╌>

Trump won't release his tax returns to voters. But to get a casino license ...

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  jwc2blue  •  10 years ago  •  15 comments

Trump won't release his tax returns to voters. But to get a casino license ...

http://www.dailykos.com/stories/2016/5/12/1525791/-Trump-won-t-release-his-tax-returns-to-voters-State-gambling-officials-are-another-story

Donald Trump’s  claim  that “there’s nothing to learn” from his tax returns is ludicrous on its face. Here’s a guy running for president basically on the claim that he’s the richest and the savviest businessman ever to make a deal, and voters wouldn’t learn anything from his tax returns? Snort.

As the  Washington Post ’s fact checker points out, we’d learn how much money Trump actually makes (as opposed to his likely inflated claims), where his income comes from, how much he gives to charity, and how aggressively he games the tax system to his benefit. We’d also learn a little something about Trump’s willingness to live up to his years of promises that he’d totally be happy to release his tax returns eventually at some future point. 

But while Trump says he won’t release his tax returns to mere voters—something every presidential candidate for 40 years has done—that doesn’t mean he’s never released them to anyone.


Trump has handed over tax returns in the midst of audits before -- to state gambling officials in Pennsylvania and New Jersey, as part of the process of seeking casino licenses in those states.


That’s right. Donald Trump will release his tax returns to get a casino license, but not to be elected president.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    10 years ago

Another smart move by Trump not doing what Tom, Dick and Harry did just because Tom, Dick and Harry did it. 

He's showing he's the real Maverick not just more of the same. 

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    10 years ago

Personally I could give a crap about Trump's or Clinton's tax returns - irrelevant to the ability or inability of either to be an effective president.

I am more worried about and interested in what the two of them will do to improve my tax situation - real tax code reform fair to all - than whether they contributed to charity, or deducted travel expenses or whatever.  This is political drama for television and campaign slogans at its very best.

And technically I do not believe there is a requirement for a candidate to release tax returns, rather only to complete FEC income information forms.

Individual income tax returns — including those of public figures — are private information, protected by law from unauthorized disclosure. Indeed, the Internal Revenue Service is barred from releasing any taxpayer information whatsoever, except to authorized agencies and individuals.

Like all other citizens, U.S. presidents enjoy this protection of their privacy. Since the early 1970s, however, most presidents have chosen to release their returns publicly.

This is more a tradition and not everyone observes the same traditions in our great country.

I do not see this in the top ten of key issues that persuade voters to vote one way or the other.  This is more a filler issue, meant to incite and anger when one side or the other does nto want to talk about the real issues of the country.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell  replied to  Robert in Ohio   10 years ago

There have been about 50 presidential candidates (at least) since 1976. Every one of them has released their tax returns.

Again, (as I said last night), WTF is Donald Trump to say no to something that 50 out of 50 people before him have done?

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

John

There is no legal requirement to do so, so Mr. Trump can choose to release or not release (s he wishes) and he must be prepared to pay the consequences for his actions.

He gets to decide - not you or past candidates or political pundits in the press; he decides what to do and the voters then decide what weight to put on his decision one way or the other.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell  replied to  Robert in Ohio   10 years ago

RIO, I don't think anyone needs you to tell them that Trump is not required by any law to release his tax returns as he runs for president. Whether or not he is legally required to is not the issue.

 

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell    10 years ago

What We Can Learn From Donald Trump’s Unreleased Tax Returns

Justin Wolfers
Donald Trump has said he won’t release his tax returns before the November election. Nathaniel Brooks for The New York Times

One of the constants of modern elections is that presidential candidates have released their recent tax returns . There is no law requiring this. This transparency is based on a norm. It’s a norm that has persisted through all modern elections, even among candidates who have suffered a degree of political embarrassment.

But Donald Trump has told The Associated Press that he does not expect to release his tax returns before the election, citing a continuing audit. Despite earlier assurances that he would release them, his stated argument is that “there’s nothing to learn from them.”

There may indeed be nothing interesting to learn from Mr. Trump’s returns. But economic theory about the incentives for disclosure suggests that voters may reach the opposite conclusion. After all, choosing not to disclose something is an action that reveals something.

A thought experiment will help illustrate why. Let’s say that you are running for president, and your tax returns are the absolute classiest tax returns imaginable. Your income is honestly earned, you pay an appropriate amount of tax, you don’t use questionable tax maneuvers, and your returns show that you give generously to charities that do good work. In this situation, you want to release your tax returns so that the voters will think more highly of you.

What if your tax returns are very classy, but not quite this classy? If you don’t release your returns, voters will infer that they’re not the very best tax returns. And if that’s all they know, they’ll infer that you’re in the middle of the pack of those who don’t disclose — that they’re merely pretty good. This means that if your returns are better than pretty good and you make your tax returns public, you’ll rise in the electorate’s estimation. And so you voluntarily reveal your returns, so that the voters learn that you’re better than they would otherwise think.

O.K., now we’re in a world in which everyone with at least pretty good tax returns makes them public. What if yours are only mildly embarrassing? If you don’t release them, the public will infer that your returns are definitely no better than “pretty good,” and perhaps much worse than that. But “mildly embarrassing” isn’t so bad compared with the universe of tax returns that are worse than “pretty good,” so you’re better off disclosing.

This explains why candidates like Mitt Romney and Hillary Clinton were willing to release their returns, despite revealing useful ammunition for their opponents. In each case, it was a savvy choice, because not revealing would have led voters to infer they were hiding something worse.

This incentive to disclose keeps cascading.

Those with the cleanest tax returns disclose, leading those with the next cleanest returns to disclose, so as to differentiate themselves from the dirtier non-disclosers. As more people disclose, the remaining pool of non-disclosers is even worse, and the least rotten among them will want to disclose to escape the inference that they have something to hide.

It’s disclosure all the way down .

If you’ve got the second-worst tax return imaginable, and everyone who is cleaner than you discloses, the public will infer that you’ve either got the worst or the second-worst possible return. Far better to clear up the confusion that you don’t have the most dishonorable tax return that’s possible, and so you also choose to release your tax returns.

Follow this logic, and you’re left to infer that the only person who won’t voluntarily release their tax returns must have the most to hide. It doesn’t just say that Mr. Trump has more to hide than Mrs. Clinton; it says that he has more to hide than any other candidate you could imagine.

Think about it. The problem for Mr. Trump is that the voters don’t know if he’s Honest Donald or some other Donald. But Mr. Trump knows. If he’s Honest Donald, he’ll release his tax returns to make sure that voters know that he’s neither dodgy nor deplorable. And if he’s dodgy, he will release his returns so that we know he’s not deplorable. Only Deplorable Donald — the worst possible Trump — has no incentive to disclose.

By this logic, a candidate would hide tax returns only if they paint a terrible picture about finances and integrity. (If there were the risk that Mr. Trump’s returns would reveal commercially valuable information, that would be a reason that he could be not-seedy yet still want to keep his returns private. He has yet to make this argument, though.)

You actually use this logic every day to make sure you don’t get ripped off. If I were offering to sell you a used car, and refused to let you take it for a test drive, what would you infer? It must be a dud, unable to even start. After all, even if it ran poorly, you would let me drive it, at least to reassure me that it actually does run.

Likewise, you wouldn’t buy stock in a company that refused to show you their books.

This same idea is why you demand the right to inspect a good before you buy it, or if it’s in a box, you demand the right to return it if it turns out to be a dud. You can’t return presidents, which is why voters have traditionally demanded the right to inspect them first.

There’s something distinct about information: Refusing to share it doesn’t keep voters in the dark. If they think about why, the choice not to reveal it is very revealing.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

There is NO question that his tax returns contain information presumed to be damaging to his candidacy. According to the logic of the article above, the tax returns are likely very damaging to his candidacy. Otherwise he would release them.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    10 years ago

So he doesn't release them. It's just one more ad the DNC can and will run against him. It'll be a "What does he have to hide?" ad and it will be very effective.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell  replied to  Randy   10 years ago

It is better forTrump to not release them, otherwise he would.

That is a fair assumption, although probably not foolproof.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    10 years ago

I was ready to vote for Romney the last cycle, but his refusal to release his tax records made me think he was involved as one of those that profited from hedge bets, and from vulture capitalization.  Things detrimental to the vast majority of American citizens. 

We don't need to be empowering the plutocracy.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  FLYNAVY1   10 years ago

I think he's afraid that people will find out he doesn't have as much money as he brags he does. One way or another, he is no doubt hiding something.

 
 

Who is online


94 visitors