It’s Time for the Elites to Rise Up Against the Ignorant Masses
It's time for the Elites to Rise Up Against the Ignorant Masses
The Brexit has laid bare the political schism of our time. It’s not about the left vs. the right; it’s about the sane vs. the mindlessly angry.
I was born in 1954, and until now I would have said that the late 1960s was the greatest period of political convulsion I have lived through. Yet for all that the Vietnam War and the civil rights struggle changed American culture and reshaped political parties, in retrospect those wild storms look like the normal oscillations of a relatively stable political system. The present moment is different. Today’s citizen revolt — in the United States, Britain, and Europe — may upend politics as nothing else has in my lifetime.
In the late 1960s, elites were in disarray, as they are now — but back then they were fleeing from kids rebelling against their parents’ world; now the elites are fleeing from the parents.
In the late 1960s, elites were in disarray, as they are now — but back then they were fleeing from kids rebelling against their parents’ world; now the elites are fleeing from the parents. Extremism has gone mainstream. One of the most brazen features of the Brexit vote was the utter repudiation of the bankers and economists and Western heads of state who warned voters against the dangers of a split with the European Union. British Prime Minister David Cameron thought that voters would defer to the near-universal opinion of experts; that only shows how utterly he misjudged his own people.
Both the Conservative and the Labour parties in Britain are now in crisis . The British have had their day of reckoning; the American one looms. If Donald Trump loses, and loses badly (forgive me my reckless optimism, but I believe he will) the Republican Party may endure a historic split between its know-nothing base and its K Street/Chamber of Commerce leadership class. The Socialist government of France may face a similar fiasco in national elections next spring: Polls indicate that President François Hollande would not even make it to the final round of voting. Right-wing parties all over Europe are clamoring for an exit vote of their own.
Yes, it’s possible that all the political pieces will fly up into the air and settle down more or less where they were before, but the Brexit vote shows that shocking change isn’t very shocking anymore. Where, then, could those pieces end up? Europe is already pointing in one direction. In much of Europe, far-right nativist parties lead in the polls. So far, none has mustered a majority, though last month Norbert Hofer, the leader of Austria’s far-right Freedom Party, which traffics in Nazi symbolism , came within a hair of winning election as president. Mainstream parties of the left and right may increasingly combine forces to keep out the nationalists. This has already happened in Sweden, where a right-of-center party serves as the minority partner to the left-of-center government. If the Socialists in France do in fact lose the first round, they will almost certainly support the conservative Republicans against the far-right National Front.
Perhaps these informal coalitions can survive until the fever breaks. But the imperative of cohabitation could also lead to genuine realignment. That is, chunks of parties from the left and right of center could break away to form a different kind of center, defending pragmatism, meliorism, technical knowledge, and effective governance against the ideological forces gathering on both sides. It’s not hard to imagine the Republican Party in the United States — and perhaps the British Conservatives should Brexit go terribly wrong — losing control of the angry, nationalist rank and file and reconstituting themselves as the kind of Main Street, pro-business parties they were a generation ago, before their ideological zeal led them into a blind alley. That may be their only alternative to irrelevance.
The issue, at bottom, is globalization. Brexit, Trump, the National Front, and so on show that political elites have misjudged the depth of the anger at global forces and thus the demand that someone, somehow, restore the status quo ante. It may seem strange that the reaction has come today rather than immediately after the economic crisis of 2008, but the ebbing of the crisis has led to a new sense of stagnation. With prospects of flat growth in Europe and minimal income growth in the United States, voters are rebelling against their dismal long-term prospects. And globalization means culture as well as economics: Older people whose familiar world is vanishing beneath a welter of foreign tongues and multicultural celebrations are waving their fists at cosmopolitan elites. I was recently in Poland, where a far-right party appealing to nationalism and tradition has gained power despite years of undeniable prosperity under a centrist regime. Supporters use the same words again and again to explain their vote: “values and tradition.” They voted for Polishness against the modernity of Western Europe.
Perhaps politics will realign itself around the axis of globalization, with the fist-shakers on one side and the pragmatists on the other. The nationalists would win the loyalty of working-class and middle-class whites who see themselves as the defenders of sovereignty. The reformed center would include the beneficiaries of globalization and the poor and non-white and marginal citizens who recognize that the celebration of national identity excludes them.
Of course, mainstream parties of both the left and the right are trying to reach the angry nationalists. Sometimes this takes the form of gross truckling, as when Nicolas Sarkozy, who is seeking to regain France’s presidency, denounces the “tyranny of minorities” and invokes the “forever France” of an all-white past. From the left, Hillary Clinton has jettisoned her free-trade past to appeal to union members and others who want to protect national borders against the global market. But left and right disagree so deeply about how best to cushion the effects of globalization, and how to deal with the vast influx of refugees and migrants, that even the threat of extremism may not be enough to bring them to make common cause.
The schism we see opening before us is not just about policies, but about reality.
The schism we see opening before us is not just about policies, but about reality. The Brexit forces won because cynical leaders were prepared to cater to voters’ paranoia, lying to them about the dangers of immigration and the costs of membership in the EU. Some of those leaders have already begun to admit that they were lying. Donald Trump has, of course, set a new standard for disingenuousness and catering to voters’ fears, whether over immigration or foreign trade or anything else he can think of. The Republican Party, already rife with science-deniers and economic reality-deniers, has thrown itself into the embrace of a man who fabricates realities that ignorant people like to inhabit.
Did I say “ignorant”? Yes, I did. It is necessary to say that people are deluded and that the task of leadership is to un-delude them. Is that “elitist”? Maybe it is; maybe we have become so inclined to celebrate the authenticity of all personal conviction that it is now elitist to believe in reason, expertise, and the lessons of history. If so, the party of accepting reality must be prepared to take on the party of denying reality, and its enablers among those who know better. If that is the coming realignment, we should embrace it.
http://foreignpolicy.com/2016/06/28/its-time-for-the-elites-to-rise-up-against-ignorant-masses-trump-2016-brexit/
Tags
Who is online
147 visitors

I really enjoyed this piece, it made me feel sane again.
it made me feel sane again.
How would you feel if other countries exit the Euro zone ? More insane ?
Howdy Petey! I haven't scuffled with you in a bit so I guess tonight's as good as any night. :0)
My reference to feeling sane again after reading this opinion piece was simply a sigh of relief that I'm not the only one who has ever thought........"gee wouldn't it be nice if we could manipulate the masses". Of course I understand that it would be completely undemocratic to do but every once in a while it's nice to close my eyes and wish for things that can never be.
So in summary - it was an expression of relief that I'm not the only one whose had these "naughty" thoughts.
I really enjoyed this piece, it made me feel sane again.
NEWSTALKERS WILL MAKE AMERICA SANE AGAIN!
A worthy cause for sure Krishna.
Wonderful article! Like you, it made me feel sane again!
Strange, isn't it, how things have changed, in the past few years... We have allowed personal religious beliefs to dominate our lives, in ways that are scary! We have allowed TV preachers to tell us how to run the politics of our country-- to the point where we have gone beyond the pale.
That is what scares me...
Putting aside the rampant straw-men and other assorted logical fallacies , this is window into the mind of a fascist. Essentially, they know what's good for people so they should shut up and be ruled and not care about their own preferences.
I don't know, Sean... It also says that if this is the future, we must embrace it.
Just as an example: we're working on band props for this year's show again. It seems that no one wants to take the laws of physics into account. They want to build a 12' tall Moai head, and have the color guard just lift it up. It will take a crane, as even making it out of styrofoam, it will weigh about 500 pounds. Yet, these girls are supposed to be able to tug on ropes and just lift it. Right. The band director has no concept of the physics of that move, nor how it is going to tear up the football field, or how on earth something on wheels will stand still at the base, while they pull... That's ignorance of reality.
Maybe it is a backlash against science. Maybe it is a backlash against women being equal. I don't know... but something is happening. We have passed the Age of Reason into the Age of Chaos. The band leaders can deny reality all they wish, but it will never work. They're going to end up with a giant Moai head, stuck to the ground. (I don't even know how they're going to pull it onto the field-- too heavy!)
This isn't a fascist thing-- do this or else, deny your feelings, or else. It is a call to face reality... Some things, we can't change. We can't make gravity go up, we can't make water run uphill, (except under pressure in a pipe). But there are a lot of people out there who think they should and can. And they will argue until they're blue in the face, that rivers run uphill and that gravity has nothing to do with life as we know it.
I see this all the time in my work. I have had clients whose wells are on the Ohio River, but who would swear that their water comes from Michigan. WHAT? You can stand on the well and throw a rock into the Ohio River, but they insist that the water from that well travels in underground rivers from Michigan, all the way down to the Ohio. That's ignorance. That is a complete lack of understanding of how groundwater works. There ARE no underground rivers leading from Michigan down to the Ohio River. It would have to cross several major water sheds, etc. And, while I believe that God can do anything-- I can't believe that God did that. Nor do I believe that God stepped on the Atlantic Ocean and all that water just boiled up out of the ground to fill it.
This is a call to face reality, not a fascist maneuver to make everyone toe the line...
We are talking about two different things. Yeah, some people will not grasp the implications of the laws of nature and will ignore them. so it will ever be.
But the author is not talking about ignorant people ignoring immutable, objective laws like gravity. He's arguing that people's subjective choices are not valid and should be ignored. He's talking about taking away the right of people to live as they see fit, (i.e. in a country that governs itself) because he claims they will be "better off" ruled by foreign bureaucrats.
How people want to live and what they prioritize for their own happiness is inherently subjective. That is what the elites want to take away from the masses.
Yes - I view it as a conundrum. I guess we would have to define disarray and stability and as you rightly point out those are subjective. The question becomes, is there a point that we as a society need to decide that some of us aren’t capable of digesting information rationally and do we then have a responsibility to neutralize the irrationality in order to maintain stability and calm.
Neutralize?
The question becomes, is there a point that we as a society need to decide that some of us aren’t capable of digesting information rationally and do we then have a responsibility to neutralize the irrationality in order to maintain stability and calm.
Neutralize the irrationality.....
Work will set you free.....
WE have already have had way too many attempts to "Neutralize the Irrationality" in history.
What about the "Melting Pot" that with makes us strong? should we rather Neutralize those that hold to different views? Everyone must hold to the same views or they are irrational?
And who is going to be the judge of rationality? and who is capable of it and who isn't?
This precept has played out before, thankfully Lenin, Hitler, Stalin and MAO are long dead and their failed ideals of Neutralizing the Irrationally died a few decades afterwards.
No one will ever neutralize my irrationality.
Okay
I posed my comment as a question not as my personal position as you may have taken it.
The question becomes, is there a point that we as a society need to decide that some of us aren’t capable of digesting information rationally and do we then have a responsibility to neutralize the irrationality in order to maintain stability and calm.
But who gets to decide what people (& opinions) are rational, and which are not?
It has been said that democracy is the worst form of government except all the others that have been tried. Winston Churchill
Isn't this an everyday occurrence?
I'm thinking of my state's helmet laws for motorcycle riders. It used to be a law that you had to wear a helmet, if you rode a motorcycle. Well, all the bikers, (or a huge contingent of them), went to the statehouse to protest. It impinged on their freedom to "ride free". So the state actually nullified the law.
What I think happened? The state realized they were paying millions of dollars to support those who were brain dead or grievously injured in bike wrecks, and thought if they just died, it would save money. So now, rather than support a bunch of people that were hurt, AND their families, they just let them die, and support only the families. Isn't that an example of the elite deciding that people can't be trusted to know what is best for them? Now, it's like Darwin-- if you're too stupid to wear a helmet, then you die...
It's sort of like-- Don't swim here signs. People may try it anyway, but if they're that stupid to ignore the safety warning, they're on their own. So, yes, at some point, and each situation should be considered separately, there comes a time when the "elite"-- in this case, the lawmakers-- have to step in and decide what is best for the majority of the people... Where that point is, I guess, depends on what the subject is.
Now, if you want to come to KY, you can ride a motorcycle without a helmet and I guess you're free to ignore the No Swimming signs at the base of Cumberland Falls, and if you drown or are badly hurt, expect nothing from the state...
Sean, I just had another shot in my back today, and am woozy from the anesthetic and hurting... I can barely string together a sentence right now, so I will try to formulate a reply when I'm more up to speed. I see your point, I just didn't take it that way...
What is an elite? An intellectual, or a person with money? Can you help me with that? Again, I apologize, but I can barely think... Thank you!
What is an elite?
Definition: An "elite" is anyone you are jealous of because they have something you don't.
Like delusions of grandeur...
Thanks, Krishna!
Actually the "unjust" power of the "Elites" is one of the major themes of 2 of the presidential candidates. And interestingly, they are on different sides of the political aisle (as opposed to the movie theatre aisle ). Much of what both Trump and Sanders talk about is actually how unfair it is that the Elites have so much power and wealth.
I think the article kind of has it wrong that "Elites" should be in control, but I agree that this movement has everything to do with anger and emotion and nada to do with what is good for each country.
Years ago, I wrote a piece about the nationalist movement in England. It was about the British National Party or the BNP. It was just a tad to neo-Nazi for the rest of England, but up in the north of England, it had taken hold. Now that there is a more palatable movement, people are going with it.
You can find my article here .
At that time, there was no ISIS, but between economic woes with the PIGGS nations, terror attacks, and mass immigration on the continent, I think the common man is just fed up and will go with anyone who promises anything but what they have, without much thought as to the real animal they are.
At that time, there was no ISIS, but between economic woes with the PIGGS nations, terror attacks, and mass immigration on the continent, I think the common man is just fed up and will go with anyone who promises anything but what they have, without much thought as to the real animal they are.
Agreed.
And it seems to be getting worse.