╌>

About That 42,000 Dollars You Owe To Pay Down The National Debt

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  johnrussell  •  10 years ago  •  6 comments

About That 42,000 Dollars You Owe To Pay Down The National Debt

Did Time magazine bum you out? The internet debunks mag's claim that you owe $42.998.12 for the national debt

http://www.salon.com/2016/04/14/did_time_magazine_bum_you_out_the_internet_debunks_mags_claim_that_you_owe_42_998_12_for_the_national_debt/

So the idea of each citizen chipping in $42.998.12 to pay off the national debt in one fell swoop is kind of silly. But even if the government paid off its debts incrementally, would eliminating the national debt be a goal worth striving towards?  Paying off the national debt "would be stunningly foolish," writes Jordan Weissmann in Slate :


For one, markets would go crazy. The entire financial world runs on Treasury bonds—they are the gold standard of safe assets, and are essentially treated as the next closest thing to cash. Paying them all off would suck the blood out of the world's financial circulatory system.


 


Erasing the whole debt, or even a significant chunk of what the U.S. now owes, would also be a waste of resources, especially at a moment when the economy is  underperforming its potential . Every dollar we spend paying down our obligations could, theoretically, be used on something more productive that would grow the economy long-term, like fixing our infrastructure, or making sure we have a functioning health care system. Faster growth would, of course, shrink our debt compared as a share of the economy. Cutting spending to pay off debt, on the other hand, could slow growth, and leave us right back where we started.


The idea that the national debt and the federal government's solvency are necessarily correlated is misguided, writes Davis:

“The government doesn’t have to pay down its debt. We can roll this over forever,” [says Dean Baker, co-director of the Center for Economic and Policy Research].

 

This may sound like bunkum to anyone with a bank loan; household debt always comes due. But the government isn’t a household. If the U.S. wants to issue bonds to cover debt payments, there is literally a world of investors who will happily buy up bonds at low interest rates. The world has little fear that America will ever default.

 

Baker compares the government not to an individual — whose lifespan is finite — but to a company. Companies hope to operate in perpetuity. And like the government, nearly every corporation maintains a significant level of ongoing debt, often reaching into the billions. General Electric, for instance, currently holds nearly $200 billion in debt. [...]

 

[T]he U.S. government plans to be around a bit longer than any 30-year bond. Indeed, there has been a national debt since 1835 , and there will continue to be one. As Alexander Hamilton said, “A national debt, if it is not excessive, will be to us a national blessing. It will be a powerful cement to our union.”

Kevin Drum of Mother Jones sums up the arguments against the Time story nicely:

You will never have to pay down this debt. Nor will your children. Or your grandchildren. Just forget about it.

 

And if we ever do have to pay some of it down? We'll get to pay it off over decades, just like any other debt. And the rich will pay a bigger share than you. But I guess "You might someday owe $145 per year" doesn't make a very good magazine cover.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    10 years ago

“The government doesn’t have to pay down its debt. We can roll this over forever,” [says Dean Baker, co-director of the Center for Economic and Policy Research].

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    10 years ago

Will they take a personal check?

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    10 years ago

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    10 years ago

Time magazine's new cover trolls economically literate people with absurd scare tactics

Matthew Yglesias

Time magazine decided to troll economically literate Americans this week with an alarmist cover story about the national debt:

The good news is there's a lot wrong with this analysis.

Ignoring inequality

One problem here is that because of inequality, the national average wealth and income is much higher than the national median wealth and income.

So when you divide the national debt evenly across every man, woman, and child in the United States, you get a number that is very high relative to the typical family's income.

According to the Federal Reserve's 2013 Survey of Consumer Finances (this happens every three years, and the 2016 edition hasn't come out yet), 3 percent of American households own about 25 percent of all wealth, and the bottom 90 percent of the population owns less than 25 percent of all wealth.

Federal Reserve

Under the circumstances, it's true that dividing up the debt burden evenly among all households would be an enormous burden on many Americans. But there is no reason to divide the burden up this way. The way the federal government finances things is it collects more money from the people who have more money.

Ignoring assets

Another problem is that assessing any institution's financial position in terms of gross debt is ridiculous. My wife and I have hundreds of thousands of dollars' worth of debt — not because we're desperately poor but because we bought a condo in Logan Circle in Washington, DC.

What you're supposed to do in this situation is look at net assets, where you subtract the mortgage debt from the value of the house. If you do this, you will reach the correct conclusion that American homeowners are generally substantially richer than American renters, even though homeowners have more gross debt.

The meaning of solvency is that you have more assets than you have debt. Apple, for example, owes more than $45 billion to various people, which is a ton of money. But it also owns more than $150 billion in various financial assets, to say nothing of the value of its brand, intellectual property, real estate, factories, etc.

By the same token, when the federal government borrows money to build an aircraft carrier it ends up with both more debt and more aircraft carriers than it previously had. The same applies to schools, highways, office buildings, and the other physical assets of the American public sector. A few years ago, I made a chart based on Thomas Piketty's data that shows the American public sector has consistently been solvent in a balance sheet sense.

Author's analysis of Thomas Piketty data

The United States of America is not a business enterprise, so there is no particular reason to think about it in solvency terms anyway, but if you want to do this we are clearly solvent.

Ignoring the economy

A business enterprise tries to make money or improve its balance sheet. The federal government is not a business enterprise. What it tries to create is prosperity for its citizens through competent economic management.

Right now in the United States, just like in other stable rich countries , interest rates on government debt are incredibly low due to massive investor demand for government debt .

The responsibility of the government is to help make the economy function smoothly by ensuring that there is adequate supply of debt to meet this massive demand. Ideally, one would use this debt to finance spending on something useful, like great transportation projects or high-quality preschool programs or removing toxic lead from American cities . But if you think there's nothing useful the government can or should spend money on, then it could at least do American households a favor by collecting less tax revenue.

Any of these moves would increase the volume of gross per capita federal debt outstanding, but for both inequality and balance sheet reasons that's irrelevant. The important issue is that these ideas would make America a more prosperous society, with more ability to produce goods and services and meet the needs of its people. That, at the end of the day, is the only thing that matters.

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    10 years ago

We are screwed as soon as interest rates get back to more normal rate of 4 or 5 percent. 

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    10 years ago

The funniest part of the absurd claim by Time magazine is that the person making 10 dollars an hour stocking shelves at Wal-Mart owes the same sum on the national debt as the zillioniare owners of Wal_mart do.

Even if the national debt was much smaller and to be paid off this year, the poor do not owe an equal amount on the national debt as the rich do. It's just an embarrassing line of corporate horsecrap by the corporate lords in the media.

 
 

Who is online



Hallux


127 visitors