Libertarian Economics Writer Declares : Carson's 'Tithing' Is Sounder Than Rubio's Tax Plan
"It's Ben Carson 's turn to get real on taxes. This is what some Republicans have been saying since Donald Trump released details of his tax plan.
Carson, who is still nose to nose with Trump in the polls , has so far stuck with the simple idea he first began mooting years ago: a 10 percent flat tax on income modeled on the biblical tithe.
A tithe sounds primitive, something involving pottery shards and sheep. The notion doesnt fit into the political culture of a primary, let alone a general election. Tax plans do not come as bolts from the clouds. They come as spreadsheets from the National Bureau of Economic Research.
Trump took advantage of such impressions in the last Republican debate to mock Carson. Trump suggested that in rejecting progressivity, Carson was simply betraying ignorance of (tax) civilization. One thing Ill say to Ben is that weve had a graduated tax system for many years.
But for Carson to back off from his plan would be a shame. His tithe reminds us that our modern tax culture features its own idols, themselves worth smashing.
Politicians worship the progressivity to which Trump referred. This is the system under which tax rates rise as workers move up the income scale. Just about every American tax plan put together by lawmakers in the past century has been progressive. Out of anxiety over seeming unjust to the poor, even self-proclaimed flat taxers tend to insert lower rates for modest earners in their plans.
But its not clear that voters themselves actually understand progressivity. Indeed, a recent study by the American Accounting Association suggested that seven in 10 liberals who say they support progressivity indicate a preference for flat rates when asked about specific examples.
Voters generally mistake progressivity for proportionality. And Carsons 10 percent tithe favors proportionality.
A Wall Street Mogul who made $10 billion would be required to give $1 billion, Carson writes in his memoir. A Harlem schoolteacher who made $50,000 would be required to give $5,000. Along with imposing that flat rate, Carson says, of course, get rid of tax loopholes.
A second idol Carson breaks is the range for the top tax rate. In the U.S. this range is set in granite at between 20 and 40 percent. At 10 percent, Carsons tithe feels utterly implausible, as the left-leaning Citizens for Tax Justice put it. With so much revenue lost, the contention is, the government will run dry as a desert.
But here again, Carson creates an opening. Experience, never mind scholarship, suggests that when a nation drops its tax rate substantially below that of other countries, it will draw commensurately substantial amounts of business, and extra tax revenues. No evidence has materialized that this phenomenon ceases when you drop your statutory top tax bracket by 75 percent, to 10 percent from the current 39.6.
So Carsons bet that a bold low rate will undam an ocean of revenue is hardly crazy. Whats more, the fervent fashion in which Carson preaches against deficits, citing Proverbs, suggests he has the will to narrow deficits with cuts.
Another tax idol is the child credit. No social conservative candidate is worth his salt until he crusades for tax changes that give an advantage to families with children.
Senator Marco Rubio recently provided an example of this when he proposed an expansion of existing child credits so generous, it would give up a good trillion dollars in federal revenue. By math the Rubio campaign itself commissioned, that shift wont yield a drop of additional economic growth.
Carson doesnt so much reject the child credit as parade past it. At a 10 percent tax rate, even the largest family will benefit.
Yet another icon is tax cuts for the poor. For decades politicians have removed lower earners from the tax rolls in the name of giving them incentives to work and earn more. Carson wants to increase taxes on the poor. The practical reason is to broaden the tax base: great idea. But he also adds: Robbing people of dignity by allowing them to be freeloaders is not compassionate. Taxing people gives them "skin in the game," he says, a stake in the common American venture.
Of course, talking about taxes today also features taboos. One taboo is against praising great wealth, even among those candidates who sometimes push for lower tax rates on the rich. Carson doesnt merely praise wealth, he glorifies it: What made America into a great nation was the fact that we said, that guy just put in $1 billion, lets create an environment thats even more conducive to his success so that next year he can put in $2 billion. Lower rates encourage rich people to work more productively and hire more people.
No, it wont be easy for Carson to stand his tithe ground. Already he has let it be known he is open to permitting his tithe to be remade into, say, Mike Huckabees Fair Tax, which buys off lower earners with a cashback early prebate. Its also quite possible that the surgeon candidate, if he stays near the top in the polls, will indeed succumb and advocate the standard Republican compromise mishmash. To all of which one can only reply: Heaven forfend. "
http://www.bloombergview.com/articles/2015-09-30/carson-s-tithing-is-sounder-than-rubio-s-tax-plan
Tags
Who is online
95 visitors

This is an astonishing article. The writer, a libertarian who specializes in economic topics, suggests that everyone in America should pay 10% of their income in taxes. If you make a billion dollars a year you should pay 10% (which would leave you with 900 million dollars) , and if you make 10 dollars a year you should pay 10% in taxes, (which would leave you with 9 dollars.) She says no deductions for children, and no breaks for the poor, becauseRobbing people of dignity by allowing them to be freeloaders is not compassionate."
This is described as "fair".
What is "fair" about the varying incomes people make? Does the person working at a broom factory get to set their own salary or give themselves a raise ? Do they get perks or golden parachutes? There is nothing "fair" about the economy, so why should the tax system be fair ? The people who benefit the most from the economy should pay the most in taxes, in rate as well as in sheer dollars. That is what is "fair".
I love the flat rate tax plan. What isn't fair is to tax the man who puts in the effort to pick three bushels of apples at a higher rate than the lazy bum that only picks half a bushel of apples. I hope more candidates adopt Carson's plan.
Dean , there are millions of people who work cleaning toilets and so forth who work harder and longer than people who make much more money.
Your belief that everyone is paid exactly according to how hard they work or how much effort they make is absurd.
That isn't my belief. My belief is the free market should set the compensation. Cleaning toilets isn't worth much. If a guy can make one hundred million a year betting at the dog track more power to him. If jerry Springer can make five million acting like a clown good for him.
And then they can pay taxes proportional to how much success they have had accumulating money. There is nothing unfair about a progressive income tax. Those who make more money have benefited more from the system.
A flat tax is the fair tax they will be paying more because they earn more. I do not agree that a progressive tax is fair.
One thing that is clear is that the current tax code is far too complicated . If it takes a flat tax to clear away all those loopholes then that is what needs to be enacted . The rate of the flat tax is all that remains to be decided upon . Paul also proposed a flat tax but with a higher rate [14.5 % IIRC] .
This a passage I found attributed to Dave Chapelle
"Ok, fine, I dont have $50 million dollars. Lets say I have $10 million in the bank.The difference in lifestyle is miniscule."
But the difference in lifestyle between taking home $50 or $10thousandper year isstaggeringand can be measured with countless metrics including average lifespan, frequency of emergency room visits and incarceration rates.
The (barely) progressive tax structure of the United States of America, which needs to become far more progressive in the near future, represents our nation's belief that there should be a thriving middle class. This is the belief that it is not only economically sound butmorallyimperative that those who have significantly higher amounts of money, beyond what they need to maintain a healthy lifestyle, pay a higher percentage of it in taxes.
Essentially it comes down to telling gazillionaires: "I'm sorry, you're going to have to settle for a 132 foot long yacht instead of a 150 foot long yacht this year so that entire communities of Americans have enough to eat."
Bumper sticker slogans do not make an efficient tax code. If someone tells you they have a simple tax system that is both fair and effective... then that same person probably has a really cheap bridge to sell you, over in Brooklyn.
Alternatively, that person has no understanding whatsoever of taxes.
Ideally, a tax system meets two imperatives: cover budget needs, and be equitable. Of course, both of those are open to very different definitions, leading to complicated politics. But the economics are straightforward.
Maximizing revenue requires a progressive rate scale. The poor literally cannot pay much, while the "dissuasive rate" for the wealthy is about 70%. So we need several brackets, from 0% to 70%.
And let's keep it simple: all income gets taxed, regardless of origin.
And loopholes. Everyone hates loopholes... except their own. Obviously, there are abusive loopholes, but there are also a lot of legitimate "incentives". Everything from home ownership to... ummm... petroleum exploration... They all must be reviewed. Personally, I would cancel all of them, and then adopt the ones we really want, one by one.
If the resulting revenue is greater than budgetary needs (including pay-down of national debt), then the following year there should be a rebate. DON'T CHANGE THE TAX RATES!!!