╌>

Veteran Campaign Reporters: “The Stakes Are Too High” To Let Trump Get Away With Constant Lying

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  johnrussell  •  10 years ago  •  9 comments

Veteran Campaign Reporters: “The Stakes Are Too High” To Let Trump Get Away With Constant Lying


 


Veteran Campaign Reporters: “The Stakes Are Too High” To Let Trump Get Away With Constant Lying




Veteran campaign reporters are calling on media outlets to sharply increase their fact-checking of presumptive Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump, telling  Media Matters  “the stakes are too high” to let Trump get away with peddling conspiracy theories and near-constant falsehoods.

In the week since Trump’s win in the Indiana presidential primary essentially clinched the nomination for him, the candidate has faced criticism from media critics and fact-checkers for his continued embrace of outlandish conspiracy theories. CNN’s Brian Stelter  on Sunday  called on journalists to  confront  Trump “head-on” over his misinformation.  Washington Post  fact checker Glenn Kessler hit a similar note in a May 7  article , writing that outlets have “no excuse” to let Trump get away with falsehoods.

In conversations with  Media Matters , Kessler and several veteran presidential campaign reporters highlighted the sheer tonnage of misinformation from Trump, with several arguing that outlets need to be more aggressive when challenging the Republican.

“The Trump lies are so many and they come out at such a rapid fire, Gatling-gun fashion, it is hard for the reporters to keep up in May. I can just imagine what it will be like in October,” said Walter Shapiro, who covered nine presidential campaigns dating back to 1980 for  The Washington Post, Newsweek,  Salon and others. “The most important thing is that you don’t put the fact checks in some separate envelope done by the fact-check expert. You have to put as many fact checks as you can in the story of the speech, in the story of the assertion and if necessary don’t resort to euphemisms, like ‘misspoke.’ He did not misspeak, he did not obfuscate, he did not miss the meaning -- he lied.”

Trump’s falsehoods and conspiracies have piled up over the course of the campaign, running the gamut from his repeated (and  often unchallenged ) boast that he opposed the Iraq War from the beginning to more bizarre claims like his recent  embrace  of a  National Enquirer  conspiracy linking Sen. Ted Cruz’s father to JFK assassin Lee Harvey Oswald.

“These are totally different problems than we have ever faced before,” Shapiro said about covering Trump. “I give lots of news organization in the months ahead a lot of latitude because we have never dealt with someone for whom truth is as dispensable as Kleenex in politics.”

He said part of the problem is when news outlets carry Trump speeches and rallies live, which by nature prevents immediate fact-checking.

“The problem is if the networks are going to give you one hour of unedited access a night, there is no way for the fact checks to catch up,” he said. “There are dictators who control the media who have less access than he does.”

David Yepsen, a former top political reporter for the  Des Moines Register  for 34 years, said news outlets need to “double-down on fact-checking” as the campaign continues.

“News organizations can take each one of these statements apart,” Yepsen said via email. “They can't be blown off or dismissed. The tone has to be calm, factual, but dispassionate and methodical. Reporters need to keep the focus on Trump and his statements.”

He later added, “It is also going to be critically important to get this debate out on social media. It's more important than a lot of reporters want to admit because more and more people are getting information about the campaign in this way.” 

Adam Clymer, a former  New York Times  campaign reporter from 1977 to 2003, said the lack of scrutiny in the past is due to time pressures and poor editing, but that cannot continue.

Asked how journalists can counter him going forward, Clymer said, “By repeating after every time he says it that ‘Mr. Trump has offered no evidence of his theory that has been debunked by X, Y, or Z.’”

“Somebody’s got to be responsible,” Clymer urged. “Everything about his substance becomes more important when someone may be the nominee.”

He added, “Since Trump makes more stuff up than most people, he becomes a particularly glaring example of the press’ shortcomings. Do the basic job, which is different than what they have been. But it is not just reporters, don’t let editors off the hook at all levels.”

“He is off the charts,” said Kessler, who writes  The Fact Checker column  for  The Washington Post .

Of the 34 fact-checks done on Trump in the column, nearly 70 percent have resulted in four Pinocchios, which is the site’s worst rating, Kessler said. “Your average politician gets 10 percent to 20 percent of their ratings as four Pinocchios.”

At  PolitiFact.com , the Pulitzer Prize-winning fact-checking site, 62 percent of Trump comments that were reviewed received either False or “Pants on Fire,” its worst rating.

Angie Holan, PolitiFact editor, says no other 2016 presidential candidate even comes close.

“The results are the results, he’s wrong pretty regularly,” she said. “He gets small details wrong, too. He said the trade deficit with China is $500 billion. It’s not, it’s $300 billion. That’s quite a bit to be wrong. You add up wrong on big things and wrong on little things and that’s how he gets such a bad record.”

Kessler agreed the answer is for reporters to increase their scrutiny as they would any unreliable source .   

“He says this stuff and keeps saying it,” Kessler said. “There is little excuse for not saying something to him when, for instance, he says he was against the war in Iraq or that Hillary Clinton started the birther movement -- things that have been fact-checked and found to be bogus.”

And Trump’s falsehoods are nothing new, according to people who covered him in the 1980s when he was a rising real estate mogul and New York gossip page regular.

Among those was Susan Mulcahy, former editor of the  New York Post ’s Page Six from 1983 to 1985. She recently penned  a piece  for Politico  recounting his history of lies.

Her advice to today’s campaign reporters who must cover him through Election Day: “Every statement that he makes has to be checked. Even mundane, innocuous things.”

She suggested treating him as a lawyer would a witness on the stand, saying “be prepared for answers to some of the questions ahead of time,” later adding that lying “doesn’t bother him, he has been doing this for so long.”

Walter Mears, a Pulitzer Prize-winning former Associated Press campaign reporter, said the challenge is for journalists to scrutinize him more than most candidates because of his poor factual record.

“It requires more homework covering a guy like this, and the trouble with Trump is you never know what he is going to make up next,” Mears said. “It is not argumentative to say that Trump is lying, it is not argumentative if you state the actual fact.”

Clark Hoyt, a former reporter and editor for Knight Ridder and McClatchy -- who covered presidential races in 1968, 1972, and 1976 -- said Trump’s level of dishonesty is unprecedented in American politics and requires a demand for truth.

“If he says something that is demonstrably false it should immediately be called that. We have an obligation to even point out the history of these things, that this has been a pattern with Trump and not to let readers or viewers forget it. The stakes are too high,” said Hoyt, also a former public editor for  The New York Times . “You have to be prepared to say what he says and then say what the truth is. That puts a great burden on news organizations to be really fast on their feet with research and the resources to dig into some of these things.”

Al Tompkins, a senior faculty member at The Poynter Institute, said reporters need to stick to the basics and not let lies pass by unchecked.

“He does seem to say a lot of things that just simply are not true,” said Tompkins. “He has a very high negative and part of that negative seems to be his demeanor, but also whether or not he can be trusted.”

Media Matters  recently highlighted several other examples of journalism experts and veteran reporters calling on the media to fact-check Trump more effectively: 

 

 



Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    10 years ago

Unfortunately, this is going to have to become a major issue in the campaign. Donald Trump lies more often than any other presidential candidate in history. His supporters CLEARLY want to hide their heads in the sand about this , but the bitter truth must prevail before this disaster (a Trump presidency) has the chance to approach the explosion point. 

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    10 years ago

“The Trump lies are so many and they come out at such a rapid fire, Gatling-gun fashion, it is hard for the reporters to keep up in May. I can just imagine what it will be like in October,” said Walter Shapiro, who covered nine presidential campaigns dating back to 1980 for The Washington Post, Newsweek, Salon and others. "

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    10 years ago

I'm not pleased with a Trump-Clinton contest. I cannot think of what would prompt me to vote for either one. It's truly a sorry dilemma. I'm pretty sure that I stand with many in our nation. I could make a decision by November, or just sit it out. I've got a few months to decide, but it's really not a happy decision.

Trump is a bullshit artist, but of the street variety. He's telling falsehoods, but he does it in a manner that many people do colloquially on a frequent basis. If I say that Anthony Rizzo has it 15 home runs already this year, but he's only hit 12, does that make me a liar? No, not really. I might be full of shit, but I'm not a liar.

Trump speaks in hyperbole. He invents things as he goes a long. He's a bullshit artist. It's a city boy streetcorner type of banter. I have had friends like that. And yes, when they spewed their bullshit, we called them out on it, and that was it. Or not. Sometimes they'd keep repeating the same bullshit, because they didn't care. Trump is the same, and he doesn't care.

The theory that this will somehow backfire on him in a debate with Hillary is laughable. Hillary has a record in the Senate. She's told lies, and they are documented. If lying is brought up in the debate, by either party, the other one will be exposed, and a pissing contest will ensue. More joy going into the worst election in my lifetime.

You see, they all lie. Every one, without exception has done it. It's not news.

Move on.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    10 years ago

Where have the "veteran campaign reporters" been for the last 8 years?

The Obama administration just rubbed their noses in the dirt over the weekend about how they lied to them to get them to support the Iran agreement and they are fine with it. 

It's amusing that reporters suddenly discovered they are upset about a candidate lying. After the amount of water they've carried for Clinton/Obama, they have no grounds to criticize a candidate for lying. 

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell  replied to  Sean Treacy   10 years ago

Sean, it is a character issue with Trump. He is a habitual LIAR. It is part of his narcissistic personality. 

Keep hiding your head in the sand. 

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    10 years ago

Trump lies constantly, because , being an extreme narcissist , the "truth" is whatever he said last. 

It is not a simple matter of him being a b.s. artist. 

How could anyone in government believe any of his promises to them? How can the people who vote for him believe any of his promises to THEM ? 

When the wall isn't built and the Muslims are not banned, he will just say they were "negotiating points" and not promises. 

There is a video of Trump lying about having the best "hand picked" instructors for his real estate "university". He never had any intention of having "the best" people be involved, for one thing it would have cost him too much money. 

He says I have the best this , the best that - much of it is in his imagination. You call it b.s..     Why should we have a habitual b.s. 'er , who does this dozens of times every day, as president of the United States?

He is utterly disqualified, far far far far far beyond anything similar that can be said about Hillary Clinton. 

 

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

He says I have the best this , the best that - much of it is in his imagination. You call it b.s..     Why should we have a habitual b.s. 'er , who does this dozens of times every day, as president of the United States?

They all lie to get what they want. They lie when they campaign. They lie while in office.

Every single candidate. Every single elected President. Democrats. Republicans.

All of them.

This is not unique, save for style.

 
 
 
pat wilson
Professor Quiet
link   pat wilson    10 years ago

Just "shared" that video on FB. Everyone should.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    10 years ago

Trump Doesn't Regret McCain Comments: My Poll Numbers Went Up! (AUDIO)

Gll0yx5t5eyh5gisrqqx
AP Photo / Jeff Chiu

 
 

During an appearance on "Imus in the Morning"  flagged by BuzzFeed News , radio host Don Imus asked Trump if he would apologize for his comments about POWs, as McCain asked called for him to do in a  Sunday  show appearance.

Trump said that he feels he's already apologized and called McCain a hero.

“Well I’ve actually done that, Don,” the presumptive GOP nominee replied. “You know frankly, I like John McCain and John McCain is a hero. Also, heroes are people that are, you know, whether they get caught or don’t get caught—they’re all heroes as far as I’m concerned. And that’s the way it should be.”

But when Imus asked if Trump regretted his comments, Trump said he didn't, pointing out that his poll numbers went up afterwards and arguing people agreed with him.

“I don’t, you know—I like not to regret anything,” Trump said. “You do things and you say things. And what I said, frankly, is what I said. And some people like what I said, if you want to know the truth. There are many people that like what I said. You know after I said that, my poll numbers went up seven points.”

 

-------------------------------------------

 

Trump is admitting that the things he says don't mean anything, they just exist until some later time when he will say the opposite, because he just says things. The only thing that mattered about his slander of McCain was that his poll numbers went up. 

Trump admits this and then laughs in our faces. Anyone who votes for him will be helping to perpetrate the biggest national shame in our political history. 

 
 

Who is online



95 visitors