Pipeline Firm Couldn't Reach Staff at California Spill Site
As thousands of gallons of crude oil from a ruptured pipeline spread along the California coast, its operator was unable to contact workers near the break to get information the company needed to alert federal emergency officials, records released Wednesday said.
Personnel for Plains All American Pipeline needed the precise location of the May 19 spill and an estimate of its size before notifying the National Response Center, according to the records released to federal elected officials.
Company workers at the site near Santa Barbara were contending with "immediate demands and distractions" and couldn't be reached by Plains personnel based in Bakersfield, the documents said.
One of the workers, along with firefighters, used shovels to try to construct a makeshift berm to slow the oil's spread. The company's account said workers also made "various calls by cellphone to mobilize resources, make notifications and coordinate activities."
It wasn't clear from the records why company personnel in Bakersfield couldn't reach their workers at the scene.
The Texas-based pipeline company has faced criticism for how long it took to relay information to the federal government on the break estimated at up to 101,000 gallons, even though its internal planning documents repeatedly stress the importance of notifying the government of a leak as quickly as possible.
Meanwhile, the cost of cleaning up the spill has climbed to $92 million, Patrick Hodgins of Plains All American told reporters Wednesday. Hundreds of workers have spent weeks excavating contaminated soil and scraping rocks.
On Tuesday, with the pipeline shut down indefinitely, Exxon Mobil Corp. announced it has halted operations at three offshore platforms because it can't deliver oil to refineries. Santa Barbara County earlier rejected the company's emergency application to truck oil to refineries.
Under federal regulations, the pipeline company was required to notify the National Response Center of the leak at the earliest practicable moment. State law requires immediate notification of a release or a threatened release.
By 11:30 a.m. on the day of the break, a Plains operator remotely shut down the entire pipeline because of what the company called pressure anomalies.
An hour later, firefighters responding to a call about a petroleum smell near Refugio State Beach discovered the spill. At that time, Plains workers who were nearby for a spill training drill went to the beach.
Another hour passed before a company employee confirmed the spill at 1:30 p.m., but it was nearly 3 p.m. before Plains All American contacted the response center.
By then, the federal response led by the Coast Guard was underway.
The Associated Press reported earlier this month that Plains had assured the government in filings that a break in the line was "extremely unlikely" and state-of-the-art monitoring could quickly detect possible leaks and alert operators.
Company calculations assumed it should take no more than 15 minutes to discover a release and shut down the flow.
The federal Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration is investigating the cause of the break along a corroded section of pipe, which is part of a network that moves crude oil to inland refineries.
The company said in its response to the lawmakers Democratic Sens. Barbara Boxer and Dianne Feinstein of California, and Edward J. Markey of Massachusetts ; and Rep. Lois Capps, D-Calif. that it would be premature to reach conclusions about the timeline of events that day.
Plains All American spokeswoman Meredith Matthews said company personnel were on the beach with firefighters at about the same time the response center was alerted to the spill by local officials.
"The response was not delayed," she said. "Our guys were doing the right thing to stop the flow of oil into the ocean."
The records were released after federal lawmakers asked the company and federal regulators to answer questions about how the spill occurred and its aftermath. The spill fouled beaches and created a 9-mile slick in the Pacific Ocean.
Though preliminary, the records provide a look inside the company trying to contend with what became the largest coastal oil spill in California in 25 years.
The records indicate that personnel in Bakersfield eventually determined the location of the break and provided a spill estimate of 21,000 gallons to the response center, even though they had not spoken with the workers at the site. That figure was significantly less than the actual amount released.
At one point, company workers drove along the pipeline searching for the source of the oil. After the spill was confirmed in the early afternoon, the personnel in Bakersfield began calling regulatory agencies, but it appears some of those calls duplicated notifications made by other agencies, the documents said.
In a letter to the lawmakers earlier this month, the pipeline agency said it planned to issue an enforcement action against the company for probable violations based on a review of the line that was completed in 2014.
The agency also disclosed that it had taken an enforcement action against Plains in 2013, after an inspection of control systems.

You would think that, after decades and decades and decades and decades of practice, that THESE ASSHOLES COULD LEARN TO KEEP THEIR FUCKING OIL IN THEIR FUCKING PIPELINES!!!
And that they would be able to contact the appropriate resources immediately instead of taking hours and hours and then lying their fucking asses off about the whole fucking thing!
Company calculations assumed it should take no more than 15 minutes to discover a release and shut down the flow.
The spill was reported by people who notified the local fire department a hour later because they smelled the oil!
And just think what the XXL has in store for us.....
You must be talking about Texas again.....
Yup. But no; the same ol' shit over, and over, and over...The same basic and careless attitude demonstrated here in not informing the Fed in a timely manner, is also the same attitude that led to the break in the first place. We really need better laws,and better enforcement of the ones already in place.
Their actions should be criminalized unless they were busy fighting another break in the pipeline further down.
Someone has to start being accountable for the destruction of the environment by these companies, and that should include workers who do not stand their posts or fail to answer the call to duty, as well as the heads of corporations who own the pipelines.
Those natural resources are FINITE! And we lose them every day to careless management and irresponsible government.
Pipe moving oil, exposed to the sea air, what could go wrong./s
Or hitting the moonshine....
Their actions should be criminalized unless they were busy fighting another break in the pipeline further down.
I agree! When shit like this happens there shouldn't just be some sort of fine for the company, people need to start going to prison for this shit! And I mean 15 to 20 years type of prison and no country club ones!
No auto shut off valve, not inspected in a very long time and the metal was down to 1/16 inch thickness in places....No problem at all.
And how many more thousands and thousands of faults like that are out there waiting to pour oil all over the beaches, into the rivers and then they expect us to believe them when they say there'll never be a pipe break into theaquifer that provides the water to grow the vast majority of America's grain crops? Once the oil is in that aquifer there is no way to get it out! Ever! Where are we going to get the water to grow our grain crops?
Want to join me, Randy, at the border of the Sioux reservation when the XL corporation tries to take their land under eminent domain to run that damn pipe over it?
And I'll bet there were "No Trespassing" signs all over the place so that private citizens couldn't take a look at the pipe.
I'll stand there with you Mimi!!!!
Can I bring a cooler with some beer and sunscreen? This crap has got to stop as it does nothing to help the greater part of America and Americans!
I think I can try to arrange to be there.
If the Sioux stand by their promise to meet them with armed resistance, I will join them.
We have been a nation of law and order so long that we have allowed the rule of government in Washington to cow all of us down to our knees; whatever they say is "law" we have come to accept without anything but a whimper, and they have stolen us blind, and set us against each other. We're constantly looking for the blow that's coming from fellow citizens and ignoring the sledge hammer that's descending from directly above.
Please keep me informed on this mimi either through the NA group, or by private message. This is one I will come home for. The XXL has to be stopped!
I may piss off my wife, but it'll probably be worth it!
Firefighters said California oil spill gushed like a fire hose 'without a nozzle,' records say
And were expected to allow them to run an oil pipeline through our massive and main gran fields? If there is a leak into the aquifer just once, it can never be cleaned up. Just one spill will pollute that huge aquifer forever! The pollution will be permanent. Where are we supposed to grow our grain crops then? And what about the millions of people who depend on the aquifer for their drinking and household use? Are they supposed to just move? And move where? And do what for a living?
The MN and ND PUC justOK'd a pipeline from the Bakken oil field in ND across ND and MN to Lake Superior inDuluth MN. This pipeline will cross some of the most pristine areas left in the U.S. It will cross the Red River, numerous lakes, streams, rivers and watershed and come within spitting distance of the headwaters of the great Mississippi River.
Two days after it was announced in MN. 5,000 people showed up at the state capital to protest it.
The Ojibwe and Dakota people will do the same as the Lakota.
Dear Friend Screminmimi: Agreed.
Accountability is a large part of prevention.
Its lack a large part of the problem.
Great point.
E.
I am trying to keep up with it and will let you know.
If all the Nations people would meet at the first invasion site and stand together it would make a big impact. We should all, Indians and white and all others who are concerned about our natural resources, especially water, stand together from the first assault.
The farmers from California should be getting on board with this. We are talking about future water resources. They are saying they feed the entire country, not just California; if they want support from the entire country, they need to give support as well, and join in on this effort to save all water resources.
I wish, I truly wish, that I could afford to be there. However I can't andam horribly sorry.
When and where?
And right through my best buddy's retirement place. 15 acres on a coulee with a couple of huge ass gardens and a half dozen pups...his heaven.Just a little south of East Grand Forks, thatdamn Enbridgemonstrosity is crossing the coulee right there,and halfing his little plot!
With the amount of yearly flooding of the Red River, some years horrible, there is no way the pipeline. even if buried beneath he river (and that doesn't seem to be the plan) there is bound to be damage and spills. I wonder what our Canadian friend will think when one of our oil spill ends up on their land
Shit, Canada is already all pissy about the Red (for those who didn't know, the Red River runs north). Yeah, exactly, spill some oil in there and see how they react!
Anyone who can't be there can still help by using their keyboard, frequently, to contact members of Congress to let them know what you think about this.
It would help also to send letters to the editorial section of major newspapers across the country about it. A lot of times people not in the immediate area of something of this nature are not informed.
When AIM was at its most active, I knew nothing about it because there were media blackouts as to what was going on. It just was not covered in some areas, and I will always believe the reason was because there was a fear there would be too much empathy for the Indians and the feds would not be able to contain it.
Knowledge is power, and as long as the knowledge is controlled, they keep the power. So get the word out when the action takes place.... get the truth out.
My wife and I will be coming home for this one.... We talked about it last night. We have 20 days of vacation each left this year, and this seem like the right place and time to take a vacation.
Dear Enoch,
Thank you for your comment.
FLY,
That is wonderful news!
There are so many great comments here about this, it's too bad we can't get them published in the "Comments" editorial section of newspapers in those areas, and in DC.
It would be a great way to let Congress know how people across various areas of the US feel about it. As far as I know, those of us here on NT represent a fair share of America'sland mass in terms of geography.
And here we are, ready to saddle up and ride to Indian Country... lol