╌>

More police officers die on the job in states with more guns

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  bob-nelson  •  10 years ago  •  32 comments

More police officers die on the job in states with more guns

More police officers die on the job in states with more guns

original article by Christopher Ingraham  --   Wonkblog

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 


Five police officers were killed  and seven others were wounded this week by sniper fire in Dallas, in what has become the deadliest day for the nation's law enforcement officers since 9/11.

Texas has  long had a strong gun culture , with the state's gun laws among the country's least restrictive according to the  Law Center to Prevent Gun Violence . But late last year, researchers at Harvard and elsewhere  discovered an alarming fact : Police officers are much more likely to be killed in the line of duty in states with high rates of gun ownership.

The study, published in the American Journal of Public Health, used FBI data  to track police officer deaths in the line of duty from 1996 to 2010. They cross-referenced this with state-level gun ownership rates as measured in  a Centers for Disease Control and Prevention survey that asked about gun ownership from 2001 to 2004. To isolate, as accurately as possible, the effects of gun ownership on police officer homicides, they corrected for a number of factors that could also affect police officer homicide rates: overall rates of violent and property crime, the racial and economic demographics of the different states, income, education, alcohol consumption and rural/urban population breakdowns.

They then compared officer fatality rates in the eight states with the lowest public gun ownership rate (13.5 percent, on average) against officer fatalities in the 23 states with the highest gun ownership rate (52 percent, on average). The states with the lowest rates of gun ownership tended to be high-population places such as New York, while the highest rates of gun ownership were in low-population places such as Wyoming. So the researchers compared the 8 "low" states with 23 "high" states to arrive at comparable numbers of law enforcement officers employed in each group over the study period.

The results were shocking: line-of-duty homicide rates among police officers were more than  three times higher  in states with high gun ownership compared with the low gun ownership states. Between 1996 and 2010, in other words, there were 0.31 officer fatalities for every 10,000 employed officers in low gun ownership states. But there were 0.95 fatalities per 10,000 officers in the high gun ownership states.

"Higher levels of private firearm ownership likely increased the frequency with which officers faced potentially life-threatening situations on the job," the study says. High rates of officer homicides appeared to be caused "by more frequently encountering situations where privately owned firearms were present," it says.

Law enforcement officers "working in states with higher levels of gun ownership faced a greater likelihood of being shot and killed on the job compared with their peers in states with lower gun ownership," the study concludes. The relationship was strong enough that every 10 percent increase in gun ownership correlated with 10 more officer deaths over the study period.

"If we're interested in protecting police officers, we need to look at what's killing them, and what's killing them is guns," said the study's lead author, David Swedler,  in a statement last year .

As with all studies, this one has its limitations. Because it only looked at correlations between gun ownership and officer death rates, it can't definitively say whether some other unseen factor may have been driving both.

But the numbers are highly suggestive given the robustness of the findings against all of the potentially confounding factors the researchers did control for. Numbers such as these are one reason many law enforcement groups have been the staunchest supporters of stricter gun control measures.

The International Association of Chiefs of Police, for instance, supports a reinstatement  of the federal ban on assault weapons, broadening background checks and creating a national gun offender registry. The Major Cities Chiefs Association, representing police chiefs in the country's largest cities and metro areas,  support similar proposals .

By contrast sheriff's groups, which tend to represent law enforcement officers from more rural areas where gun violence is less of a problem,  tend to be more skeptical  of stricter gun control measures.

The mass shooting attack in Dallas was carried out by one or more assailants armed with what appeared to be assault-style rifles,  such as the ones used in seven of the eight  other most recent mass shootings in the U.S. These rifles have become  very popular  among gun enthusiasts in recent years, with the NRA  estimating that there are millions in circulation  and hundreds of thousands more manufactured each year.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    10 years ago

More guns, more dead cops. 

Gee, isn't that surprising. 

Doesn't "more guns" mean "safer"? That's what our gun-nuts keep telling us... 

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    10 years ago

Here's another thing I found interesting - did you see that immediately after the Dallas event, a photo was being circulated of a possible suspect? It was a black male who was seen with the protesters, and he had an assault rifle slung on his  shoulder.  It turns out that he was just another proud Texan exercising his ridiculous right to openly march around carrying a mass murder tool.

I want to know what happened to him when the shit went down.  Had he already left the protest by then, or did he say screw this I'm outa here when the bullets started flying?  Smart move if he did, since if he had started aiming his gun around looking for the shooter, he would certainly have been mistaken for the shooter and shot by police. Death by second amendment.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Hal A. Lujah   10 years ago

He immediately turned his gun over to the police. Video proof of his non-involvement was all over social media within minutes, while TV was still "building a case against this gun-carrying Black man". 

I wonder what would happen if a dozen Black men began walking around downtown Open-carry City... 

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah  replied to  Bob Nelson   10 years ago

Kind of defeats the purpose of carrying around a weapon like that, doesn't it?  Someone starts shooting into a crowd, and he immediately gets rid of his gun?  I thought we are all supposed to be safer when everyone has guns for protection.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell  replied to  Hal A. Lujah   10 years ago

Had he brought his gun into firing position when the sniper started shooting and looked around for a bad guy to shoot at ( the NRA "good guy" scenario) he would have undoubtedly been gunned down by the police within seconds. At least he would have been true to his second amendment rights.

 
 
 
TTGA
Professor Silent
link   TTGA  replied to  Hal A. Lujah   10 years ago

Someone starts shooting into a crowd, and he immediately gets rid of his gun?  I thought we are all supposed to be safer when everyone has guns for protection.

Actually, he helped make the situation safer.  When police officers are on crowd control duty, long guns are kept in vehicles (which were not immediately available).  For that sort of duty, rifles are heavy and bulky and are not the sort of weapon needed for crowd control anyway.  Suddenly, however, a protest march incident became a sniper incident, a purpose for which a rifle is the ideal weapon.  The man with the rifle, probably marching with it to show that he had the right to do so, saw that he wouldn't be able to use it to help for the reason that John stated.  That is, if he had tried to use it, he would have been thought of as an accomplice of the sniper.  So, instead of using the rifle himself, he gave it to someone who could use it; a police officer who didn't have one of his own available.  That's good thinking, the presence of the gun helped make things safer for everyone, even if the owner didn't fire a round out of it himself.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah  replied to  TTGA   10 years ago

Thanks for restating the obvious.  Here's the thing - the guy was openly marching around with a gun that would be of no use to anyone, since police were already there in force to respond to any 'bad guy with a gun' scenario.  So why did he bring his gun in the first place?  Is it not a dangerous liability for him to have it?  Couldn't he easily have been a casualty of friendly fire just for having it?

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming   replied to  Hal A. Lujah   10 years ago

hal , the only one it was of use to was himself in the act of protest , to him it could have been a visible signal that he could defend himself ( an act I have already said I don't believe in or do , if I carry no one knows but me ) and I wont condemn anyone that would choose to use that visable show , that has the right to bear. but not a smart one IMHO.

 yes there was a police presence , but not one that was equipped for a sniper situation at first.

 someone initially posted on one of the articles about how the cops were out gunned by semi and automatic weapons , no the cops were not out gunned as the end showed , what happened was the cops were taken by surprise and at first they were out positioned  which changed once they knew where everything was coming from.

 as for liability, that was a choice he made and was free to make , but everyone is liable for their own choices , that old chestnut , your free to make your own choices , your just not free of the consequenses of those choices.....

 

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    10 years ago

In other shocking news, states with more cars experience more car accidents. News at 11.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Cerenkov   10 years ago

Ummm... C? 

Did you think it through before you hit the "Post" button? You've just agreed that more guns means more killings. Will you take the obvious next step, and agree that fewer guns would mean fewer killings? 

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov  replied to  Bob Nelson   10 years ago

Yes, that's obvious. Why would I possibly not agree to that?

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Cerenkov   10 years ago

Are you therfore in favor of limitations on the possession of firearms? 

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty  replied to  Bob Nelson   10 years ago

I'm not. I believe part of the reason civilians are allowed weapons is in case we need to overthrow a tyrannical government like our founding fathers did. They wanted us to have the control over our government. We need to relax some of the gun laws and restore the power to the people. We need to restore our right to purchase new automatic weapons. It's good when government fears the people and bad when the people fear the government. 

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Dean Moriarty   10 years ago

The guy who just murdered five cops felt he was striking a blow against tyranny. 

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov  replied to  Bob Nelson   10 years ago

No, I'm not. Reducing the number of cars would also decrease fatalities. Why aren't you endorsing that?

The benefits of guns outweigh the tiny chance that one will kill you. The benefits of cars also outweigh the (much larger) danger.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Cerenkov   10 years ago

What are the benefits of guns? 

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty  replied to  Bob Nelson   10 years ago

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Dean Moriarty   10 years ago

Ah, Dean... 

Another totally irrelevant post. Your record is intact: never a single pertinent contribution! 

 

 
 
 
TTGA
Professor Silent
link   TTGA  replied to  Bob Nelson   10 years ago

How is that irrelevant Bob?  You just asked the question

What are the benefits of guns?

and you just got told.  Shooting robbers is a very great benefit (or do you think that robbers should just get a hand slap)?

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  TTGA   10 years ago

I asked that of C, in the context of an exchange of posts. Dean butted in, with a particular event, which in no way answers the question. But don't be upset for Dean. His posts are almost never pertinent, because he doesn't intend them to be. Dean only posts to derail.

So you needn't defend Dean... unless of course your purpose is also to derail...    waving

 

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober  replied to  Bob Nelson   10 years ago

unless of course your purpose is also to derail

How do we know if someone is derailing ? Le Bob will tell us his opinion !

 
 
 
TTGA
Professor Silent
link   TTGA  replied to  Bob Nelson   10 years ago

You've just agreed that more guns means more killings. Will you take the obvious next step, and agree that fewer guns would mean fewer killings?

Only if guns are the only means of killing.  More guns means more GUN killings, fewer guns means fewer GUN killings.  It definitely does not mean fewer overall killings.  (Nice try Bob, but that trick (equating gun killings with all killings) has been used before).

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  TTGA   10 years ago

I kinda doubt there would be thirty thousand more knife murders... but if that's what you believe... BE HAPPY! 

     crazy      crazy      crazy      crazy

 

 
 
 
TTGA
Professor Silent
link   TTGA  replied to  Bob Nelson   10 years ago

I kinda doubt there would be thirty thousand more knife murders

Since there haven't been thirty thousand gun murders, you wouldn't need that many knife murders, now would you.  Remove twenty thousand suicides and all justifiable homicides and you have less than ten thousand.  Remove gang killings, which won't be affected by any gun control measure, and you're down to less than two thousand.  That is about three ten thousandths of a percent of the population.  An increase of two thousand knife murders is entirely possible.

So you needn't defend Dean... unless of course your purpose is also to derail...

What derailing?  You asked a legitimate question and he gave you a legitimate answer.  The incident he gave you represents a class of uses.  You just don't like the answer since it doesn't fit your agenda, so you try to pass it off as derailing.

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     10 years ago

Well I read the article and decided to do a little looking myself , and chose to go to the Officer down memorial page.

for those that don't know about this page its is a page set up as a memorial to those officers that have died while on duty. It does have a break down of officers who died by state , at least how many of them.

 and here are some numbers I came up with using the premise of which state was the safest using total number of OODD( officer on duty deaths).

 and what I have seen on this site is the safest 10 states to be a LEO areas follows:

10 Idaho 61 OODD

9 Hawaii  56

8 N Dakota 55

7 Wyoming 54

6 S Dakota 53

5 Rhode Island 50

4 Alaska  48

3 New Hampshire 46

2 Delaware 41

1 Vermont 24

 actually some of the safest US controlled places is in its posessions and protectorates that are not states , like American samoa 3  the marshall islands 3 , with the exception of Puerto rico which has over 100,  the rest are basically down in the double or single digits, but they don't have state status.

 You will also notice that only 3 states on the 10 best list ( I should say states with least officer fatalities) are states with what most would consider stringent  gun control.

  That led me to think ok which states have the highest OODD. states that if I chose , I wouldn't want to be a cop in due to officer mortality numbers.

Remember these are the states that have had the MOST officer deaths.

10 Tennessee 601

 9  Missouri  663

 8  Georgia   691

 7  Kentucky  770

 6  Florida      787

 5  Ohio        826

 4  Illinois     1070

 3  New York  1571

 2  California   1604

 1  Texas        1874 ( includes the recent dallas ambush)

 

 now in fairness, these numbers represent how many officers have died while on duty , for ANY AND ALL causes, and they are from when a state gained statehood and joined the union.

 as of today 7/09/16  57 officers have died on duty of that 26 have died by gunfire , be it purposeful or accidental( no distinction made on the site) and 23 have died by automobile. vehicular insidents, wait that's only 49 what happened to the other 8? near as I can tell those officers died on duty , from other reasons , most likely a heart attack or something they don't normally encounter , but that's not the point , to date 57 officers gave their lives in the performance of their duty.  but I will point out until weds night , the Number 1 killer of on duty cops was not someone with a gun , but someone in a motor vehicle. be the cop was ran over , or he was hit in his vehicle or simply had an accident himself. again it didn't tell the specifics there either.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser  replied to  Mark in Wyoming   10 years ago

I wonder if part of KY's high numbers are because we've been a state for so long?  Since 1792, I think...  We had an ambush that killed a state trooper last year in Bardstown.  Everyone is still looking for the killer, as far as I know.  People rallied around and donated enough money to send his kids to college, and help out the widow.   

But, yet again, we're in the top 10 of the list for bad things...

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming   replied to  Dowser   10 years ago

D, well Vermont has been a state just as long as Ky  and some of the other states listed and if you look at either list it has a bit of both states with lax , and stringent gun laws.

but  listing the states with the least and most does bring into question the validity of the articles title, meaning is the title actually supported by facts , or is it an emotional kneejerk  statement  meant to mislead?

looking at the title one would think states with stringent gun control would have the least LEO deaths , but that's  not proving to be the truth  now is it?

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser  replied to  Mark in Wyoming   10 years ago

Perhaps I'm wrong, but I see Vermont as being a more civilized state than KY.  We had all that turmoil with the Civil War and reconstruction and all...  Then we have all those mountain counties, that aren't known for their higher education and have high drug use rates, etc.  Maybe that has a lot to do with it.  And poverty, we have a lot of poverty...  All of those things could be part of it.  As a rule, I see us as caring about our state troopers, but I also see that there would be some people who want to kill them.  Not that I agree with that-- but we have a lot of people that want to live in a sub-society, so to speak.  (I'm thinking of the KKK enclave here.  Pot growers.  Moonshiners.  People who live outside the law, so to speak.  People who would view the state police as a threat.)

This isn't a list that I'm proud to be at the top of, as you can imagine...  But, I love my state and will help defend the state troopers any way I can.  If living a "clean" life and not causing trouble is a good thing, then I'm good... 

I mean, I've seen police on the side of the road and stopped to ask if they need any help.  Of course, they are insulted that I would ask, and wave me on, but I mean well.  I'm just another set of eyes, or another warm body to put between them and the shooter, should they need it.  I can call for help, or do whatever is needed.

It is an endemic problem, I think, with many factors.  I don't know how to fix it, but we need more help.  Maybe, with help, we could get off this list!  Happy

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Mark in Wyoming   10 years ago

Mark, 

The seed presents numbers that are pretty clear. On what basis do you dismiss tjem? 

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     10 years ago

Dowser, every thing you mentioned can be applied in some form and to some degree to every state possession and protectorate within the united states, its how it is dealt with in all those different places  that's going to matter, and something that's going to have to be remembered , that a solution in one place may not be the solution that works in another ( no matter how much someone thinks it will).

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     10 years ago

@bob-nelson

Mark, 

The seed presents numbers that are pretty clear. On what basis do you dismiss tjem? 

Bob what actually caught my eye was the title , so I gave the article a read , now I haven't dismissed the numbers at all , I decided to go look at RAW numbers with no biases built in.

 And like I said in my post , I asked myself , IF I were still LEO which would be the safest states to go look for work ( a reasonable question ) and one way of dedusing that would be to look at how many officers die on duty per state, what I posted is what I have found , and it contradicts the title of the article  to a good degree and at the least calls into question the actual validity of the title

 If you look at the list of  states  with the least officer deaths , it contains many states I am sure you would consider lax in gun regulation AND HIGH  in gun ownership rates even my state of Wyoming which is mentioned in the body of the article ( that's when my BULLSHIT detector went  off in the pegged mode). as one of the worst states because of lax regs and high public ownership.

 You may also think that the list of states that have the highest rates of OODD works in your favor  because I stated these numbers all are how many officers have died since a state gained statehood , Not really because  it has the same cross sectionas the other list , some states are older some not as old ,  some have lax gun laws some more stringent , of the top 4 worst ( answering my initial which is worse or best question) ONLY Texas would be considered a lax gun law state , NY Cal and Ill  are all strict gun law states .

 So the question is, is the title of the article supported by the facts? I don't think it is as I have shown with the raw numbers I have posted , at the least it raises more questions . questions I am sure others are asking themselves .

is that a clear enough explaination?

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     10 years ago

Bob , I got a wild hair so I did some simple math here .

 I used Wy and NY,  now Wy has been a state for 126 yrs this year and has had by my numbers 54 officers die while on duty( all causes) that would put the officer mortality rate over that period of time at .4 per year.

Now NY is 228 as of this year  and has had 1571 OODD for all causes  giving them an OMR  of 6.8 per year.

Now there is a 102 year difference , so lets see what or how many deaths WY will have  if it had been a state as long as NY , for this I will simply use the ,4 and multiply assuming things all stay the same rate of loss , but we do know such things will fluctuate due to different factors .

 OK add 102 years @ .4 and that comes up with an additional 40. 8 OODD that could conceivably be expected , add that to the current 54 already experienced and that comes to 94.8 IF Wy was just as old as NY when it comes to statehood.

 Now if that holds constant , 95 ( rounded) is still under 100 for a possible 228 year history, might add , that's a long ways from 1571 currently recorded too.

 

 
 

Who is online