╌>

House Democrats Sit On The Floor And Pout Like Babies

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  xxjefferson51  •  10 years ago  •  213 comments

House Democrats Sit On The Floor And Pout Like Babies
Let’s say you’re a House Democrat (sorry) and you’re not getting what you want just because it’s unconstitutional. Whaddaya do next? That’s easy: You throw a big baby fit!

NBC News:

Rep. John Lewis, one of the last living icons of civil disobedience during the civil rights movement, was leading a sit-in on the House floor Wednesday in an effort to force a vote on gun control…

The protest is not being televised because the House has not formally gaveled into session. House members took to social media to lodge their protests using the hashtags #NoBillNoBreak, #NOMORESILENCE and #goodtrouble.



Read more: http://dailycaller.com/2016/06/22/house-democrats-sit-on-the-floor-and-pout-like-babies/#ixzz4CM5P3sCm

Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   Spikegary    10 years ago

Now, turn off the lights, turn off the A/C and don't allow food deliveries to the floor.  These protesters are using their staff, paid by your tax dollar to deliver them food while they lay around and mug for the media.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov  replied to  Spikegary   10 years ago

Let them sit in their own waste. 

 
 
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   Spikegary    10 years ago

This just in, the Dems are quitting their protest, now that they got their pictures in the paper and few pathetic quotes into the news.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov  replied to  Spikegary   10 years ago

Ah. Their political theater is over for the weekend. What dedicated social justice warriors! Lol.

 
 
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   Spikegary    10 years ago

Ah, now this makes more sense.....from another news story today, tonight is the annual Dems vs. Pubs baseball game:

"On Thursday, following one of the most bitter party clashes ever witnessed on the House floor, the right-handed Louisiana lawmaker will try to lead his Democratic colleagues to their eighth consecutive win over Republicans in the annual Congressional Baseball Game at Nationals Park."  --NBC News

Now we know why they ended their sit in......

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    10 years ago

Democratic Sit-in Gun Control Protest Fueled by Ironic Takeout

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober  replied to  sixpick   10 years ago

At least they've got good taste ...

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick  replied to  Petey Coober   10 years ago

At least they've got good taste ...

Really pissed off the LGBT and Bill DeBlasiass!

 
 
 
jennilee
Freshman Silent
link   jennilee  replied to  Petey Coober   10 years ago

Apparently chick fil a is the choice of democratic congress too ! 

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov  replied to  jennilee   10 years ago

Their ridiculous rules aren't meant to affect THEM!

 
 
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   Spikegary    10 years ago

Did you see pictures of the spread laid out for them to sustain them during their horrible ordeal of sitting in the air conditioned chamber?  I wonder who paid for that?  Yeah, I think we know who.........

 
 
 
jennilee
Freshman Silent
link   jennilee  replied to  Spikegary   10 years ago

"No vote no recess"  sounded good for media effect but did any of them actually give up their holiday to stick to their so called principles?    

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov  replied to  jennilee   10 years ago

Nope. They are classless that way.

 
 
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   Spikegary    10 years ago

Nope, they all had to get over to the annual Congressional Baseball game.  I mean, they had been practicing and all, and the Dems need to keep their record going, since they beat the 'Pubs 8 out of the last 9 games.  I mean, you have to have priorities and all.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    10 years ago

I hope their constituency is suitably embarrassed by this cynical, childish stunt.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    10 years ago

I guess they could have called it a boycott and refused to work. But since they don't work anyway, nobody would notice. On the bright side, the local economy made money: caterers delivered food: dry cleaners will clean expensive suits; the tailors will re-stitch pants that burst at the seams when the sit in began; and the drug store will sell ointment to soothe all those arthritic knees not used to hoisting lard off the floor.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    10 years ago

Democrats protesting on House Floor.jpg

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell    10 years ago

Not one liberal came to this article.

One has to limit the exposure one has to raw sewage.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    10 years ago

The headline and its heartless ignorant half truth got it mixed up; House Democrats were not pouting LIKE CHILDREN …

THEY WERE POUTING ON BEHALF OF CHILDREN SHOT TO DEATH BY ONE MORE GUN CRAZY BASTARD!

THESE (and other) children.

What kind of (alleged) human beings have such f'd up priorities and, are more than willing to mischaracterize on behalf of murderers with firearms?

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov  replied to  A. Macarthur   10 years ago

It was a publicity stunt and fund raiser. They accomplished nothing but embarrassing themselves.

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty  replied to  Cerenkov   10 years ago

Hopefully it opened some eyes to who the gun grabbers are and they lose their next election. 

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    10 years ago

It was a publicity stunt and fund raiser.

Quoting Paul Ryan who lacks the character to indicate that (i.e.) THE PHOTOS OF THE MURDERED CHILDREN ARE REAL, NOT A PUBLICITY STUNT, and, LIKE WITH ABORTIONS, THEIR BEATING HEARTS WERE STOPPED … TO SOME DEGREE BY PRO-LIFE-HYPOCRITE-NRA-OWNED LEGISLATORS AND A MENTALLY-ILL KILLER WHOSE GUN-NUT MOTHER BOUGHT HIM FIREARMS!

Yes, I'm shouting …

… murdered kids will affect my tone …

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov  replied to  A. Macarthur   10 years ago

POLITICAL THEATER. A cynical attempt to raise funds via tragedy. Disgusting and a waste of time.

 
 
 
Bloody Bill
Freshman Silent
link   Bloody Bill    10 years ago

Hey, if it makes them feel better then more power to them. But it has all the practical effect of yelling at clouds.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov  replied to  Bloody Bill   10 years ago

Exactly. It's all political theater. That's all they have.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    10 years ago

It's like watching people blame Zyklon B for the Holocaust. If only there'd been laws banning Zyklon B in Nazi Germany!

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur  replied to  Sean Treacy   10 years ago

It's like watching people blame Zyklon B for the Holocaust. If only there'd been laws banning Zyklon B in Nazi Germany!

No, Sean … your "reasoning" is flawed … terribly flawed.

It's actually like watching people ATTEMPTING TO DO WHATEVER POSSIBLE TO REIGN IN, TO MITIGATE, THE UNFETTERED ABILITY OF THOSE WHO WOULD USE "ZYKLON B" AGAINST INNOCENT PEOPLE … TO PUSH THOSE IN POWER TO ACT RESPONSIBLY.

Who among you actually believes that a law that allows "holocausts" of any kind … be they genocide, corrupt business practices that destroy the lives of innocent citizens … OUT-OF-CONTROL-GUN-VIOLENCE … is a law that should stand for all time regardless of how the times and populace affected by that law changes?

The Constitution was configured to allow amendments … even amendments to existing amendments, that, because its authors anticipated changes over time and the corresponding need for laws to reflect those changes.

Christians in Germany who looked the other way as Jews were scapegoated and murdered … FDR in America who turned away Jews trying to escape the Nazi Death Camps … PEOPLE WHO HAVE THE POWER TO DO THE RIGHT THING AND/OR INFLUENCE THOSE WHO DO, are GUILTY of cowardice at the least, and tacit complicity at worst.

The CONSTITUTION was not intended to enable the analogous "Zyklon Bs" through the on-going existence of rights that for whatever reasons, need to reflect CURRENT REALITY!

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    10 years ago

I helped you out I voted the non substance deleted comment down also, just now.  

POOR BABY!!!!!!!!!!!!laughing dude

Your avatar name suits your style and use of the thumb quite aptly. 

Try adding something to the site and the conversations instead of representing the place where complicated thoughts go to die.

WTF would some of you do without the emoticons to express your views?

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    10 years ago

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov  replied to  Dean Moriarty   10 years ago

Another liberal media hack who doesn't know what an automatic weapon is...

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur  replied to  Cerenkov   10 years ago

Another liberal media hack who doesn't know what an automatic weapon is...

Almost as annoying as a gun-loving-pro-life-pro-war-pro-torture-anti-environmentalism-anti-health-insurance-for-kids-with-cancer schmuck who doesn't care what assault weapons and high capacity magazines do to humans … AS LONG AS THE SCHMUCK CAN BE A MACHO GUN-GUY …

… everything else is of no significance.

 

 

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov  replied to  A. Macarthur   10 years ago

Another liberal with no understanding of the Constitution or due process. Enjoy your dead children pictures.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    10 years ago

Another liberal with no understanding of the Constitution or due process. Enjoy your dead children pictures.

Wow! The statement says a lot about who/what you are, your deranged perspective and distorted sense of the relative significance of reality! I don't know whether to deem you as disgusting or pitiful.

Constitutional scholar are you?

The documents from 1789 that detailed the  First Congress’ debate on arms and militia , contain a constant theme: the 2nd Amendment was created to protect the American government.

The James Madison resolution on the issue clearly stated that the right to bear arms “shall not be infringed” since a “well-regulated militia” is the “best security of a free country.” That's why we have a National Guard instead of relying on a bunch of armed White Nationalists at a Trump rally.

A  locally-based, well-regulated -- under the control of local authorities, who answer to national authority - militia.  Today, we call this the National Guard.    

Virginia’s (i.e.) support of a right to bear arms was based on the same rationale: “A well regulated Militia composed of the body of the people trained to arms is the proper, natural and safe defence of a free State”

The 2nd Amendment reads: “A well regulated militia being necessary to the security of a free state, the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed.” It's a  conditional statement . It means, " … to maintain this defensive militia, we must allow Americans to keep and bear arms."

We now have been a standing army/military.  

Article 1, Section 8, line 16 of the Constitution doesn't put a limit on the National Guard militia. Instead, it gives Congress the right: "To provide for organizing, arming, and disciplining, the Militia, and for governing such Part of them as may be employed in the Service of the United States , reserving to the States respectively, the Appointment of the Officers, and the Authority of training the Militia according to the discipline prescribed by Congress." 

Line 15 says Congress has the power to: "To provide for calling forth the Militia to execute the Laws of the Union, suppress Insurrections and repel Invasions." There's nothing about taking down the government -- nothing to validate the macho, faux-patriot fantasies.

A National Guard militia is a civic duty not a personal right. Defense of the state is not defense against the state.

As for guns needed to protect the citizen from criminals …

Having a gun in your home significantly increases your risk of death — and that of your spouse and children.

And  it doesn’t matter  how the guns are stored or what type or how many guns you own.

If you have a gun, everybody in your home is more likely than your non-gun-owning neighbors and their families to die in a gun-related accident, suicide or homicide.

Furthermore, there is no credible evidence that having a gun in your house reduces your risk of being a victim of a crime. Nor does it reduce your risk of being injured during a home break-in.

 

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov  replied to  A. Macarthur   10 years ago

Have fun with your poor reasoning. SCOTUS has already determined that the 2nd is an individual right.

"...anti-health-insurance-for-kids-with-cancer..."

Wow, that says a lot about you and your hypocrisy. 

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur  replied to  Cerenkov   10 years ago

Have fun with your poor reasoning. SCOTUS has already determined that the 2nd is an individual right.

Even the NRA concedes that you can’t have mad men running around with weapons of mass destruction. So there are some restrictions that are permissible and it will be the task of the legislature and the courts to ferret all of that out and draw the lines. 

"...anti-health-insurance-for-kids-with-cancer..."

Wow, that says a lot about you and your hypocrisy. 

Really? You can't see the obvious hypocrisy of being simultaneously pro-gun, etc. and anti-health insurance for children et al (that conservatives consistently want to repeal)?

A little insight …

Following are the words of Chittister, nun, author and speaker: “I do not believe that just because you’re opposed to abortion, that that makes you pro-life. In fact, I think in many cases your morality is deeply lacking if all you want is a child born but not a child fed, not a child educated, not a child housed. And why would I think that you don’t? Because you don’t want any tax money to go there.

“That’s not pro-life. That’s pro-birth. We need a much broader conversation on what the morality of pro-life is.”

____________________________________________________________________

As usual, you come with a dismissive comment and a thumb and fail to offer substantive counter points.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov  replied to  A. Macarthur   10 years ago

No hypocrisy there. One is a human right and one is not.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur  replied to  Cerenkov   10 years ago

No hypocrisy there. One is a human right and one is not.

In the U.S., that's true … but a rather ugly indictment regarding our priorities.

How ironic … after a gun puts a bullet in an American, if the victim survives the manifestation of a patriotic gun owner's right-to-bear-arms (that patriot, of course pulling the trigger while wearing in his well-regulated militia outfit), if that victim doesn't have health insurance, he gets to choose between life and bankruptcy … or death.

And the same fucked-up legislators who keep it that way are the ones likely to pander to those who declare that "This is a Christian Nation".

Since we're talking hypocrisy … 

Just sayin' …

Post thumbs, I request explanations as to the specific basis of any dislikes/disagreements.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov  replied to  A. Macarthur   10 years ago

Conflating Christianity with fiscal responsibility, gun control, or health care is just a cheap shot. Not all conservatives are religious.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur  replied to  Cerenkov   10 years ago

Conflating Christianity with fiscal responsibility, gun control, or health care is just a cheap shot. Not all conservatives are religious.

No conflation at all; hypocrites want it both ways … they talk the religiosity when it's politically expedient then avoid it when it's time to walk-the-walk.

It's true, not all conservatives are religious, but right-wing politicians pander to the religious in their base and ALWAYS PLAY THE "OUR THOUGHTS AND PRAYERS GO OUT TO THE VICTIMS (of mass shootings)."

That's hypocrisy; same with health care/insurance. Republicans are Pro-life as long as it doesn't violate "fiscal responsibility" -- give us all a fuckin' break! You put a dollar cost value on human life, do you?

The CHEAP shot is yours … LITERALLY … when you advocate placing money over life!

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov  replied to  A. Macarthur   10 years ago

Well, since I am not religious, I will leave you to argue with these other strawmen.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur  replied to  Cerenkov   10 years ago

Well, since I am not religious, I will leave you to argue with these other strawmen.

Apparently you are limited in your ability to discuss concepts that do not apply to you directly …

That's why there are schools, books, thought … 

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober  replied to  A. Macarthur   10 years ago

That's why there are schools, books, thought …

Thought is usually a beneficial thing to have . I have seen very little from you . Mostly you just fly into a rage ... newsflash : that is not thinking , its emoting .

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany  replied to  A. Macarthur   10 years ago

The documents from 1789 that detailed the  First Congress’ debate on arms and militia , contain a constant theme:  the 2nd Amendment was created to protect the American government . . .

I have a different view. At the time of the American Revolution, it was not uncommon for males over the age of 16 to have a gun. Nobody objected to disarming people who were a proven threat to public safety but there was strong objection to generally disarming the public. The British knew that the colonies were nearing rebellion and they also knew that they could not easily impose military rule on an armed populace. So the British implemented warrantless searches and seizures, in large part, to seize guns/ammunition/black powder. The British also blocked the importation of arms and ammunition to the colonies. As the British became more strident, the colonies began to form their own militias outside of British command structures. Some militias were more loosely organized than others; some provided guns and others expected the men to bring their own; some did both. 

The war began as a reaction to a British force sent to Lexington and Concord to confiscate American arms. The American colonists tried to make a stand against the British at Lexington but were routed. More colonists grabbed their guns and rushed to stop the British at Concord where they drove the British back. When the British tried to retreat to Boston, the colonists fell upon them either in hastily formed units or as individual sharpshooters picking the British off with their duck-shooting long rifles. Although the colonists had many gripes, they fought back in earnest when the British government tried to disarm them. The men who were most remembered for courage were the individual minutemen who grabbed their own weapons and rushed to the defense at a minute's notice. 

The first Congressional discussions, in my opinion, were centered on whether the federal government needed a standing army or whether the nation could be defended by militias. Standing armies were viewed as dangerous to liberty. Whether there was a standing army or not, they wanted to make clear that the federal government could not confiscate guns or interfere with local militias (both were problems under imperial British rule). 

In my opinion, the 2nd Amendment was in part created to protect the American government and in part to protect the American people from the government. If you read the Declaration of Independence, it makes quite clear that it's premised on a right to self-defense. That, in turn, is based on the belief that the government is servant to the people, not the master, and that the people have the right of armed revolt against tyranny. It says ". . . But when a long train of abuses and usurpations, pursuing invariably the same Object evinces a design to reduce them [the People] under absolute Despotism, it is their right, it is their duty, to throw off such Government, and to provide new Guards for their security." This is not the preservation of the right to hunt, since people do not bear arms against animals; it is the justification for armed rebellion against a tyrannical government. 

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur  replied to  1ofmany   10 years ago

In my opinion,  the 2nd Amendment was in part created to protect the American government and in part to protect the American people  from  the government.  If you read the Declaration of Independence, it makes quite clear that it's premised on a right to self-defense.

The Constitution came into force in 1789, the Declaration on July 4, 1776. In the thirteen year gap, IMO, the Founding Fathers took a more enlightened view.

This is not the preservation of the right to hunt, since people do not bear arms against animals; it is the justification for armed rebellion against a tyrannical government. 

In  a tirade  against CNN’s Piers Morgan, Alex Jones argued, “The Second Amendment isn’t there for duck hunting. It’s there to protect us from tyrannical government.”

So sayeth the gun nuts.

It’s an argument that’s often echoed by gun nuts – as though their fully-loaded AR-15 with 100-bullet drum will keep them safe from Predator drones and cruise missiles. If indeed this is the true intent of the 2nd Amendment, protection from the government, then here’s the newsflash: you guys are woefully outgunned. And the 2nd Amendment would have allowed you to own a cannon and a warship, so America today would look more like Somalia today with well-armed warlords running their own little fiefdoms in defiance of the federal government.

The Supreme Court put an end to that reticence last week when it came down squarely on the side of the individual-rights interpretation. In so doing, the court struck down the D.C. gun ban as a clear violation of that right.

Yet the court also recognized that this right is not absolute. “Like most rights,” Justice Antonin Scalia wrote for the majority, “the right secured by the Second Amendment is not unlimited.” The court offered no opinion, however, on exactly where that right ends, and reasonable regulation begins.

For example, the court did not disturb D.C.’s requirement that all gun owners be licensed. Federal, state, and local officials, as well as the American public, must now grapple with that question, which may ultimately end up back before the high court.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany  replied to  A. Macarthur   10 years ago

In my opinion,  the 2nd Amendment was in part created to protect the American government and in part to protect the American people  from  the government.  If you read the Declaration of Independence, it makes quite clear that it's premised on a right to self-defense.

The Constitution came into force in 1789, the Declaration on July 4, 1776. In the thirteen year gap, IMO, the Founding Fathers took a more enlightened view.

And, in my opinion, the Founding Fathers wanted to make sure that the federal government could not become as tyrannical as the British. The 2nd Amendment and the Declaration of Independence fit together like a hand in a glove. In fact, the entire Bill of Rights can be viewed as a states rights document, limiting federal authority.

This is not the preservation of the right to hunt, since people do not bear arms against animals; it is the justification for armed rebellion against a tyrannical government. 

In  a tirade  against CNN’s Piers Morgan, Alex Jones argued, “The Second Amendment isn’t there for duck hunting. It’s there to protect us from tyrannical government.”

So sayeth the gun nuts.

So sayeth history. It would have never crossed the Founding Father's minds that anyone remotely thought the 2nd Amendment was about hunting.

It’s an argument that’s often echoed by gun nuts – as though their fully-loaded AR-15 with 100-bullet drum will keep them safe from Predator drones and cruise missiles. If indeed this is the true intent of the 2nd Amendment, protection from the government, then here’s the newsflash: you guys are woefully outgunned. And the 2nd Amendment would have allowed you to own a cannon and a warship, so America today would look more like Somalia today with well-armed warlords running their own little fiefdoms in defiance of the federal government.

News flash for the historical revisionists: The British army was the best in the world in its time and the minutemen were only a match in courage, not weaponry. Still they fought back with what they had. As an example, the Finns were hopelessly outgunned and outnumbered when the Soviets invaded in 1939 yet they held them off for months. The Soviet army was probably larger than the entire population of Finland. But the Finns fought back. When the they ran out of ammo, they fought with knives. When they had no vehicles, they fought on skis. Finland remained free.

I agree that the right to bear arms does not extend to owning drones, machine guns, missile systems, cannons, and warships. But an AR-15 is basically a cool looking small game hunting rifle. I'd buy one if getting it inside my house didn't require me to shoot my wife on the way in . . . because she would stand in the doorway and say it's coming inside only over her dead body lol. 

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty  replied to  1ofmany   10 years ago

The founding fathers did intend for private citizens to have warships. 

Article 1, Section 8 of the US Constitution states that Congress has the following power: 

"To declare War, grant Letters of Marque and Reprisal, and make Rules concerning Captures on Land and Water;"

A letter of marque is a kind of a naval hunting license. It allows a private citizen to fight on behalf of the government in wartime, stopping and capturing enemy vessels on the high seas. This is called privateering. In order to wage war at sea the said private citizen would have to have a warship. That would be  something like the frigate in the picture, a ship armed with cannon. 

Since one cannot be a privateer without a warship, the fact that this is in the Constitution demonstrates that it's authors fully expected armed warships to be in private ownership. A warship was basically the WMD of it's day, the most destructive weapon in existence. A ship's battery could level a coastal city. 

So, the argument that the weapons the Founders knew about were limited to muskets and swords is completely baseless.  The founders might be shocked by many things in  our day (women voting?), but weapons wouldn't be one of them. 

Warship of the time and private. 

320

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur  replied to  Dean Moriarty   10 years ago

Since one cannot be a privateer without a warship, the fact that this is in the Constitution demonstrates that it's authors fully expected armed warships to be in private ownership. A warship was basically the WMD of it's day, the most destructive weapon in existence. A ship's battery could level a coastal city. 

And how long ago was "its day"?

The Constitution was ratified with the ability to be a living document … AMENDABLE to reflect THE DAY ON WHICH ANY/ALL PARTS ARE TO BE APPLIED.

How old is that WMD in the picture, Dean?

A  privateer  (sometimes called  corsair  or  buccaneer ) was a private person or ship authorized by a government by  letters of marque  to attack foreign vessels during wartime, and take them as prizes. Captured ships were subject to condemnation and sale under  prize law , with the proceeds divided between the privateer shipowners and crew. Privateering was a way of mobilizing armed ships and sailors as naval auxiliaries.

Historically, the distinction between a  privateer  and a  pirate  has been blurred, sometimes depending on the source as to which label was correct. [1]  At times, pirates sought dubious government sanction to operate under a veil of legitimacy.

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty  replied to  A. Macarthur   10 years ago

You miss the whole point. They wanted the citizens to have access to the most advanced weapons available. 

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur  replied to  Dean Moriarty   10 years ago

You miss the whole point. They wanted the citizens to have access to the most advanced weapons available. 

Not so; they wanted citizens to have access to the weapons that fit the times. The point of an AMENDABLE DOCUMENT is its logistical ability to change with and reflect the reality that times can and do change.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov  replied to  A. Macarthur   10 years ago

"The Constitution was ratified with the ability to be a living document … AMENDABLE to reflect THE DAY ON WHICH ANY/ALL PARTS ARE TO BE APPLIED."

Go ahead and start a campaign to ammend the Constitution by whittling down the bill of rights. I acknowledge that's a legal option.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser  replied to  Cerenkov   10 years ago

This gun was banned in the 1860s, because it could wipe out an entire flock of ducks with one shot.  There wasn't any of this hand-wringing about gun owner's rights back then.  Just a thought.  Remember, I'm a gun owner, too.

320

 
 
 
TTGA
Professor Silent
link   TTGA  replied to  Dowser   10 years ago

Actually Dowser, that is a punt gun and they are not banned; they simply are no longer made because they have no conceivable use.  If you wish to own one and can still find one, they are perfectly legal to own and even to shoot.  What was banned was not the ownership of them but using them to hunt waterfowl.

There wasn't any of this hand-wringing about gun owner's rights back then

That's because there was no organized political campaign back then to steal the rights of the people.  Now there is.  You may be a gun owner now, but give it 20  or 30 years and you  may not be.  The gun grabbers are thinking long term.  They want them all, but are willing to take them a few at a time.  That way, they can keep denying that their intention is to take all guns from civilians.  Some of them have made a small error, though, and have revealed their ultimate intentions (see the speeches of Nancy Pelosi on the subject from 1995).

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser  replied to  TTGA   10 years ago

Ahhhh... I misread the article-- it was unusual photographs of history, and this was shown.  I don't think they ever gave that much explanation!  Thanks!

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur  replied to  Cerenkov   10 years ago

"The Constitution was ratified with the ability to be a living document … AMENDABLE to reflect THE DAY ON WHICH ANY/ALL PARTS ARE TO BE APPLIED."

Go ahead and start a campaign to ammend the Constitution by whittling down the bill of rights. I acknowledge that's a legal option.

You missed some whittling down it seems …

Amendment XIII ABOLITION OF SLAVERY

Passed by Congress January 31, 1865. Ratified December 6, 1865. The 13th Amendment changed a portion of Article IV, Section 2

 

SECTION 1

Neither slavery nor involuntary servitude, except as a punishment for crime whereof the party shall have been duly convicted, shall exist within the United States, or any place subject to their jurisdiction.

 

SECTION 2

Congress shall have power to enforce this article by appropriate legislation.

____________________________________

The  Nineteenth Amendment  ( Amendment XIX ) to the  United States Constitution  prohibits any United States citizen from being denied the right to vote  on the basis of sex. It was  ratified  on August 18, 1920. Until the 1910s, most states disenfranchised women. The amendment was the culmination of the  women's suffrage movement in the United States , which fought at both state and national levels to achieve the vote. It effectively overruled  Minor v. Happersett , in which a unanimous Supreme Court  ruled that the  Fourteenth Amendment  did not give women the right to vote.

 

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov  replied to  A. Macarthur   10 years ago

Which of the bill of rights ammendments were eliminated by the prohibition of slavery or women's suffrage?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur  replied to  Cerenkov   10 years ago

Which of the bill of rights ammendments were eliminated by the prohibition of slavery or women's suffrage?

Did WOMEN and SLAVES enjoy the full benefits of the FIRST AMENDMENT?

Please answer specifically. If one cannot vote … or leave the slave owner … do those circumstances not abrogate speech, assembly, protest, the press (slaves were not legally permitted to read or write).

The 2nd Amendment blinds a whole lot of otherwise intelligent people to much of reality.

 

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov  replied to  A. Macarthur   10 years ago

So, as I surmised, neither the prohibition of slavery nor women's suffrage whittled any right ensconced in the first ten ammendments? 

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur  replied to  Cerenkov   10 years ago

 

So, as I surmised, neither the prohibition of slavery nor women's suffrage whittled any right ensconced in the first ten ammendments? 

It ain't about "ensconced" -- that's equivocation; certain rights under the First Amendment were de facto denied to classes of individuals by virtue of gender and slave status. Those rights were subsequently extended to those classes via Constitutional Amendments.

Among the Amendments beyond those comprising the Bill of Rights, is the 14th which interestingly, coming in 1868 …

The radical Republicans who drafted the language of the 14th Amendment realized that by making a "natural rights" case for including blacks as full citizens, with all the rights and obligations, they would be making the same case for women. Had the amendment contained only the language of Section 1, women's rights advocates would have been thrilled because it would have strengthened their argument for female suffrage, even though it had to do with establishing citizenship rather than the right to vote per se:

You can do your own homework to learn the rest; after all, at least one of your previous comments implies that you're an expert and I don't know what I'm talking about.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov  replied to  A. Macarthur   10 years ago

I begin to wonder if you do know what you are talking about. I suggested you start a movement to amend the Constitution to whittke down the bill of rights since that was legal. You made a snarky comment about how the bill of rights was already whittled down by other ammendments. I demonstrated that your examples were wrong. Your move (and not the goal posts again)...

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur  replied to  Cerenkov   10 years ago

I begin to wonder if you do know what you are talking about. I suggested you start a movement to amend the Constitution to whittke down the bill of rights since that was legal. You made a snarky comment about how the bill of rights was already whittled down by other ammendments. I demonstrated that your examples were wrong. Your move (and not the goal posts again)...

And I'm beginning to wonder why I think I can have a reasonable dialogue with you.

I definitive explained which part of the Bill of Rights was "whittled down" (YOUR WORDS NOT MINE); the rights of the First Amendment were initially denied in part to women, and denied in full to slaves (I won't argue whether or not their non-citizenship precluded such).

If you found that explanation "snarky," there is no point in continuing with you … you asked what you thought was a "gotcha" question out of a failure to see a connection that clearly exists.

Subsequently, because you can't deal with legitimate give-and-take-dialogue, you suggested that I am dishonest in my comments.

That ends it.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov  replied to  A. Macarthur   10 years ago

No part of the bill of rights was whittled down by future ammendments. In fact, they were expanded. You are wrong.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur  replied to  Cerenkov   10 years ago

No part of the bill of rights was whittled down by future ammendments. In fact, they were expanded. You are wrong.

I took your reference "whittled down" to mean merely altered without regard to how the "whittled down" version manifested itself.

I see your point; but because of the way you consistently speak to "strict constructionism," I incorrectly took your comment as quantitative rather than qualitative.

Nevertheless, my points regarding how the First Amendment became de facto amended via subsequent Amendments are valid. The Bill of Rights' First Amendment rights were not afforded to all Americans until the Constitution itself was amended.

My apologies for the misinterpretation.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov  replied to  A. Macarthur   10 years ago

No problem. It seemed like we weren't completely different in our views.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur  replied to  Cerenkov   10 years ago

No problem. It seemed like we weren't completely different in our views.

Appreciate that.

Peace.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany  replied to  A. Macarthur   10 years ago

I guess I'm missing something. The 2nd Amendment, as part of the Bill of Rights, is essentially a guarantee that the federal government cannot abridge the right to bear arms. It is both an individual and state right in the sense that the federal government cannot confiscate guns or interfere with state militias.

No one ever had a right to piracy. Privateering was government sanctioned piracy as part of a war effort. Issuance of a Letter of Marque is a right expressly given to Congress, not the states. That makes sense since only Congress can declare war. To me, since a Letter of Marque can only be issued by Congress, it cannot be an individual right or a right expressly reserved to the states (like the 2nd Amendment). 

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov  replied to  1ofmany   10 years ago

I don't think he was arguing for the right to piracy. He was arguing that the framers had no issue with private citizens operating war craft.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany  replied to  Cerenkov   10 years ago

I don't think he was arguing for the right to piracy. He was arguing that the framers had no issue with private citizens operating war craft.

But that's why it doesn't work. The 2nd Amendment is a right reserved by the states that cannot be abridged by Congress. Privateering is only a right granted by Congress and had nothing to do with the states. So, to me, the framers absolutely had a problem with private warcraft unless they operate under a Letter of Marque. Without the Letter of Marque, privateering is piracy. 

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov  replied to  1ofmany   10 years ago

Privateering without a LOM would be illegal. Owning a warship was not.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany  replied to  Cerenkov   10 years ago

Privateering without a LOM would be illegal. Owning a warship was not.

Maybe you could own a private warship but operating it would be a different story. For the reasons, I stated earlier, I don't think it's covered under the 2nd Amendment. Federal law regulates navigable waterways under the Commerce Clause. State law would control state waters and you couldn't get around state interference without an LOM from Congress. So, I doubt you could simply take your warship out for a spin, without an LOM, and just sail back home. As near as I can tell, most privateers refitted commercial vessels as warships but I assume that they did that after they got an LOM or had good reason to believe that it would be issued. Otherwise, they risk going to the expense of a refit for nothing. Interesting question though.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur  replied to  Cerenkov   10 years ago

I don't think he was arguing for the right to piracy. He was arguing that the framers had no issue with private citizens operating war craft.

You know we're not arguing for the right of piracy; we're arguing about the relationship between the time a document is formulated and what happens in terms of its applicability as time passes.

Playing dumb, after a while, has a way of making you look like you're not playing.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov  replied to  A. Macarthur   10 years ago

You argue dishonestly. Stop moving the goal posts and address the points. Playing dumb is not effective. 

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur  replied to  1ofmany   10 years ago

The 2nd Amendment, as part of the Bill of Rights, is essentially a guarantee that the federal government cannot abridge the right to bear arms. It is both an individual and state right in the sense that the federal government cannot confiscate guns or interfere with state militias.

It is not without exceptions.

Can we have a discussion about the realities rather than the incorrect perceptions?

In those two Scalia-penned paragraphs he outlined several "legal exceptions" where gun ownership  could be  "constitutionally" constrained:

1) limits the type of weapon;

2) concealed weapons prohibitions;

3) prohibitions on the possession of firearms by felons and the mentally ill;

4) forbidding the carrying of firearms in sensitive places such as schools and government buildings;

5) laws imposing conditions and qualifications on the commercial sale of arms;

______________________________________________________________

 

United States v. Miller ,  307 U. S. 174 ,  does not limit  the right to keep and bear arms to militia purposes,  but rather limits the type of weapon  to which the right applies to those used by the militia, i.e., those in common use for lawful purposes. Pp. 47–54.

  2.  Like most rights ,  the Second Amendment right  is not unlimited . It is not a right to keep and carry any weapon whatsoever in any manner whatsoever and for whatever purpose:  For example,  concealed weapons prohibitions  have been upheld under the Amendment or state analogues. The Court’s opinion  should not be taken to cast doubt  on longstanding prohibitions on the  possession of firearms by felons and the mentally ill , or laws forbidding the carrying of  firearms in sensitive places  such as schools and government buildings, or laws imposing  conditions and qualifications on the commercial sale of arms .
[...]

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany  replied to  A. Macarthur   10 years ago

The 2nd Amendment, as part of the Bill of Rights, is essentially a guarantee that the federal government cannot abridge the right to bear arms. It is both an individual and state right in the sense that the federal government cannot confiscate guns or interfere with state militias.

It is not without exceptions.

Can we have a discussion about the realities rather than the incorrect perceptions?

I have never said that the right to bear arms is unlimited and in fact said just the opposite earlier. What I was doing was contrasting the right to bear arms with privateering -- which seems to me to be outside the 2nd Amendment for the reasons that I stated. 

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    10 years ago
(deleted)
 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

Wasn't Henry Lee, Robert E.'s father?  Just curious...

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming   replied to  Dowser   10 years ago

I believe grandfarther, could be wrong though.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser  replied to  Mark in Wyoming   10 years ago

Thanks!  His dad was Light-Horse Harry Lee, who fought beside GW...  Interesting!

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

A living document NO! NEVER!

A document that can be modified within it's framework to deal with the unknown without losing the precepts on which it was created? YES!!!

Anyone who claims that the constitution is a living document subject to the whims of the people and language meanings of today, has thrown the baby out with the bathwater. And our liberty (and the only free nation on the planet) has gone with it.

I would agree with your premise if there were no provisions and protocol to amend … but there are … and that in-and-of-itself, regardless of Madison's views, makes the Constitution not only alterable within its framework, but, via its inherent ability to do so, expand its frame work. 

I did not say that Amendments should arise "subject to the whims of the people," and unless elections and phenomena of REALITY are entirely whimsical (granted, some outcomes seem to reflect a whimsical, ill-informed or uninformed electorate), pragmatism along with causes and effect relationships reflecting times require "living" documents.

What liberties have gone? I'm asking you in all sincerity to list them; if you list "certain voting rights" for example, I'm in agreement … but I'm willing to consider your response.

We almost always disagree on these kinds of issues, but I respect your efforts in making your positions clear and providing the reasons for holding them; so indulge me and tell what liberties we have lost.

Strict and Liberal Constructionists come and go and render the Constitution either living or … stifling.

My two cents.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy  replied to  A. Macarthur   10 years ago

Then amend it in accord with the rules set forth in the constitution

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  A. Macarthur   10 years ago

If what you say is true, then we do not have a constitution, just a rule book that the party in power can change at a whim. And, because the point and purpose of the constitution is viewed backwards, the real power resides in the interpretive body. which makes the Supreme Court the ultimate power in this country.

So if this view is the truthful one, then we are already in a monarchial dictatorship, no matter how the dictators get chosen.

That was never the intent of the founders, and we the citizens have already lost.

Some of us recognize it, some of us are still blinded to it.

We will all eventually get trampled by it.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

Sorry, "this season's people" decide the meaning of the Constitution. Every single Supreme Court decision that is given is an INTERPRETATION of the constitution, and cannot be anything else.

Frankly, I doubt if the founders would want us deciding 21st century problems using 18th century notions.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

Every single Supreme Court decision that is given is an INTERPRETATION of the constitution,

Exactly the point (among others);

The  Supreme Court of the United States  is the only court specifically established by the  Constitution of the United States , implemented in 1789 ; under the  Judiciary Act of 1789 , the Court was to be composed of six members—though the number of justices has been nine for almost all of its history, this number is set by Congress, not the Constitution. The court convened for the first time on February 2, 1790. [1]

Why would a document allegedly intended to be binding-as-originally-ratified in perpetuity, establish within itself, a body to interpret its meanings?

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell  replied to  A. Macarthur   10 years ago

Why would a document allegedly intended to be binding-as-originally-ratified in perpetuity, establish within itself, a body to interpret its meanings?

Good point.

Let me add, even when , such as the case with the Heller decision on gun rights, the majority decides a case according to the so called 'originialist' interpretation ( as Scalia did) , it is STILL an interpretation even then. Every SCOTUS decision is an interpretation, as you indicated.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov  replied to  A. Macarthur   10 years ago

"Why would a document allegedly intended to be binding-as-originally-ratified in perpetuity, establish within itself, a body to interpret its meanings?"

Because human language is not a perfect communication medium.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur  replied to  Cerenkov   10 years ago

"Why would a document allegedly intended to be binding-as-originally-ratified in perpetuity, establish within itself, a body to interpret its meanings?"

Because human language is not a perfect communication medium.

More equivocation; if human language is not a perfect communication medium, then the Constitution, WRITTEN IN HUMAN LANGUAGE, is ever subject to interpretation … 

By your premise above, all that you posited before is untenable.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov  replied to  A. Macarthur   10 years ago

Not at all. All communication must be interpreted. The basis of the interpretation should be the writers intent, not modern progressive newspeak. Please try again.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur  replied to  Cerenkov   10 years ago

All communication must be interpreted. The basis of the interpretation should be the writers intent, not modern progressive newspeak. Please try again.

FYI:

Normally, courts adhere to the four corners rule, meaning that, where possible, intent is gleaned (=determined) from the written provisions of the contract itself and nothing else. The court will not look outside the contract unless there is ambiguity (=uncertainty) in a contract provision.

Contract provisions may be considered ambiguous if consideration of the plain meaning and context of the provision can lead to two or more reasonable constructions. 

The fact that the SCOTUS accepts cases in which parties take issue with the constitutionality of a practice, policy or law,  in-and-of-itself implies that "writer's intent" is not always determinable particularly when evaluated in the context of its time vs. a subsequent time.

 

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany  replied to  A. Macarthur   10 years ago

. . . The fact that the SCOTUS accepts cases in which parties take issue with the constitutionality of a practice, policy or law,  in-and-of-itself implies that "writer's intent" is not always determinable particularly when evaluated in the context of its time vs. a subsequent time.

I'm not sure what you just said but interpreting contracts and statues can (and often does) turn on the legislature's intent in crafting the statute or the parties' intent in a contract.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov  replied to  A. Macarthur   10 years ago

Thanks for the vocabulary lesson. It was unnecessary. 

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany  replied to  A. Macarthur   10 years ago

Why would a document allegedly intended to be binding-as-originally-ratified in perpetuity, establish within itself, a body to interpret its meanings?

A contract is subject to interpretation because there may be a dispute as to what was intended by the parties. Courts resolve those disputes but they don't redraft the contract by giving the words the meaning they would have given it if they were parties to the agreement. The Constitution is like a contract and it should be interpreted based on intent and the understanding of the drafters at the time they drafted it.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur  replied to  1ofmany   10 years ago

A contract is subject to interpretation because there may be a dispute as to what was intended by the parties. Courts resolve those disputes but they don't redraft the contract by giving the words the meaning they would have given it if they were parties to the agreement.

As one involved in literally more than a hundred such contractual disputes, grievances and arbitrations over the span oa a career, I can tell you that "intent" is rarely the basis on which such disputes are resolved.

Although an arbitrator or other duly authorized, neutral third party in a dispute will often respond to the argument … "That's not what that clause (in a contractual agreement) means," with "I don't care what you think it means, that's what it says," -- WHAT SOMETHING SAYS IS MANY TIMES SUBJECT TO INTERPRETATION -- which is precisely why grievances, arbitrations and litigations occur regularly and in significant numbers.

And while you are somewhat correct in …

"Courts resolve those disputes but they don't redraft the contract by giving the words the meaning they would have given it if they were parties to the agreement."

… when a decision is BINDING, while the document from which a dispute arises is not redrafted/reworded by the court, etc., the MEANING AS OFTEN INTERPRETED BY THE COURT, going forward, stands for the duration of the contract. It becomes precedent …

…a legal decision or form of proceeding serving as an authoritative rule or pattern in future similar or analogous cases.

 

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany  replied to  A. Macarthur   10 years ago

A contract is subject to interpretation because there may be a dispute as to what was intended by the parties. Courts resolve those disputes but they don't redraft the contract by giving the words the meaning they would have given it if they were parties to the agreement.

As one involved in literally more than a hundred such contractual disputes, grievances and arbitrations over the span oa a career, I can tell you that "intent" is rarely the basis on which such disputes are resolved.

Despite what your experience has been, Courts routinely examine intent in contract disputes. I don't have time to pull cases so here's a guide to contract interpretation and it includes intent.

"Courts resolve those disputes but they don't redraft the contract by giving the words the meaning they would have given it if they were parties to the agreement."

… when a decision is BINDING, while the document from which a dispute arises is not redrafted/reworded by the court, etc., the MEANING AS OFTEN INTERPRETED BY THE COURT, going forward, stands for the duration of the contract. It becomes precedent

I'm not disputing that decisions are binding when made. The fact that they're binding doesn't mean that the Court is doing anything other than interpreting the intent of the parties through various tools of construction . . . the plain meaning of the words, ambiguity in phasing etc..

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur  replied to  1ofmany   10 years ago

The fact that they're binding doesn't mean that the Court is doing anything other than interpreting the intent of the parties through various tools of construction . . . the plain meaning of the words, ambiguity in phasing etc..

Possibly we're arguing semantics … the court does not interpret intent, it interprets meaning of the language as written and ratified. 

One key issue in any contractual dispute is whether the court will allow the parties to introduce extrinsic evidence regarding how the subject contract should be interpreted.

Absent the Founding Fathers' ability to introduce extrinsic evidence, Constitutional disputes often come down to interpreting previous interpretations.

Intent is a mental attitude with which an individual acts, and therefore it cannot ordinarily be directly proved but must be inferred from surrounding facts and circumstances. Intent refers only to the state of mind with which the act is done or omitted. It differs from motive, which is what prompts a person to act or to fail to act.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany  replied to  A. Macarthur   10 years ago

The fact that they're binding doesn't mean that the Court is doing anything other than interpreting the intent of the parties through various tools of construction . . . the plain meaning of the words, ambiguity in phasing etc..

Possibly we're arguing semantics … the court does not interpret intent, it interprets meaning of the language as written and ratified. 

I was typing too fast. I meant to say that I meant to say "determining intent" not "interpreting intent".

Absent the Founding Fathers' ability to introduce extrinsic evidence, Constitutional disputes often come down to interpreting previous interpretations.

The Court doesn't reinterpret. If it's already been interpreted, then you cite the precedent and the court applies it. Maybe you're talking about arbitrations where a decision by one arbitrator may not be binding on another.

Intent is a mental attitude with which an individual acts, and therefore it cannot ordinarily be 

If there's an ambiguity in the meaning of words, courts use a number of tools to resolve it can't be inconsistent with the intent of the parties. The court can't bind the parties to a bargain they never intended to make.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

Sorry, "this season's people" decide the meaning of the Constitution. Every single Supreme Court decision that is given is an INTERPRETATION of the constitution, and cannot be anything else.

Frankly, I doubt if the founders would want us deciding 21st century problems using 18th century notions.

I disagree with that completely. If you think an 18th century notion doesn't fit a 21st century problem, then the appropriate action is to amend the Constitution not read words into and out of it on the whim of nine people on the Court.  

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell  replied to  1ofmany   10 years ago

1 of Many,

Every Supreme Court decision, every decision by any court which refers to the constitution is an interpretation of the constitution, and cannot be otherwise. In 2016 there is no such thing as an original reading of the constitution. In Heller, Scalia interpreted the words of the second amendment as HE saw fit, basing his opinion on what HE thought was the framers intent. And he had to go outside the exact words of the second amendment to do so, because the exact words cry out for interpretation.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

Every Supreme Court decision, every decision by any court which refers to the constitution is an interpretation of the constitution, and cannot be otherwise . . .

If you are interpreting the intent of the drafters, then I agree. However, if you are reading into the words an understanding that the drafters could not have had, then that is legislating from the bench and I disagree. Same sex marriage comes to mind as a ridiculous interpretation since sodomy was illegal at the time the Constitution was drafted.  

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell  replied to  1ofmany   10 years ago

There was no social security or Facebook when the framers wrote the constitution. Does that mean that the Supreme Court cannot rule on cases focused on those things?

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

There was no social security or Facebook when the framers wrote the constitution. Does that mean that the Supreme Court cannot rule on cases focused on those things?

Depends on the issue. 

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming   replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

and I believe Scalia , had dictionaries from the different time periods that amendments ( as well as the constitution itself) explaining exactly what the definitions of words meant at those times, words meanings change in usage with time .

 an example is what is a faggot? today its derogatory name for a homosexual , 30 years ago I was taught from a dictionary , it was a bundle of sticks, a fag back then was british slang for a cigarette still was in the 80s during my travels , but it also could mean a homosexual.

In reference to regulate in the 2nd ,regulate then doesn't mean what it means today, back then it was to make all the same , to make orderly, today to regulate has a meaning to control.  like regulate the flow .

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

I agree. It's not a living document. It should be interpreted as it was meant to be established. That's exactly why it is possible to amend it.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur  replied to  Cerenkov   10 years ago

I agree. It's not a living document. It should be interpreted as it was meant to be established. That's exactly why it is possible to amend it.

Do you not understand the meaning of the word "interpreted" nor the significance of a provision in a document that authorizes a body to interpret that very document?

 

"the action of explaining the meaning of something"

If the Founding Fathers were confident that their intent was clear and applicable for all time, they would not logically have created the body whose function it is to explain the meaning of the Constitution as it from time-to-time comes in conflict with the time.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov  replied to  A. Macarthur   10 years ago

Of course they would! They, unlike today's pundits apparently, understood that language can be imprecise and require a body to make the final call as to the original intent.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany  replied to  A. Macarthur   10 years ago

If the Founding Fathers were confident that their intent was clear and applicable for all time, they would not logically have created the body whose function it is to explain the meaning of the Constitution as it from time-to-time comes in conflict with the time.

That's not true. Every legislature currently enacts laws intended to be binding unless repealed and yet there is a large body of court decisions devoted entirely to statutory interpretation.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  A. Macarthur   10 years ago

 If the Founding Fathers were confident that their intent was clear and applicable for all time, they would not logically have created the body whose function it is to explain the meaning of the Constitution as it from time-to-time comes in conflict with the time.

Incorrect.

It is the issues of the times that comes into conflict with the principles embodied in the constitution.

The analogy runs thus...

We, (and the founders) believe that the issues of the times must conform to the principles of the constitution.

You, (and all living constitutionalists, or better put, judicial pragmatists, this philosophy dates from 1926, as espoused by Woodrow Wilson) believe that the Constitution must conform to the issues of the times.

If the constitution must conform to the wishes of the people living under it, then there are no principles it was based upon.

Chuck everything they believed and fought for right out the window as no longer needed and substitute what ever whim you have to base your ideals upon. Claim your right and everyone else is wrong and your done.

The mob, that is all that is left.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

If the constitution must conform to the wishes of the people living under it, then there are no principles it was based upon.

I disagree … and I'm not the only one.

"The Constitution of the United States is a carefully balanced document. It is designed to provide for a national government sufficiently strong and flexible to meet the needs of the republic, yet sufficiently limited and just to protect the guaranteed rights of citizens; it permits a balance between society's need for order and the individual's right to freedom.

To assure these ends, the Framers of the Constitution created three independent and coequal branches of government. That this Constitution has provided continuous democratic government through the periodic stresses of more than two centuries illustrates the genius of the American system of government.

In retrospect, it is evident that constitutional interpretation and application were made necessary by the very nature of the Constitution. The Founding Fathers had wisely worded that document in rather general terms leaving it open to future elaboration to meet changing conditions.

As Chief Justice Marshall noted in McCulloch v. Maryland, a constitution that attempted to detail every aspect of its own application "would partake of the prolixity of a legal code, and could scarcely be embraced by the human mind. . . . Its nature, therefore, requires that only its great outlines should be marked, its important objects designated, and the minor ingredients which compose those objects be deduced from the nature of the objects themselves."

Charles Evans Hughes

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  A. Macarthur   10 years ago

AS much as I respect learned opinion, it is only opinion. I can cite 100 such opinions many from the writers citing their intent directly.

Opinion does not answer the direct challenge I laid out. The founders left a method to change the document as society evolves yes, but they also specifically stated that the correct method to change it is by vote in congress and people as the people are the only ones with the right to change it.

A living constitution is a precept that the court or government can change it to whatever they think it should be given their own beliefs.

That is directly circumscribed by the founders. Who repeatedly said that was not the right way to go about it.

WHY ARE THEY WRONG?

That is the question I am directly asking, and a thousand quotes from living constitution believers will not answer that.

I am asking YOU......

Are we ruled by the mob of public party opinion or by laws passed and approved by the people?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

I am asking YOU......

Are we ruled by the mob of public party opinion or by laws passed and approved by the people?

WE THE PEOPLE, my friend; representative democracy is not mob rule; I stand by my position that the Constitution would not contain an Amendment provision if the Founding Fathers intent was to (metaphorically) write it in stone.

We disagree.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  A. Macarthur   10 years ago

I know we disagree. I am trying to find the common ground here, cause I know we have some. lemme say this....

An argument against the concept of a "living Constitution" ironically, is similar to the argument for it; the fact that the Constitution itself is silent on the matter of constitutional interpretation. The doctrine of the "living Constitution" relies on the concept that the original framers either could not come to a consensus about how to interpret, or they never intended any fixed method of interpretation. This would then allow future generations the freedom to reexamine for themselves how to interpret the Constitution.

This view does not take into account why the original constitution does not allow for judicial interpretation in any form. The Supreme Court's power for constitutional review, and by extension its interpretation, did not come about until Marbury v. Madison in 1803. The concept for a "living constitution" therefore relies on an argument regarding the writing of the constitution that had no validity when the constitution was written.

(from wiki)

Since the ideal of constitutional interpretation was not mentioned in the document itself, and constitutional modification was a right reserved for the people themselves. (until usurped/taken by the court 20 years later)

How can one even consider the ideal of a living constitution unless the intent is to change it by other means than the constitutionally prescribed one reserved for the people?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

How can one even consider the ideal of a living constitution unless the intent is to change it by other means than the constitutionally prescribed one reserved for the people?

An amendment becomes an operative part of the Constitution when it is ratified by the necessary number of states, rather than on the later date when its ratification is certified. [12]  No further action by Congress or anyone is required. 

Is that not ratification by the people?

The Constitution is silent on the issue of whether or not Congress may limit the length of time that the states have to ratify constitutional amendments sent for their consideration. It is also silent on the issue of whether or not Congress, once it has sent an amendment that includes a ratification deadline to the states for their consideration, can extend that deadline.

Can that not be deemed an intent to give "the states" (which I take to be synonymous with its PEOPLE) whatever time they require to deliberate and decide?

Am I overlooking something or are we arguing the same position from both sides of the street?

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  A. Macarthur   10 years ago

Yes we are arguing the same thing, but by making or establishing that ideal, you have to reject a "Living Constitution" in the judicial sense. The courts are specifically proscribed from legislating on the bench. (there is no article in the constitution that covers the manner of "interpreting" it)

So no matter if we agree or disagree with these famous, contentious court decisions, (corporations are people, right to privacy, right to marry, etc, etc,,, ) one has to agree that the decisions were constitutionally barred. (there is no right to privacy, right to marry, or legal fiction of peopleness for business entities) the court did not have the right to make those determinations. Sans a passage of law by congress.

It was the peoples right, through their elected representatives to make said decisions..

Irrespective of politics or personal opinion.

Do we agree on this one?

We are beginning to reach common ground.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

It was the peoples right, through their elected representatives to make said decisions..

Irrespective of politics or personal opinion.

Do we agree on this one?

We are beginning to reach common ground.

Let me put it this way; if the powers that be, regardless of how they logistically interpret and apply law, do so in a manner that reflects the (majority) will of the PEOPLE, then we agree.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  A. Macarthur   10 years ago

Yes, we do agree.

As long as the constitution is followed.

Any and all judicial activism is unconstitutional, no matter who does it. (and both sides do it)

The ends do not justify the means, Madison's...

"There is nevertheless sufficient scope for combating the spirit of
party, as far as it may not be necessary to fan the flame of liberty, ......"

WE are in agreement Brother... thumbs up

When talked out, most of the political disagreements in this country are purely ideological. but one has to have faith and seek the common ground before any progress can be made.

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming   replied to  A. Macarthur   10 years ago

some proposed amendments have built in time limits written into themselves ERA amendment is an example , some have been proposed and still await ratification , one of the latter of the 27 amendments  was actually proposed at the same time as the bill of rights ( there were 12 proposed , but 10 made the ratification process) only to later be ratified by the needed number currently.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  Mark in Wyoming   10 years ago

It depends on if congress puts a time limit on the ratification process, they can or not, it is up to them. There is no limitation in the constitution about it.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

When present day justices rule on various cases before the court, the ARE conforming present issues to the principles of the constitution.

They are , evidently, just not always doing it to your satisfaction.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

When they create something that isn't there, they are legislating from the bench, which they cannot do. their job is not to make a law work, their job it to make sure a law passes constitutional standards.

Escobido and Miranda pass constitutional muster, Roe v Wade and Citizens United do not.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    10 years ago

As Chief Justice Marshall noted in McCulloch v. Maryland, a constitution that attempted to detail every aspect of its own application "would partake of the prolixity of a legal code, and could scarcely be embraced by the human mind. . . . Its nature, therefore, requires that only its great outlines should be marked, its important objects designated, and the minor ingredients which compose those objects be deduced from the nature of the objects themselves."

And a Constitution as loose as you would have it is no real guarantee at all because it becomes subject to the whim of judges who feel free to twist it to suit their personal preferences. Legislatures make law; courts should limit themselves to determining what the legislature meant. If the intent is clear, then the court has nothing left to do but apply the law as written.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur  replied to  1ofmany   10 years ago

And a Constitution as loose as you would have it is no real guarantee at all because it becomes subject to the whim of judges who feel free to twist it to suit their personal preferences. Legislatures make law; courts should limit themselves to determining what the legislature meant. If the intent is clear, then the court has nothing left to do but apply the law as written.

What legislators MEANT … if intent is clear, the language will reflect that … when that tandem fails to exist, we have a dispute … when we have a dispute, we may need a court to square the two …

Can we agree that there's an endless stream of attempts to square meaning and intent?

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov  replied to  A. Macarthur   10 years ago

Yes.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany  replied to  A. Macarthur   10 years ago

What legislators MEANT … if intent is clear, the language will reflect that … when that tandem fails to exist, we have a dispute … when we have a dispute, we may need a court to square the two …

Can we agree that there's an endless stream of attempts to square meaning and intent?

I agree that when there is a dispute a court should resolve it. In resolving it, the court should confine its efforts to deciding what the legislature intended and exclude as irrelevant what the court thinks the legislature should have said or what most people think the law should say. If you agree with that, then we're in agreement.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur  replied to  1ofmany   10 years ago

I agree that when there is a dispute a court should resolve it. In resolving it, the court should confine its efforts to deciding what the legislature intended and exclude as irrelevant what the court thinks the legislature should have said or what most people think the law should say. If you agree with that, then we're in agreement.

The words "should have said" are the keys; I believe there can be a degree of objectivity if/when a court tries to determine intent, or, interpret ambiguous language.

But if a so-called interpretation is actually a value judgement based on a court's preference or prejudicial leanings … then I would deem that malfeasance and consequently judicial activism.

So, I think we are in agreement.

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     10 years ago

So, exactly WHAT bill is before the house they want to have a vote on? I know 4 bills have been defeated in the Senate with a 5th bill being written which I have contacted my senators to vote against , so whats the house dems proposal? or do they even really have one that hasn't been voted on and defeated?

 

 
 

Who is online