS (CO-HOST): Well I think as far as bringing in the aides I think this is a big deal. We know from the FOIAed emails that Cheryl Mills and Huma Abedin were colluding to suppress evidence. So FBI works, as everybody knows, they collect all the data, then they bring in the suspects, right? And then they ask them these questions. If Huma or if Cheryl Mills tries to lie to the FBI that is a felony, 10 years immediately. That is how they always get everybody. One hundred percent conviction rate. That's how they got Martha Stewart. All you have to do is lie. All you have to do is cover up. We know though that they've already acted together to collude that evidence. So I think there is strong chance that either of these two women will go to prison. Hillary Clinton I don't believe they will indict her. I think this entire administration is in on it. I think that she should go to jail but I do not believe that they will indict. I think the FBI will recommend charges. [Fox News, Outnumbered , 3/28/16 ]

LA Times Report Notes That Experts Say "Clinton Faces Little Risk Of Being Prosecuted"

LA Times : "Legal Experts Believe Clinton Faces Little Risk Of Being Prosecuted For Using The Private Email System." The March 27 Los Angeles Times report cited by Fox and MSNBC stated that "legal experts believe that Clinton faces little risk of being prosecuted for using the private email system to conduct official business." The Times reported that experts say that "using a private email system was not banned at the time, and others in government had used personal email to transact official business," and the article says the "chances she will be found criminally liable are low":

Many legal experts believe that Clinton faces little risk of being prosecuted for using the private email system to conduct official business when she served as secretary of State, though that decision has raised questions among some about her judgment. They noted that using a private email system was not banned at the time, and others in government had used personal email to transact official business.

The bigger question is whether she or her aides distributed classified material in email systems that fell outside of the department's secure classified system. But even if prosecutors determine that she did, chances she will be found criminally liable are low. U.S. law makes it a crime for someone to knowingly or willfully retain classified information, handle it in a grossly negligent manner or to pass it to someone not entitled to see it. [ Los Angeles Times , 3/27/16 ]

Plus, Legal Experts Say Elsewhere That Clinton Is Not Likely To Be Indicted Over Private Email Use

AP: "Several Legal Experts" Agree That "It's A Stretch" To Say That Clinton Could Be Indicted. In a March 22 article, the Associated Press reported that "several legal experts" said that "it's a stretch" to apply "laws that govern the handling of classified materials" to Clinton's email use, pointing out that Clinton's "communication of sensitive materials was with aides -- not a national enemy":

Asked earlier this month whether she'd be indicted over her use of a private email server as secretary of state, Hillary Clinton responded, "It's not going to happen."

Though Republicans characterized her response as hubris, several legal experts interviewed by The Associated Press agreed with the front-runner for the Democratic presidential nomination.

The relatively few laws that govern the handling of classified materials were generally written to cover spies, leakers and those who illegally retain such information, such as at home. Though the view is not unanimous, several lawyers who specialize in this area said it's a stretch to apply existing statutes to a former cabinet secretary whose communication of sensitive materials was with aides - not a national enemy. [Associated Press, 3/22/16 ]

Former Homeland Security Classification Expert: "There Is No Reason To Think Clinton Committed Any Crimes With Respect To The Use Of Her Email Server." In a March piece for The American Prospect , Richard Lempert -- a University of Michigan professor of law and sociology and a former Department of Homeland Security classification expert -- said that thus far there's "no reason to think that Clinton committed any crimes with respect to the use of her email server, including her handling of classified information":

Should Clinton be indicted?

Based on what has been revealed so far, there is no reason to think that Clinton committed any crimes with respect to the use of her email server, including her handling of classified information. While it is always possible that information not revealed will change this picture, at the moment Clinton's optimism that she will not be criminally charged appears justified. [ The American Prospect , March 2016 ; Media Matters , 3/21/16 ]

TPM's Josh Marshall: Experts Agree Clinton Indictment "Chatter Is Just Plain Ridiculous." In a February 1 article, Talking Points Memo editor Josh Marshall reported that law professors and former federal prosecutors have told him that the chances of an indictment are a "far-fetched" idea and that "on the possibility of an indictment, most of this chatter is just plain ridiculous -- a mix of ignorance and tendentiousness":

[A]s a legal matter, the chances of Hillary Clinton facing any kind of indictment are very, very low.

Start with the fact that as far as we know, she is not actually even being investigated for anything, let alone facing a looming indictment. The simple facts, as we know them, just don't put her in line for an indictment. The first reason is the facts, which rest heavily on intent and reckless negligence. The second is tradition and DOJ regulations which make professional prosecutors very leery of issuing indictments that might be perceived or in fact influence an election. This was my thinking. But as the press coverage has become increasingly heated, I started trying to figure out if there was something I was missing - some fact I didn't know, some blindspot in my perception. So I've spoken to a number of law profs and former federal prosecutors - based on the facts we know now even from the most aggressive reporting. Not like, is this theoretically possible? Not, what the penalties would be if it happened. But is an indictment at all likely or is this whole idea very far-fetched. To a person, very far-fetched .

So why the press coverage? I think it's a combination of reasons. The most irreducible and perhaps most significant is simply prestige reporter derp and general ignorance of the legal system. Second is journalists' perennial inability to resist a process story. And third, let's be honest, wingnut page views.

As I've said, the political calculus and potential political damage is a different matter altogether. There is little doubt that this whole on-going controversy, along with stuff in the background about the Clinton Foundation, have hurt Clinton badly on public estimations of her honesty and trustworthiness. But again, on the possibility of an indictment, most of this chatter is just plain ridiculous - a mix of ignorance and tendentiousness. [Talking Points Memo, 2/1/16 ]

Former House Judiciary Officials: "There Is Clearly No Evidence Of Any Kind Of Crime." In an August 23 column for USA Today , former counsels to the House Judiciary Committee Julian Epstein and Sam Sokol said there is "clearly no evidence of any kind of crime" committed by Clinton through the use of her private email server:

We've seen this movie before. And it always ends the exact same way.

Hyperventilating Republicans rush to the cameras claiming they've found the smoking gun proving their political opponents aren't just wrong, but that they're criminals. Traffic hungry reporters take "off the record" spin and run with it, publishing dramatic (and click-driving) stories predicting perp walks any day. Then months later, when the facts actually come out, there is far less to the story than meets the eye.

We saw it in its purest form during the Dan Burton Whitewater years and more recently with a string of supposed Obama Administration scandals from Fast and Furious to the IRS. Lois Lerner may have been guilty of bad management but, despite the calls of Republicans from both ends of Capitol Hill, she is most definitely not in jail.

And it is happening again right now with the overblown, misunderstood controversy regarding Hillary Clinton's decision to use a private email server during her service as secretary of State.

There are legitimate questions to be asked about that decision of course. Clinton herself has said she regrets it. And Republicans who want to argue it shows bad judgment certainly are entitled to do so.

But a bad decision is not a crime. Using a personal email server for State Department work during Secretary Clinton's tenure was not a crime; the statute requiring official email accounts for official business wasn't even passed until 2014.

And receiving or transmitting information that was not known to be classified at the time also was not a crime. This is true even if the information was mislabeled or misclassified. And reports that a larger number of emails are now under review don't change this -- the essential fact remains that there is no evidence that Secretary Clinton sent or received any email marked classified.

[...]

Republicans hoping to beat Hillary Clinton aren't going to be bailed out by some mythical criminal prosecution in a case where there is clearly no evidence of any kind of crime. [ USA Today , 8/23/15 ]

National Law Journal : "An Analysis Of Classified Information Laws Shows It Takes Intentional Disclosure To Get An Indictment." The National Law Journal 's Laurie Levenson noted in a September 21 piece that most criminal statutes involving classified information require "a knowing or intentional disclosure or mishandling" of the classified information, which does not apply in Clinton's case. Levenson further pointed out that "it is difficult to find prior cases where the unwise handling of classified information led to a federal indictment. For the last 20 years, the federal statutes have been used when there were intentional unauthorized disclosures":

Thus, in sorting out Hillary Clinton's actions, there are at least two critical questions: First, to what extent was using a private email server an "unauthorized" handling of classified information. Second, did Clinton ever knowingly mishandle classified information or act in a grossly negligent manner that led to information being lost, destroyed or stolen?

Politics aside, it is difficult to find prior cases where the unwise handling of classified information led to a federal indictment. For the last 20 years, the federal statutes have been used when there were intentional unauthorized disclosures. The Department of Justice appears to have gone after "leakers," but not bunglers. Twenty years ago, John Deutsch found himself in hot water and the target of a DOJ investigation for transferring classified materials to his government-owned computer at home -- a computer that he used to access a wide range of Internet searches. He was never charged; President Bill Clinton pardoned Deutsch on his last day as president. It remains to be seen what will happen in Hillary Clinton's case. [ National Law Journal , 9/21/15 ]

New Yorker 's Jeffrey Toobin on Clinton Emails: "This Is Not Now A Criminal Matter, And There Is No Realistic Possibility It Will Turn Into One." In an August 18 article, New Yorker staff writer and CNN senior legal analyst Jeffrey Toobin noted, "Criminal violations for mishandling classified information all have intent requirements" and there is "no evidence she" knew the information was classified and disclosed it on purpose to "an unauthorized person":

The consequences for Clinton, in the midst of a Presidential run, are far more likely to be political than legal. Criminal violations for mishandling classified information all have intent requirements; in other words, in order to be guilty of a crime, there must be evidence that Clinton knew that the information was classified and intentionally disclosed it to an unauthorized person. There is no evidence she did anything like that. This is not now a criminal matter, and there is no realistic possibility it will turn into one. [ The New Yorker , 8/18/15 ]

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

All of that is wrong John . Prove it isn't ...

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell  replied to  Sean Treacy   10 years ago

Criminal violations for mishandling classified information all have intent requirements; in other words, in order to be guilty of a crime, there must be evidence that Clinton knew that the information was classified and intentionally disclosed it to an unauthorized person. There is no evidence she did anything like that.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    10 years ago

It’s Time for Hillary Clinton to Concede the Democratic Nomination to Bernie Sanders

laughing dude Keep trying. It's a waste of your time and effort and will result in nothing, but what the fuck, everyone needs a hobby. Try building model boats instead. At least then you'll have something to show for your efforts when you are done.Laugh

 
 

Who is online



Dismayed Patriot


108 visitors