Labor Substitution and the Digital Revolution
To borrow a phrase, these are the best of times, and they are the worst of times.
If you’re a technologist, the future has never looked brighter; whereas if a computer can do your job, there’s a lot of darkness out there ….
We are waking up to the implications of robots rapidly replacing manufacturing jobs. We’re starting to understand what it means for technology and offshoring to transform white-collar and manufacturing jobs.
The bad news is that few if any of us are aware of the ticking time-bomb that is the service sector tipping toward permanent joblessness. This is a problem that’s two to four times the order of magnitude of the loss in manufacturing and white-collar jobs.
Look around major airports. Look at parking garages, at fast-food and coffee chains. Look at hotel front desks. Attendants, cashiers, and desk clerks are going the way of the pay phone. A permanent percentage of these jobs are becoming automated. Where are all these laid off workers going to find work?
The forecast is daunting. By 2020 we will lose some seven million jobs—five million routine white-collar, administrative office roles; and two million manufacturing, production, and construction positions, according to “The Future of Jobs” by The World Economic Forum. At the same time we will also gain two million computer, mathematics, architecture, and engineering jobs.
But here’s the rub: A critical mass of the population works in the low-wage service sector. They don’t have the skills to perform new jobs created by the forces that are making their current jobs obsolete.
The average parking lot attendant and most coffeeshop cashiers don’t qualify. The pace of change, sped more and more by technology, is outstripping our systems for retraining displaced workers. The numbers are scary. Today in the U.S. alone, nine million low-wage, hourly workers are cashiers, customer service reps, and fast-food preparers and servers. Their lack of contemporary skills could create a step-function in the rise of unemployment. If we do not act now.
Sure, we’ve seen labor displacement in manufacturing, where the number of global industrial robots has grown 72 percent in the past ten years and the number of U.S. manufacturing jobs has fallen 16 percent. The projected net job losses in the manufacturing and white-collar sectors is a problem. But we must also take a deeper look at the hourly service sector which contains double the workers and where many jobs only require basic skills that can easily be replaced by technology.
Mobile internet, connected devices, and cloud technologies are replacing simple-skill jobs at a speed that makes it challenging to retrain the service workforce displaced.
Retraining this large, at-risk population in five years is a massive challenge for the private sector, governments, and the larger society. Building new skills to perform new jobs is a step-function change—not gradual, incremental evolutionary change.
The difficulty is that by 2020 one-third of the desired core skill set of most occupations will comprise elements that are not considered crucial by today’s standards. Two-thirds of the participants in the World Economic Forum study view investment in retraining current employees as a key part of change management. They think, however, that too many underestimate the technological upheaval of labor markets and too many are guided by short-term profitability pressures—65 percent of all jobs are created by less than 2 percent of global companies most of which are under shareholder pressure for continuous growth.
We, the consumer, drive growth. We, the people, also want workers to have better income and health care. We, the business owner, also want U.S. manufacturing to thrive. But we the people, don’t want to pay more than a few dollars for a hamburger or a cup of coffee. We want inexpensive clothing and electronics. These market dynamics, alongside with regulatory increases on healthcare and wages, drive technology deeper and deeper into every corner of business.
Offshore manufacturing and robotics create cheaper high-quality goods. In 2012, we hit 900,000 operational robots in American, German, Chinese, South Korean, and Japanese manufacturing facilities 1 (one-third were concentrated in Japan). While demand for industrial robots grows, manufacturers are also enhancing their competitiveness in service robots. Offshoring is not an option in the services economy, but service robots are.
Most people think that robots live only in the industrial realm. But ubiquitous mobile technologies—that is, apps—are robots by another name. Mobile apps will replace many jobs in the services economy.
Apps for ordering and checkout at large fast-food chains not only replace costly cashiers and customer service reps who need breaks and benefits. Apps also reduce order errors, further reducing costs. Automated check-in for trains, planes, automobiles, and hotels is here to stay, likewise for parking lots, toll booths, and gas stations.
What can we do? Mobile matching technologies will partially address the gap in low-wage service jobs. Matching apps like Uber balance supply and demand of services where in the past spare capacity sat permanently idle. Matching and dispatching workers in real-time will certainly address part of the problem by replacing traditional staffing and employment agencies. Yet it does not solve the fundamental problem:
Can we equip at-risk service workers with the knowledge and tools they need to fill their skills gap—and can we do it fast enough?
This requires a public-private effort of epic proportions. The private sector can shoulder a big load of the responsibility for closing this gap. But still there are millions of low-wage workers who are simply unprofitable for private companies to train and educate. More than 50 percent of adults in the U.S. lack the skills necessary to identify or interpret one or more pieces of information, essential for succeeding at work.
The U.S. government has tried for years. In 2009, nine agencies spent $18 billion on 47 public programs to elevate low-skill workers’ skills and quality of life (up from $5 billion and three programs since 2003). However, they haven’t worked. Studies show that these employment and training programs spread funding over too many issues and failed to eradicate any of them. Even in times of high unemployment, these programs saw sub-10 percent participation rates.
We need to try another way, and a good first step is to provide affordable access to mobile technologies in order to enable real-time training and participation in the matching economy.
By 2020, the totality of labor substitution by technology will be magnitudes larger than the 5 million job losses in 15 countries estimated by the World Economic Forum. Based on current trends, 5 million low-wage service jobs could be replaced by technology in the U.S. alone. If that’s true, labor substitution will become a critical social and economic problem to address not only in the white-collar and manufacturing sectors but also in the larger service hourly-jobs sector. Ignore it and that time-bomb will tick down to zero.
https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/labor-substitution-digital-revolution-ticking-luis-salazar
Tags
Who is online
94 visitors

I have read many articles railing against automation and its effect on jobs, wages, profits etc but found this article quite balanced in its views on the positive sand negatives of the onward flow of automation in the service sector and elsewhere.
For those interested the article author Luis Salazar, CEO Jobaline listed these resources for his article that some might find interesting reading - I did.
sources:
U.S. Bureau of labor statistics - Q1 2015
Japan Robots Association Administration Department - Oct 2015
Program for the International Assessment of Adult Competencies (PIAAC), 2012.
There is no reason to argue that we shouldn't automate the workplace and the retail/service space in which we live our lives, because the reality is that is happening and will continue to happen.
We need to remold our ideas on education, job training and careers for the current and future generations.
Excellent article RIO.
''Most people think that robots live only in the industrial realm. But ubiquitous mobile technologies—that is, apps—are robots by another name. Mobile apps will replace many jobs in the services economy. ''
I hadn't thought about this type of automation, yet it sure will replace jobs in the services economy.
''We need to remold our ideas on education, job training and careers for the current and future generations.''
Your comment really hits the mark. I know that many people laugh at Bernie Sanders on free collage for state run schools. But if you think about it we have free 1 through 12. The world is changing fast and way to many are being left behind. As a comparison Germany offers free collage for everyone, including foreign students. Many of their classes are taught in English and other languages. When asked about the foreign students taking advantage of this and then leaving the country the response was that around 50 percent of those students stay in country and that the benefit to the German economy is increased.
Kavika
I also had not thought of "apps" as robots or considered that they were replacing jobs, but in retrospect it is clear customer service, order entry specialists, bank tellers etc are all apps now.
Thanks for the feedback.
We don't need free education as much as we education that readies people (young and old) for employment challenges providing the skills, experience and motivation needed to get the new, technical jobs that are on the horizon.
We are taught that technology holds the key to wealth, freedom, leisure and family time, and happiness; yet, that hasn't happened. Instead, we are faced with an ever increasing population bound by a scarcity of basic staples and time, and a widening chasm of despair.
Technology is not going to solve problems that are the fault of our heads and hearts.
Larry
Technology does not cause or solve problems in and of itself.
Problems and solutions are created and promulgated by people, with the aid of automation.
Raging against the machines in much like screaming with a bucket on your head - no fun and not productive.
Thanks for the feedback.
Just another article that tells me that people are starting to see the reality of the automated future. We are just starting to see kids graduating from college whom are unemployable through no fault of their own. Not everyone is cut out or has the passion to be a computer programmer, or an engineer. This article points out correctly that these are careers which will continue to grow.
Those involved in biological research and development will also be hot fields. We will need more and more nurses, and surgeons will be in demand, but diagnostic practitioners and pharmacists will be shrinking in numbers. But again, not everyone is cut out for medical or biological research.
Profit margin looking to deliver on the demand for low cost products and services is not going to change and will only accelerate the future outlined in this article. I have no answers.
There use to be a commercial that made the statement, "A mind is a terrible thing to waste." We are going to be blowing that to where an entire human life is going to be wasted. This is going to happen by the millions. Simple changes in education is not enough...... the entire concept of monetary gain being the measure of success is detrimental to the future of humanity.
Excellent post FlyNavy. You got to the heart of the matter. The march of automation and technology will bring the profit motive itself into question.
John
Believe it or not, the "profit motive" as you put it has always been in question and always will be
As long as there are "things" (money or whatever) people will always strive to have enough of it to live the lives they want and some will compete to have more than anyone else.
Part of the human condition like it or not.
FLY
Excellent perspectives thanks for sharing them.
There will be plenty of jobs that are not computer programmers to be had in the future in what we know as the trades (skilled and unskilled) so there will always be a choice other than programmer/engineer.
We will always need technical and semi-technical support positions in medicine, there will be teachers etc
A mind is a terrible thing to waste." We are going to be blowing that to where an entire human life is going to be wasted.
I appreciate our perspective, but this is more hyperbole and rhetoric than anything else - what people are trained to do, how much time they will devote to those endeavors and how they will be compensated all will be changing, but the end of life as we know it is not at hand - not by a long shot and for a very long time.
We need to change, improve and focus education and training rather than throw up our hands in defeat
Having land, commodities, gems, gold, money etc has always existed since the beginning of time and some similar measure (whether we call it money) or not will always be part of the human condition.
We need to embrace, use and thrive in conjunction with the automation of present time and the future rather than cower in fear at the rise of the machines.
Robert.... Education and technical training will become out-priced for many in the coming years given the race to the bottom. And even with technical training, the wages for those jobs will be suppressed due to the great number of candidates that want those jobs while the price for it goes up. Minimum wage service jobs are going to disappear at a much faster rate going into the future because of automation as well. I don't know what the breaking point is in our economy. 35% real unemployment?
I suggest you consider what has happened in the last 35 years with regards to workers wages, automation, unions. Step back and take a broader view. Spending more to train more people for technical positions is not going to solve this matter. It will drive the cost of this education up due to supply and demand, while the wages are going to drop due to oversupply. This isn't hyperbole or rhetoric. This is how I clearly see things playing out.
Take this number to heart. I have found that 1 person can keep 12 automated systems running well. Even if that automation only replaces one person, then we only need 1/12 of the work force. But then again.... if only 1 person in 12 can buy what is being produced, do you even have an economy at that point?
Some people have faith that the "free market" and capitalism can solve any problem, including this one.
Rather what is eventually going to happen will thus be even more ironic.
People will be paid not to work. Guaranteed Basic Income. Maybe 50-75 years away, subject to change to sooner.
The profit motive requires that every job that can be automated will be. Far fewer workers will be required, even with new types of jobs that haven't been invented yet, because those new jobs will eventually be automated also. The profit motive will make robot owners extremely rich, and then they will be taxed on that wealth to fund the paying of people who won't be able to work.
The profit motive will make robot owners extremely rich, and then they will be taxed on that wealth to fund the paying of people who won't be able to work.
That sort of system can't last. The history of inherited wealth controlling the masses is pretty much over, and will be quickly overthrown going into the future.
FLY
That sort of system can't last. The history of inherited wealth controlling the masses is pretty much over, and will be quickly overthrown going into the future.
I agree that tax reform and a new and improved process that stimulates investment into the economy, the people and new technologies is long overdue.
I think changes are coming to "inherited wealth in a tax sense (and it is about time) but there will still be a place for a father to pass on "wealth" to his sons and daughters in varied forms.
You make great points and I appreciate the back and forth a lot.
John
Some people have faith that the "free market" and capitalism can solve any problem, including this one.
I have no illusions and believe that people, rather than an economic philosophy, will solve this challenge just as people have solved other challenges in the past. I and millions of others are cognizant of the current and impending effect of automation on the employment, education, training and social welfare of our people and country but rather than throw up our hands in fear or preach about the end of the economic world, we choose to have faith that people will rise to the challenge and that life (perhaps a little different than now) will go on.
Nowhere Man
I am told that I am an upbeat and happy guy, but that is a depressing picture you paint.
Changes in how and how much people are compensated is surely coming and thus a change in what signifies wealth and what is exchanged for things.
But whether it is coins, bills, beads, rocks or moonbeams people will accumulate that medium and some will accumulate it faster and some will save it rather than spend it all - that is way things have been, are and wll be.
Thanks for the perspective
I appreciate the response.
But whether it is coins, bills, beads, rocks or moonbeams people will accumulate that medium and some will accumulate it faster and some will save it rather than spend it all - that is way things have been, are and wll be.
I think you missed my point.
In a profit model driven society there will always be a medium of exchange, and those of that society that collect more of it than others.
My belief is in a mediumless society where value is exchanged without the ability to collect it or store it for future use.
In many ways the socialist utopia everyone says is coming.
And if it actually happens, the future proves that Marx was right, (not about communism, about socialism itself) the greatest irony of all will be that it was brought about by the one thing he hated the most. The accumulation of tokens of exchange and the power that it brought to the accumulators.
Capitalism.
Capitalism is the one economic model that destroys itself upon it's own needs and efficiencies. That need being the desire for more than the next guy. I say desire cause once one has acquired something, the need for it, (and the resulting desire) goes away.
Fundamental human understanding of the society we live in has to change, the economic forces for greater and greater efficiencies are driving that change, it is inevitable.
I don't think the inevitable will come without a lot of anguish.
N M
Thanks for clarifying
I do not think the demise of capitalism is a given nor do I think that a socialist utopia is possible
But changes for sure must be made
As always thanks for the back and forth