╌>

Trump Says Things That He Thinks Conservatives Are Supposed To Say And It Is A Disaster For The Right

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  johnrussell  •  10 years ago  •  8 comments

Trump Says Things That He Thinks Conservatives Are Supposed To Say And It Is A Disaster For The Right

http://www.arcamax.com/politics/fromtheleft/michaelgerson/s-1814335

 He doesn't employ the careful words of a politician. He is so appealingly unprepared. So refreshingly ignorant. So disarmingly half-baked.

But the durability of Trump's appeal creates a conundrum for many Republicans. For decades, some of us have argued that the liberal stereotype of Republicans as extreme, dim and intolerant is inaccurate and unfair. But here is a candidate for president who fully embodies the liberal stereotype of Republicans -- who thinks this is the way a conservative should sound -- and has found support from a committed plurality of the party.

If the worst enemies of conservatism were to construct a Frankenstein figure that represents the worst elements of right-wing politics, Donald Trump would be it. But it is Republicans who are giving him life. And the damage is already deep.

Trump: The Liberal Stereotype of Republicans



Michael Gerson  on  Apr 1, 2016

WASHINGTON -- This campaign season has offered an unexpected form of reality television entertainment: Watching the light of discovery and calculation in Donald Trump's eyes when he is presented with difficult policy issues, apparently for the very first time.

Abortion is the current case in point. In the late 1990s, Trump supported the legality of partial-birth abortion. For a few hours on Wednesday, he endorsed criminal sanctions against women who have abortions.

On this issue, Trump has been to the left of Harry Reid (who voted for a partial-birth abortion ban) and to the right of Mike Huckabee (who has consistently rejected punishment for women who have had abortions). And Trump is utterly incapable of defending either position. He shows no capacity for ethical reasoning -- balancing claims about the moral and legal value of nascent life against claims about autonomy and choice.

If that seems harsh, let's go to the transcript of MSNBC's Chris Matthews trying to corner Trump on criminalization. Asked if this is the logical consequence of pro-life views (it isn't), Trump doesn't advance an argument about religion, morality and the role of law (other than to call attention to Matthews' Catholicism). At the outset, Trump observes that "people in certain parts of the Republican Party and conservative Republicans would say, 'Yes, they should be punished.'" Trump eventually embraces what he thinks a social conservative would say.

In fact, this is not the pro-life position. It is the left's stereotype of the pro-life position. "No pro-lifer would ever want to punish a woman who has chosen abortion," responded Jeanne Mancini, president of the March for Life. "This is against the very nature of what we are about. We invite a woman who has gone down this route to consider paths to healing, not punishment."

Trump ended up hurting the pro-life cause by reviving a stereotype of harshness. And it is part of a pattern.

In the immigration debate, the restrictionist side makes some serious arguments for prioritizing control of the border and for an immigration system that puts greater emphasis on skills. I generally don't find such arguments compelling, but they are worth debating.

Trump has not, however, made this case in any serious or systematic way. Instead, he has embraced an anti-immigrant caricature. Illegal immigrants, he says, are disproportionately "criminals" and "rapists." The Mexican government is purposely sending criminals across the border. When two Trump supporters beat up a homeless Hispanic man in Boston, Trump called them "passionate." He retweeted that Jeb Bush "has to like the Mexican illegals because of his wife."

When Trump eventually loses -- as he certainly will in the primaries, at the convention or the general election -- the movement to restrict immigration will be left as a stereotype of exclusion and bigotry.

Trump has had a similar, malignant influence on debates concerning the war against terrorism. There is no doubt that America and Europe face a heightened threat from returning Islamic State fighters, and from homegrown terrorists inspired by the Islamic State. Additional measures will be required -- in the Middle East and at home -- to pre-empt these threats.

But Trump has chosen to inhabit a cruel and counterproductive parody of toughness. He calls for banning all Muslim immigrants. He would conduct the war against terrorism with war crimes, such as killing the families of terrorists. He calls Syrian refugees fleeing violence the "ultimate Trojan horse." He entertains the possibility of using nuclear weapons against the Islamic State -- which would, of course, also kill everyone the Islamic State oppresses.

This stereotype of strength actively undermines the war against terrorism by alienating Muslim allies and cultivating mistrust in Muslim communities.

For many of Trump's supporters, this extreme and unpredictable use of language is part of the appeal. 



Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    10 years ago

Excellent analysis. Trump has, on numerous issues, said what he thinks right wing Republicans want him to say, and as we know much of it is buffoonish and ignorant. He thinks the way to appeal to Republican voters is to take simplistic, cruel, harsh positions on many issues. The disastrous thing for the GOP ,when they attempt to appeal outside their base, is that Trump's appeal to the right is working. 

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    10 years ago

My take on Trump is slightly different. Trump intends to run the country as he runs his business i.e. he will do as he pleases, when he sees fit to do so, as the opportunity arises. Basically, he would be a dictator. (it's not clear to me whether and to what extent he can he can be president and corporate CEO at the same time) Anyway, in becoming dictator, he's selling attitude not detailed plans and he makes the whole thing up as he goes along. His opinion on abortion is largely irrelevant because, as president, he can't do a single thing to possibly affect it other than appoint a pro-life Supreme Court justice . . . who, if confirmed, may never have an opportunity to reverse Roe vs Wade. He doesn't give a rat's ass about abortion and it shows. On illegal immigration he's right in saying that illegal aliens should be deported. It doesn't matter to me whether they're rapists and murderers (which I'm sure most are not) or harmless computer geeks . . . if they jumped the fence to get in, then they should be escorted back out to wait their turn like everybody else. This appeals to many people, partisan and non-partisan alike. His anti-Muslim rant is more troublesome and could create problems at home and abroad. However, he is really just appealing to the common sense notion that, if you don't know which snakes are poisonous, then don't let any of them in until you find out which is which. What his followers hear from the media and Democrats is "see if the snake bites before judging it." That doesn't give people confidence that their safety is the paramount concern. His statement that he would use nuclear weapons was really just a statement that he won't take any option off the table no matter how stupid it is and even though nobody seriously thinks that even he is stupid enough to drop a nuclear bomb on anybody.

Trump's shine may dull as people realize that he's not particularly wedded to a thing he says but he's basically selling the idea that Americans come first. That message is going to be hard to beat.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell  replied to  1ofmany   10 years ago

The Presidency is always relevant in terms of what the occupier of the office thinks. A president who opposes punishing women who have abortions could veto potential congressional legislation that attempts to implement such punishments. etc. The presidency and executive branch is a third of the entire government and is in the middle of everything that happens. 

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    10 years ago

The Presidency is always relevant in terms of what the occupier of the office thinks. A president who opposes punishing women who have abortions could veto potential congressional legislation that attempts to implement such punishments. etc.

Theoretically relevant but practically irrelevant. The pro-life side has no such view to materialize in legislation to then be subject to a veto.  

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell  replied to  1ofmany   10 years ago

Trump is the most ignorant major party candidate in anyone's memory. 

He is the most disliked candidate in anyone's memory. 

He has less than 40% of the vote from a small portion of the American people. There is no "mandate" for a Trump presidency, even among Republicans. 

Even discussing him as if he should be a credible candidate is a tough sell. 

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

Trump is the most ignorant major party candidate in anyone's memory . . .

Yep, he is. I heard a wrestler once say that the thing that frightens him most about the crowd is that they can reproduce and that they can vote. Trump is clearly going after that crowd and they like him. If he were not rich, he could be poor white trash . . . maybe he's a new category of rich white trash.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    10 years ago

There's some merit to this, as there is with any politician.  But it's grossly oversimplified. Certainly his "wall" statement gave him credibility  with  conservatives that he would never otherwise have, given his long term identification and donations to the democratic party. No doubt his abortion statement was probably an attempt to pander as well, because no believes he's actually pro-life given his history on the subject before he declared for the Presidency. 

But he also says a lot  of things that are directly oppositional to the stereotypes of what conservatives think. He's farther to the left than Hillary Clinton in his support of nationalized health care. He supports a pathway to citizenship for illegals. He's been effusive in his praise of Planned Parenthood.  He condemned Scalia and stated his support for affirmative action. In the one debate, Cruz and Rubio shredded him for his lack of  conservative principles and it really didn't effect his support. He still gets a 1/3 or so share of voters in Republican primaries. 

Because his supporters don't support him as a  conservative. He does best in open primaries where he can obtain support from democrats and independents. His supporters simply don't care whether he's Conservative or his ideology. It's more of a personality cult.  They support him because he's the candidate whose entire candidacy is a giant FU to the establishment and the state of the country. It's that simple. 

 
 

Who is online

afrayedknot
Nerm_L


82 visitors