(Opinion) Americans are helping eight million people break this bad law
Last week immigrants, their families, and legal advocates rallied outside the U.S. Supreme Court as eight justices heard oral arguments in United States v. Texas , an immigration case concerning the Obama Administration’s Deferred Action for Parents of Americans and Lawful Permanent Residents ( DAPA ) program, which would have offered deferred action status and work authorization to nearly 4 million unauthorized immigrants.
Based on the photos and news coverage of the demonstrators, the working parents, restaurant owners, and other small business and household employers who break U.S. immigration laws by hiring unauthorized immigrants were, as usual, noticeably absent.
Too often immigration is seen as a problem for immigrants and their families. But if you hire someone to care for a family member at home, buy produce at the grocery store, eat out at a restaurant, or have your house cleaned, the fight to legalize the status of unauthorized workers is your fight, too.
According to the most recent data gathered in 2012, 8.1 million of the estimated 11.3 million unauthorized immigrants were employed. They represented 5.1 percent of the United States workforce. Some of the industries with the highest numbers of unauthorized immigrant workers include landscaping services, private households, crop production, dry cleaning services, construction, and eating and drinking establishments. Thus, many Americans benefit from the work of unauthorized immigrants either because they employ these immigrants illegally or because the goods and services they consume are made cheaper by the use of unauthorized immigrant labor.
Unauthorized immigration and the hiring of unauthorized immigrants is a kind of workaround against immigration laws that do not reflect labor demands. As Americans have become older and more educated , the demand for lower-skilled workers, namely workers in occupations that do not require a high school diploma, has been met by immigrants. Yet lower-skilled workers only qualify for a handful of visas that would allow them to work lawfully in the United States, in part because U.S. immigration laws favor family immigration and higher-skilled temporary workers.
The lack of sufficient channels of lawful entry for lower-skilled workers makes it difficult for them to stand in line and wait their turn for legal entry and difficult for employers who need lower-skilled workers to find workers authorized to work, which results in rule breaking by both parties.
If so many people are breaking the law — both immigrants and United States natives — it begs the question: are bad laws happening to good people? Yes, and everyone implicated by these laws should be fighting to fix them.
Household employers, small business owners, and consumers should push to legalize the status of those workers already in the United States, advocating for the creation of new visa categories for lower-skilled work, as well as easier ways for employers to verify that employees are authorized to work.
Opponents of legalization and visas for lower-skilled workers often argue that such measures would cause U.S. workers to be displaced. But this is not true. First, arguments about displacement are a red herring in the debate about whether to provide a path to legal status for the more than 11 million unauthorized immigrants already in the United States, since more than 8 million of them already have jobs in the United States.
Second, most economists agree that immigrants and native U.S. workers do not generally compete for the same work and when they compete, they have different skills , language and education, which positions each group differently in the job market. When immigrants enter the workforce they often cause U.S. workers to specialize or they engage in work that complements the work of U.S. workers. In the restaurant industry, for example, native-born workers move to communication-intensive work in the front of the house and immigrants focus on manual labor in the back of the house.
Any residual concerns about displacement could be addressed by tying any new immigration to employment and labor conditions in the United States.
Fixing immigration laws to provide legal status to individuals already working in the United States could also result in higher wages and more rights for people who are currently unauthorized to work. And yes, even those who support immigration might worry that higher wages could make it more expensive to go out to eat or tackle projects like remodeling a kitchen.
But not fixing our laws because of wage concerns would mean a tacit endorsement of black market wages and the hiring of cheap immigrant labor over more expensive U.S. workers.
Finally, a focus solely on enforcement, which some candidates have called for, will not effectively disrupt the demand for immigrant labor or deter rule breaking. We simply do not have the financial resources or personnel — nor does it make sense — to deport 11.3 million people, build a wall across a nearly 2,000 -mile border with Mexico, or go after restaurant owners, working parents, cooks, nannies or roofers.
This is not an indictment of people who hire unauthorized workers. Instead, it is a call to action. It’s time to broaden the coalition and demand that politicians offer solutions that fix our immigration laws so good people — immigrants and citizens alike — do not feel compelled to break them.

According to the most recent data gathered in 2012, 8.1 million of the estimated 11.3 million unauthorized immigrants were employed. They represented 5.1 percent of the United States workforce. Some of the industries with the highest numbers of unauthorized immigrant workers include landscaping services, private households, crop production, dry cleaning services, construction, and eating and drinking establishments.
I thought this was a decent article to consider. I have two additional points....
1) Our population is getting older, as such, it is good that we have the influx of younger workers coming into the system paying taxes.
2) Neither business, nor our politicians want to change the current system. Republicans want cheap labor for their sweat shops, and Democrats are looking at potential future voters.
We don't need them technology will replace these low wage workers. They will become victims of the welfare system that keeps them trapped in poverty in return for their vote Democrat. We are better off if they are illegal that way we can still benefit from their desire to work without the risk of the becoming dependent on government.
2) Neither business, nor our politicians want to change the current system. Republicans want cheap labor for their sweat shops, and Democrats are looking at potential future voters.
That is exactly why the status won't change.
ts about displacement are a red herring in the debate about whether to provide a path to legal status for the more than 11 million unauthorized immigrants already in the United States, since more than 8 million of them already have jobs in the United States.
That's a false argument. It means that illegal immigrants have already displaced 8 million American workers. Considering the high unemployment rates among the young and unskilled, that's 8 million jobs already taken from the Americans who have the most trouble finding them.
Second, most economists agree that immigrants and native U.S. workers do not generally compete for the same work
There's really no competition. Employers prefer the cheaper worker. Immigrants accept lower wages and drive down wages for all low skilled workers. There's a reason corporations and the Chamber of Commerce are the biggest champion of immigration. They understand supply and demand.
Sean, here is a real life example. My friend owns a business, landscaping which include building retaining walls patios, fire pits etc. They are not unskilled.
He has always done it the legal way, by applying for visa's for the 11 workers that come back years after year. This year all 11 were denied because it was stated that the unemployment rate was to high in our area. He has advertised in papers, and done everything possible to get those positions filled. You would think that he could fill the positions. Not true, he has not been able to fill one position with our local unemployed. Wages are not the problem, since he pays a minimum of $10 hour with benefits.
Now he had to drop some of his regular customers because of a lack of employees. That is the reality of it here.
Why doesn't unemployment office coordinate with employers and send thise collecting checks to employers needing workers? If they turn a job down, check gets cut off.
I had a couple stints with long term unemployment. I wasn't eligible for unemployment benefits on the first one, because my boss was a lying piece of shit who laid me off because we ran out of work, then reported to the unemployment office that he fired me with good cause so that his unemployment insurance taxes wouldn't go up. It would have cost more than I had to take him to court.
The second time I was eligible and collected for a couple months, but what I really wanted was a job. I foolishly took a temp job, which ended far earlier than it was supposed so, because the engineering project they hired me to work on got cancelled. I didn't know that you can't re-apply for unemployment benefits within a certain timeframe from previously receiving them, so I had nothing to live off of. The economy was shit and there were no job opportunities in my field, so I applied for anything and everything. You can forget about getting an unskilled labor job when your resume indicates a lifetime of skilled employment making three of four times what they are offering. I would have gladly taken a job, but employers in unskilled labor don't want to hire people who (a) are smart, (b) would start at the high end of their pay scale, and (c) will leave on a moment's notice once a better opportunity presents itself.
The moral of this story is that getting an unskilled labor job is not as easy as you think.
Wages are not the problem, since he pays a minimum of $10 hour with benefits.
I would say wages are the problem. I did that exact sort of work almost 30 years ago for a couple of summers. Whether you want to call it skilled or not, it's hard work. But I was paid more than double minimum wage for my time.
Fast food jobs at the local McDonalds pay more than $10 an hour now. I can see why someone would rather push buttons in an air conditioned restaurant than engage in back breaking manual labor for less money while exposed to the elements. Landscapers are probably one of the biggest beneficiaries of illegal immigrants whether they actually employ illegals or not. The number of those that do employ illegals drive down the wages for all in the industry, creating a situation where landscapers pay less than fast food.
That said, your story shows how truly messed up and perverse our broken system is, unless there are no healthy people in your area collecting welfare or unemployment.
Sean, I didn't say that he paid minimum wage. I said that the minimum he pays is $10 per hour. Many of his employees make well about that.
I agree the system is really screwed up. And this area has plenty of people that could work, but choose not to.
I agree the system is really screwed up. And this area has plenty of people that could work, but choose not to.
I would like to add to that, that these immigrants are doing the jobs that other Americans wouldn't do. There was a time when American's would work the fields and wash dishes, but not anymore. These immigrants fill the gap.
Part of the issue is characterization. The issue is within ourselves when we get to decide in how we look at the opposite sides.
"Republicans want cheap labor for their sweat shops"......
Yet we are making the call to change the law to allow more immigrant labor legally and more republican sweatshop owners to be able to hire them legally.
What employer is going to want to work with someone that calls him a sweatshop operator with everything that connotes??
Yes immigrants obviously do jobs that the brainy smarter Americans don't want to do anymore. But just because they will, doesn't mean that the person that hires them are treating them like slaves.
You can't have it both ways.
And the problem won't go away until EVERYONE changes their attitudes, including the elites that think they know better than everyone else.
As long as business owners can get away with hiring illegals without facing prosecution, things won't be changing.
WE both know that the first amnesty granted illegals during the Reagan Administration had a bunch of provisions for enforcement against employers hiring illegals.
It was part of the deal that got Reagan to sign off on the amnesty. Without said provisions Reagan would have vetoed it. The problem came with a democrat congress that refused to fund said provisions. They got their amnesty, and ignored the other side of the equation.
NOW, it's all the Republicans fault cause the laws have no provisions for enforcement.
It's nice to place the blame, but ignore the cause. (probably cause they would have to acknowledge that Reagan was right, but politics always trumps reality)