Clinton will trounce Trump on foreign policy
Remember way back when Hillary Clinton looked like a sitting duck on foreign policy? (That would have been 2015.) She’d been secretary of state for a president who made numerous errors. The Middle East is aflame, with Iraq coming apart at the seams. As long as the GOP put up someone minimally competent who did not scare the voters, she wouldn’t get to the Oval Office, right?
My, how things change. A microcosm of what we could expect in a Trump-Clinton general election played out on the Sunday talk shows. Here was Trump in all his semi-isolationist, disjointed glory on Fox News Sunday :
CHRIS WALLACE: The question is if we’re going to disengage from that part of the world, how do we promote stability? You talk about in your speech the futility of creating democracies. Do you — would you like to see a return to strongmen in the Middle East, people like Mubarak and Saddam Hussein?
TRUMP: Isn’t it true that we knocked them out in the first place? OK.
You know, if our presidents went to the beach for 365 days a year, we’d be a lot better in the Middle East than we are now. Now, you have a mess. You have a big fat mess and I called that a long time ago, in ’04 and ’03, I said, don’t knock out — when you knock out Iraq, you are just — you’re going to ruin the balance, and the balance has been horrible.
Then you had Libya and Syria and everything. I mean, they couldn’t have been worse. The people that advised our presidents or our presidents, whoever was the one that came up with this plan — I mean, what we’ve done in the Middle East, we’ve spent $4 trillion and we’re far worse than the first gunshot that was fired.
And what we’ve got to do is we’ve got to knock off ISIS and we’ve got to at some point get out of there, because we have to rebuild our country. Our country is becoming third world, our airports, our roadways, our train systems. You go to China and you go to other places, they have trains that travel 300 miles an hour. We have the Long Island railroad that can hardly — it can hardly move. I mean, we are like a third world country.
But we have to get rid of ISIS and we have to get rid of them very decisively.
WALLACE: Let me —
TRUMP: And I’ve been saying for a long time, keep the oil. ISIS now has Libyan oil. You know, it’s among the finest oils in the world. ISIS now has the Libyan oil. We don’t even do anything to —
WALLACE: Mr. Trump —
TRUMP: We don’t even do anything to stop it. They’re making a fortune with Libyan oil.
WALLACE: Let me pick on this —
TRUMP: And if we would have left Gadhafi, you wouldn’t have that.
Look, every move we made in the Middle East was wrong. And a lot of times, they want me to get these great foreign advisors and these great geniuses and they’ve been involved for 15 years. I don’t want the people that have been involved for 15 years because those are the people that have absolutely — what they’ve done to this country and our country and on top of it we owe $19 trillion in debt.
WALLACE: But let me pick up on this because when you talk about, you know, we need to stop spending money overseas and spend it at home, that sounds more like a liberal Democrat.
And the question I have is, you talk about the mess — your words — that Bush and Obama and Clinton have made in the Middle East, interventions in Iraq and Libya. It almost sounds like you would be — as a general election candidate, you would be criticizing Hillary Clinton from the left, that we should be less intervening in the rest of the world.
TRUMP: I want to rebuild our country. I want to rebuild our military, make it bigger, better, stronger than ever before. I want to take care of our vets. We have to handle education. We have to get rid of Obamacare. You know, our education system is a disaster and we’ve got to get rid of Common Core which is absolutely no good.
It is worth wading through the long exchange to appreciate how incoherent he can sound and how many easily debunked assertions he makes (e.g. the Islamic State does NOT have access to Libyan oil. Whichever adviser told him otherwise is misinformed.) Wallace is right: Trump is to Clinton’s left and is less committed to international leadership than she.
Compare Trump’s meanderings with her interview on Sunday on CNN :
JAKE TAPPER: You talked about Donald Trump’s foreign policy. He gave a foreign policy address recently. I’m wondering if you had a chance to see it or think — or read about it and what you thought.
CLINTON: Well, I certainly read about it. And I think it’s quite concerning.
His talk about pulling out of NATO, his talk about letting other countries have nuclear weapons, which runs counter to 70 years of bipartisan national security policy, his idea that he — quote — “has a secret plan” to get rid of ISIS and he’s not going to tell anybody, I find it disturbing because I — as a senator from New York for eight years, as secretary of state for four years, I know that the stakes are high, that we face some real challenges and dangers in the world.
And I don’t think loose talks about loose nukes, I don’t think turning our back on our strongest allies, I don’t think pretending you have some sort of secret plan is a very smart way to go forward in leading the world, which is what we must do.
TAPPER: On some issues, it seems like he’s going to run to your left, on a populist left, and one of them might be the use of force and military intervention, and whether it’s Libya or Iraq, what will your response be when he says Hillary Clinton is part of the group that gets but into these wars?
CLINTON: Well, look, I think that I’m always someone who uses military force as a last resort. It’s not a first choice.
As secretary of state, I talked a about smart power, about diplomacy and development. So, when you have somebody who says he’s going to be tough and he’s going to get results, but he doesn’t tell you how he’s going to do it, I think we will have a lot to contrast with.
You’ll notice she speaks in complete sentences, is measured and correctly identifies a few of Trump’s more ludicrous ideas (backing away from NATO, a complete absence of explanation as to how he achieves his aims). If you knew nothing about foreign policy — and many voters don’t — you’d perceive her as calmer, more reasonable and more rational. If asked which one sounds and looks more like a commander in chief with his or her finger on the button, it would be a no-brainer. And in this case most foreign policy experts would agree with that assessment.
That’s what the general election is going to look like — a raving, ignorant candidate who cannot get out a sentence or two without contradicting himself up against a poised, sober Clinton. It’s why many Republicans, without the choice of a third candidate, will vote for her.
Jennifer Rubin writes the Right Turn blog for The Post, offering reported opinion from a conservative perspective.

That’s what the general election is going to look like — a raving, ignorant candidate who cannot get out a sentence or two without contradicting himself up against a poised, sober Clinton. It’s why many Republicans, without the choice of a third candidate, will vote for her.
Exactly.
Rubin is an interventionist hawk. Of course she's going to support an interventionist hawk.
Clinton has to answer for Libya, calling Assad a reformer and then trying and failing to drive him from power, her failure in Iraq, her failed reset with Russia and her support of the Muslim brotherhood takeover in Egypt etc etc...
Trump doesn't. Incoherence beats a demonstrated track record of terrible decisions and abject failure.
But hey! she flew in a plane!
It sounds like Sean is getting ready to climb on the Trump train.
If someone is incoherent, how can they beat anyone? We don't know what they are saying.
I know that Trumps foreign policy advisers have been described as "weirdo nobodies" by a militarily historian/national security expert. I don't like hearing 'weirdo' in the same sentence with people who might effect our national security policy.