Obama Administration Rule Would Permit Thousands of Eagle Deaths
The Obama administration is revising a federal rule that allows wind-energy companies to operate high-speed turbines for up to 30 years, even if means killing or injuring thousands of federally protected bald and golden eagles.
Under the plan announced Wednesday, wind companies and other power providers could kill or injure up to 4,200 bald eagles a year without penalty — nearly four times the current limit. Golden eagles could only be killed if companies take steps to minimize the losses, for instance, by retrofitting power poles to reduce the risk of electrocution.
Fish and Wildlife Service Director Dan Ashe said the proposal will “provide a path forward” for maintaining eagle populations while also spurring development of a pollution-free energy source that’s intended to ease global warming, a cornerstone of President Obama’s energy plan.
Ashe said the 162-page proposal would protect eagles and at the same time “help the country reduce its reliance on fossil fuels” such as coal and oil that contribute to global warming.
The proposal sets objectives for eagle management, addresses how bird populations will be monitored and provides a framework for how the permitting system fits within the agency’s overall eagle management, Ashe said.
Wind farms are clusters of turbines as tall as 30-story buildings, with spinning rotors as wide as a passenger jet’s wingspan. Blades can reach speeds of up to 170 mph at the tips, creating tornado-like vortexes.
The Fish and Wildlife Service estimates there are about 143,000 bald eagles in the U.S. and 40,000 golden eagles.
http://www.sfgate.com/nation/article/New-federal-rule-would-permit-thousands-of-eagle-7393933.php

It seems that the eagle population is not a part of the environment worth protecting.
What could they do to make wind turbines less attractive for eagles? Surely something can be done!
What I don't understand is that every time I have seen a video of a wind turbine, the rotor seems to be moving so slowly, yet the article indicates that they could be spinning at 170 mph at the tips.
Buzz
I have seen that appear to be turning quite slowly as well, but it is not nearly as windy in some areas than others so I can believe that top speed.
Appreciate the feedback
There is an optical illusion effect at work as well. You may see a windmill in the distance spinning, and do not realize just how big those blades are and just fast how those tips are moving.
I read an article a while back that Europe has addressed this problem with a new type of wind turbine.
I'll have to try to find it again.
Kavika
Thanks for checking I would be interested in that article.
We have some nesting areas for eagles around here and they are beautiful to watch in the air
Here is the article RIO. There are a number of others as well.
We have a nesting pair of eagles on the front of your property, about 50 years from the lake. We can watch they ''fishing'' quite often.
Should read ''our property'', not your property. LOL, stone fingers.
LOL, Kavika! Is that your new nickname? Mine is No-see-um!
It sure is my new name for today, Dowser. LOL
Kavika
Thanks
Though it can appear as though they’re turning at a slow, almost relaxed pace, wind-turbine blades actually move very rapidly: The outer tips of some turbines' blades can reach speeds of 179 mph (288 kilometers per hour) and can easily slice off an eagle's wing.
And when hawks, falcons and eagles are flying, they're usually looking down at the ground for prey, not glancing up to watch for a knifelike blade whipping down on them from above. "There is nothing in the evolution of eagles that would come near to describing a wind turbine," Grainger Hunt, a raptor specialist with the Peregrine Fund, told the AP.
"There has never been an opportunity to adapt to that sort of threat." - See more
at:
Maybe something more like this would scare the eagles away and keep them safe...
Dowser
Not sure how efficient it is, but is sure looks nice
Probably not terribly efficient, but maybe something that moves, with bright colors would scare away the eagles and other birds...
Probably not terribly efficient, but maybe something that moves, with bright colors would scare away the eagles and other birds...
Any approach that saves the eagles is a good idea to try in my view
I feel the same way! Also, the smaller birds! Some of these designs are not only beautiful, but make noise, and have LED lights attached to them, so they would be seen at night. I don't think it would take much to modify those we already have... And the power usage would be minimal...
Actually, I think solar energy has much more potential, and is really much better overall.
When first developed the solar cells were very expensive, but now apparently the cost has come considerably.
In addition to killing birds, wind turbine have moving parts, which I believe must eventually wear out.
Actually, I think solar energy has much more potential, and is really much better overall.
Not really ...
Why not?
(What to do on days sun isn't shining? Or-- transporting energy from sunny areas to far-away areas that are mostly cloudy?)
Why not ?
For one thing concentrating solar can kill birds too . For another , solar is not as "green" as wind power . I would go into more detail but that would be a derailing of the article we're on now .
Krishna
I think it depends on the area, the need and other variables but I like solar more than wind as well.
We have a huge windmill farm coming through the Banning Pass West of Palm Springs and yes sometimes Eagles and Hawks get killed. However that's certainly not the same thing as saying they're being killed on purpose or that anyone at the EPA (or Obama) doesn't think they're not worth protecting. Wind power is just too plentiful and renewable not to use and it is certainly a lot cleaner then generating electricity in a coal fired plant. I am concerned with Raptor deaths, but wind power is just one of many ways to generate electricity, plus under some circumstances they can be located off-shore. I like to think of all of the wildlife that is now not dying off because of polluted air. There are trade off on everything (nothing is free) and as technology advances we'll get a handle on this too.
Solar is good in smaller applications, but birds tend to fry flying over large solar farms. Some of the massive mirror light concentrating types being built in the desert are going to make the birds dying by getting hit by windmill blades look small.
No one has said that anyone is out to get the eagles and hawks but your point about big wind farms being killing machines is absolutely correct.
I favor solar, but that is just me
I also think eagles and hawks are beautiful birds would rather have them than a wind turbine.
I also think eagles and hawks are beautiful birds would rather have them than a wind turbine.
I don't know if there has been a study done (though I'm sure there will be if not yet), but it would seem to me that we can have both. And a wind farm is better then coal fired plants any day, IMHO. Also I did not say that wind farms are "killing machines", because I think the problem is being wildly over-exaggerated.
The numbers from the government are up above.
What is being exaggerated?
Dean
Unless you can provide context and a source for your photograph it is simply another irrelevant useless offering
Keeping looking up it usually just goes over your head.
Dean
Provide a source so that the photo can be authenticated or it is nothing but political hyperbole, rhetoric and drivel
Is it a problem? Certainly. Is it being addressed? Absolutely. Would we be better off without wind farms? Not if they are properly installed.
Randy
No one said they should be banned, but there needs to be a way of creating ro locating them that protects the bird population.