╌>

What's behind the 'anti-vax' movement?

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  flynavy1  •  10 years ago  •  39 comments

What's behind the 'anti-vax' movement?

This spring saw the first death from measles in the United States in 12 years.

Measles infections there are at their highest since the disease was supposedly eradicated. The reason for this is that the number of people vaccinated against measles has been falling.

More and more parents have been refusing to immunise their children. The influence of a loose group of fringe campaigners against immunisation - "anti-vaxxers", as they're known - has been spreading. And with it, disease.

Vaccines can cause adverse reactions in a small number of people, like many medicines, but the accepted science is that the benefits far outweigh the risks. And that's why none of our expert witnesses this week is an anti-vaxxer.

Instead we're asking why, given the body of scientific evidence and the advice of national and global health authorities, has childhood immunisation become so controversial? What's behind the anti-vax movement? Four key players in the story share their thoughts.

  A syringe being prepared

Dyan Hes: Everyone must play their part


Dr Dyan Hes doesn't accept any patients at her children's clinic in New York who aren't up-to-date with their vaccinations.

"I make a promise to my patients that I will do my best to keep their children healthy. So if I have a patient that has cancer or leukaemia or any type of immunosuppressive illness and they sit in my waiting room and somebody comes in with measles and my patient dies, then I didn't keep my oath. That's how I feel.

"You need a population to be immunised to protect the people who cannot be immunised."

Measles virus

If the vast majority of people in a community have had their vaccination against a disease, and then someone turns up from out of town carrying the disease, it's unlikely they'll come into contact with anyone it can pass on to. The disease won't spread. And especially vulnerable people, who can't be immunised, will be safe.

This is called "herd immunity".

"Right now in Seattle, Washington, in the United States, 80 to 88% of children are immunised for polio. But you need a 95% rate of polio immunisation to keep up herd immunity. So polio can theoretically re-emerge in Seattle, Washington because there are so many people who are not being immunised at this time."

The first successful vaccine was the smallpox vaccine, developed in the late 1700s. But ironically it's the success of childhood immunisation programmes which has in part started the backlash against them. Dr Hes says parents don't see the point in taking action against a disease they've never known anyone to suffer from.

"They don't see that so they don't know, so they say, 'What's the big deal? It's a rash, you know, it won't be my kid.' But people forget what childhood death is and what infantile mortality is, people forget how many children died or were left with encephalitis or terrible brain diseases that caused mental retardation and people to be institutionalised for the rest of their life from measles."



Brian Deer: Bad science


Brian Deer is an investigative journalist for the British newspaper The Sunday Times.

"There was a paper published in February 1998 in The Lancet and basically what it said was that there was a group of parents who brought 12 children to a hospital in North London here in England. Those parents said that they gave their child the MMR [measles, mumps and rubella] vaccine and within 14 days, eight of the families said their child had developed the first signs of autism.

"And the paper also said these same children had a new kind of inflammatory bowel disease which, taken together, was a new syndrome in children and it set off the most extraordinary public alarm.

"When this story broke, very quickly parents started to shun the MMR vaccination. This man, Wakefield, went on television and it was reported at saturation levels, his recommendation that the MMR should be suspended in favour of vaccinating your children with single shots. But many parents just didn't vaccinate their child and we started to see outbreaks of measles. In fact, I had the misfortune to report the first measles death in the UK resulting from this scare. It was an absolute panic and a real public health crisis."

But something didn't quite ring true about the story to Brian. He began to take a closer look at the scientist behind the research, Andrew Wakefield.

"I went to interview one of the mothers of the children in the research and she told me a story that was completely different to the story that she'd told to participate in the research that led to the 1998 Wakefield paper. It was a different story."

Brian Deer found inconsistencies in a number of the paper's case studies and questioned how impartial the research was. The medical authorities began to investigate Andrew Wakefield's research methods. It took years. He was eventually found guilty of serious professional misconduct, and struck off the medical register. The Lancet withdrew the paper. But all this happened 12 years after the study was first published.

No scientist has been able to replicate the study's findings. No study has since found any link between the MMR vaccine and autism. And yet the story hasn't gone away.

"In the UK the British public is now pretty apprised of the situation. Vaccination uptake levels of MMR have gone back to where they were before Andrew Wakefield's paper, but this story is now rolling out across the world.

"I am subject to relentless abuse, emails telling me that how can I sleep at night because of what I've done and that I'm working for the drug industry and that I'm somehow involved in some sort of global conspiracy to harm children."

Juniper Russo: Changed view


Juniper Russo is a single mother living in the city of Chattanooga in the southern US state of Tennessee, and used to be part of the anti-vax movement.

"Andrew Wakefield's study was one of the things that had really scared me. People who are in the anti-vaccine movement largely believe that he was silenced and that he was actually a hero who was speaking up about something important."

Juniper now writes a blog, Back From Nature , in which she advocates evidence-based healthcare. Like journalist Brian Deer, she's faced a vicious backlash and even threats from anti-vaxxers for changing her views. But at one time there was no question in her mind: vaccinations were a conspiracy.

"I was only 20 when I got pregnant with my daughter and I was really young and really naive and I had gotten wrapped up in this world view that said that nature is just this wonderful thing and that everything about our big scary industrialised world was bad

"I thought that the government wasn't to be trusted and I very much believed in the idea that there was this big organisation called Big Pharma and I thought that people would be willing to make my child sick to make a dollar.

"All that I could think about was that I was doing what I needed to do to protect my children from this beast of modern medicine. I didn't think about the possibility that I was putting anyone else in danger, but I now know that I was."

But Juniper's views changed after her daughter, who had never had a vaccination, was diagnosed with autism.

"That was the beginning of me starting to face that I had made a mistake in assuming that if I did everything in this perfect... way that nothing wrong would ever happen to my kids.

"I was seeing a lot of it on the news, and I now realise that it was actually very irresponsible of the media. They would have a physician who worked with the World Health Organization on TV, and then debating with him they would have a mum who said that her kid had autism from the vaccine.

"It was very easy for me to side with the person that I could relate to the most, instead of siding with the big scary doctor who was, I assumed, paid off by the government."

Heidi Larson: Managing the conversation


Heidi Larson, an anthropologist at the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, has dedicated her career to understanding how people feel about vaccines.

"The reason that [people] get more entrenched [in their opposition to vaccination] is they feel like they're not being listened to. So you don't throw information at the problem. Instead you learn to listen.

"I do think we need to do a much better job at supporting health workers and health professionals to have difficult conversations. They're absolutely not trained to manage a conversation which is challenging what they do.

"It's very much... you get trained as a doctor, a health worker, a nurse, to deliver these good things that are going to help the health of the public, [to] give people the jab.

"Increasingly people have the performance indicators and they feel like they have to check so many off and I've had interviews with people that say, 'I feel like a number. You know, I'm in, I'm out, get the jab.'

"Additionally there's all this focus on the public understanding the science. I think we're not focusing enough on scientists understanding the public.

"We can't keep finger pointing at the public and think they're the issue."

http://www.bbc.com/news/health-33774181


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  FLYNAVY1    10 years ago

People hear what they want to hear, and disregard the rest.  Do so at your own risk.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  FLYNAVY1   10 years ago

And what does it say about education and critical thinking skills?

Is Government in cahoots with Big Pharma?

ABSOLUTLY!

To bilk billions of dollars out of the system to line their own pockets.

To Kill Children?

NOPE, A COLD DAY IN HELL OF A CHANCE!

Why?

killing Kids would kill the cash cow Pharmaceuticals have become.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    10 years ago

It's not that hard to be distrustful of Big Pharma. You can't even watch a tv show without being inundated with ten pharmaceutical commercials, in which half of the content is a list of hideous possible side effects.  And don't even get me started on Martin Shkreli and his protégés.  While vaccines are a crucial component to maintaining societal health, they unfortunately come from an industry that makes it quite clear that they are pawns of capitalism.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  FLYNAVY1  replied to  Hal A. Lujah   10 years ago

they unfortunately come from an industry that makes it quite clear that they are pawns of capitalism.

Hence the need for laws and regulations to protect people from the negative aspects of capitalism.

 
 
 
Wheel
Freshman Quiet
link   Wheel    10 years ago

My mother lost a brother and sister to whooping cough.  I had a cousin with polio who walked on braces and crutches his whole life.  I remember television shows about iron lung wards.  Room after room of people in iron lungs because they can no longer breathe for themselves.  I have left some people very butthurt over my blunt opinion of their intelligence and their fitness to be parents because of their antivax nonsense.  A major outbreak of whooping cough, polio or small pox will be a REAL cause for some butthurt...against the people who chose to compromise the 'herd immunity'.  IDIOTS!!!

 
 
 
Wheel
Freshman Quiet
link   Wheel    10 years ago

Any anti vaxxer who can understand these charts and still chooses not to vaccinate their children really don't deserve to have children.

 
 
 
PJ
Masters Silent
link   PJ  replied to  Wheel   10 years ago

Excellent points, Wheel.  I don't think the data can be dummied down any more than it has and as you say, they are putting more than just their own children at risk.  

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  FLYNAVY1    10 years ago

they are putting more than just their own children at risk.  

Give that man a cigar!

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    10 years ago

So let me start that this became a very personal issue for me, and ended a friendship. But I also found out some truths about our current crops of vaccinations. 

A baby's immune system isn't fully developed. With that in mind, think back to when most of us got our shots. It was one at a time. We didn't blast a child with combo vaccines at one time. When I had my daughters, the CDC recommended trying to get the doctor to break up the vaccination into 2 separate doses, since there was a number of deaths due within 24 hours of vaccination. That is what I did. 

It is the same thing with the MMR. When we were kids, we were given these shots separately. What has been found is that with this vaccine, that some kids autoimmune response was kicked into overdrive. 

That being said, vaccinations are necessary, but there needs to be a meta study on the effects of group vaccines.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  FLYNAVY1  replied to  Perrie Halpern R.A.   10 years ago

Excellent points Perrie.  Separation of the immunizations will make them more viable as well in the long run.  Unfortunately, costs and profits which seem to work into everything is at odd with benefits in medicine as well.  Insurance companies are making the calls here.  But if you can.... do split them up from a biological standpoint.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    10 years ago

What's behind the 'anti-vax' movement?

Ignorance.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  Randy   10 years ago

Gotta vote ya down on this one brother, it isn't ignorance. And it isn't so simple that one word can explain it either.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

It is ignorance of the complex relationships Wheel pointed to in his charts comment . I agree with RDS here .

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  Petey Coober   10 years ago

And read the comments after the charts. Most of today's, the modern, anti-vax movement was started by the former doctor Andrew Wakefield after he published a horribly flawed research paper in The Lancet. It was pulled immediately after it's deadly flaws were pointed out and the doctor's License was taken from him, but not before many thousands of children had died for no good reason and his conspiracy theory has spread wildly throughout the internet. He is responsible for the deaths of ten's of thousand's of children. And because of the herd mentality of many parents, will be responsible for perhaps hundreds of thousands more, before people regain some of their commonsense.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    10 years ago

What's behind it?

Easy peasy, (taken right from the article)

"Additionally there's all this focus on the public understanding the science. I think we're not focusing enough on scientists understanding the public.

"We can't keep finger pointing at the public and think they're the issue."

Elitism, The scientists think we as intelligent people should just accept what they say without having to explain to people who do not understand the importance of such. Why don't they understand? they have no experience in understanding the issue.

Educated people make educated judgments. Experience is a huge part of knowledge and education. the success of VAC's over the decades is starting to come back on the ministers of health who fail to educate those who have no knowledge. Why are they failing to educate? because they reduce the budgets for such cause it is accepted science and should automatically be applied. They ASSUME that everyone will just accept what they say.

Individuals are not wired that way. We are taught in schools to question blind authority and rightfully so. Do not assume anything until you have proof.

On top of that, in the chase for profit, they change the application in a way that might be an issue with safe application of VAC's. But we should all assume that they are safe and sound when such application is not the way VAC's succeeded in the war on childhood diseases.

So two things are in action here, the individuals ability to reason and judge things by knowledge and experience, and science's changing the way things are done without knowing the complete effects of such change. (with some highly visible evidence to the potential adverse effects of such change)

And parents, loving parents making decisions that are best for their children in the world of assumed correctness.

Some will choose caution.

The problem is, the Elite scientists and science supporters that argue this is all settled science and those people are stupid, are stupidly excusing their own blindness and lack of intelligence to their own faulty assumptions..

Seeing it here makes me wonder at what other infallible assumptions are being foisted upon an unknowing public by a scientific community that is so imbued with their own infallibility they cant even see when they are failing.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  FLYNAVY1    10 years ago

Who do you trust more NWM....... the scientific community, or insurance companies?

 

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  FLYNAVY1   10 years ago

I submit that it is still mostly ignorance and an ignorance that leads to the deaths of thousands and, in some cases 10's or even 100,000s of deaths, mostly those of children, caused by the unbelievably small risk of vaccination. The benefits of mass vaccination by far outweigh the comparatively microscopic risks of not doing so and have for many, many years. If you don't want to get your children vaccinated, home school them, let them die, but don't let them even play with my young grand-daughter and put her life at risk, because you choose to believe in wild conspiracy theories and the ignorance of them.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  FLYNAVY1  replied to  Randy   10 years ago

Again, there is a social responsibility that people have to the other members "the herd".  You want to take part in how the herd educates it kids, or participate in non-school activities, then you need to do what the herd does.

It is your right of choice to not do what the herd does for health and survival, but the herd then has the right to exclude you as you are compromising the herd's health and survival.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  FLYNAVY1   10 years ago

To a certain extent I have trust in both and distrust both. There is a verifiable issue with the multi vax that is somewhat provable.

I always remember going back to the old earth revolves around the sun story when asked which I believe, the PTB or scientists. Yes Vax's are good. but people reading about a few cases of adverse outcomes start asking question and don't get decent answers start refusing to comply, the issue usually isn't with those refusing to comply, it is with those refusing to give decent answers.

The article makes that point, emphatically. when well educated people refuse something that is known to be good practice with a long established history, the time should be taken to explain all the ramifications of such.

And, if there wasn't a history of Big Pharma putting out false and misleading information and doctors passing on such to patients. I might agree with your assessment. (Celebrex ring a bell)

Unfortunately the truth is something different than that which compels complete acceptance.

I've had all my shots, except the flu shot. Every time I've been given one I get sick as a dog for three weeks with the flu. (despite proclamations that such don't happen) The problem stopped when under the advice of my doctor I stopped getting them.

PS: if we listen to another branch of the scientific tree the human race is about 100,000 years overdue for another mass extinction event or it may even be underway already. History is replete with mass extinctions.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

I've had all my shots, except the flu shot. Every time I've been given one I get sick as a dog for three weeks with the flu.

Same here, except the measles shot, because it wasn't widely available when I was a child. So I got and survived the Measles, which I would have never had to worry about if I'd had my shot. I get a flu shot every year and have had especially since I have become older. I am going to be 60 in July and I have never had the flu or any bad side effects in years when I have received my flu shot. My wife refuses to get her flu shot, just because she doesn't like doctors. And every year I spend more then a week taking care of her when she gets the flu. She has never had a Measles or flu shot and is 72 years old. One of these years, perhaps this flu season, I will end up a widower because of her refusal to get an annual flu shot. I am not happy with the idea of losing her. In fact it will tear me apart.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  FLYNAVY1  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

That mass extinction event may be programmed into our DNA..... I seeded this a few days ago.

Kavika called it right as possibly being a human "doomsday button" in our own DNA.

 

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  FLYNAVY1   10 years ago

Yes it may very well be, the greatest irony of them all.

WE very well be the seeds of our own destruction, and it's probably pre-ordained.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

But the research says (so far) that only some people have this sequence in their DNA. Being as I am a superior human being, myself, nor my descendants should have it.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  FLYNAVY1  replied to  FLYNAVY1   10 years ago

What really should make your head bake is what would be a possible trigger to activate these viruses in our DNA?

The other detail about natural adaptation from the piece that I found fascinating:

In fact, about 8 percent of what we think of as our "human" DNA actually came from viruses. In some cases, HERV sequences have been adopted by the human body to serve a useful purpose, such as one that helps pregnant women's bodies build a cell layer around a developing fetus to protect it from toxins in the mother's blood.

Instructions at the genetic level would seem to be one of the most awesome powers in what we know of the universe.  It's capabilities to transform are just only now being grasped.

 

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  FLYNAVY1   10 years ago

Nah. What really makes my head bake is being outside without a hat here in the Cochella Valley in August!stunned

 
 

Who is online








86 visitors