Brexit: A Working Class Revolt
That makes this a good time to look at a perceptive article by John Harris in The Guardian from last week. Remember that he was writing from the perspective of the left. Here’s an extract:
To quote the opinion pollsters Populus: “Both socioeconomic groups C2 and DE disproportionately back the UK leaving the EU.” To be a little more dramatic about it, now that Scotland has been through its political reformation, England and Wales are in the midst of a working-class revolt.
To be sure, there are many nuances and complications among leave voters. In the inner-city Birmingham neighbourhood of Handsworth, I met Sikh shopkeepers who claimed that the country is full, with just as much oomph as anyone white; in Leominster, Herefordshire, there are plenty of Tory voters gleefully defying Cameron’s instructions, and fixating on questions of sovereignty and democracy.
But make no mistake: in an almost comical reflection of the sacred lefty belief that any worthwhile political movement will necessarily be built around the workers, the foundation of the Brexit coalition is what used to be called the proletariat, large swaths of which are as united as in any lefty fantasy, even if some of their loudest complaints are triggering no end of anxiety among bien-pensant types, and causing Labour a great deal of apprehension.
In Stoke, Merthyr, Birmingham, Manchester and even rural Shropshire, the same lines recurred: so unchanging that they threatened to turn into cliches, but all the more powerful because of their ubiquity. “I’m scared about the future” … “No one listens to us” … “If you haven’t got money, no one cares.”
And of course, none of it needs much translation. Instead of the comparative security and stability of the postwar settlement and the last act of Britain’s industrial age, what’s the best we can now offer for so many people in so many places? Six-week contracts at the local retail park, lives spent pinballing in and out of the benefits system, and retirements built on thin air?
It may have been easy to miss in the London-centred haze of the “knowledge economy” and the birth of the digital future, but this is where millions of lives have been heading since the early 1980s – and to read that some Labour MPs have come back from their constituencies, amazed by the views they encounter on the doorstep, is to be struck by a political failure that sits right at the heart of the story. How did they not know?
Let’s go back to John Wilkes, that great champion of British liberty, writing in the North Briton in 1762: You politicians of the town are so totally engaged in the transactions of the great world, that I suppose you will hardly think it worth while to take notice of any occurrences, however important, that happen amongst the obscure folks of the country.
Harris, meanwhile, turns his attention to immigration: Between 1991 and 2003, on average about 60,000 migrants from the EU came to the UK each year. Between 2004 and 2012, that figure rose to 170,000. The 2011 census put the number of UK residents from Poland alone at 654,000. To state the obvious, that’s a lot. If people had felt more connected to politics, public services had been quicker to adapt, and the Blair/Brown government had opted for transitional controls, perhaps such huge changes might not have triggered quite so much rage and worry. But such thoughts are now for the birds: f or millions of people, the word “immigration” is reducible to yet another seismic change no one thought to ask them about, or even explain.
To maintain a narrow zone of ‘acceptable speech’, the Asiktskorridor, to borrow that useful Swedish phrase (I wrote about it here), is not only a democratic failure, it also paves the way to the dramatic political disconnect that we are now seeing manifesting itself tonight, a disconnect for which British membership of the EU must bear some, but by no means all the blame.
To go back to Harris’ question: How did they not know? That, of course, may be too kind. They may well have known. But they may well have been content to ignore what they were hearing
Chickens. Home. Roost.
Read more at: http://www.nationalreview.com/corner/437068/bremainbrexit-balance
Tags
Who is online
120 visitors

Lot of overlap between what's driving the populist Trump phenomena and what motivated the English working class to vote to leave the EU.
Gerard Baker of the WSJ:
Levels of dissatisfaction with leadership have reached revolutionary levels. It’s a paradox of mass modern democracy that voters feel themselves governed by rulers who “neither see nor feel nor know,” a political-business nexus that feeds on itself and promotes its own interests while mouthing platitudes at election time to keep the populace at bay. In Europe and the U.S. today, traditional political authority is worn like a scarlet letter. . .
The very idea that the state has a primary obligation to its native citizens has become unfashionable and virtually unsayable within the tightly controlled bounds of political correctness. . .
The stunning reality of Brexit needs to be understood as simply the most dramatic development yet in these trends. The British people have spoken, the first to break publicly from the institutional structures that define our modern, integrated international system.
They are very unlikely to be the last.
Sean,
You do realize that most people don't really understand what they voted for, right?
The British are frantically Googling what the E.U. is, hours after voting to leave it
Yes Chickens. Home. Roost.
That may very well be true Perrie; but, do you think it's possible that the decision is uninformed as well as a working class revolt? It seems to me that many such revolts have had a fair share of ignorance, as well as legitimate complaints, that fuel them.
That may very well be true Perrie; but, do you think it's possible that the decision is uninformed as well as a working class revolt?
Well, I'm no expert, but I think both are true. Most Brits, like most Americans, are both pretty stupid as well as pretty uninformed. Don't believe me? Then read the comments in political discussions in online forums...heh
(But then again, that's true of most of the human race, not just the Brits & the Americans
From everything I've read about it, one major factor influencing the "leave" camp was fear of immigration. So many of the Leave voters have some similarities to Trump supporters in the U.S. But there's more to it than that- so the comparison is not totally accurate.
It seems to me that many such revolts have had a fair share of ignorance, as well as legitimate complaints, that fuel them.
Excellent point! IMO both were at play here.
It seems that ultimately the decision to leave will probably do more harm than good to the average Brit. And BTW, while its not been mentioned as much, this is also very negative for the EU as well.
Is your point that working class British voters are stupid and shouldn't be allowed a say in their destiny? Otherwise I have no idea why you think that's relevant.
Is your point that working class British voters are stupid and shouldn't be allowed a say in their destiny?
That comment wasn't addressed to me, but Ill add my 2 cents (or my Euros?) anyway. Of course their working class voters are stupid. but so are their elites.
But the way democracy is structured, everyone gets to vote-- you can't just let intelligent people vote! (In fact, often really stupid people even get elected..to run countries).
Democracy is the worst form of government, except for all the others.
(-quote falsely attributed to Winston Churchill)
Is your point that working class British voters are stupid and shouldn't be allowed a say in their destiny?
Churchill weighs in:
“The best argument against democracy is a five-minute conversation with the average voter.”
― Winston S. Churchill
and IMO this is especially true in light of the vote to exit Brexit. (Some of the less stupid ones who voted to leave will most certainly soon have a case of "buyer's remorse").
(Some of the less stupid ones who voted to leave will most certainly soon have a case of "buyer's remorse")
Does that also apply if other Euro countries decide to leave too ?