"This is a lovely little piece of political rhetoric offered by a number of supporters of raising the minimum wage: Someone who is working full-time should be getting a living wage. Period. It’s used as a statement of such obviousness that who could possibly disagree with it? And I’m perfectly content with the message on the face of it. Yes, of course, someone who is working full-time should indeed be getting enough money to be able to live upon that sum. The U.S. is a rich country–why shouldn’t it, why wouldn’t it, guarantee some minimum standard of living for those sweating their brows and minds to do the work?
However, as always with political rhetoric, that surface message isn’t all that is being said. For that correct point quickly morphs into the idea that a living wage is something a little bit more than the poverty line for a family of four (currently around $24,000 a year) and thus the minimum wage should be $15 an hour, or around $30,000 a year. It’s never quite explained why one wage should be able to support 4 people. Perhaps some atavistic sense that Pops, Mom and two kids should all be able to live off one wage. Not that that has ever been the modal family arrangement in the first place (back when most kids were born inside marriage there were usually more kids than that, today there’s perhaps that number of kids but they’re very much less likely to be inside a marriage or even a two adult household). Perhaps there’s another atavistic point here. In some golden past Pops could go out to work and support a family. Perhaps in 1968, 1969, when the minimum wage was at its highest ever real value? But then if you’re willing to live at the standards of 1968, 1969, it would be pretty easy to live on the current minimum wage too.
Yes, I know, doesn’t seem that way when we think about inflation adjustment–it should reflect the change in the cost of living of a certain lifestyle. But it doesn’t. It reflects the change in the costs of the average lifestyle. And the truth is that the inflation rate for the richer among us has, over those decades, been very much higher than the inflation rate for the poorer among us. Food is, in real terms, markedly cheaper than it was back then. Telecoms, cars (when you include running and repair costs) are cheaper, and it’s mostly the services we consume which have risen in price (as Baumol’s Cost Disease tells us they would). I would, in fact, quite happily take the bet, even to the point of happily being the guinea pig in a TV reality show about it, that if we took the living standards of that 1969 minimum wage worker then, barring the obvious issue of rents in the more expensive places, then we could achieve that living standard on the current minimum wage. But that’s a slight discursion.
Say that we do indeed want to insist that everyone gets a living wage from full-time work. Our problem is that what is a living wage changes given the family commitments being undertaken. The single teenager living at home with Mom doesn’t need to be able to support a family of four on her wages. That 35 year old trying to raise two kids and keep a spouse does. Thus it’s not obvious that a minimum wage change is the method to achieve this goal. In fact, it’s worse than that. Most of the benefits of a higher minimum wage don’t go to people in poverty at all :
Well, it’s not well targeted because of the structure of the program. So the minimum wage applies to hourly wage workers regardless of the overall income of the household in which those workers live. So a single mom with two kids at home qualifies for the minimum wage. At the same time, the teenage daughter of parents who earn a six-figure income qualifies for the minimum wage. And so what you’re doing is you’re increasing the minimum price that firms can pay for an hour of labor. And it’s simply a matter of fact that those benefits are distributed throughout the income distribution.
Again, if you look at raising the federal minimum wage to about $10, the overwhelming majority of the benefits — say something like 80% of the extra income that people would receive from the minimum wage increase — goes to households above the poverty line, with incomes above the poverty line because the minimum wage goes to everybody and not just to people who live in poor households.
Which brings us to the standard efficiency argument. Whatever it is, we want to achieve the goal at the least cost. And again, I’m perfectly happy with the idea that all of those who put the hours in should gain a living income. But spraying money through a $15 minimum wage at the teenager saving up for her prom dress just isn’t an efficient manner of making sure that full-time workers do have an income sufficient to raise their families. In fact, there’s no manner at all of doing through this through wages which will. Precisely because familial arrangements will differ and we can’t vary wages according to familial arrangements. We did once: married men usually got a pay raise upon their marriage (my own father got a pay raise when the Royal Navy thought he was old enough to marry in the form of the usual spousal benefits which were not on offer to those younger than that age) but that’s all a bit patriarchal for the modern day.
So, we need a system separate from wages to top up the incomes of those who need their incomes topped up. Which, amazingly, we do. We call it the welfare system. That’s what it’s there for. We acknowledge that market determined wages will not meet the financial needs of all of those who work for their living. Thus we all dip into our own pockets, via taxation, to top up those incomes. And that is the efficient method of doing this.
Thus this is the system we should use. If we want to insist that all gain, all those who do the work gain, whatever income it is that we regard as a living wage for that structure of family then we need to be willing to pay for it. Don’t mess with the price system of wages, instead, use the much more efficient method of the welfare state to top up wages. For that is what it’s there for, that’s why we have a welfare state and system in the first place. To provide a living income to those who cannot gain one through the market value of their labor."

Interesting article. Mr. Worstall would play God and decide which low wage earners deserved more money. If you have x amount of dependents, I guess you would, but maybe x-1 and you wouldn't. Your age would undoubtedly be a factor, and your expenses, etc.
He continues the current way of doing things, which is for the American taxpayer to supplement the wages of WAL MART ( and Wal Mart type employers) employees, presumably so that they stockholders of Wal Mart (mainly the Walton family) can continue to amass personal billions.
We never seem to realize that there is something inherently wrong with a system that does not provide a living wage to everyone who works a full time job.
We have to come to that realization , and not pick and choose which working poor people deserve relief, before economic justice can proceed.
Corporations want to ''maximize'' profits, and consumers want the cheapest possible price. Combine the two and you can see why we are in the situation that we're in.
Corporations want to ''maximize'' profits, and consumers want the cheapest possible price. Combine the two and you can see why we are in the situation that we're in.
You may have a point there. But has there ever been any period in history where corporations didn't want to maximize profits?
And, for that matter, when consumers didn't want to pay the cheapest price?
No it's two of the best things ever. Profit is both good and moral and the desire for lost cost goods and services has driven many technological advancements. It's the businesses that are losing money that you have to stay away from.
Probably not Krisha, but it seems to be on steroids now.
The question is a simple one. Either pay the workers with an employer provided salary, or pay them through entitlements.
Why are the taxpayers funding corporations payroll obligations?