The Clinton Myth
From Counterpunch
by Andrew Levine
Republicans are known for forming opinions “unencumbered by the thought process,” as Tom and Ray, the Car Guys, used to say. They have problems with facts too.
Democrats are supposed to be better at such things, but many, maybe most, of them have a similar problem. How else to account for the widespread belief that while Hillary Clinton may be unappealing, inauthentic, untrustworthy, uninspiring, and more “moderate” than the average Democratic voter, at least she knows how to get things done?
Like what? Examples please! She bungled health care reform so thoroughly in the early nineties that, for the next two decades, appalling numbers of Americans remained uninsured or underinsured.
Obamacare fixed some of that, but it also further entrenched the power of private insurance companies, for-profit health care providers, and, worst of all, Big Pharma. A lot of the blame for these “revolting developments” goes back to Hillary’s machinations a generation ago.
Her tenure at the State Department was more disastrous still. No doubt, Obama had his reasons for making her his Secretary of State, but what was he thinking!
All she knew of world affairs was what she picked up as an official wife and as a lackluster Senator. Unlike, say, Sarah Palin, she could name of a lot of world leaders, and she could probably have picked many of them out of a lineup. She could also call upon the services of what remained of her husband’s far from stellar foreign policy team. But that was about it.
The transition from Condoleezza Rice to Hillary was, all things considered, a step down. American foreign policy remained about the same, but at least Rice had no time for “humanitarian interveners” of the Samantha Power type.
Hillary got her feet wet encouraging the bloody 2009 coup in Honduras, and, from her first days at Foggy Bottom, she was busy sowing seeds of mischief in far away places. Thankfully, though, when it came to exercising her “responsibility to protect,” she took her time getting up to speed. When she finally did, the Queen of Chaos messed up royally.
The disaster in Libya isn’t entirely on her, but it would be fair to say that the harm she did outweighs the harm done by other high officials in the American government, including the President, whom she more or less bullied into letting the war proceed.
She botched every other American intervention into the unfolding Arab Spring as well. The results are evident now in Egypt and Yemen and throughout the Gulf. All that pales in comparison, however, with the changes she helped set in motion in Syria and Iraq.
The refugee crisis in Europe, a direct consequence of Western intervention into the Syrian Civil War, isn’t entirely her fault either, nor are the terror attacks currently afflicting European countries that have joined the United States as co-belligerents in the Bush-Obama wars.
However, her clueless blundering contributed mightily to both of those on-going disasters. The buck never did stop with her, but it would be fair to say that, for all that, and for the resulting strain on the European Union itself, her responsibility is nearly as great as Barack Obama’s.
Her passion for provoking Russia makes her more dangerous still. People who worry about Donald Trump’s little fingers on the buttons that could unleash a nuclear holocaust have reason to worry about her fingers too. Hillary relishes sending others out to fight the empire’s wars; and where Obama is at least hesitant, she is gung ho. On the Russia Question, Trump seems by far the more rational of the two.
Then there is China. Trump just says he wants to negotiate better trade deals; OK, if he gets a chance, which he won’t, let him knock himself out. Hillary, on the other hand, was one of the authors of the “pivot” towards Asia. In other words, she wants to provoke the Chinese too. At a time when wars with nuclear powers can end life on earth “as we know it,” as they say in Clintonese, this is no small consideration.
It is far from clear how Sanders would deal with Russia and China or the Middle East or anywhere else. But he seems to be a levelheaded and thoughtful person whose testosterone levels are under control. This puts him way ahead of Hillary.
As has been pointed out countless times by supporters and critics alike, his foreign policy views fall within the normal range for “progressive” Democrats. But, unlike Hillary, he is a J-Street, not an AIPAC, type of guy; and neoconservative and liberal imperialist ideologies leave him cold. The contrast is not, by any means, all that it should be, but it is not insignificant.
And yet, according to more than a few well-meaning liberals, Sanders is selling dreams that he cannot realize, while Hillary is a “pragmatist” who knows her way around, and who can make at least some of those dreams come true. “You can’t fool all of the people all of the time,” but you sure can befuddle a lot of liberals.
How did the myth of Hillary’s competence come about and why does it remain resilient in the face of overwhelming evidence to the contrary? Future historians will have a lot to ponder. All that we can say for sure now is that the explanation is emphatically not that she actually is competent.
http://www.counterpunch.org/2016/04/01/the-clinton-myth-and-the-strange-case-of-donald-trump/

Hmmmm.....another view from the vast Leftwing conspiracy.
..another view from the vast Leftwing conspiracy.
Counterpunch is even well beyond that...its a source of so many really, really nutty conspiracy theories from the most extremist hate mongers on the very furthest fringes of the far left . . .
Caveat emptor!!!
(And, not surprisingly...many on the crazier extremist fringes on the far right also find Counterpunch's dissing of Democratic progressives to be appealing as well...)
While it's true that Indy Left sights like Counterpunch, Truthdig and Common Dreams don't hold their punches when it comes to democrats, they tend to be nice to the very very very few democrat progressives that still exist.
While it's true that Indy Left sights like Counterpunch, Truthdig and Common Dreams don't hold their punches when it comes to democrats, they tend to be nice to the very very very few democrat progressives that still exist.
Hmmmm...I wonder. Recent articles from Counterpunch on Sanders:
- Does Bernie Sanders' Imperialism Matter? - Counterpunch
- Why Bernie Sanders is a Dead End - Counterpunch
- Bernie Out of the Closet: Sanders' Longstanding Deal with ...
Indeed..Counterpunch pulls no punches..in attempting to tear down the more progressive candidates!
They are doing their best to make sure that whomever the Democratic party candidate is-- that that person will lose to Trump in the upcoming election!!!
Bernie Sanders has barely been attacked , by anyone, in this campaign. Clinton doesn't do it because she believes she will win the Democratic nomination with a little room to spare, and she doesn't want to antagonize potential Democratic voters that support Sanders. The Republicans don't attack him because they want him to win against Clinton. Should that be the case, they will open up on "socialism" with both barrels. It would be phenomenally ugly.
Recall, the right has been calling Barack and Michelle Obama "communists" for 8 years, and then use your imagination on how they will deal with Sanders as the Democratic Party nominee.
How did the myth of Hillary’s competence come about and why does it remain resilient in the face of overwhelming evidence to the contrary?
Do you have any thoughts or answers to this question JR? It is a valid question many of us on the Independent Left ponder a great deal. Democrats rave constantly about the competence of Hillary, yet on those issues I believe to be most important to the well-being of our country (foreign intervention, neo-liberal economic policy, trade policy) I disagree with Hillary 100%. And I would venture that I have been proven correct much more often than she has.
One could write up a bad review about any one of the candidates. It is the nature of politics that you are always against something a lot of other people are for.
I do not believe Clinton is sufficiently progressive, but she is eternities more progressive than Ted Cruz or Donald Trump. The Lesser Of Two Evils Is Less Evil.
Even if Sanders were to get elected, he would not have sufficient firepower in Congress to get his plans enacted , at this time. The groundwork for progressive success has not been layed at the state and local levels across the country.
We would elect Sanders on a hope and prayer that miraculously he could get something done. That has to be weighed against the risk that a GOP smear campaign against him in the fall would work (good possibility, imo).
If progressivism were stronger in the country across the board, I would be behind Sanders completely, but I don't think it is yet.
What do you think Clinton, who has the highest negative ratings of any Presidential front-runner ever beside Trump, can accomplish that Sanders, who some people actually like, can't?
She will win and at the least prevent a Republican president from appointing federal and Supreme Court judges and prevent a Republican president who would fail to veto right wing legislation.
Sanders could do those things also, but I believe he is higher risk for the Democrats in terms of winning the November election.
Sanders/Cruz? metrics show as a pick'em. Neither has a distinct advantage over the other. Cruz's avocation of religion hurts him here.
Sanders dusts T Rump, where metrics show Hillary with only a slight advantage over T Rump, she would need ALL of Bernies people to show up and vote. And THAT is not likely.
Cruz/Hillary metrics are showing Cruz with an advantage there, Cruz's integrity values are greater than Hillary's and people are saying they will risk the religion over the honesty issues every time.
I have no dog in this race, the best candidate IMHO is not in this race.
Oh, and Rince Pribus , (yes it's newsmax but Pribus was broadcast on the radio today by CBS news) stated that the Republican rules at the convention allow the convention to elect a candidate that is not currently running. Something I mentioned almost a month ago might be a possibility. I don't see how with out some changes to the rules (of which I'm quite familiar) And I hinted at the fix might already be in.
I'm now telling you that the fix is in. THIS was the exact announcement I was waiting for. The party is going to fix it so probably neither T Rump nor Cruz can win. And if that happens? expect a war.
The rank and file will not tolerate another lynching of the peoples choice.
If the numbers in the WA state primary is any indication, Hillary has a serious problem with people connecting with her message. (the state went 70% for Bernie) Most democrats here feel she is done, old news and is not trustworthy. They were talking about ways to shift the party delegates over from Hillary to the Bern. If such does happen and they do switch over. It will be much like 2008 when they switched over from Hillary to Obama.
It could happen, she ain't too popular in the western half of the nation.
Hillary has warts just like everyone else this election cycle. The simple truth is that we as voters have the worst choices (possibly ever) come November.
For me, the choice is clear....1) Keep T-Rump as far from the oval office as possible. 2) Maintain and improve the separation of state and religion in our government. After that.... hope we get something done?
Fly,
In agreement with your assessment. The choices given America are the worst I've seen in my lifetime.
Regarding Clinton's accomplishments - the few that usually come to my mind are her efforts to pass CHIP (the token door prize in absence of inclusive healthcare legislation), orchestrating the sanctions on Iran (the lifting is perhaps discussion for another time) and overall I believe she was instrumental in coalescing our allies after Obama took office (shedding our bully on the block image). She has also been a voice for women's rights around the world. Has established relationships with a myriad of both parties.
On the downside, she's more hawkish then many may realize. But as you pointed out in another post, truth requires work, our American electorate is willing to saddle up to media outlets that feed their positions. Apathy abounds
I agree that Trump would be an absolute disaster. There is only 1 person in our country who I believe would have a chance of being an even worse president. Ironically, she's running for the democratic nomination. WHAT ARE THE FRIGGIN' ODDS OF THAT!
I've said before, as a hard libertarian and solid conservative voice, I'm stating that Bernie is the best choice of the lot.
HANDS DOWN!
What does that tell ya?