╌>

Money for Obama’s nuclear upgrades better spent on conventional weapons

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  flynavy1  •  10 years ago  •  38 comments

Money for Obama’s nuclear upgrades better spent on conventional weapons

As they prepare to leave office, presidents often seek to do something about nuclear weapons. President Bill Clinton tried to ratify the Comprehensive Nuclear Test Ban Treaty, only to be blocked by a Republican Congress. President Ronald Reagan negotiated a treaty with the Soviet Union banning intermediate-range nuclear forces, and dreamed of doing away with nuclear weapons altogether.

President Barack Obama entered office concerned about the dangers posed by nuclear weapons. In his April 2009 Prague speech, Obama pledged “to seek the peace and security of a world without nuclear weapons.” His initial efforts produced a stabilizing arms-control treaty with Russia and a series of international summits that made modest progress in securing nuclear material. Since then, however, the effort to control the world’s most dangerous weapons has stagnated.

 

Without progress this year, Obama could leave his successor an ambiguous and unsustainable nuclear policy. Lack of progress also makes it far more difficult for Washington to provide effective leadership at the president’s fourth Nuclear Security Summit in Washington on Thursday and Friday.

In the past few years, the United States has begun a vast effort to modernize its nuclear arsenal. Nearly every piece of the nuclear triad — submarines, aircraft and land-based missiles — is reaching the end of its service life and must be retired, replaced or refurbished. The military services, bound by the president’s nuclear guidance, are planning to rebuild the triad piece by piece, an effort that could raise the cost of nuclear deterrence to as much as $1 trillion over the next 30 years. Many consider that figure untenable.

Rather than tackle the problem, the president’s last budget, released in February, stays the course by adding more than $1.5 billion in new funding for major nuclear acquisitions programs. The Pentagon is “wondering how the heck we’re going to pay for” the rebuilding program, Deputy Undersecretary of Defense for Policy Brian McKeon recently told a reporter , “and probably thanking our stars we won’t be here to have to answer the question.”

Yet, Congress has placed limits on defense spending, even as the Pentagon is starting other large programs to acquire conventional weapons that the services say they need. Every dollar spent on nuclear weapons endangers one that could be invested in more useful military capabilities or in vital domestic spending priorities. Because Congress is unlikely to provide full funding, the nation’s next nuclear arsenal could be shaped by partisan infighting rather than by prudent strategy.

In any case, pressing ahead with the current nuclear modernization plans is unnecessary and unsustainable. Only the president can ensure that the next nuclear arsenal is strategically rational and fiscally prudent.

 

Obama can still take steps to ensure that his Prague agenda endures and that the next president has the flexibility and data necessary to make the hard choices of paring back the modernization plans.

First, Obama should have the Pentagon conduct a comprehensive study on the expected costs of nuclear modernization that could be ready for the next president on day one.

Second, he should alter guidance that forces the military to replicate the current arsenal piece for piece.

Third, before leaving office, Obama should cancel — or at least pause — programs that are getting to the point where it will be difficult to call them off because of too much money spent and too many contracts signed. The new air-launched cruise missile, for example, is a slower and riskier way of threatening targets that can be struck by ballistic missiles. The Minuteman intercontinental ballistic missile does not need to be replaced with a new equivalent missile.

In addition, cancelling a program to refurbish 180 tactical nuclear bombs stationed in Europe could save $28.8 billion — too much money for too little deterrence.

Instead of varying the number of ballistic-missile submarines from 14 to 12 to 10 and back up to 12, as planned, the next administration should order that the submarine fleet be immediately reduced to 10 — and kept there. It should also vigorously pursue a new arms-control agreement with Russia to limit the most dangerous elements of their modernization plans.

Each of these steps could save between $20 billion to $30 billion over the next 25 years. The savings could be used to fund more useful military capabilities. Cutting just one of these systems, for example, could cover the recently quadrupled program to fortify deterrence in Europe against an aggressive Russia for the better part of a decade. Alternatively, it could provide major funding for education, poverty relief or scientific research here at home.

 

Obama’s last chance to reduce the role of nuclear weapons — and provide the necessary leadership for encouraging nuclear security around the globe — is likely also his best. He could ensure that the country remains on the long path to a world without nuclear weapons rather than sliding headlong into a new arms race.

http://blogs.reuters.com/great-debate/2016/03/30/money-for-obamas-nuclear-upgrades-better-spent-on-conventional-weapons/


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  FLYNAVY1    10 years ago

I think the days of the Nuclear Triad are behind us.  Bases with nuke armed bombers, and silos with ICBMs make for targets within the United States.  Stop making our cities and citizens targets of collateral damage from fallout because of their proximity to these nuclear sites.  ICBM submarines offer the most secure way to maintain our nuclear deterrence.  I'm not being biased here being ex-Navy, I just know that it is a bitch for our potential adversaries to find and track these submarines.  Land based targets are just that, .....targets.

My recommendations:

  • Kill what should have been killed long ago in the F-35 program.
  • Design and build a replacement for the B-52 "Bomb Truck" with focus on conventional ordinance.
  • Maintain the Minuteman ICBMs to the end of their service life, but do not replace them.
  • Replace the Ohio class ICBM submarines with possibly up to 16 subs.  Eight out on station, 4 on workups, and 4 undergoing repair/overhaul/replacement during their 40 year lifecycle.
  • Please, please, please, go back to building cheaper air superiority fighter aircraft with, range, decent weapons payloads, and performance that will give our pilots a chance to win in a knife-fight, and get back home.

This is just a start. 

 

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    10 years ago

Design and build a replacement for the B-52 "Bomb Truck" with focus on conventional ordinance.

The B1 was supposed to do that, but nothing has been able to replace the B52. My suggestion is to maintain the main characteristics and design of the B52, but just build new ones that are as close a possible to the old ones we are flying today. In effect, just build more of them.

Maintain the Minuteman ICBMs to the end of their service life, but do not replace them.

I disagree completely. ICBM is silos are targets in a sense, but most of the silos themselves scattered widely in corn and sunflower fields in no particular order or formation. They are not good targets anyway because in a full exchange the Russians are going to hit major cites and military bases themselves and not ICBM silos because they know that the missiles will already be on there way at them, so why waste bombs blowing up something that's not there anymore. Underground Minuteman silos are still a very much needed part of our nuclear response to an attack and will be for the foreseeable future.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  FLYNAVY1  replied to  Randy   10 years ago

They are not good targets anyway because in a full exchange the Russians are going to hit major cites and military bases themselves and not ICBM silos because they know that the missiles will already be on there way at them, so why waste bombs blowing up something that's not there anymore.

We have managed to dodge WWIII/full exchange scenario to date.  What about the chances of an accidental launch.  Or something goes off by our own mistakes.  We have had several incidents (Titan II for examples) where there were nuclear weapons involved in fires, crashes, and explosions where the potential for a full thermonuclear explosion was real.

Minimize the risk to our people..... put the nukes on subs, and sub tenders. 

 

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient  replied to  FLYNAVY1   10 years ago

...and watch the movie "War Games".

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  Buzz of the Orient   10 years ago

...and watch the movie "War Games".

That's not how it really happens. The movie is just a movie and so far from what it actually takes to launch a Minuteman that it is laughable. What happened in the Movie is not even close to what needs to happen in the real world and it would be impossible for a launch to happen that way. Completely impossible.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient  replied to  Randy   10 years ago

You can't possibly believe I was being serious....

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  FLYNAVY1   10 years ago

 What about the chances of an accidental launch.

Slim to none. yes there have been incidents but nowhere near or even close to an accidental launch. Not even 10 or 15 safety steps away. It's simply not going to happen. Way to much has to happen and way too many personal have to agree from several bases in an exact sequence that it is just not going to happen. The fail safe on the Minuteman program are as good of better then ICBMs are handled in a submarine. The chances of an accidental launch are so small they are hardly worth mentioning. And the risk is no better or worse on a sub then it is in an underground silo.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  Randy   10 years ago

We have had several incidents (Titan II for examples) where there were nuclear weapons involved in fires, crashes, and explosions where the potential for a full thermonuclear explosion was real.

The Titan program has long since been retired. It was inferior.The safety of the Minuteman program is impeccable. Comparing the two programs and missiles would be like comparing a Yugo to a Ferrari.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  FLYNAVY1  replied to  Randy   10 years ago

The question remains Randy.  Why have a high value target in the middle of the US when you really don't need to have it?  Why give the enemy a reason to target the center of the US?

Not that they aren't going to target our cities anyway, but why give them military targets that they have known coordinates for?  It makes no sense to me.

A potential adversary, knowing that they can't avoid a retaliatory strike from submarines makes for the best deterrence.  Then we go full circle to MAD.... why start something that you know you will exterminate yourself with at the same time? 

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  FLYNAVY1   10 years ago

Why have a high value target in the middle of the US when you really don't need to have it?  Why give the enemy a reason to target the center of the US?

Again, the Minuteman ICBM missile silos are not a high value nuclear target because the Russians are going to know that we already launched them all as soon as theirs were detected heading our way and all their nukes would be destroying would be empty silos and corn and wheat fields. There is nothing around the silos but farms and a few very small towns and those are not high value targets. Unless of course they're your farms, crops and tiny towns. You really need to go out looking for the individual silos to truly appreciate how wide spread and isolated they are. I mean it's not like they're bunched together. They are miles and miles apart from each other. I went to nearly every one that was attached to the old 321st SMW and they stretched from a far as down near Fargo to the Canadian border and at least 100 miles into North Dakota away from the base and without the classified maps were a bitch to find. They have nothing around them. They are out in the middle of nowhere in fields and once empty, useless.

The silos are an extremely low value target. Why would they waste weapons on empty holes in the ground? Unless destroying corn and wheat farms was their goal. The Minuteman missiles would be long, long gone before their missiles got to the silos and they are smart enough to know that and not waste their weapons trying to destroy some things that they know are not even there any longer.

The only thing the enemy is going to target in middle America are going to be major cites and various military installations that are there anyway for reasons that have nothing to do with ICBM underground silos.

A potential adversary, knowing that they can't avoid a retaliatory strike from submarines makes for the best deterrence.

A potential adversary also knows they can not avoid a retaliatory strike from underground ICBM Minuteman Missiles, because they be launched long before the first enemy weapon comes close to hitting us. And they won't be bothering to aim at the empty holes in the ground where the missiles were and that they know are not there anymore because they are already on their radar coming into Russian airspace. They are every bit as equally good deterrence as a sub.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  FLYNAVY1  replied to  Randy   10 years ago

And a decapitation strike launched by submarine at Washington DC?   What three, three and a half minute warning?  I'm not sure what the current protocol is if there is no one in DC to issue the launch codes.

I know the subs cannot launch without permission.  There has to be command authorization that electronically unlocks the missiles.  Personnel on the subs cannot launch independently.  I think our land based ICBMs are locked in the same way. 

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  FLYNAVY1   10 years ago

An attack on Washington killing the President and even the joint Chiefs would not stop the launch of silo based ICBMs in a matter of 10 minutes or less. Far less time then needed for the Russians to take them out. The only way they wouldn't be empty holes when they dropped Nukes on them would be if they were each, individually, sabotaged in their silos before hand.

I will not discuss how it would happen if there was an attack that destroyed Washington or what would happen if the President was killed because I had a Top Secret security clearance and as unlikely as it is as far as I know the procedure may still be in place at the ICBM bases we have left. I am sure you understand.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  FLYNAVY1  replied to  Randy   10 years ago

I believe that we are talking something along the lines of "Dead Hand".  

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  FLYNAVY1   10 years ago

I am not comfortable discussing any of this in anymore detail then I already have. So let's just say that based on what I know I believe silo launched ICBMs still very much have a place in our nuclear force and will have into the future and agree to disagree beyond that.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  Randy   10 years ago

Though I do think that for conventional bombers that can still carry nuclear weapons the original B52 design has never been beat. Let's build more of them. New ones with the same design, but with updated Avionics, communications, engines and perhaps a lighter, but stronger skin. To start with. The ones we have ow have proven to be fantastic aircraft, so why fix what is not broken. The only real problem with the B52 is that the average crew is flying in a bomber older then they are. Let's change that. Plus it would be more cost effective to not have to reinvent the wheel, so to speak.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  FLYNAVY1  replied to  Randy   10 years ago

Yep... need a conventional "Bomb Truck" to replace the B-52, or just modernize the design.  By the time the Pentagon gets done with it, it will cost more than a dysfunctional F-35.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  FLYNAVY1   10 years ago

I support modernizing the design. If we start from the ground up on a new bomber were going to go way over budget and pay way to much for a new bomber that can't beat out a 40 year old B52.

Boeing is still going to screw the government for a new version of the B52, but maybe not as bad as they will for a whole new aircraft design.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  FLYNAVY1  replied to  Randy   10 years ago

Boeing has nothing on Lockheed when it comes to screwing the Pentagon on the price of military hardware.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  Randy   10 years ago

Though I have to confess a prejudice for the B52 ever since I saw the first one take off up close and especially the first time I watched one land in a high crosswind. Incredible that the whole aircraft looks like it's coming in sideways for certain crash, but wheels are straight down the runway. In my spare time a spent a lot of time sitting parked just across US2 that ran right across the fight path for the runway at Grand Forks, just watching them. And the size of it! Man!

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  FLYNAVY1   10 years ago

Not so much the pentagon, it's all those aircraft companies that promise what they cannot produce. And then spend billions trying to make it.

The B-52's can use some upgrading for sure, there isn't another aircraft in the world that can do what it does.

The current ones we have now are only about 32% or so original as built, only the basic airframe. On most even the main wing spars have been replaced already. They have all been reskinned at least twice some of them three times.

Some of the pilots are flying planes their grandfathers flew.

At this point there really isn't much you can do to upgrade them, and without a serious leap forward in aviation technology, they really can't be improved.

All that said, I say we should build another 300 or so.

It might be old, and shake rattle and roll, but it's rocking on.....

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

All that said, I say we should build another 300 or so.

I'll 2nd that! No one yet has come up with a bomber that is it's equal or even close.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  FLYNAVY1  replied to  Randy   10 years ago

Put me down as a third.  Now we just need to convince the Air Force that this is the way to go on their "new bomber| project.  Watch us get something about 3/4 of the cost of a B-2 per copy with half the payload.

Current price of a B-52 should be somewhere around $70 million a copy.  Of course by the time congress gets done with it, they will be $200-million a copy. 

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  FLYNAVY1   10 years ago

Every Senator and congressman will be demanding that part of it be built where they are or they'll vote no on it. They'll even fight over who gets the contract to paint them and it'll be the highest bidder. The bombers will assembled in one state, with parts from at least 30 different states and then be partially dis-assembled to be moved two states over to be painted. Then moved back to be re-assembled again.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    10 years ago

We do not have a high value target in the middle of the US because of ICBM silos because there would be Air Force bases where they are if they also had Missile Wing attached to them or not because they all have other purposes too, like B52 Wings or Air refueling Wing or Fighter Wings. Also, as I said, the missiles and silos are of no target use because the Russians would know we already launched them, making them a no value target. In order not have any high value targets in the middle of the US we would have to shut down every military base, including every Marine and Army base there (including NORAD) and evacuate every major city in the middle of the US.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    10 years ago

Here's a book everyone should read before offering up opinions on what direction to take in the future of nuclear arms.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  FLYNAVY1  replied to  Hal A. Lujah   10 years ago

Read it twice now Hal...... thanks to your recommendation years ago!  Quite informative.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  FLYNAVY1  replied to  Hal A. Lujah   10 years ago

Read it twice now Hal...... thanks to your recommendation years ago!  Quite informative.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  Hal A. Lujah   10 years ago

Read that quite a while back, it's a good read, if your into such subjects.

I love the way they did the cover, makes it look like a government military tech manual.

Want to eliminate nuclear weapons? Develop a counter weapon that destroys their effectiveness at the job they do. They will go away on their own based upon the costs. No angst needed.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  FLYNAVY1  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

The best counters we have are the advanced Patriot, and the RIM-161 SM3.   While they have the ability to shoot down at 100% rates, they have to be used during the boost stage, and cannot handle a saturation launch.  Given the boost stage requirement, their launchers (with the RIM-161 on Aegis ships) have to be in pretty close proximity of the country launching the ICBMs making themhigh on the list of preemptive  targets for sure.

What was the movie line.... "the only way to win is not to play." 

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  FLYNAVY1   10 years ago

Yeah Wargames...

The WOPR (pronounced Whopper) says.....

"Strange Game, the only way to win is not to play, Wanna play a game of chess?"

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  FLYNAVY1   10 years ago

On the missiles, you have a 90 second window from detection to launch for 100% destruction. Patriot was only 60% and that was against Scuds not ICBM's. Of course Patriot has been greatly improved since those days. Particularly in detection integration. (satellite detection not being communicated to the missile battery fast enough (if at all) and slow acquisition by radar and snail paced tracking computers) But it proved the concept was sound and effective, 60% in an actual use environment first time out the gate is outstanding. They are trying to widen that detection/acquisition/tracking computing window issue all the time.

Beyond that, the percentage of success starts dropping until the ICBM's reach perihelion, and warhead sep takes place, interception in the re-entry phase is virtually impossible. We have the tech capability to destroy such warheads that isn't the problem, it's finding and tracking them that is.

Once a warhead separates/dispenses from the missile body there is no recovery. AOL showed promise, but like everything concerning optics range and tracking are still major hurdles.

And then there is the issue of our enemies, lets say we are capable of destroying all their missiles in flight? it would be useless to launch them wouldn't it?

Quite the contrary. There would be a huge desire to use it before you lose it. Probably not the two other legs of the big three with ICBM capability, but the lesser lights. Any strategic power they gain from ICBM's would go right out the window overnight.

THAT is the real danger of N Korea having ICBM's.

 

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    10 years ago

Y'all should watch this movie.

By Dawn's Early Light.

Once Nuclear war is turned on it is very difficult to turn off.

The issue is should we even have them in the first place. WE have to have them cause the other side has them. and there is no more efficient system of delivery to the other side of the planet than an ICBM. What will make an ICBM worthless is a missile defense system 100% capable of destroying one (or a couple of dozen) in flight.

That my friends will never happen, not given the state of current tech. Submarines are a more survivable delivery system for nuclear weapons, and make for a much smaller harder to destroy missile.

Out of the nuclear triad, Bombers are the weak link. Air defenses have reached the point that penetration of an enemy's airspace is pretty much a suicide mission. Stealth or not. This is why they developed standoff weapons. But do they really need to be delivered by aircraft? and Aircraft take hours to get into launch positions. (by the time they reach their IP the base they took off from with be ashes)

Nuclear weapons are the sledgehammer in the weapons toolbox, the tool that destroys everything and cannot be stopped. Using them is suicide for everyone.

WE (read everyone) have known this for years. Decades in fact.

Outside of needed maintenance, why waste billions on improving a weapon that has already reached the peak of it's development?

Nuclear weapons will quickly disappear once someone develops a completely successful defense to them. One in which any application of the weapon is prevented. It is technically possible, it just hasn't happened yet. The right mix of science and engineering has not been struck upon yet. Once that happens they will become too expensive to maintain and have no practical use.

That is when they will finally be eliminated.

But not until.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  FLYNAVY1  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

Saw the movie recently..... always good.  

Your points are all spot on target as well.  We must be reading much of the same materials.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  FLYNAVY1    10 years ago

Let me toss in another point here.....

Is there a use for tactical nukes that don't escalate into a full thermonuclear exchange, and if so, at what yield?

My aircraft was capable of launching a 15Kt depth charge if you will.  The hydrodynamic force from one was quite capable of knocking out a submarine at over......(xxxx) miles.  They were to be used when you absolutely...had to... without fail.... kill an enemy sub.  

If one of those were used, do we launch the kitchen sink in retaliation?

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  FLYNAVY1   10 years ago

Hard to say in that scenario, The Russian commander in Cuba had the authorization to use tactical nukes against any ground forces that landed. (probably wouldn't have until the second armored was coming ashore) But then again that is the only time such orders were given, and we were into full WWIII mode at that point.

I would say no, not worth a full nuclear exchange. but as we all know, war is opening the gates of hell, and all manner of destruction is unleashed. what ever manner is needed to get the job done in the most efficient manner possible.

I would not, but I'm sure others would.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  FLYNAVY1  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

I would not, but I'm sure others would.

I'm with you, there are the minds that would lean towards "Use them or lose them".  North Korea might be in that boat.  I can't say Israel wouldn't use them either.  

 
 

Who is online

Nerm_L
afrayedknot


86 visitors