╌>

Senate passes bill allowing 9/11 victims to sue Saudi Arabia

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  flynavy1  •  10 years ago  •  14 comments

Senate passes bill allowing 9/11 victims to sue Saudi Arabia

The U.S. Senate passed legislation on Tuesday that would allow families of Sept. 11 victims to sue Saudi Arabia's government for damages, setting up a potential showdown with the White House, which has threatened a veto.

The Saudis, who deny responsibility for the 2001 attacks, strongly object to the bill. They had said they might sell up to $750 billion in U.S. securities and other American assets in retaliation if it became law.

The "Justice Against Sponsors of Terrorism Act," or JASTA, passed the Senate by unanimous voice vote. It must next be taken up by the U.S. House of Representatives, where the Judiciary Committee intends to hold a hearing on the measure in the near future, a committee aide said.

If it became law, JASTA would remove the sovereign immunity, preventing lawsuits against governments, for countries found to be involved in terrorist attacks on U.S. soil. It would allow survivors of the attacks, and relatives of those killed in the attacks, to seek damages from other countries.

In this case, it would allow lawsuits to proceed in federal court in New York as lawyers try to prove that the Saudis were involved in the attacks on the World Trade Center and Pentagon.

Saudi Foreign Minister Adel bin Ahmed al-Jubeir has said his country's objection to the bill is based on principles of international relations. "What (Congress is) doing is stripping the principle of sovereign immunities which would turn the world for international law into the law of the jungle," he said in a statement on Tuesday.

James Kreindler, a prominent trial lawyer who represents 9/11 families and won large payouts for the victims of the 1988 bombing of Pan American Airways Flight 103 over Scotland, said he expected the bill to pass the House and become law.

"It would be crazy for (President Barack) Obama to veto bipartisan legislation (which would) open (U.S.) courts to victims of the worst terrorist attack in U.S. history," Kreindler said.

Senator Charles Schumer, a New York Democrat and a JASTA co-sponsor, said the bill is overdue.

"Today the Senate has spoken loudly and unanimously that the families of victims of terrorist attacks should be able to hold the perpetrators, even if it's a country, a nation, accountable," Schumer told a news conference.

CLASSIFIED PAGES OF 9/11 REPORT

Republican Senator John Cornyn, also a sponsor of the bill, said JASTA does not target the Saudis, although he alluded to a still-classified section of a report on the Sept. 11 attacks that Saudi critics say might implicate Riyadh.

"We have yet to see the 28 pages that have not been yet released about the 9/11 report, and that may well be instructive," Cornyn said at the news conference.

Other lawmakers who have seen the 28 pages have said releasing them would quiet such rumors.

Cornyn said it was up to the court to decide whether the Saudis were liable. "I don't believe that this will be destructive of the relationship that we have with the kingdom of Saudi Arabia," he said.

The White House said Obama still plans to veto JASTA.

"This legislation would change long-standing, international law regarding sovereign immunity," White House spokesman Josh Earnest told a daily press briefing.

"And the president of the United States continues to harbor serious concerns that this legislation would make the United States vulnerable in other court systems around the world."

Asked if Senate Democrats would back a veto, Schumer said he would vote against Obama.

Republican Senator Lindsey Graham, who had opposed the bill, said the version passed on Tuesday eased his worries that it might leave U.S. allies more vulnerable to lawsuits, for example if groups based within their borders but not supported by their governments were behind a terrorist attack.

"We don't want to alienate allies, but we do want to create redress if a nation-state was involved in helping a terrorist organization attack American interests, and I think they should be held liable," Graham said in a brief interview.

http://www.reuters.com/article/us-saudi-usa-congress-idUSKCN0Y8239


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  FLYNAVY1    10 years ago

This bill is a very dangerous double edged sword.  Some "thinking points" I have found on the matter....

“…a decision to derogate further from the customary international law of sovereign immunity would weaken substantially our arguments against other governments taking analogous action against the United States.”

 

“…although the provision expanding the tort exception to include certain terrorist acts outside the United States was drafted with specific countries in mind, it could potentially be used to bring suits against other nations, including even close U.S. allies like Israel, if their actions outside the U.S. result in personal injury or loss of property in the U.S. For instance, it is conceivable that this bill could remove Afghanistan’s immunity from suit for a military action in Afghanistan, or Israel’s immunity from suit for a security action in Gaza, that results in personal injury or loss of property by an Afghan or Palestinian family member in the U.S.”

 

“…Congress should be particularly cautious at this time when considering amendments to the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act. The U.S. is engaged internationally in two wars and countless efforts to protect our country from terrorist attacks. U.S. agencies are engaged in necessary acts of lethal force in distant parts of the world. Congress should carefully consider the risk that removing the protections foreign governments enjoy in our courts could invite lawsuits in other countries against the U.S. or its officials for alleged extrajudicial killings or acts of terrorism if the U.S. is seen as departing from the sovereign immunity principles recognized in customary international law.”

 

“Iran and Cuba have already passed legislation removing U.S. sovereign immunity in their courts in response to U.S. legislation that allowed large judgments against them in U.S. courts. The U.S. has been sued in both countries and faces billions of dollars in default judgments as a result.”

 

“And over the last decade, numerous legal actions have been brought against U.S. officials in Europe arising out of official actions they have taken to fight terrorism.”

 

“Moreover, the ability of the United States to enter into multilateral agreements that would enshrine the very principles of international law that we ourselves have championed for years will be even more limited if Congress carves out new exceptions to the FSIA.”

 

“Broadening the exceptions to the FSIA would open the door to unprecedented civil lawsuits against countries with which our leaders are conducting sensitive diplomatic business. I would note, in this regard, that President Bush was forced to veto the National Defense Authorization Act for FY08 after Congress included an amendment to the FSIA that allowed Iraq to be sued for terrorists acts under the Saddam Hussein regime, which complicated the political and financial reconstruction of Iraq.”

It's an election year..... this sucker is going to pass in congress.  I just hope those voting in favor of this bill have really looked at the ramifications of this bill rather than just their political asses.  (anyone taking bets?)

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    10 years ago

When you are forced to do business with someone that would have no other reason to associate with, you tend to put on an air of friendship. You get to know them, meet their families and have barbeques with them. You attempt to find commonalities, so that you will feel better about doing business with them.

We have nothing in common with these people. We were fake friends. We don't have to hate them, but if we no longer need to do business with them, we can bow out gracefully, and send a friendly email every now and then.

They are an authoritarian dictatorship. They subjugate women and execute homosexuals. They censor their population. They force them to adhere to strict religious norms. We're not friends. We don't need their oil anymore. Time to cut the cord.

If they are guilty of abetting the worst act of terrorism in our history, they need to pay up.

 

 

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    10 years ago

Jonathan,

I usually agree with you, and as a 9/11 survivor, I do want justice. But I think Fly brings up a good point, that we would be opening the door for other such actions on countries all over the world, as he spelled out well in paragraph 2 of his first comment. And there is no way we would ever see a dime of that money, since they would never admit to knowing. 

Even cutting ties is unwise. We have air bases there. They are our useful friendimies and a necessary evil. 

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     10 years ago

Unintended consequences. You can bet that if this passes that there will be massive suits against the US.

Although I think it's (the law) is justified, the blow back is going to be huge.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    10 years ago

So, P & K,

What you are saying is that we should set aside the obvious complicity of Saudi Arabia in this catastrophe, and continue along our path in maintaining this relationship. We can't satisfy ourselves by proving, in a court of law, that this country is not a friend, and we must continue to maintain the relationship for the sake of an airbase or 2.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika   replied to  Jonathan P   10 years ago

What I'm saying Jonathan is to be prepared for the blow back. Because there will be from countries other than SA.

I'm no fan of SA as I indicated above.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    10 years ago

Those are strategic airbases for us. 

But even more than that... review this sentence:

Israel’s immunity from suit for a security action in Gaza, that results in personal injury or loss of property by an Afghan or Palestinian family member in the U.S.”

That should mean something to you. 

Remember that the pound of flesh came along with an unforeseen consequence. 

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P  replied to  Perrie Halpern R.A.   10 years ago

Yes, I saw it, and you have to be prepared to defend yourself.

We've sold ourselves down a road, and it has to be undone, and it could hurt. IMHO, the potential pain is worth it. We have to rip the band aid off. It will feel better, eventually.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  FLYNAVY1  replied to  Jonathan P   10 years ago

It is hard to argue with your stance JP, it really is.....

My point here is that in an election year, I'm betting that congressional members are looking more at protecting their political asses than they are looking at all the facets and future ramifications of this bill going well into the future.  I just want to make sure that everyone is crystal clear on the consequences.  This sucker has been running under the radar too quickly in my opinion.  I would prefer a bit more of a pragmatic approach with this bill.

 

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P  replied to  FLYNAVY1   10 years ago

Fly,

If you throw enough shit against the wall, some of it is bound to stick. Altruism runs uncharacteristically high in election years, to be sure. Whether it's real, feigned, opportunistic or whatever, sometimes serendipity gets a shot. This is one of those times.

My stance is that the consequences are worth the benefit. Are they lending enough credence to the possible consequences? Perhaps not. Hey, an upside of this is to look for ways to prosecute war in a more thoughtful manner. What's wrong with that? I see far more pluses than minuses.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  FLYNAVY1  replied to  Jonathan P   10 years ago

I guess that we need to wait to see what the final bill passed by congress really looks like. 

This may also be a case of political brinkmanship.  Congress may make final passage of this bill just before a congressional recess, which would give them political cover if the president decided to make use of a "pocket veto" allowing it to go unsigned.  Stranger things have happened.....

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  FLYNAVY1   10 years ago

I agree. I want to see the final product before deciding. There is still a lot of work to do before a Bill gets passed to the President's desk and this on still has a long way to go.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    10 years ago

As much as I like the idea of laying a precedent that would sue Israel into penury for its actions, eliminating sovereign immunity for Saudi Arabia is an ill-advised start down a slippery slope. The basic notion of sovereign immunity is that one government is not inferior to another. In our system, we have three branches of government: the executive, legislature, and judiciary. All are co-equal. They cannot sue each other for money nor can they be sued for money by citizens (except in the limited instances where the federal government, as a whole, has waived immunity).

On an international scale, the idea that one government can be dictated to by the legislature/court system of another would lead to a serious erosion in the equality of governments and quickly become an economic weapon or at least be seen as such. The government being sued will retaliate as Saudi Arabia has threatened to do. It can also pass laws that negate foreign judgments and/or allow its own citizens (and others) to sue the government that sued it. This cycle of retaliation works contrary to the international cooperation that we all need to advance our mutual interests. If sovereign immunity is to be waived, then it should only be for suit in an international court of justice (separate from the control of any particular government) and only against those countries that have voluntarily agreed to submit to the court's jurisdiction.

To me, this idea of allowing lawsuits against foreign governments who have not voluntarily waived jurisdiction to suit is just a way for trial lawyers to make (a lot of) money at everybody else's expense.

 
 

Who is online


116 visitors