CNN panel bursts into laughter after Trump advisor says Hillary will destroy 2nd Amendment
Pretty big lie by the Trump folks and other right wingers and Republicans.
The Trump spokesman says that because Clinton wants to have Heller revisited by the Court or legislation that means she wants to abolish the second amendment. To my knowledge Clinton has never said that all individual right to bear arms should be ended, she says that there should be more regulation of the right to bear arms. As noted in the CNN video, even Justice Scalia said that the 2nd amendment allows for some regulation of guns.
The thing that makes the "abolish" rhetoric more of a lie is the definition of "abolish"
Abolish - to do away with; put an end to; annul; make void
Abolishing the 2nd amendment would mean no more discussion of it and no more court decisions about it. Clinton has NEVER advocated this. Yet Trump lies about it, just like he lied about General Pershing, the size of trade imbalances, that he knew Putin personally, that he had been against the war in Iraq from the beginning, the New Jersey Muslims and everything else he lies incessantly about.
Tags
Who is online
74 visitors

The words of the Trump spokesman on the video are silly. That is why the panel all laugh at him.
I wonder how much they had to pay those idiots to make fools of themselves. Talk about bad acting.
I wonder how much they had to pay those idiots to make fools of themselves. Talk about bad acting.
You're wrong; no one has to pay Trump to be an idiot and make a fool of himself. But I agree, he is a bad actor.
nton has never said that all individual right to bear arms should be ended
That's like saying you don't think the constitutional right to abortion should be ended, but Roe v. Wade should be overturned. The whole point of Heller is establishing the individual right.
Sean, this is very simple. Abolishing the 2nd amendment would mean no further court rulings about it, because it wouldn't exist anymore. Clinton has never called for that. Claiming that she did or does is a bald lie.
One can lie through semantics.
Maybe this article can shed a little light
"Hillary Clinton believes a 2008 Supreme Court ruling that is the linchpin of an individual's right to own a gun was "wrongly decided," her policy adviser told Bloomberg Politics on Friday.
"Clinton believes Heller was wrongly decided in that cities and states should have the power to craft common sense laws to keep their residents safe, like safe storage laws to prevent toddlers from accessing guns," Maya Harris, a policy adviser to Clinton, said in an e-mailed statement. "In overturning Washington D.C.'s safe storage law, Clinton worries that Heller may open the door to overturning thoughtful, common sense safety measures in the future."
The stance by Clinton, the all-but-certain Democratic presidential nominee, carries potentially profound implications for the future of gun rights in the U.S.
In striking down a longstanding handgun ban in the District of Columbia, the D.C. v. Heller ruling marked the first time the Supreme Court held that the Second Amendment protected an individual's right to own a firearm for lawful purposes such as self-defense in the home.
The author of the contentious 5-to-4 opinion was Justice Antonin Scalia, who died in February. Republicans who control the Senate have vowed to block the confirmation of a successor until the next president is chosen. If Clinton, a lawyer before she entered politics, becomes president and chooses a nominee who reflects her view, a future Supreme Court could revisit, and potentially overturn, that ruling. Such a scenario could permit state and local governments to take stricter steps to restrict the sale of firearms in attempt to curb gun violence.
In addition, with several justices poised for possible retirements in the coming years—as of Election Day, Ruth Bader Ginsburg will be 83, Anthony Kennedy will be 80 and Stephen Breyer will be 78—the next president's picks could have a profound impact on the future of gun rights in the country.
In her statement, Harris also took issue with remarks by presumptive Republican nominee Donald Trump at the National Rifle Association convention Friday—where he accepted the gun-rights lobby's endorsement—that Clinton wants to "abolish" the Second Amendment.
"Along with the vast majority of Americans, Hillary Clinton believes there are common sense steps we can take at the federal level to keep guns out of the hands of criminals while respecting the 2nd Amendment. As both PolitiFact and Factcheck.org recently reported, Donald Trump is peddling falsehoods," Harris said.
Harris said. "Donald Trump's conspiracy theories are simply his latest attempt to divide the American people and distract from his radical and dangerous ideas, like his promise to mandate that every school in America allow guns in their classrooms."
While Trump is campaigning on a staunchly pro-gun-rights platform that includes granting a right to carry a firearm in all 50 states, Clinton has taken an aggressive stance for gun control, including strengthening mandatory background checks and banning assault weapons."
JOhn, you should get your information from a source other than the Clinton's p.r. machine:
From a Constitutional law Professor:
An advisor to Hillay Clinton said that Heller was “wrongly decided.” But she has absolutely no idea what the case held.
The critical, constitutional issue, was whether the District of Columbia could ban the private ownership of handguns. The case in no way affected “safe storage laws.” In fact, the District of Columbia still has safe storage laws in effect.
From the Metropolitan Police Department’s website :
If Ms. Harris is going to criticize a Supreme Court decision, she should have some clue what the case is about.
And, ALL democrats should take a course in constitutional law and Supreme Court precedence.
Heller was a case of first impression, which means it was the first time the right to bear arms was directly before the courts. (the reason it has come to this point at this late date cause the commonly held belief that the citizen does absolutely have said right)
Being a case of first appearance means the court actually decides what it actually means under the constitution. They visit the Founders statements of what it means and decide based upon their intent. (using the meanings in place at the time it was written)
And it complied with the founders plain intent. the citizens of this nation should never have their rights to own or possess firearms abridged. That does not mean regulated, means taken away. the Second Amendment cannot be legislatively abridged.
And that sets the precedent that all future cases are adjudicated by. Unless by some hook or crook anyone can come up with word meanings that mean the opposite of what the founders actually wrote.
The Citizen have the rights to own weapons, and not only did Scalia state that such weapons can be regulated, he stated that such weapons the founders contemplated as the weapons covered by the amendments means the same weapons any ordinary soldier would carry as part of his usual duties connected to the military. (comforms to Kellerman and other cases along that vein)
So what this means is an upholding of decisions that regulate possession, but specifically upholds decisions that allow possession of military grade common personal weapons also. (you can regulate but you cannot regulate to the point of removing possession. (Rifles, Carbines, Pistols and Shotguns) Automatic weapons although commonly used by the military as personal weapons the automatic functionality can be regulated. explosive devices can be regulated and banned as they are not covered by the second amendment. (there goes your atomic bomb arguments as well as the civilian possession of non-demilled fully functional tanks and armored vehicles, aircraft and aircraft carriers, chemical and biological weapons and any other highly destructive forms of weapons)
that is what happens with a case of first impression, it sets the impression under the constitution of what the founders intended. And is virtually impossible to overturn.
That's nice.
Don't see the excuse for right wing and Trump lies in it though.
I don't see it as a lie, but as a YUUUGE exaggeration.
Would Clinton "Like" to do away with the second amendment, I believe that is a true statement she would love to do exactly that.
BUT, she is also smart enough to know that is never going to happen, not in 20 lifetimes. (or democrat presidencies)
So is she actually saying it, no. Her position is that the decision was decided wrongly in it specifically limits the ways Democrats like to "Regulate" weapons which is regulate to non-possession. That is why she feels it was wrongfully decided.
She would use regulation to effectively gut the second amendment, without abolishing it, Heller puts a stop to that.
Would Clinton "Like" to do away with the second amendment, I believe that is a true statement she would love to do exactly that.
I disagree. However it is not virtually impossible to overturn Heller, with the right justices on the SCOTUS. AND that is in no way getting rid of the 2nd amendment. The man is a liar and his rational is a joke. He is a paid Trump media whore with no self respect. Thus the well deserved laughter.
You musta missed this.....
She would use regulation to effectively gut the second amendment, without abolishing it
Which is what the law Heller struck down actually did. And is the position she supports.
AND the position the court took in establishing the specific definition of the second amendment is not overturnable, unless the highly unlikely situation comes about that someone argues in a court of law that there is no right to own a weapon.
Good luck with that.
Although they may attempt to overturn pieces of it like the limits on regulation.
She would use regulation to effectively gut the second amendment, without abolishing it
Where did she say that? I haven't heard her say it. Even Trump's paid media whore on the tape didn't say she said it. Got a link?
Though the one woman sitting next to the paid whore got it right when she said that even Scalia said the 2nd amendment should have some restrictions.
I didn't say she said it, I said it was an accurate statement of her position on the subject. And as a knowledgeable person on the political position of most politicians on the second amendment, I believe I know her position better than most.
She believes that the court went too far in blocking the government ability to regulate. and by deciding heller in that way it prevents the government from enacting regulations like the one struck down that improve the safety and environment in society for those that do not own guns.
And the court ruled the exact opposite cause the regulation she supports was a defacto ban on handguns. Which is an impermissible infringement on the second amendment.
You CAN regulate, but you cannot regulate to the result the amendment was created to prevent.
I said it was an accurate statement of her position on the subject.
I disagree. I believe that, like Scalia, she thinks there should be some gun restrictions. That's not a new idea as we have some of them now and have had for all of my life that I can remember. I think that she is a strong supporter of the 2nd amendment and that her position that it should not be a completely unrestricted amendment is certainly not a radical idea as it already is. Gut it? Not hardly. That is an NRA scare tactic.
IMHO.
And the court ruled the exact opposite cause the regulation she supports was a defacto ban on handguns. Which is an impermissible infringement on the second amendment.
And the Court once ruled that Black people were not human beings and had no rights. Courts can and do change rulings. And they may rule differently after Clinton gets to appoint several new Justices over the next 8 years.
Oh and you said:
"You musta missed this....."
"She would use regulation to effectively gut the second amendment, without abolishing it"
And then when I asked you when she had said that and did you have a link to her saying it you said she didn't say it. Well if she or nobody else said it, then how could I have missed it if nobody ever said it? You can't "miss" something that was never said.
Oh Wow!
Hilarious, really Hilarious!
Way beneath your intelligence level, but hilarious none the less.
Have you ever noticed that when you have nothing intelligent to say (which is getting to be more often and mostly when you've been caught in a lie or are in over your head) that you try belittle others by saying you're smarter then they can understand when the truth is you haven't a clue and laugh. What are you? 8 years old?
You don't seem to have a clue what this is about. Scalia's Heller decision allows some gun regulations, but overturned the outright ban on individual ownership that Washington D. C imposed. Clinton says it was "wrongly decided" even though it allows "common sense" regulations. She's manipulating her ignorant followers into thinking overturning Heller is about allowing regulations. It's not, because Heller allows regulations,which you should recognize when you say Scalia allows it. Heller is wrong to Hillary only because she wants outright bans.
Think about it. Since Heller already allows "common sense" regulations, why does Hillary want to change it?
The hilarious thing is that you spin your wheels trying to find a way to paper over the fact that Trump and the Republicans have been deliberately falsifying what Clinton has been saying. She wants to have the courts or law to reopen the issues of Heller, including what restrictions can be placed on individual gun ownership.
That is NOT the same thing as abolishing the second amendment. Courts , including the Supreme Court, could still rule on the constitutional meaning of the 2nd amendment, and even rule in the conservatives favor. If the amendment is "abolished" it is gone from all consideration forever.
Stop lying Trump and fans.
ncluding what restrictions can be placed on individual gun ownership.
Heller allows restrictions, yet She said Heller itself is wrongly decided, That can only mean either she doesn't think there should be any restriction or she favors the total ban that the Heller court overturned. Which is it John?
Simply, if you think citizens have a right to carry arms but that right is subject to reasonable restrictions, than Heller is perfectly decided. Hillary obviously doesn't believe that since she thinks it was wrongly decided.
Keep spinning.
She has not discussed abolishing the second amendment.
Heller affirms the right of people to carry guns under certain circumstances. I agree it does offer some restrictions. However there are other restrictions that could be put into place that would not infringe on the 2nd amendment, such as not allowing weapons to be carried (except by peace officers) into places where alcohol is served or into schools, with the same exception. Heller was wrongly decided because it did not go far enough in containing further restrictions. Scalia believed that the 2nd is no absolute and it's not. A person can not walk into a store (or any other place) carrying a Bazooka for instance. Or a machine gun. Or a rocket launcher. Yet some people have wrongly interpreted Heller as meaning they can carry whatever weapon they want anywhere they want with no restrictions at all. Heller needs to be clarified, which means either overturning it and starting over again or add more restrictions to it.
Scalia believed that the 2nd is no absolute and it's not
compare with
believe that, like Scalia, she thinks there should be some gun restrictions.
Scalia believed that the 2nd is no absolute and it's not
compare with
believe that, like Scalia, she thinks there should be some gun restrictions.
The same (except I have a typo on the first one. The word "no" should read "not". Cheap KB on a cheap laptop). Your point?
And a bazooka is not a weapon covered by the second amendment.
Your constant hyperbolic argument destroys any logic or sanity you were hoping to bring to the table.
Scalia clearly laid out which weapons the second amendment covers eliminating all the rest.
Hillary supports gun regulation to the point of eliminating possession, she supports the ideal that the government has the right to do such over the constitution.
And that is a position she has not been shy about, despite Hillary bots claiming otherwise. (and yeah I apologize for calling you a hillary bot, but you are taking their position against all logic and common sense)
And I'm going to step out of the conversation cause three people in a conversation that is not threaded makes for a confusing to follow jumble of comments.
And a bazooka is not a weapon covered by the second amendment.
Of course it is. Scalia said that any weapon that could be carried and operated by a single person was a weapon under the 2nd amendment.
Hillary supports gun regulation to the point of eliminating possession, she supports the ideal that the government has the right to do such over the constitution.
When and where did she say that?
I accept your apology for saying your sorry for calling me a Hillary-bot, but it really wasn't necessary as I am nobody's bot, such as an NRA-bot.