A Socio-Philosophic Question For You - 'Dog Eat Dog"
Do you believe in, or to put it another way, do you agree with, or yet another way, do you accept , the concept of "dog eat dog" as applied to the activities, intentions, necessities and inevitabilities of human life and existence ?
Go off in any direction you like as long as it relates to the question.

red rules
off topic comments are subject to removal at the discretion of the author of the article
'Dog Eat Dog' is, as I understand it, "the strong survive" , and those who are not strong are 'eaten'.
This was the popular understanding of Darwin's "survival of the fittest" , or Darwinism, and then was converted to Social Darwinism , which was the moral justification for laissez-faire or unfettered capitalism.
Ayn Rand called it enlightened or rational selfishness.
Libertarians fantasize about a dog eat dog world, where the weak are kamikazes from the 100th floor doing swan dives to the streets.
I think that "libertarians" and Randians and social darwinists should lay their cards on the table so to speak, and tell us what should happen to the losers in a dog eat dog world. We rarely see them do so.
"We rarely see them do so."
Have you met Dean and BadFish?
I believe if one dog wants to help another dog it should be his free will. I do not believe it is the job of government to steal one dogs bone and give it to another dog.
What if the dog swindled the other dog out of his bone and that's why he no longer has a bone?
take the bone back to it's rightful owner
No bones about it! :o)
Taking back the bone would probably require the Libertarian's favorite tool: guns.
This is why I say that the Libertarian philosophy is directionless and ultimately regressive. It depends on a very different mode of governing - trusting that society will just coagulate around your ideas of freedom, morality, and what direction to go in the future.
A citizen living on eight acres in rural BFE is not likely to have enough commonality with an urbanite to agree on anything.
The libertarian mindset sounds nice, but in reality it would be like taking one step forward and twenty steps backwards. The ensuing societal discord would eventually have to work itself out, right back into the same sort of government we have right now. That process could take decades to refine, and other countries will be flying by us while we flail around in our 'freedom'.
I believe if one dog wants to help another dog it should be his free will. I do not believe it is the job of government to steal one dogs bone and give it to another dog.
I believe that if one of the dogs has a bone and the other dog has no bone at all, it is the government's responsibility to take enough, just some, of the bone away from the dog with the bone and give it to the non-bone dog to avoid the non-bone dog starving to death. That way the dog with the bone is only missing a small part of the bone, while the non-bone dog gets to live so it can try to find other bones of it's own, that it can in turn give small amounts of that (or those) to other non-bone dogs, who the government will require to do the same, etc. Eventually all dogs will posses bones of their own with all of them missing a small piece, instead of just one or a very few dogs having complete bones, while the rest of the dogs starve to death. I believe that to be the American way.
Also if some full bone possessing dogs refuse to give up any part, even a small, tiny part of their bone, then it is the responsibility of the government to tax them for a piece of that bone for the good of all of the dogs, because in America there are not just two dogs.
There is no need for government to be a part of what should be natural.
However, without the government, the minority of people who own the bulk of the bones would not give up any pieces of them. Libertarianism isn't going to make them do it (at least not without forcing (taxing) them), because most people are not altruistic enough to share even a small part of their bones and the one that are don't consitutute nearly enough to take help all of the other starving dogs, because there are too many of them. Without government the bulk of them will hold on to all of their bones and let the rest of the dogs starve. That is what is natural in America and in many people's human nature. "I've got mine, so fuck you!" Sadly what you think is "natural", isn't.
Libertarianism, much like Communism, only works the way it's supposed to in small groups of good hearted people.
Also you stopped far too short on the example of liberal thinking to give it the proper meaning. You took it out of context. Here is what it said.
it is the government's responsibility to take enough, just some, of the bone away from the dog with the bone and give it to the non-bone dog to avoid the non-bone dog starving to death. And there is where you stopped, which does not complete the point I was making. You needed to continue with:That way the dog with the bone is only missing a small part of the bone, while the non-bone dog gets to live so it can try to find other bones of it's own, that it can in turn give small amounts of that (or those) to other non-bone dogs, who the government will require to do the same, etc. Eventually all dogs will posses bones of their own with all of them missing a small piece, instead of just one or a very few dogs having complete bones, while the rest of the dogs starve to death.
Without it's full context it means something completely different. See the difference in context?
If a person is a true libertarian, he will give to help his brother in need, he doesn't need someone to tell him or force him to do such..
Without the rational, the context, the rest of the paragraph, the amount you posted made no sense and did NOT represent liberal thinking in any manner at all as you claimed it did.
Also, in a perfect world, which is what you are claiming a Libertarian world would be, then everyone would help everyone. What you are saying is no different then what is preached from tens of thousands of pulpits around the world. However there are not now and never will be enough "true Libertarians" to help all of their brothers (and sisters and children) in need here in America or the rest of the world. The number of those who need a hand up is too great to depend on charity or the number of people who follow the Libertarian view or ever will. It may work with one person helping another, but when millions or "brothers" need help there has to be a mechanism in place to take the help and distribute it fairly and where truly needed. That mechanism is called a government.
If every person in the world followed the words of some religions or Libertarianism then governments wouldn't be needed at all, because everyone would share everything they have with everyone else (Pure Communism). Nor would armies or police or laws, etc., be needed. That is a simplistic view and one of the reasons why Libertarians will never succeed as a governing force or power. Both Pure Communism and Libertarianism only work in very small groups. Never at a governmental level. Both fail (as does a theocracy) to take the human element into account.
NM seems to have an almost religious faith in libertarianism.
The fact that a libertarian needs a "government" to ensure private property rights, and to ensure the sanctity of "contracts" shows us that there is something in human nature that requires societal regulation. Human beings are "fallen" , not elevated , creatures. If they were elevated we would live in a paradise or utopia.
The people form governments and societies to provide a sense of equality and justice and security. Government should be a good, which prevents and mitigates exploitation. We just haven't perfected it yet.
And we have perfect examples of why we do not explain ourselves.
The statements above are also perfect examples of a very sad view of life. A depressing view, and cynical one.
I am saying that everyone Should help everyone, no where claiming that they would. It is their choice to make. In Libertarian belief there is no perfect world.
By claiming that such is libertarian belief proves you do not understand and there is no need to go further.
And no John, Libertarianism is not a religion, although I'm sure you would like to categorize it as one as an easy mechanism to dispose of it as irrelevant.
But that also proves that you do not understand either in fact it goes one step further than Randy, any knowledge gained would be used to deliberately disparage.
I'm wise enough to take Mac's advice, I won't hazard my own house.
I'm done here.
This is unfruitful ground. But it was a shot in the dark, and shows all libertarians that there is still no point in sharing our beliefs with anyone that is unwilling to understand.
I'm sure no one minds that you would like to live your life as a "libertarian". Please do. I am sincerely glad it makes you happy. Just don't be too surprised if our actual government is forced by necessity to take shape in a different direction.
I agree. By all means if it makes you happy, then be a Libertarian. Just understand that it does not take into account many human desires and failures and humans will not be changing or having a libertarian government in our lifetime. What you are asking is the same thing many hippies sought in forming communes and farm collectives in the 1960s. How many are left? A few sure, but the bulk of them failed because the grew and when they grew they had to create a structure to make sure everyone was treated fair and did their fair share of work and contributed to the commune or collective in an equal manner. That meant they needed a form of a government. When they reached that point most of them collapsed under their own weight because a government wasn't what they signed up for, just like the phony Communism of the old Soviet System. It collapsed under it's own weight because it was destined to fail from the beginning because it failed to take into account the human element. The element of good yes, but also the elements of possessiveness and greed. In order for libertarianism to succeed, all people would have to be Christ like and they just are not and are not going to be.
I am quite sure there are different levels and different types of libertarians. That is one of the reasons I thought this might be a useful article. People can agree with "dog eat dog" , or disagree , or interpret, as they see fit.
Libertarianism taken to it's logical end would involve no government, because, "freedom" . But what seems to happen in reality is that libertarians pick and choose what level of and what intrusiveness they want from their government. To some libertarians, the only true function of government is to protect private property.
Why would anyone need government to protect private property? Because in a truly "free" society, private property does not , and cannot, exist. Without government sanctions, property is only "yours" to the extent you can defend it from someone else.
Why would you have to defend it? Because human beings are "fallen" creatures and will engage in "dog eat dog" behavior if not restrained.
The libertarian pitch is "take government off MY (Our) back".
The "socialist" pitch is "have government help me (Us). "
One pitch is that I need government to protect my personal property, and maybe my business interests, from "dog eat dog. "
The other pitch is that I (we) need government to protect us from being exploited by forces (dog eat dog) too large and powerful for us to handle on our own.
Both libertarians and socialist want government, they just want it for different reasons.
Since the vast majority of people , in America and elsewhere , have rejected libertarianism as the organizing basis for the society and the government, from where comes any justified criticism?
There are aspects of the libertarian view I adhere to, it is not a despicable philosophy, but I do think it is an impractical one.