World's Most Famous Liar Says Hillary Clinton Wants To Abolish The 2nd Amendment
If Donald Trump has proven one thing it’s that he is a master of control. He learns keywords that keep simple people focused on him like kittens to a shiny object. He’s figured out that ANY question can be answered with, “We’re gonna do it better.” He doesn’t need to provide explanations to people who don’t understand the federal government outside of the guy they contract with to deliver the mail.
Trump’s carefully crafted message full of 4th-grade vocabulary appeals to ignorant bigots, uneducated racists and angry xenophobes. Those people all happen to be, or are now registered as, Republicans. Trump chose the Republican party because you don’t need facts to win with their base. His campaign was a joke at first and spun into the colossus of stupid that it is now, all built on bullying and lies. Now that it looks like Clinton is going to be his opponent, Trump has begun selling what will turn out to be an effective lie for the conservative base: Hillary Clinton wants to abolish the 2nd Amendment.
The Hill reports that at an event in Washington, Trump officially appealed to the gun nuts of America with a preposterous lie that, if his record is any indication, he will NEVER retract:
“Hillary Clinton wants to abolish the Second Amendment. She wants to abolish it. Hillary Clinton wants to take your guns away and she wants to abolish the Second Amendment. She wants to take the bullets away.”
Trump went on to tell the crowd how much we should all cherish the 2nd Amendment. By moving the conversation from racism, xenophobia and fear directly to guns, Trump is making a dangerous connection for some very stupid people. If the idiots who believe the right to beat up protestors you disagree with is in the Constitution, what are the chances they won’t show their support for Trump’s favorite amendment and show up armed? They won’t get in, but they could engage in some friendly banter outside and maybe shoot someone. That makes America great.

forthcoming Trump mailers, probably
It's not just Hillary a large portion of Democrats in government want total control and to strip us of all of our freedoms. Hillary is no friend of the gun lover. Even Bernie has spoken out about her desires to grab our guns. If not for Republican obstructionism saving our freedoms Obama would have been leading the charge in taking our guns. He tried and fell flat on his face.
lol
"Clinton is in favor of universal background checks, closing loopholes on gun purchases and increasing restrictions on domestic abusers and the mentally ill. And she wants to repeal the law that prevents victims of gun violence from suing retailers or manufacturers, among other measures.
But Clinton said at a recent event that "we can't ignore the Second Amendment" and has never proposed ending legal gun ownership entirely.
After Trump's comments, Clinton spokesman Jesse Lehrich tweeted that the presumptive GOP nominee has "no regard for facts.""
Clinton has stated the Supreme Court is wrong and doesn't give an individual right to own firearms. She has also voiced support for laws similar to Australia'a gun confiscation. She's certainly wants to destroy the way the Second Amendment is interpreted and leave it as a meaningless husk. So Trump's right.
No surprise the left wing hate site got it wrong in it's attempt to pander to it's far, far leftwing readers that can't handle honest discussion. When you pander to bottom feeders, you get tripe like this.
Clinton has stated the Supreme Court is wrong and doesn't give an individual right to own firearms. She has also voiced support for laws similar to Australia'a gun confiscation. She's certainly wants to destroy the way the Second Amendment is interpreted and leave it as a meaningless husk. So Trump's right.
Can you post a source? I'd like to read about that.
I believe it's Alex Jone B.S. … but I'm open if there's legitimate documentation.
When Heller was decided by the Supreme Court nine years ago, and four of the nine justices had the opinion that the second amendment does not affirm the right to individual gun ownership, no one said that those justices wanted to abolish the amendment. They were voicing their extremely educated interpretation of the second amendment.
Similarly, whatever opinion Clinton has about individual gun rights does not mean she wants to abolish the amendment. If the amendment were abolished there would be no more Supreme Court decisions about it, so that would be a big deal.
Clinton has never advocated abolishing the second amendment, so when Trump says she does he is flat out lying.
inton has never advocated abolishing the second amendmentl
If you take away the individual right to own a gun and allow the government to confiscate guns (Australia) you've effectively abolished the Second Amendment, whether you bother to formally repeal it or not.
Let's say politician A gives a speech acknowledging that Roe V. Wade is the law but arguing that any Doctor who preforms an abortion should go to jail and speaks positively about the laws of Country B where all abortion is illegal, because those laws work great. Is Candidate B lying if he says candidate A wants to overrule Roe v. Wade, even though he never said he wanted it overruled?
Sean, 45% of the Supreme Court said that there is no individual right to own guns. Did they want to abolish the second amendment, or did they interpret it differently than you do?
John's position in a nutshell, Hillary doesn't want to abolish the Second Amendment, she just wants to strip it of all meaning and make it legal for the government to confiscate guns.
I haven't looked up her quotes on the topic yet, so I don't have an opinion on her position, other than to note that the dissent in Heller did not advocate abolishing the second amendment. You don't seem to understand that.
Trump's a fricking bald liar. Deal with it Sean.
If there's no individual right to posses firearms (the dissent's position that Clinton supports) then the Second Amendment is meaningless.
Trump is a liar, but not here. She would abolish second amendment protections and rights given the chance.
Trump is a liar, but not here.
He is an obvious liar here.
"VOTER: Back to handguns. Recently, Australia managed to get away, or take away tens of thousands, millions of handguns. In one year, they were all gone. Can we do that? If we can’t, why can’t we?
HILLARY CLINTON: Australia is a good example, Canada is a good example, the U.K. is a good example . Why? Each of them have had mass killings. Australia had a huge mass killing about 20-25 years ago, Canada did as well, so did the U.K. In reaction, they passed much stricter gun laws.
In the Australian example, as I recall, that was a buyback program . The Australian government, as part of trying to clamp down on the availability of automatic weapons, offered a good price for buying hundreds of thousands of guns. Then, they basically clamped down, going forward, in terms of having more of a background check approach, more of a permitting approach, but they believe, and I think the evidence supports them, that by offering to buyback those guns, they were able to curtail the supply and set a different standard for gun purchases in the future.
Communities have done that in our country, several communities have done gun buyback programs. I think it would be worth considering doing it on the national level , if that could be arranged. After the terrible 2008 financial crisis, one of the programs that President Obama was able to get in place was Cash for Clunkers. You remember that? It was partially a way to get people to buy new cars because we wanted more economic activity, and to get old models that were polluting too much, off the roads. So I think that’s worth considering . I do not know enough detail to tell you how we would do it, or how would it work, but certainly your example is worth looking at . [Applause]"
"Communities have done that in our country, several communities have done gun buyback programs. I think it would be worth considering doing it on the national level , if that could be arranged."
So what Clinton actually advocated was making local American programs that buyback guns into a national program. She compares it to Cash For Clunkers. Were people forced to sell their cars in Cash For Clunkers?
Where in this exchange do you see her advocating specifically the Australian model?
Q: Did gun control in Australia lead to more murders there last year?
A: This ‘Gun History Lesson’ is recycled bunk from a decade ago. Murders in Australia actually are down to record lows.
FULL QUESTION
Is this true??
FULL ANSWER
The e-mail says that "[i]t has now been 12 months since gun owners in Australia were forced by new law to surrender 640,381 personal firearms." Actually, it’s been 13 years since Australian gun law was originally changed. In 1996, the government banned some types of guns, instituted a buyback program and imposed stricter licensing and registration requirements. Gun ownership rates in Australia declined from 7 percent to 5 percent . Another law in 2002 tightened restrictions a bit more, restricting caliber, barrel length and capacity for sport shooting handguns.
Have murders increased since the gun law change, as claimed? Actually, Australian crime statistics show a marked decrease in homicides since the gun law change. According to the Australian Institute of Criminology, a government agency, the number of homicides in Australia did increase slightly in 1997 and peaked in 1999, but has since declined to the lowest number on record in 2007, the most recent year for which official figures are available.
Let's look at how the NRA lied about Clinton's comments
This is from an NRA site quoting Clinton
" “The Australian example,” she said, “that was a buyback program.” She went on to explain that the Australian government “offered a good price” for “buying hundreds of thousands of guns, and then they basically clamped down going forward … .” They were thus able, she explained, “to curtail the supply” of guns and “to set a different standard for gun purchases in the future.”
Here in America, she went on, “I think it would be worth considering doing it on the national level if that could be arranged.” She compared the Australian and U.K. regimes to local gun “buybacks” and to Obama’s own “cash for clunkers” program, in which Americans were offered tax credits for trading older, gas-guzzling vehicles for newer, fuel-efficient models. “So I think that’s worth considering,” Clinton said. “I don’t know enough details to tell you … how we would do it or how it would work, but certainly the Australian example is worth looking at.”"
What did the NRA leave out? The most crucial sentence between her description of the Australia program and her saying it would be "worth considering".
"Communities have done that in our country, several communities have done gun buyback programs."
The NRA left out that key sentence, in order to make it look like Clinton was endorsing gun confiscation as they see it occurring in Australia.
Then it is off to the races in the right wing internet and media.
A lie is born.
John's position in a nutshell, Hillary doesn't want to abolish the Second Amendment, she just wants to strip it of all meaning and make it legal for the government to confiscate guns.
John didn't say that -- YOU SAID HE SAID THAT!
Again, please post her exact statement and where/when she specifically said she wanted to abolish the Second Amendment.
John didn't say that -- YOU SAID HE SAID THAT!
Yes, I was summarizing his position. That's the essence of his argument.
This is what Clinton said, as opposed to what you and other right wingers imagine or spin.
"Communities have done that in our country, several communities have done gun buyback programs. I think it would be worth considering doing it on the national level, if that could be arranged."
That is apparently the sum total of her announced desire to confiscate guns. Sean, what US communities have had mandatory gun buybacks? I couldn't find any. Since Clinton was clearly referring to American communities as the model for a gun buyback, she wasn't talking about confiscation. This was another right wing lie that went "viral".
Australia instituted a gun confiscation program. She spoke favorably about it. This is what she said:
The issue came up again on Friday when Mrs Clinton was campaigning in New Hampshire (a state whose number plate slogan is "Live Free or Die"). A man in a public meeting asked her why the US could not follow Australia's lead and ban certain types of guns.
"Can we do that? If we can't, why can't we?" a man asked.
"Australia is a good example, Canada is a good example, the UK is a good example," Mrs Clinton responded.
"Why? Each of them have had mass killings. Australia had a huge mass killing about 20 to 25 years ago. Canada did as well. So did the UK. In reaction, they passed much stricter gun laws.
I read the entire exchange. There is nothing in there about Clinton advocating mandatory gun buybacks.
At the ONE POINT where she is talking about "considering" a program, she is talking about local US communities , and then she says we could consider this on a national (as opposed to local) basis.
"Australia is a good example, Canada is a good example, the UK is a good example," Mrs Clinton responded.
Yes, I was summarizing his position. That's the essence of his argument.
That's incorrect, Sean; you were mischaracterizing his position by unfair extrapolation.
Rather than put words in someone's mouth, just say what you think, not what you think someone else thinks.
Moving goal posts ?
If you take away the individual right to own a gun and allow the government to confiscate guns (Australia) you've effectively abolished the Second Amendment, whether you bother to formally repeal it or not.
If my grandmother had had testicles she would have been my grandfather!
Where burden of proof is required to substantiate an allegation, starting with the word "IF" renders the charge untenable.
But, since you care to predicate on "ifs," I'll give you a list.
Let's begin:
The late Justice Antonin Scalia proclaimed “handguns are the most popular weapon chosen by Americans for self-defense in the home, and a complete prohibition of their use is invalid.” Scalia though went on to endorse a laundry list of gun regulation including bans on automatic weapons and sawed-off shotguns as implicitly constitutional.
So, IF Scalila were alive and an AMENDMENT TO THE CONSTITUTION WERE TO BE ADDED STATING "The AMENDMENT PROHIBITING the Sale, Purchase, Possession of, and, or any/all forms of access to automatic weapons, sawed-off shotguns, etc. as well as weapons/devices of similar or greater destructive power … this to any but individuals or entities of bona fide law enforcement … " Scalia would write, "The Amendment is upheld as 'constitutional'."
Scalia, then, was moving towards supporting the repeal of the 2nd Amendment.
I mean if he wrote the Heller thing, what else could it imply?
_________________________________________________
Next on the list, if I so decide, will "if" Mr. Trump's ass.
I'm assuming Clinton is able to articulate her beliefs and preferred policies in her speeches. She's said Heller (individual right to own firearms) was wrongly decided and spoken favorably about Australia's gun confiscation law. Those policies are incompatible with the Second Amendment as it is understood.
Or was she lying when she made those statements? Hard to tell with her, I know.
I'm assuming Clinton is able to articulate her beliefs and preferred policies in her speeches. She's said Heller (individual right to own firearms) was wrongly decided and spoken favorably about Australia's gun confiscation law. Those policies are incompatible with the Second Amendment as it is understood.
What is incontrovertibly understood is that she didn't say she wants the repeal of the Second Amendment.
If she had said "drunk driving is a danger," would that have meant she wanted to reinstate prohibition and ban motor vehicles?
incontrovertibly understood is that she didn't say she wants the repeal of the Second Amendment.
Why would she want to repeal it? She simply wants to render in meaningless and strip it of all protections and rights for citizens and leave it as a hollow shell with no purpose. You seem
It's the same thing at the end of the day whether the Amendment is formally repealed or it's protections are eviscerated like she favors.
drunk driving is a danger," would that have meant she wanted to reinstate prohibition and ban motor vehicles
No, but if she claims that laws that allow individuals to own cars and buy booze are wrong and she thinks those countries that ban automobiles and booze have a good idea, than yeah, it's fair to say she wants to ban automobiles and booze.
No, but if she claims that laws that allow individuals to own cars and buy booze are wrong and she thinks those countries that ban automobiles and booze have a good idea, than yeah, it's fair to say she wants to ban automobiles and booze.
In your biased, pre-determined way of wanting to believe what you want to believe … characterizing/concluding something is so on the basis of "it's fair to say" -- is your opinion, not proof.
But in reality and in law, if you cannot prove she said something, it's "hearsay," conjecture, wishful thinking.
So why not be forthcoming and state that "it's what you believe," but you have no proof?
You guys did this all the time and create ill will simply because you're not willing to separate editorialization, political bias, opinion … or just plain partisan b.s. from verifiable fact.
Similarly, whatever opinion Clinton has about individual gun rights does not mean she wants to abolish the amendment. If the amendment were abolished there would be no more Supreme Court decisions about it, so that would be a big deal.
Clinton has never advocated abolishing the second amendment, so when Trump says she does he is flat out lying.
I'm waiting for one of those among us who believes that Clinton wants to repeal the 2nd Amendment, to just document it.
Although Clinton has never made any statement in support of abolishing the second amendment or confiscating the personal firearms of citizens, she has stated that Heller v District of Columbia, a case where the supreme court overturned Washington DC’s ban on handguns by a 5-4 vote, was wrongly decided. In that case, the court held that the second amendment provided for an individual right to bear arms and the late Justice Antonin Scalia proclaimed “handguns are the most popular weapon chosen by Americans for self-defense in the home, and a complete prohibition of their use is invalid.” Scalia though went on to endorse a laundry list of gun regulation including bans on automatic weapons and sawed-off shotguns as implicitly constitutional.
____________________________________________________
I think it might be fun to begin some discussions with a particle of truth … then spin the shit out of it and see how those who do so regularly react.
As we see from your post Mac, Clinton has a different opinion about the second amendment than the gun rights people do. But her opinion is in keeping with almost half of the Supreme Court so it is hardly a tiny minority opinion.
The most important thing is that Clinton does not advocate the abolishing of the amendment, thus she establishes her belief in and acceptance of the rule of law and the SCOTUS decision.
Trump lies about it the way he lies about many things, brazenly and unapologetically.
The article isn't about who does or doesn't want gun control. The article is about Trump being a hopeless liar.
Yeah tell that to everyone else who posted.
And which one is the worlds most famous liar, Hillary or Trump? seems to me they are tied in that department.
I tried.
“Hillary Clinton wants to abolish the Second Amendment. She wants to abolish it. Hillary Clinton wants to take your guns away and she wants to abolish the Second Amendment. She wants to take the bullets away.”
That is a lie. Just a plain lie. An obvious lie. What's the problem? No intelligent person is dumb enough to believe that, are they?
If you do not like Hillary Clinton and think she lies, it does not change the fact that the above statement by Trump is an out and out lie.
You don't even begin to understand my point.
It's the political silly season, justification for everyone to spew all the embedded hatred of everything they do not believe in against everyone who doesn't believe the same as they.
This article is just another example of it.
And this is just the beginning and I'm already sick of it.
One word. Valium.
Besides I was not responding to you or any of your points in any manner. It was not made as a reply to anyone's comment. It was a general statement. Bit egotistical of you to think I was addressing you isn't it?
I said;
And which one is the worlds most famous liar, Hillary or Trump? seems to me they are tied in that department.
YOU SAID:
If you do not like Hillary Clinton and think she lies, it does not change the fact that the above statement by Trump is an out and out lie.
Just because you put it in a new thread doesn't mean it wasn't a direct response to the point I made.
What, are we all supposed to be brainless?
Or is this the typical childish slop we are going to have to deal with the next 7 months.
You DO have a big ego, don't you! It was not, no matter how much you think of yourself, any response to anything you had posted. It simply was not. Grow up a little.
It was a general statement about the title of the article. If I wanted to address something to you, I would have.
Right. Lay that on someone else. (they might be stupid enough to believe it)
You honestly believe I was responding to you? Really? Wow! That's incredible! Hey, whatever makes your socks roll up and down, but there are people here who make comments that are not centered around you. Surprise, you are not the only person who posts on this site and the site does not revolve around what you do post, though you sure seem to think so!
Right, Insults really make your argument more valid.
I made a point, you responded to that point.
Nothing to do about my ego, except my valid point is minimized, and you attempt to disguise it and change the argument to me instead of my point.
Typical liberal tripe.
I expected better out of you, maybe that was too much to ask given the atmosphere of answering to the salivating bell.
I'm done here.
I'm no longer going to enter the pisspot the rest of you seem bound and determined to drag everything into.
Morning NWM.....
Yes, it is silly season, and it will be for the next seven months.
But to your point, is it not correct to point out, call, uncover, discredit, or shine the light on the lies the candidates make? If we don't, aren't we then as bad as the liars?
As I have said, we have a number here on NT that don't care about the truth, just the message. I know that both of care about the truth, and that truth is usually one of the first casualties in politics.
Unfortunately Fly, there are a lot of people I care about here, some of them I call friends, that seem to want to wallow in it the same as those that shovel it.
It is very difficult and heartbreaking to read.....
Very sad.
What are you talking about? Maybe you woke up on the wrong side of the bed this morning.
You have a point, and one that is on display here on NT everyday.
It is the same reason we have what we have to vote for this year too. People hear what they want to hear. The real shame is that to get closer to the truth doesn't really take that much effort.
Unfortunately Fly, there are a lot of people I care about here, some of them I call friends, that seem to want to wallow in it the same as those that shovel it.
When a definitive claim, charge, allegation or alleged statement of fact is made, in the absence of direct, supporting information, in the absence of PROOF, it is only logical that a reasonable, thinking individual would insist on those supporting the charge, colloquially speaking … "shit or get off the pot"!
Instead, what lives among us are those who not only post unsubstantiated bullshit, but, who then rely on a cadre of supporters to annoy, mock and insult anyone who dares to debunk, question or outright call for verification of a claim.
Wait for it …
A-Mac.... You and NWM are some of the best, and most thoughtful people here on NT. Yes, we need to challenge the bullshit that others want to pass off as truth. We also need to avoid getting ourselves pulled into the same stuff to where we are throwing it rather than trying to dispense with it.
It's going to be a long nasty seven months. All we can hope for is that our mental faculties stay intact to where we still know shit from shinola, and on the first Wednesday in November, there are people we still respect and want to converse with here.
Go move some goal posts . Your vague references are not worth the time to read .
This is another good example of the "a pox on both your houses" bs of which there is a constant attempt by some here to make relevant.
This article is about Trump lying about Hillary Clinton. I am the one who took the time to go and look up the relevant quotes about it, and it is clear that , even using the right's own source material, which was a Clinton townhall exchange, she never claimed to want to abolish the second amendment or confiscate guns through a mandatory buyback.
People who don't want to address the topic can leave the thread.
Trump is just worried about the big tywanical gubbamint taking his favorite gun ... the one that fits so well in his hand.
LMAO, perfect.
World's most famous liar? There is a bigger liar out there than Hilary? Or she she talking about herself again?
World's most famous liar? There is a bigger liar out there than Hilary? Or she she talking about herself again?
Whether that hyperbole is true or not, it does not address the fact that there is no proof of Trump's claim.
The usual dismissive comment.
You could always move some goal posts ...