Via: johnrussell • 10 years ago • 63 comments
Trump’s income tax returns once became public. They showed he didn’t pay a cent.
The last time Donald Trump’s income-tax returns were made public, the bottom line was striking: He had paid the federal government $0 in income taxes.
The disclosure, in a 1981 report by New Jersey gambling regulators, revealed that the wealthy Manhattan investor had for at least two years in the late 1970s taken advantage of a tax-code provision popular with developers that allowed him to report negative income.
Today, as the presumptive Republican presidential nominee, Trump regularly denounces corporate executives for using loopholes and “false deductions” to “get away with murder” when it comes to avoiding taxes.
“They make a fortune. They pay no tax,” Trump said last year on CBS. “It’s ridiculous, okay?”
Sounds like the same nonsense as when Harry Reid lied and claimed Romney paid no taxes. That turned out to be a bs lie that NPR claims Reid must have pulled out of thin air. You wouldn't believe how many liberal idiots parroted Reids lie as if it was fact.
You're continuing this stream of thought, but it really doesn't add up, John. He has done nothing illegal.
Are you saying his transgression was that he used the tax code to his advantage? Are you saying that, in order to be viewed as a suitable candidate, you need to forego the tax code and pay lots of taxes?
I'm not getting your message. What is the message here?
He disqualified himself to be president when he decided he didn't want to pay income taxes.
If it turns out that he usually pays something substantial and only rarely did he pay nothing or next to nothing, I will change about this one thing. I'm fairly confident that will not be the case.
It's legal to lie every 5 minutes too. Another strike against Trump in my book.
He disqualified himself to be president when he decided he didn't want to pay income taxes.
Do you mean when HE SAID he didn't want to pay taxes?
If it turns out that he usually pays something substantial and only rarely did he pay nothing or next to nothing, I will change about this one thing. I'm fairly confident that will not be the case.
What if he did it legally? What if he stayed within the tax code? I don't understand this. Really, I don't know what you're getting at here.
It's legal to lie every 5 minutes too. Another strike against Trump in my book.
We weren't talking about his other nonsense. I already posted my disclaimer.
Just trying to get my head around this "not paying taxes" issue.
lol. Maybe not with his super duper secret tax returns, but only an idiot believes tha Donald Trump plays by the rules in general. I doubt the mob would be partnering up with him if that were the case.
Besides proving that Trump is a smart little basterd, it really proves nothing, but it does point out the fact that if you have enough money, you can hire enough accountants/lawyers and get out of paying anything. I feel that it is unfair to the rest of us, but then, we've had special interest groups shoving their little tax breaks down everyone's throat for far too long.
I don't like Trump. However, if the law allows him to do it, then we have to change the laws, and good luck with that!
Most corporations don't pay that much in taxes, either. Like GE, years ago, they paid VERY LITTLE in taxes, both state and federal. (My ex was an accountant for the state.) As long as they paid their payroll taxes, the state didn't bug them.
If one of the problems that we are trying to solve in this country is tax equity, then people like Trump are part of the problem.
The wealthy pay lobbyists and make political contributions in a quid pro quo where they get tax laws passed that continue to favor the wealthy. Continuing to go down this course places us that much closer to a plutocracy than the republic our constitution says we are suppose to be.
So far as I can tell, the left is gnashing their teeth and bemoaning the end of the Republic today because Trump followed the rules and took the deductions entitled to him by law. As if the Clintons don't take deductions.
What's really interesting is the sound of crickets from the left over the tax returns of the Clintons' "charity." They've already had to be refiled because of material misstatements to the tune of tens of millions of dollars and just this week a financial whistle blower prepared 40 reports on the Clintons' financial irregularities that amount to fraud. And there's always the issue of the Clintons' charity donating money to a company owned by Bill's mistress.
So following the law disqualifies Trump from being President, but actual financial improprieties are just peachy for Hillary Clinton. The left's hypocrisy knows no bounds
What's really interesting is the sound of crickets from the left over the tax returns of the Clintons'
It would have been a good argument if the Clinton's refused to release their tax returns but they have released them. And because they have released them it has afforded you additional information to attack them on.
I don't like the fact that some are able to work the system and pay very little or nothing but I have to agree that if there are loop holes why wouldn't one use them to keep as much of their own money.
My issue with Mr Trump not releasing his tax returns is not what he doesn't pay but what he "claims" he pays such as towards charities.
Just a side note: I don't know why men have to constantly bring up Bill Clinton's mistresses as if it's Hilary's fault. I've heard Donal Trump blaming her and chastising her for not being nice to them (really????) but it would be nice if the guys on this site wouldn't be assholes and take the same line of attack. It's smarmy to blame the victim.
I have to agree that if there are loop holes why wouldn't one use them to keep as much of their own money.
When you decide to pay no taxes you are disqualified to be President. The President proposes to spend a lot of taxpayer money, Trump would spend billions and billions of taxpayer money for his initiatives if he is elected. If he hasn't paid income tax, none of it would be his money. This is not acceptable in a president.
t would have been a good argument if the Clinton's refused to release their tax returns but they have released them.
It' what in the returns that matter. Trump's returns that were made public don't appear to have any red flags. The Clintons are shady as hell and possibly fraudulent. A best selling book was written about all the financial shenanigans they engaged in with their charity. The left doesn't simply doesn't care about the Clintons' fraud, so why should they care about Trump's returns?
don't like the fact that some are able to work the system
There's no evidence Trump worked the system that I'm aware of. He simply took the deductions that were already available. Do people who take a mortgage deduction to lower their tax bill "work the system?"
I don't know why men have to constantly bring up Bill Clinton's mistresses as if it's Hilary's fault.
Well, when Hillary's charity gives the private business Bill mistress owns 2 million dollars, it becomes an issue. Or do you think a charity its appropriate for a charity to act like that?
There's no evidence Trump worked the system that I'm aware of. By his own accord he has admitted to working the system. As I said, I don't care if he's worked the system or not. I take whatever deductions my accountant tells me to take. It is what it is but he is applying for a job that I will be paying him for and I'd like to know the type of person he is. If he doesn't want to answer my questions then in my book he is disqualified to apply for the position. It's that simple for me. If you don't want to know and you'd rather go on blind faith that's your choice.
A best selling book was written about all the financial shenanigans they engaged in with their charity. Yes, and the author had no other objective when he wrote the book other than to inform the public. He had no idea he would make millions of dollars. Puuuuulease..... EVERYONE IS WORKING THE SYSTEM. From the Trumps to the Clintons to the writers of both. I don't doubt that some of the information has truth to it. The difference is now I KNOW and can weigh that information in my decision.
Well, when Hillary's charity gives the private business Bill mistress owns 2 million dollars, it becomes an issue. Hilary personally wrote a check to Bill Clinton's mistress?.......I don't think so Sean. Just STOP making Bill Clinton's infidelity Hilary Clinton's fault. There are many other issues you can bring up that Hilary has done herself. I'm really sick of men making it the woman's fault because they can't keep their dicks in their pants.
ilary personally wrote a check to Bill Clinton's mistress?
The Bill. Hillary & Chelsea Clinton Foundation gave a 2 million dollar check to the for profit business owned by Bill's mistress.Is that an acceptable use of a "charity" with her name in the title funds to you?
Just STOP making Bill Clinton's infidelity Hilary Clinton's fault.
I'm not. Bill makes his own choices. But it is Hillary's fault when her "charity" is used to give millions of dollars to her mistress. Bill' s ongoing infidelity and the reasons for it are private, but the actions of Hillary's charity are public. She acquiesced in giving a supposed charity's money to a mistress. That's a legitimate issue, as I'm sure you can see.
Okay so the Clinton foundation is now just Hilary's foundation and Hilary is the only one making decision and the only one managing the money? Jesus fucking christ. You guys are really something. I hope you have your membership fees paid up to date. We don't want you getting kicked out of the "boy's club".
Is Hillary capable of doing anything on her own? Or is she just Bill's puppet? Why do you think she should bears no responsibility for the actions of her own "charity?"
Last time I looked, a person is capable of acting independently when presented evidence of wrongdoing. Maybe Hillary's not. If she can't, how can you think she's capable of executing the office of President?
I think she's just Bill's puppet and a way for a backdoor third term. He's already proven he can walk all over her and she will remain obedient. It looks like she suffers from codependency problems.
She even publicly announced that she has plans to allow Bill to resume his destruction of the economy.
Oh Dean! Well it looks like there must be a club meeting happening today.
I think it's absolutely hilarious how women are judged and described as puppets and obedient because they chose to stay in their marriage after the man broke the vows. I thought the churchy people liked this? Where's X at?
X X XX X XX X…….. oh ….. X X XX X XX X Where are you? Can I get a little help here.
I'm sure X will agree with me 100% that the woman should forgive her husband and do everything possible to stay in the marriage.
What I'm hearing from the boy's club is that for everyone else it's a good thing unless you're Hilary Clinton and then you're just a puppet and unable to think for yourself.
Today, as the presumptive Republican presidential nominee, Trump regularly denounces corporate executives for using loopholes and “false deductions” to “get away with murder” when it comes to avoiding taxes.
Yet in his speeches when he mentions his taxes he says he does everything he can do to pay as little as possible. He contradicts himself. Either that or he thinks dodging taxes should be for only him and him alone.
Perhaps he wants to be President because he thinks Presidents don't pay any taxes. I mean he really is that dumb about things to do with the government.
This is a non-issue to me. When I do my tax returns, the goal is to pay as little as possible. If I could legally get away with paying zero, then I would happily pay zero. Trump has denounced certain tax loopholes yet uses them himself so I guess that's supposed to mean he's a hypocrite. However, what he's actually saying is that the loophole should be closed not that people should ignore the loophole and pay more taxes than necessary. As long as the loophole is there, then I expect Trump and anybody else to use it. This is like any sports game. The player is not at fault for playing the game by the existing rules even if he thinks the rules should be changed. He plays to win . . . it's not a question of hypocrisy, philanthropy, fairness to less gifted players or any other irrelevant factor. So blame the game, not the player.
Also, Trump says he's in an IRS audit. He says he's been advised not to disclose his returns during an audit and he'd be a fool to ignore that advice. He's a ostentatious buffoon but not a fool. Trump's return may show that he's not as charitable as he claims to be (at least as reflected in claimed deductions) and that his net worth is inflated. Puffery is not an attractive attribute but it's not a crime either. And his puffery is not exactly a secret. After all, he has indicated that his name alone is worth $3 billion to him and that the value of his property to him and its actual market value may not be the same. The returns won't show his actual net worth but it would show what he pays in property taxes and bank interest . . . not much more than a scent but it's enough to get the media hounds bounding off to chase the truth to the ground.
The president recommends and advocates for hundreds of billions of dollars of federal spending every year. Anyone who does not pay into those funds through their taxes has no business running for president. Trump knows this, and that is why he won't reveal his taxes.
I think there is also a very good chance he never gave to veteran's charities the way he has been blowharding about on the campaign trail.
The president recommends and advocates for hundreds of billions of dollars of federal spending every year. Anyone who does not pay into those funds through their taxes has no business running for president. Trump knows this, and that is why he won't reveal his taxes.
He can spin that around and say that one of the president's fundamental responsibilities is to make us prosperous as a nation. Anyone too stupid to use legal loopholes to maximize their personal wealth is too stupid to create national prosperity.
Anyone too stupid to use legal loopholes to maximize their personal wealth is too stupid to create national prosperity.
No they're not.
I wasn't giving my personal opinion but rather saying how Trump could spin it. Inasmuch as he can easily spin it that way, he has no reason to hide his returns simply because he may pay no taxes.
I've been saying all along that Trump is trying to conceal the fact that he pays next to nothing, or nothing, in taxes.
I've been saying all along that Trump is trying to conceal the fact that he pays next to nothing, or nothing, in taxes.
Disclaimer:
I am not a supporter of Donald Trump.
John,
What do you mean to convey by your statement?
Are you upset that, if you are correct, that he uses the tax code to get him to a zero tax debt?
Are you upset that he does not wish to publicize his tax return?
Are you upset that the tax code has not been changed to create new taxes for the wealthy?
I suppose it could be all of these, but you seem upset, despite the fact that he's done nothing illegal.
Trump has publicly stated that the rich do not pay enough in taxes (and when he said it he was specifically talking about income tax).
Do you think that he thinks he pays enough?
This is "do as I say, not as I do" ?
It's a contradictory statement. Politicians do it all the time. This is a generic two-face. It's not one of the special Trump-isms.
If he changes laws to tax the rich more, he will be directly affected.
Trump does not want to release his income taxes. I believe they will show that for the past 40 years he has paid next to nothing in income taxes.
I don't think such a person should be president.
Sounds like the same nonsense as when Harry Reid lied and claimed Romney paid no taxes. That turned out to be a bs lie that NPR claims Reid must have pulled out of thin air. You wouldn't believe how many liberal idiots parroted Reids lie as if it was fact.
So Trump is part of the 47% that don't pay income tax. I wonder how many like him there are?
Trump pays taxes don't believe the Democrats lies.
You're continuing this stream of thought, but it really doesn't add up, John. He has done nothing illegal.
Are you saying his transgression was that he used the tax code to his advantage? Are you saying that, in order to be viewed as a suitable candidate, you need to forego the tax code and pay lots of taxes?
I'm not getting your message. What is the message here?
He disqualified himself to be president when he decided he didn't want to pay income taxes.
If it turns out that he usually pays something substantial and only rarely did he pay nothing or next to nothing, I will change about this one thing. I'm fairly confident that will not be the case.
It's legal to lie every 5 minutes too. Another strike against Trump in my book.
He disqualified himself to be president when he decided he didn't want to pay income taxes.
What? He disqualified himself by following the law?
He disqualified himself to be president when he decided he didn't want to pay income taxes.
Do you mean when HE SAID he didn't want to pay taxes?
If it turns out that he usually pays something substantial and only rarely did he pay nothing or next to nothing, I will change about this one thing. I'm fairly confident that will not be the case.
What if he did it legally? What if he stayed within the tax code? I don't understand this. Really, I don't know what you're getting at here.
It's legal to lie every 5 minutes too. Another strike against Trump in my book.
We weren't talking about his other nonsense. I already posted my disclaimer.
Just trying to get my head around this "not paying taxes" issue.
"He has done nothing illegal."
lol. Maybe not with his super duper secret tax returns, but only an idiot believes tha Donald Trump plays by the rules in general. I doubt the mob would be partnering up with him if that were the case.
Besides proving that Trump is a smart little basterd, it really proves nothing, but it does point out the fact that if you have enough money, you can hire enough accountants/lawyers and get out of paying anything. I feel that it is unfair to the rest of us, but then, we've had special interest groups shoving their little tax breaks down everyone's throat for far too long.
I don't like Trump. However, if the law allows him to do it, then we have to change the laws, and good luck with that!
Most corporations don't pay that much in taxes, either. Like GE, years ago, they paid VERY LITTLE in taxes, both state and federal. (My ex was an accountant for the state.) As long as they paid their payroll taxes, the state didn't bug them.
If one of the problems that we are trying to solve in this country is tax equity, then people like Trump are part of the problem.
The wealthy pay lobbyists and make political contributions in a quid pro quo where they get tax laws passed that continue to favor the wealthy. Continuing to go down this course places us that much closer to a plutocracy than the republic our constitution says we are suppose to be.
So far as I can tell, the left is gnashing their teeth and bemoaning the end of the Republic today because Trump followed the rules and took the deductions entitled to him by law. As if the Clintons don't take deductions.
What's really interesting is the sound of crickets from the left over the tax returns of the Clintons' "charity." They've already had to be refiled because of material misstatements to the tune of tens of millions of dollars and just this week a financial whistle blower prepared 40 reports on the Clintons' financial irregularities that amount to fraud. And there's always the issue of the Clintons' charity donating money to a company owned by Bill's mistress.
So following the law disqualifies Trump from being President, but actual financial improprieties are just peachy for Hillary Clinton. The left's hypocrisy knows no bounds
Obviously the Trumpsters are going through the motions to put lipstick on this pig.
It's going to be a tough sell if it turns out Trump hasn't been paying income tax for 40 years. I don't think there's enough lipstick in existence.
What's really interesting is the sound of crickets from the left over the tax returns of the Clintons'
It would have been a good argument if the Clinton's refused to release their tax returns but they have released them. And because they have released them it has afforded you additional information to attack them on.
I don't like the fact that some are able to work the system and pay very little or nothing but I have to agree that if there are loop holes why wouldn't one use them to keep as much of their own money.
My issue with Mr Trump not releasing his tax returns is not what he doesn't pay but what he "claims" he pays such as towards charities.
Just a side note: I don't know why men have to constantly bring up Bill Clinton's mistresses as if it's Hilary's fault. I've heard Donal Trump blaming her and chastising her for not being nice to them (really????) but it would be nice if the guys on this site wouldn't be assholes and take the same line of attack. It's smarmy to blame the victim.
I have to agree that if there are loop holes why wouldn't one use them to keep as much of their own money.
When you decide to pay no taxes you are disqualified to be President. The President proposes to spend a lot of taxpayer money, Trump would spend billions and billions of taxpayer money for his initiatives if he is elected. If he hasn't paid income tax, none of it would be his money. This is not acceptable in a president.
Not at all I'm looking for a president that wants to do away with Income tax entirely. Our founding fathers did not pay income tax.
Taxes funded the federal government. It wasn't donations.
t would have been a good argument if the Clinton's refused to release their tax returns but they have released them.
It' what in the returns that matter. Trump's returns that were made public don't appear to have any red flags. The Clintons are shady as hell and possibly fraudulent. A best selling book was written about all the financial shenanigans they engaged in with their charity. The left doesn't simply doesn't care about the Clintons' fraud, so why should they care about Trump's returns?
don't like the fact that some are able to work the system
There's no evidence Trump worked the system that I'm aware of. He simply took the deductions that were already available. Do people who take a mortgage deduction to lower their tax bill "work the system?"
I don't know why men have to constantly bring up Bill Clinton's mistresses as if it's Hilary's fault.
Well, when Hillary's charity gives the private business Bill mistress owns 2 million dollars, it becomes an issue. Or do you think a charity its appropriate for a charity to act like that?
There's no evidence Trump worked the system that I'm aware of. By his own accord he has admitted to working the system. As I said, I don't care if he's worked the system or not. I take whatever deductions my accountant tells me to take. It is what it is but he is applying for a job that I will be paying him for and I'd like to know the type of person he is. If he doesn't want to answer my questions then in my book he is disqualified to apply for the position. It's that simple for me. If you don't want to know and you'd rather go on blind faith that's your choice.
A best selling book was written about all the financial shenanigans they engaged in with their charity. Yes, and the author had no other objective when he wrote the book other than to inform the public. He had no idea he would make millions of dollars. Puuuuulease..... EVERYONE IS WORKING THE SYSTEM. From the Trumps to the Clintons to the writers of both. I don't doubt that some of the information has truth to it. The difference is now I KNOW and can weigh that information in my decision.
Well, when Hillary's charity gives the private business Bill mistress owns 2 million dollars, it becomes an issue. Hilary personally wrote a check to Bill Clinton's mistress?.......I don't think so Sean. Just STOP making Bill Clinton's infidelity Hilary Clinton's fault. There are many other issues you can bring up that Hilary has done herself. I'm really sick of men making it the woman's fault because they can't keep their dicks in their pants.
ilary personally wrote a check to Bill Clinton's mistress?
The Bill. Hillary & Chelsea Clinton Foundation gave a 2 million dollar check to the for profit business owned by Bill's mistress.Is that an acceptable use of a "charity" with her name in the title funds to you?
Just STOP making Bill Clinton's infidelity Hilary Clinton's fault.
I'm not. Bill makes his own choices. But it is Hillary's fault when her "charity" is used to give millions of dollars to her mistress. Bill' s ongoing infidelity and the reasons for it are private, but the actions of Hillary's charity are public. She acquiesced in giving a supposed charity's money to a mistress. That's a legitimate issue, as I'm sure you can see.
B
Okay so the Clinton foundation is now just Hilary's foundation and Hilary is the only one making decision and the only one managing the money? Jesus fucking christ. You guys are really something. I hope you have your membership fees paid up to date. We don't want you getting kicked out of the "boy's club".
Is Hillary capable of doing anything on her own? Or is she just Bill's puppet? Why do you think she should bears no responsibility for the actions of her own "charity?"
Last time I looked, a person is capable of acting independently when presented evidence of wrongdoing. Maybe Hillary's not. If she can't, how can you think she's capable of executing the office of President?
I think she's just Bill's puppet and a way for a backdoor third term. He's already proven he can walk all over her and she will remain obedient. It looks like she suffers from codependency problems.
She even publicly announced that she has plans to allow Bill to resume his destruction of the economy.
The economy was a lot better under Clinton... So maybe he would help! Not hurt it.
Oh Dean!
Well it looks like there must be a club meeting happening today.
I think it's absolutely hilarious how women are judged and described as puppets and obedient because they chose to stay in their marriage after the man broke the vows. I thought the churchy people liked this? Where's X at?
X X XX X XX X…….. oh ….. X X XX X XX X Where are you? Can I get a little help here.
I'm sure X will agree with me 100% that the woman should forgive her husband and do everything possible to stay in the marriage.
What I'm hearing from the boy's club is that for everyone else it's a good thing unless you're Hilary Clinton and then you're just a puppet and unable to think for yourself.
Today, as the presumptive Republican presidential nominee, Trump regularly denounces corporate executives for using loopholes and “false deductions” to “get away with murder” when it comes to avoiding taxes.
Yet in his speeches when he mentions his taxes he says he does everything he can do to pay as little as possible. He contradicts himself. Either that or he thinks dodging taxes should be for only him and him alone.
Perhaps he wants to be President because he thinks Presidents don't pay any taxes. I mean he really is that dumb about things to do with the government.
This is a non-issue to me. When I do my tax returns, the goal is to pay as little as possible. If I could legally get away with paying zero, then I would happily pay zero. Trump has denounced certain tax loopholes yet uses them himself so I guess that's supposed to mean he's a hypocrite. However, what he's actually saying is that the loophole should be closed not that people should ignore the loophole and pay more taxes than necessary. As long as the loophole is there, then I expect Trump and anybody else to use it. This is like any sports game. The player is not at fault for playing the game by the existing rules even if he thinks the rules should be changed. He plays to win . . . it's not a question of hypocrisy, philanthropy, fairness to less gifted players or any other irrelevant factor. So blame the game, not the player.
Also, Trump says he's in an IRS audit. He says he's been advised not to disclose his returns during an audit and he'd be a fool to ignore that advice. He's a ostentatious buffoon but not a fool. Trump's return may show that he's not as charitable as he claims to be (at least as reflected in claimed deductions) and that his net worth is inflated. Puffery is not an attractive attribute but it's not a crime either. And his puffery is not exactly a secret. After all, he has indicated that his name alone is worth $3 billion to him and that the value of his property to him and its actual market value may not be the same. The returns won't show his actual net worth but it would show what he pays in property taxes and bank interest . . . not much more than a scent but it's enough to get the media hounds bounding off to chase the truth to the ground.
The president recommends and advocates for hundreds of billions of dollars of federal spending every year. Anyone who does not pay into those funds through their taxes has no business running for president. Trump knows this, and that is why he won't reveal his taxes.
I think there is also a very good chance he never gave to veteran's charities the way he has been blowharding about on the campaign trail.
The president recommends and advocates for hundreds of billions of dollars of federal spending every year. Anyone who does not pay into those funds through their taxes has no business running for president. Trump knows this, and that is why he won't reveal his taxes.
He can spin that around and say that one of the president's fundamental responsibilities is to make us prosperous as a nation. Anyone too stupid to use legal loopholes to maximize their personal wealth is too stupid to create national prosperity.
Anyone too stupid to use legal loopholes to maximize their personal wealth is too stupid to create national prosperity.
No they're not.
Anyone too stupid to use legal loopholes to maximize their personal wealth is too stupid to create national prosperity.
No they're not.
I wasn't giving my personal opinion but rather saying how Trump could spin it. Inasmuch as he can easily spin it that way, he has no reason to hide his returns simply because he may pay no taxes.
Jeesus 1, your making too much sense here.