What the Republican Assault on James Comey Reveals About Today's GOP
What the Republican Assault on James Comey Reveals About Today's GOP
The confrontation between FBI Director James Comey and his would-be tormentors on the House Government Oversight Committee revealed something far more fundamental about politics in America today than the reasons why Hillary Clinton will not be prosecuted over her "damned emails."
The calm, intelligent, upright Comey, focused on facts and fair play, represents what the Republican Party once was at its best. The dim, ultra-partisan, conspiracy-obsessed Republicans who interrogated him on Thursday represent the sad condition of the Grand Old Party today.
That dismal contrast between sanity and lunacy is why such Congressional show trials repeatedly flop. The interrogation of Comey ordered by Rep. Jason Chaffetz, R-Utah, the committee chair, provided a perfect example of the syndrome that afflicts them, which now appears to be incurable.
House Republicans blew a perfectly good opportunity to embarrass Clinton over the highly critical remarks made by Comey in announcing his decision not to prosecute -- remarks that were unusual, since most investigations are just thumbs up or down, with no public explanation.
The Republicans could have invited Comey up to Capitol Hill to enumerate the problems his investigators found in Clinton's email system. They could have asked him to explain why he described her handling of classified and sensitive information as "extremely careless." They could have displayed those findings in a way that emphasized the distrust too many Americans feel toward her.
But that kind of hearing would have required them to accept Comey's decision, as Chaffetz had previously said they would. Instead, they denounced his decision, hinted that he had participated in a corrupt process, and attacked the integrity of the FBI director and his agency. They set up a debate that they could not win, since he knew the facts and they clearly did not.
Indeed the hearing may well prove beneficial to Clinton overall, with revelations of basic facts that tend to bolster her exoneration and soften Comey's verbal indictment of her.
The committee Democrats, led by the sharp and indefatigable Rep. Elijah Cummings, D-Md., made the most of the opportunity afforded them by the Republican leadership. Meanwhile the Republican members, throwing up baseless theories that Comey easily shot down, repeatedly violated the most basic rule of competent trial attorneys: Never ask a question if you don't already know the answer. Their reward was to listen haplessly as Comey, whom they had antagonized from the beginning, delivered answers that made them look foolish.
Was Clinton's email system penetrated by "Guccifer," the Romanian hacker who had boasted of purloining her messages, inquired one eager Republican, reiterating a staple of right-wing conspiracy-minded websites. "He admitted that was a lie," replied the FBI chief. "Well ... it's good to know that," said his inquisitor, lamely.
The Republican questions pandered heavily to their most paranoid constituents, who believe that "the Clintons" have repeatedly escaped punishment for a variety of mostly imaginary offenses. Having suggested that Comey colluded in that pattern, by allowing Hillary Clinton to escape prosecution for conduct that led to convictions in earlier cases, they forced him to prove those charges false. And with the assistance of committee Democrats, who became his de facto allies, he did.
Comey demonstrated exactly how the offenses committed by retired General David Petraeus, who had disclosed reams of highly classified information to his mistress (and biographer), differed from Clinton's accidental disclosure of a few innocuous documents that probably shouldn't have been classified at all. Indeed, he retreated from his criticism of Clinton, to a degree, when he conceded under Democratic questioning that out of tens of thousands of documents, only three were arguably "classified" when they crossed her email account -- and that those three were incorrectly marked. Based on the inconspicuous and incorrect markings, the FBI director could scarcely defend the notion that she should have known those pages were classified.
None of those fundamental findings will change the aggrieved mindset of the GOP base, however, as they listen to whispered accusations against Comey, an honorable, lifelong Republican who has devoted three decades to public service. Republican leaders, to their disgrace, have encouraged those corrosive attitudes for many years and continue to do so. Then they ask, in self-pitying tones, why their party is afflicted by a figure like Donald Trump.

In an interview on CNN this morning, the ABC News legal analyst Dan Abrams said this - "I know this is going to upset some people , but this decision (to not indict Clinton) wasn't even a close call, from a legal standpoint."
A fact disputed by many other "legal analysts." She's a crook and a liar.
The Republicans "lost" in the hearing the other day. A few more hearings like that and you will have Hillary elected.
What was the official score after that "loss?"
You know very well that this whole sordid adventure will dog Hillary until November.
Only John can believe a hearing where the director of the FBI detailed how a Presidential nominee lied repeatedly to the press and Congress and described her as "not that sophisticated" can be described as a "win." It's really amazing. The FBI director calls her a careless, unsophisticated liar and Democrats celebrate.
Not to mention how he admitted rewriting a statute to save her from jail.
but I guess when you support a crook, any day she's not indicted is a win. That's the bar Democrats set for themselves.
I think the extent of Clinton's "lying" is very much in doubt. We now know that she did not lie when she said she never sent or received emails that were marked "classified". There weren't any such emails on her system. Yet, talk about liars, there are those on the right who continue to this second to claim that she did send such emails.
Clinton's "lies" depend upon the assertion that she intended to use her home server for classified messages. If she did not, her number of "lies" shrinks considerably.
There is no evidence she intended to use her home server for classified messages, and some good evidence that she did not. (None of them were marked "classified".)
Clinton received classified messages at her SOS office or other secure government facilities abroad. A small number of classified messages were sent to her house, possibly by mistake.
She was wrong, and careless. It was not worthy of a criminal charge and has devolved into a witch hunt.
I think the extent of Clinton's "lying" is very much in douby
you've lost touch with reality. Watch her March 23, 2015 press conference and compare it what Comey said. She been caught lying about every aspect of this.
We now know that she did not lie when she said she never sent or received emails that were marked "classified"
Now you are calling Comey a liar.
Clinton's "lies" depend upon the assertion that she intended to use her home server for classified messages
Not true at all
Again, the Director of the FBI details how she lied repeatedly and you think it's no big deal. B
We now know that she did not lie when she said she never sent or received emails that were marked "classified"
Now you are calling Comey a liar.
Comey acknowledged the other day that none of Clinton's emails were marked classified.
Q: Secretary Clinton said there was nothing marked classified on her e-mails sent or received. Was that true?
Comey: That's not true.
Q: Secretary Clinton said "I did not e-mail any classified information to anyone on my e-mail there was no classified material." That is true?
Comey: There was classified information emailed.
I know you are not this dumb so you must be playing games.
Comey said that 110 emails were found that had been classified at the time (as opposed to the couple thousand that were retroactively upgraded to "classified" when they were about to be made public) .
None of the 110 that Comey called classified at the time were "marked classified". He determined they were classified by querying government agencies about the content.
This is what Clinton is saying. She says she was sent these emails by people who did not believe they were classified. She also says these were mainly career state dept. people.
The crux of the dispute according to Clinton is that her people, and her I guess, did not believe these emails should have been classified, and since they were not marked, she assumed that they were not.
A lot of the "lies" you keep referring to revolve around this issue.
It's really amusing to watch you attack Republicans for "assaulting James Comey" when that's all you are doing. You are misrepresenting pretty much everything he said to make some point he said is irrelevant (about whether top secret information had a big stamp on it)
You keep skipping over the part where he said any reasonable person would know she was handling highly classified material and that it was inappropriate to send and store highly classified material on a server less secure than gmail.
ANY REASONABLE PERSON WOULD KNOW this was wrong according to Comey.
We now know that she did not lie when she said she never sent or received emails that were marked "classified".
BULLSHIT
At 2.30 he says classified emails were sent, some top secret then says SEPERATE FROM THOSE there were some sent that were up-classified.
Just a thought: Has anyone here gotten 50,000 emails in 4 years? That's 12,500 emails per year, or 34 emails a day, roughly...
Have you ever replied to an email, without looking at which server was used? I usually get 40-50 emails a day... Mostly junk. I have no idea which server everyone used. They all come to my home server, TWC. I don't have any idea from which server the email originated. Granted, I'm not doing anything that could remotely considered to be "classified"-- but then again, some of them contain 'sensitive' information that I wouldn't want spread all over kingdom come. Then again, anything that comes from MARC, (Mid-American Resource Center-- satellite photography), the KY Geology Bd of Registration, or the water company, could be deemed "classified" at any time-- after the fact.
I'm not about to look up these email servers... It's a pain enough to have to delete all that crap. Yet, keep the important ones. (You know, receipts from software purchases, or other purchases, Bd of Registration issues, coordinates and photography information from MARC).
I can't bring myself to criticize her for something that I very likely do myself. And yes, I've had a security clearance, from MARC, and the Board. I've also been investigated by the FBI, because I had a good friend that turned out to be a bank robber. My background is checked yearly, as a volunteer as a band parent. So what?
I realize that y'all hate her. Believe me, I get that. I realize that all of you are foaming at the mouth to discredit her, bring her down, etc. Believe me, I get that, too. But how much more taxpayer money are you willing to waste beating a dead horse?
As much as it takes. She was grossly negligent and is making a mockery of the rule of law. Comey said it himself, anyone else would be facing penalties now. If we let the elite operate outside the law in this case, the next one will be even more egregious.
I heard where he said that she was careless, and called her a liar, and said she was stupid, but I didn't hear where he said that she was a felon that should be prosecuted. Or a member of the 'elite' who was getting away with it because she was an elite...
Do I need to listen to it again?
Here's his entire remarks. Pretty damning, but not to the point you are taking it.
My point was, can any of us withstand this level of scrutiny?
Well since you are running for President, I guess that's the same thing then.
Vote Clinton! She screws up just like you and mishandles the most secret information the county has ! And She lies! Just like you too!
Sean, there are times when you behave like a boil on the butt of humanity. I am not thrilled with Clinton as a presidential candidate. I have made that clear, I thought. I'm not pleased with ANY of the candidates, to be honest.
But, I can see how things happen. And, I don't lie, you cretin. I may have a different point of view, but I don't lie. You don't lie, I know. You may exaggerate, obfuscate, or snark your way out of things, but you don't lie. So don't accuse me of lying-- or offer proof that I have.
Note: I am highly insulted that you would accuse me of lying. Think I lie? Prove it.
Let me clarify. I meant that as a campaign slogan Clinton could run on. Where she proclaims how incompetent and dishonest she is so people could identify with her. I was not accusing you of lying specifically.
But yeah, it shocks me that you think carelessly (to put the best possible spin on her actions) mishandling the nation's most secret material and lying about it is no big deal. I'd bet if she had an (r) next to her name you'd feel a lot differently.
Not really... You would be surprised at how open-minded I really am in the world. For me, she is a reasonable choice. If we got rid of all the politicians that lie, we would have none. Also, in my position as a Bd of Registration member, I can't tell all the truth, all the time. That would violate ethics standards and privacy laws. All I'm saying is that the majority of us would not look good at this level of scrutiny.
Few of us handle real classified documents on a regular basis-- she did. Yet, in my life, I have to ask-- what is classified? What is company and/or board policy and what would represent a danger? I sent emails reassuring customers that their water was good-- or, it left the plant as good water. I'm not responsible for what happens to it when it gets in the pipes of your home. All I can say is that contamination is unlikely, because water pressure in the pipe is typically 120 lbs/in2, (psi). It would take a pressurized system, like in a soft drink machine, or a strong swimming pool pump, anything with a pressure of 120+ psi, to be able to overcome the force of the water leaving the pipe-- and believe me, that is common in restaurants, but not homes. (It would also need a cross connection...) I got in trouble for telling them the constituents in the water when it left the plant... I had no idea I wasn't supposed to talk about that. It was "classified". Yet, it was the truth. My question: How could this be classified information if the water company publishes a consumer confident report every year, detailing the constituents of the water? I have no idea.
Same for the board. Someone once asked me if we kicked out pot growers who were practicing geology. Since pot grows naturally in the state, just about everywhere, the only time we would do this is if they were a convicted felon. Our laws state that convicted felons can't get a license to practice. So, we would have to jerk a geologist's license if they're a convicted felon. But, and I can't add, the who, or the how, or what felony they were convicted of. Not the whole truth. But that could be interpreted as lying, even though I have to uphold ethics and privacy laws, too. So, tell me what I should do?
Something that is declared "classified", after the fact, does not mean that I lied or breached confidentiality for my company. Not telling the entire truth, follows our laws. Am I a liar? Would I deserve to be investigated for my lapses in judgement? She was and they couldn't find anything they could defend in court. So, it is what it is... Why waste more money trying to reverse a decision? BAsed on his remarks, I have the feeling that he WANTED to charge her, but there was no way he could, and prove it.
If you have a question as to my integrity, please ask me about it. I will tell you the truth. I always have.